3 ms·
I don't understand what's so hard about putting their whole film catalog online. Let me pay a buck to download any movie your studio produced in some simple for
by adrianN 10y ago
I don't understand what's so hard about putting their whole film catalog online. Let me pay a buck to download any movie your studio produced in some simple format without any crapware or subscriptions or region-locking and I will do so every time instead of pirating.
The marginal cost of offering a movie for downloading must be pretty close to 0. Why can't studios simply tap the opportunity of cheap hassle-free downloads?
- martin-adams 10y agoI suspect they value the offering higher if it's in limited supply. Disney do this with the Disney Vault[1]. Each Disney film is available for purchase for a limited time, after which it is put "in the vault" and not made available in stores for several years until it is once again released. However, Disney may be the exception here. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disney_Vault https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disney_Vault
- tajen 10y agoLike, I pay $5, I get the official .torrent link legally? This is pure fiction!
- adrianN 10y agoHave them set up private trackers with dedicated seedboxes and add a "tip a buck for this movie" button with some a convenient payment processor. Technologically it's a weekend project for a small team and I really don't see what they lose financially.
- pc86 10y ago> I really don't see what they lose financially Uh, a lot of money? There is no way that a torrent with a $1 tip function would make the same amount of money they make through all the distribution deals, advertising, $6 24-hour HD rentals through cable providers and Amazon, etc. > Technologically it's a weekend project for a small team Famous last words.
- squeaky-clean 10y agoOn top of top of pc86's reasoning, a lot of small payment methods like this get abused for credit card fraud. Get a list of a thousand CC numbers from somewhere shady, and test them all out on small $1 donations like this. If it succeeds, the card is valid and the owner likely won't notice anytime soon. Eventually, when they do cancel the card and order chargebacks, the company has to pay a large flat fee to refund that $1. This is also why a lot of OSS projects don't have donation options.
- r00fus 10y agoIt's also a liability magnet. The MAFIAA already wants to nuke free-for-all pirating, but if you make money off that? Easier to find, and prosecute.
- KevanM 10y agoDoes it make sense financially for them to divide markets and then play the broadcasters off for exclusive rights to show films on scheduled TV.
- chatmasta 10y agoStudios sign different distribution deals in different regions. These include box office release and "DVD" (web) release schedules. These regional licensing contracts are often in the range of 5-7 years. As a result, studios cannot simply offer a film or TV series online at the same time for everybody. As the regional contracts expire and the studios restructure them, I expect to see more direct distribution via online channels.
- Klathmon 10y agoAs much as I'd like to believe that it's going to get better, in my experience it's getting worse. Instead of consolidating and simplifying their terms, they are digging deeper and getting more complex. It's not uncommon to see a setup like: * Show airs during primetime * Available the next day on on-demand (not that same night) * Expires from on-demand after 30 days * Last 5 episodes but not the most recent episode available for purchase per-episode on something like google-play or amazon. * Large gap between the last 5 episodes and the previous season where it's literally impossible to buy or watch an episode legally. * second-to-most-current season available on Hulu-Plus * All seasons previous to that available on netflix or amazon prime (not both) And that's just in one country, not even taking into account the various restrictions and petty limitations like no HD and no ability to rewind or even pause in some cases. Not to mention the hardware you'd need to watch all of that on a regular TV. You are looking at least at a Fire-stick, Roku or chromecast, a STB from the cable company, and in some cases a PC that can HDMI over to the TV.
- Cthulhu_ 10y agoIt's not hard, it's just not maximized profit. There's a lot of brain power invested in how much they can charge and how much advertising they can cram into content, finding the most profitable balance between acquiring, retaining and losing viewers.
- andy_ppp 10y agoThis isn't canonically true is it; if more people consume more media at $1 per go you could make back much more than you loose by charging £25 that very few people pay for new Blu ray disks.
- prebrov 10y agoIt's also about effort per buck earned. A single exclusive deal for a season of Game of Thrones for a specific release window with a local/regional PayTV provider brings in, say, ten million bucks. And you make this deal in a nice 3 Michelin Star restaurant. Compare that with actually delivering 10 million streams to end users, on iPhones, iPads, Androids, AppleTVs, Chromecasts, [edited: with] payment gateways and support for technically challenged people.
- andy_ppp 10y agoDelivering 10m streams to the end user is a solved problem; just pay to transcode your video. The point is to avoid even streaming - let people download films, no drm, for a buck (maybe 2 bucks for 4k) and trust most people not to steal.
- rhino369 10y agoHow sure are you that more than 25X people will pay for a 1 dollar movie? Because that sounds way high to me. Do you know anyone would watch 25X more content if it were cheaper? I wouldn't. And the movie industry taps this demand in other ways. They eventually sell the movie to netflix/amazon/tv station.
- collyw 10y ago
- lifty 10y agoI would love to have the possibility to be able to hassle free download movies, and I would be willing to pay up to 5 bucks (for certain movies) to do so. But I don't have that option, so instead I have other ways of getting my movies.
- e12e 10y agoThey've made this web for themselves, by lobbying for longer and more restrictive copyright. The most pathetic irony here, is Disney, who made a small fortune milking public domain fairy-tales and yet have fought to prevent their extremely popular figures to become part of that same public domain - even after they clearly are part of a common world-spanning culture - much like 1001 nights, or the Greek mythos.