17 ms·
Vast majority of purebreds have some serious generic issues. I'm hoping that we as a society will solve this whole situation soon. There is a BBC documentary o
by adamnemecek 10y ago
Vast majority of purebreds have some serious generic issues. I'm hoping that we as a society will solve this whole situation soon.
There is a BBC documentary on this https://vimeo.com/17558275 https://vimeo.com/17558275
- ethagknight 10y agoWhats the solution here?
- Cthulhu_ 10y agoNot breed to optimize for certain traits. But that's what dogs (and the current 'breeds') are all about anyway, both pugs and what most people consider 'anatomically correct' dogs.
- worldsayshi 10y agoOr at least don't optimize for traits that are disconnected from the health and wellbeing of the dog, like pure looks? Optimizing on more practical or athletic aspects probably makes it more difficult to end up with a sick dog.
- Periodic 10y agoDogsled racing is a working area that has seen trend away from pure huskies. There are still plenty of huskies in the sport, but mixed teams are very common in the Iditarod now. In 2000 there were only three all-husky teams in the whole race. The racers are crossing with other breeds and bringing in new dogs that are more optimized for the race. There's a danger that in the long run they could end up with something extreme, like what greyhounds are for racing, but right now it's full of healthy, diverse dogs.
- hyperpape 10y agoMutts mostly, maybe a few different kinds of pure breeds. Might offend someone's aesthetic sensibilities (though I can't see why), but that seems like a worthwhile trade.
- whyileft 10y agoBan breeding. There are plenty of dogs available for adoption. Once we run out of those we can reconsider the ban. Pretty simple stuff.
- imjustsaying 10y ago>Ban X the username checks out
- proactivesvcs 10y agoRealise that the incarceration (physically and/or psychologically) of animals for a purely comforting or entertainment purpose is an affront to proper morals.
- bionsuba 10y agoDon't buy a pure bred, especially not at a premium.
- nailer 10y agoMaybe: we stop using terms like 'purebreed' and 'mongrel'. Or reclaim 'mongrel' I like the term 'natural dog'. "I'd like a medium sized natural dog with a long coat because it's cold here."
- kharms 10y ago"Natural dog" is a silly term. Dogs are a domesticated animal and breeds have been around for almost as long as writing. [1] I call mine a "mutt" - it's inoffensive and gets the point across. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dog_breed#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dog_breed#History
- tetrep 10y agoMutt is intended to be an insult. While I'm fairly confident I've never heard it used as such first hand, it's still the 2nd definition on whatever Google uses for defining things: a person regarded as stupid or incompetent. "“Do not give me orders, mutt.”"
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- zeveb 10y ago'Dog' is also an insult, and for that matter so is 'bitch' (n.b. for non-English-speakers: 'bitch' is the English word for a female dog). I don't think that there's anything wrong with calling things by their proper names.
- bitwize 10y agoIf you wish to be pedantic, "mix" and "mixed breed" are fairly neutral terms.
- nailer 10y agoA natural dog's parents picked each other because their butts smelled good. An unnatural dog's parents were chosen by someone looking to make an animal with a squashed snout.
- acconrad 10y agoHave them mate with other breeds
- maxxxxx 10y agoEliminate purebreds. Can you imagine we did the same with humans? Selecting for only one characteristic is a recipe for genetic disaster.
- CM30 10y agoOh, there's a pretty good chance people will try doing the same for humans when genetic engineering becomes a tad more common/extensive. There's a reason talk of 'designer babies' and the likes is a hot topic, especially in regards of selecting for certain characteristics here too.
- fixermark 10y agoI think you're throwing out the baby with the bathwater in that approach. Purebreds carry common genetic weaknesses. They also carry common genetic strengths. How confident are we that we can preserve the strengths as we mitigate the weaknesses?
- maxxxxx 10y agoAgain, imagine we bred humans that need to have their back shaped in a certain form, nose of a certain length and so on. It won't work in the long run. Even worse, they breed for genetic defects like the hips on German shepherds. You can select maybe for certain personalities or physical attributes but you need to allow for other variations. The guidelines for purebreds are just stupid.
- ceejayoz 10y ago> Can you imagine we did the same with humans? I can! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haemophilia_in_European_royalty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haemophilia_in_European_royalt...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bdittmer 10y agoThis is why mutts are the best. Genetic diversity is good. Anecdotal, but growing up my two mutts lived to the ages of 16 and 18...well past the life expectancies you see in the purebred world.
- fixermark 10y agoIt's really a case-by-case basis thing. I grew up with a mutt that I loved dearly. My parents got her because my Dad had read something or other in (I think) Popular Science about how the "dog of the future" would be a mutt, and the mutting of genes would suppress bad recessive traits. Then she got sick as a puppy, had an allergic reaction to her medication, and suffered permanent brain damage. That having been said, she was a perfect house pet; lived to be a very ripe old age and was good natured, just a little slow to respond to things. If you're a breeder and there's something wrong in the genetics of the dog you're breeding, stop breeding that dog. But resolving genetic issues isn't as simple as just throwing mutts together; you really just roll the dice on a new set of strengths and weaknesses when you do that.
- rjsw 10y agoA mutt could still be the offspring of two pure bred dogs and have inherited genetic problems from both.
- Jtsummers 10y agoExactly. Mutts may often be better than their purebred parents (by various objective and subjective criteria), but in the end it'll take a few generations of mutts and, well, survival of the fittest before you can see a general trend towards improvements in health and longevity. Genetics are a lottery, starting with unhealthy parents the odds are against the offspring. It'll take generations for the population as a whole to move towards being healthier on average.
- jbmorgado 10y agoWell, the only problem with mutts (for me) is that you have no good idea on what size they will have as adults. Living in an apartment I can't really have a big dog and by getting a breed dog (even if it's not really pure bread) I know it will not get too big for the space I have available.
- 13of40 10y agoSuppose there was a breed of, say, monkey, that was popular as a household pet. They were considered to be quite clever and could be trained, over some years, to use a toilet, fetch things from the fridge, even manage primitive forms of communication. The only problem is that they're a genetic trainwreck. They've got a pronounced, gourd-like head with a snout so compact that it's common to have to surgically remove some of their teeth. They've got limited ability in their front legs that forces them to spend their entire life in an abnormal posture, resulting in a cornucopia of spinal and joint problems that cause many of them lifelong pain. On top of all this, all of their natural defenses (claws, canines, protective fur) have been bred out and disease traits bred in (myopia, hemophilia, diabetes, and so on). Now, knowing all of this, suppose your sister, who already has three of these things running around her house, calls up and gleefully announces that they're getting another one. What do you tell her?
- elthran 10y agoWell, when the monkey gets older it can use tools to defend itself, as well as keep itself alive. However, I would perhaps suggest teaching it abstinence, sterlilisation if it has one of the particularly debilitating genetic diseases
- maxerickson 10y agoHumans are apes not monkeys. What if you sister called and said there was a safe, cheap and effective way to remove, say, the myopia from her spawn (in the case of dogs, stop inbreeding, in the case of humans, currently imaginary)? Would you tell her not to do it?
- 13of40 10y agoI had some in-laws at one point who had a kid with cystic fibrosis, and they decided to roll the dice and have a second one. (Murphy's Law won that round.) I can't imagine convincing those people to get their $1200 purebred pug[1] neutered for the good of the species. [1] https://www.reference.com/pets-animals/much-pugs-87fd8b209cadf864 https://www.reference.com/pets-animals/much-pugs-87fd8b209ca...
- wukerplank 10y agoTotally agree! The only counter argument I've heard ist that purebreds also have predictably the same character traits, which is important if the dog has to fulfill a job. But to private owners health and longevity should matter more.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]