3 ms·
Where were really smart people in charge?
by tome 17y ago
Where were really smart people in charge?
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI believe the scope of than answer is greater than a HN thread, but I might just be wussing out. Hopefully others will engage you. If not, happy to take it offline. I will say this: be careful of selection bias! Looking back, sure, if I show you a thousand examples that ended poorly your response will be something like "But they weren't really smart. Look how poorly it all turned out!" This is, at best, circular reasoning. The important thing is that, at the time, these folks were the best and brightest and put in charge for that very reason. Good starting point: http://www.amazon.com/Logic-Failure-Recognizing-Avoiding-Situations/dp/0201479486 http://www.amazon.com/Logic-Failure-Recognizing-Avoiding-Sit...
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- tocomment 17y agoI'd like to know also. Can you start new topic on HN perhaps?
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoWill do. Perhaps I can set this up as a blog entry and then cross-post. The problem, I think, is to keep this non-political. Somebody brought up the Rumsfield example, which I think is a good one. I also think McNamarra is another good example. The problem is that decisions that are very visible and make a big impact can also politically-charged. I think using a couple of SecDefs is okay, but I'm not sure.
- nradov 17y agoUS Department of Defense, 2001 – 2006. Donald Rumsfeld's writings show he is clearly quite intelligent, yet he still managed to make numerous disastrous mistakes.
- asdflkj 17y agoMore importantly, where were really smart non-psychopathic people in charge? Psychopaths crave power, and intelligence allows them to get it. Smart people in general (and especially the smartest of the smart) tend to dislike any authority in their lives, even the kind wielded by them. This poor dude is actually a case in point. He could not even allow himself the small bit of authority needed to stand up for himself and not get kicked out of college. I imagine that to him, working with shitkickers is a bit like working with plants.