8 ms·
Electronics robust enough for Venus
- ChuckMcM 10y agoWonderfully the paper is available: http://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/1.4973429 http://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/1.4973429 consider swapping the link for this one. Reading through the paper I have to admit those are some really impressive numbers. A typical soldering station might run at 343C (650F) while Venus is 460C (860F) hotter than a reflow oven to be sure.
- akiselev 10y agoThe best part of that comparison is that solder might not even melt on Venus at that temperature. The atmospheric pressure on the surface is roughly 90 atm which is the pressure you'd experience if you were 1,000 meters underwater. Even modern nuclear attack submarines made out of titanium and high strength alloys can barely go past 800 meters without completely losing structural integrity so solder would probably be under way too much pressure to change phase from solid to liquid.
- aexaey 10y ago> under way too much pressure to change phase from solid to liquid. Nope. 90 bar is way too little for that. You'll need to crank up pressure to ~70 kilobar to get solid tin a at 460'C (733'K). [1] [1] https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Phase_diagram_of_tin_(1975).png https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Phase_diagram_of_tin...
- WaxProlix 10y agoTo clarify for anyone as dim as I - Venus is 460C (860F) and is hotter to be sure than a typical soldering station, which runs at around 340C (or 650F) - it's not the case that Venus is 460C hotter than a reflow oven.
- logfromblammo 10y agoThis is where a grammar enthusiast might extol the virtues of the em dash. > ...while Venus is 460C (860F)--hotter than a reflow oven, to be sure.
- th0ma5 10y agoThe is intense. I've often thought about the Russian Venus lander. In the same vein I occasionally think about what could survive deep within the Earth. Of course I then immediately get tripped up wondering if any useful satellite could be made to work within the Sun, and that's where I realize I should just think about something else.
- mirimir 10y agoIn The Killing Star by Charles Pellegrino and George Zebrowski, one group of survivors orbits a ship around the Sun, just below the chromosphere. There's also a story about "distilling antihydrogen" near the Sun, in Vernor Vinge's Marooned in Realtime.
- masklinn 10y agoDavid Brin's Uplift series had mechanised lifeforms "floating" on the sun to collect matter, and IIRC Sundiver has life forms floating in the chromosphere.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoAs I recall, Sundiver used a laser to beam away the accumulated heat into space faster than it was absorbed.
- mathgenius 10y agoBuilding a quantum computer often gets compared to building a (regular) computer that can operate inside the sun.
- marcosdumay 10y agoMeasured by log(hot_temperature/cold_temperature), we are actually much closer to the sun than to current quantum computers or even space.
- rabboRubble 10y agoI recall a story from a Russian aerospace engineer describing a Russian unmanned probe to Venus. They mounted a camera and arm to the probe to take pictures and to measure the chemical composition of the planet's surface. He said the camera cover popped off at the appropriate moment to land exactly where the arm hit the ground. They got a very good measurement of the camera cap's chemical composition. I'll see if I can dig up a link. Found it... actually the arm was to measure the compress-ability of the Venusian soil https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venera_14#Landing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venera_14#Landing
- westbywest 10y agoActually, the camera was embedded deep inside the probe's pressure vessel. The aperture on the probe's surface was glazed with a quartz window, and the image projected through a long periscope arrangement to the sensor inside.
- Jun8 10y agoThe thing that struck me was the Glenn Extreme Environments Rig (GEER), (https://geer.grc.nasa.gov/geer-overview/overview-of-geer/ https://geer.grc.nasa.gov/geer-overview/overview-of-geer/). That thing is a beast! Operating 24 days with 470 C and 1400 psia gas mixture (including acids) sounds like an amazing feat.
- Robotbeat 10y agoI think I have some pictures of it that I took while I was an intern there. It's basically an autoclave with fancy gases.
- general_ai 10y agoIt just blows my mind that Soviet Venera landers were sending digital (!) images back from the surface of Venus in early 80s. This would be a heck of an achievement even today some 35 years later.
- tmsldd 10y agoYeah, amazing achievement... there are many applications scenarios where the old vacuum tubes are still unbeatable ..
- Animats 10y agoFinally! We need more info about Venus. Mars is a boring desert. Venus has more action. So when do we see a Venus rover?
- Sir_Cmpwn 10y agoCertainly not any time soon. A rover has a lot of complicated moving parts that will have to be exposed to work properly, and will almost certainly fail after a short time on the surface. All of the sensors will also have to be exposed, and the interface between the sensors and the enclosure will be vulnerable. A lander may work for some time, but a rover would be very difficult. Venus is a very, very harsh place.
- Animats 10y agoSo is the drilling end of an oil well, but there are sensors and motors for that.[1] "The heavy duty motor range is designed to withstand temperatures over 240°C at pressures up to 1,733 atmospheres. They can withstand vibrations to 25 Grms, impacts to 100 G." A 2005 study indicates how to get motors to run at up to 500°C, which is above what's needed for Venus.[2] Power systems for a Venus lander have been studied by NASA.[2] Sodium-sulfur batteries, which need to be hot to work at all, were considered. [1] http://www.maxonmotorusa.com/maxon/view/application/Brushless-DC-motors-for-down-hole-and-directional-drilling http://www.maxonmotorusa.com/maxon/view/application/Brushles... [2] https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20140017762.pdf https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/201400... [2] http://www.firstmarkaerospace.com/pdf/vhtmotors.pdf http://www.firstmarkaerospace.com/pdf/vhtmotors.pdf
- curtis 10y agoElectronics aren't the only problem for a Venus probe. You also need some way to power the thing. One interesting possibility is that lithium will combust in a carbon dioxide atmosphere, and it is also, conveniently, liquid at Venus surface temperature. http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20160705-the-toughest-spaceship-weve-ever-built http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20160705-the-toughest-spaces...
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIdea: put a good insulator under the surface of the probe to keep as much of it as cool as possible (first making sure it cools off in space). Ship it with a thermoelectric generator. I'm not sure how much useful power you'd get from the spacy-cool - Venus hell temperature gradient, so maybe it's a stupid idea.
- Sunset 10y agoPark a satellite in orbit and beam down energy.
- geon 10y agoWhat would be the total energy required to heat the probe from space cold to venus hot? That's your theoretical maximum output. Assuming the probe doesn't heat up during entry.
- masklinn 10y ago> first making sure it cools off in space Heat dissipation is actually a gigantic problem in space: you can only radiate heat away (and try to reflectively shield against the sun) since you're in hard vacuum which is a fantastic insulator.
- simonbarker87 10y agoNice to see this area is still evolving, my PhD was in SiC-related tech, specifically how would you power a device embedded in a hostile environment so I was researching SiC-based photovoltaics, temperature response of piezoelectrics, high-temperature DC-DC converters and a very light touch effort on high-temperature storage. As soon as you start heating electronics up to these sorts of temperatures the things we already take for granted become problematic. As highlighted already, solder joints become a huge pain, wire bonds pop off, even just building the test rigs to test these devices is usually a pretty interesting problem - I built a high-temperature photovoltaic characterization rig and a high-temperature vibration rig, which was involved enough but the true monster was the gas-sensor characterisation lab which had evolved over many years that could do gas, high pressure and temperature up to 700 degC (I think). All good fun, if someone is looking at a PhD in electronics I would recommend this area if even vaguely interested as it's a good mix of practical and theory and when you can't even bank on your solder joints holding, let alone a dielectric surviving then it makes for some interesting problems away from the pure electronics.
- SticksAndBreaks 10y agoCould some genetic engineered plants survive the upper layers of the atmosphere if they where able to fly/float?
- runholm 10y ago"While Venus’s surface is awful, its upper atmosphere is surprisingly Earthlike. 55 kilometers up, a human could survive with an oxygen mask and a protective wetsuit; the air is room temperature and the pressure is similar to that on Earth mountains. You need the wetsuit, though, to protect you from the sulfuric acid." https://what-if.xkcd.com/30/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/30/ (not quite a scientific source, so make what you want of it) Maybe if your plants can deal with the acid you might be able to do it. (I am not a biologist, chemist or anything relevant to answer this question, this is just my best guess).
- mirimir 10y agoSome bacteria would be OK with that.
- sohkamyung 10y agoExploring the atmosphere of Venus has been considered. Here's an article on it [1] [1] "NASA Study Proposes Airships, Cloud Cities for Venus Exploration" http://spectrum.ieee.org/aerospace/space-flight/nasa-study-proposes-airships-cloud-cities-for-venus-exploration http://spectrum.ieee.org/aerospace/space-flight/nasa-study-p...
- mcbits 10y agoVenus has very little water, so a starting point would be to launch large solar-powered balloons that just float around and collect water by cracking the sulfuric acid in the clouds. Living systems also require a lot of trace minerals that would have to be harvested from the surface. I think it could all be done, but probably not for a price that anyone is willing to pay.
- Symmetry 10y ago
- jeff_vader 10y agoHas anyone ever bumped into similar articles about electronics longevity? Sayyy.. Could we build a simple Voyager like probe that can last 1000 years? 10000?
- jerf 10y agoGiven the challenges involved in making a 10,000 year clock, a 10,000 year space probe seems currently infeasible: http://longnow.org/clock/ http://longnow.org/clock/ Putting it in space opens up some advantages, though that comes with its own whackload of disadvantages, too. Perhaps you could stick something in permanent shade on the moon to avoid 10,000 years of thermal stress, for instance, but you've got a decent chance of something hitting you hard enough to break something over that time span, too.
- avian 10y agoSome sources claim that in the 1980s USSR already developed instruments that were capable of operating at surface environment of Venus as part of their Venera program. From [1]: While never deployed, a seismometer and thermopile battery were developed and tested, capable of operating indefinitely on the surface of Venus. [1] http://mentallandscape.com/V_Venera11.htm http://mentallandscape.com/V_Venera11.htm
- imglorp 10y agoA closely related subject is radiation. If you want to explore Jupiter, Saturn, or Fukushima you have some new challenges. In the latter case, they're talking only a few hours of lifetime for ROV's going into the 500+ Sv/hr environment. I bet the military has a bunch of research on rad-hard equipment they're not keen to share. http://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/fukushima-reactor-shows-highest-radiation-level-initial-meltdown-180962050/ http://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/fukushima-reactor-s...
- Robotbeat 10y agoInterestingly, with a few hundred gates you can produce the circuitry needed to digitize data from a seismometer (one of the main reasons you'd want a long-duration lander on Venus), do some basic forward error correction, and transmit to a relay satellite. You'd have basically no memory, since memory is extremely expensive energy-wise and consumes a lot of gates, so you would just transmit the data as it is received. Just a few hundred gates is not unreasonable to make out of these relatively primitive high temperature circuits. A full computer with memory is not feasible, but neither is it required to accomplish the mission. Here is a paper describing a Venus mission operating entirely at high temperature using the kinds of digital circuits I described: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/272522839_Venus_high_temperature_atmospheric_dropsonde_and_extreme-environment_seismometer_HADES https://www.researchgate.net/publication/272522839_Venus_hig...