5 ms·
Indicated airspeed is based on the force of the oncoming air, and decreases as air gets less dense. There's some altitude where 358kt indicated is Mach 0.9. Ed
by mikeash 10y ago
Indicated airspeed is based on the force of the oncoming air, and decreases as air gets less dense. There's some altitude where 358kt indicated is Mach 0.9.
Edit: before I get more replies attempting to lecture me on how wrong I am, please look up the difference between true airspeed (how fast the air is moving past the airplane) and indicated airspeed (a measurement derived from the difference between static and dynamic pressure on the aircraft that only matches how fast the air is moving when you're at sea level).
- lutusp 10y ago> There's some altitude where 358kt indicated is Mach 0.9. Not really: http://www.aerospaceweb.org/question/atmosphere/q0112.shtml http://www.aerospaceweb.org/question/atmosphere/q0112.shtml
- mikeash 10y agoThose tables make no reference to indicated airspeed.
- sk5t 10y agoThanks for the clarification. Is it normal to refer to kts with the assumption this is related to pressure on the airframe and not actual airspeed? The reference to the 365KIAS rating later in the article provides only a clue IMO.
- mikeash 10y agoIt literally says "indicated air speed." There's no need for interpretation or assumption. If I saw a raw airspeed without and qualifier, I'd probably assume it meant indicated speed. But I fly small planes where that's the only airspeed available. If you want true airspeed, you have to take what's indicated and convert manually.
- sk5t 10y agoSo it does. I still find this disunion of UOM disagreeable, in the way that "in thousandths, take 300 grams of acetaminophen twice daily" is troubling.
- mikeash 10y agoI'm not familiar with that one. Does that mean to take 300mg?
- Filligree 10y agoI hope so. It sure as hell can't mean 300g, and anything other than mg would be crazy, but I'm not feeling very confident here.
- NamTaf 10y agoWhy? Do you take issue to the fact that scales show you a measurement in kg rather than N despite it varying as you move around the world (and potentially with changes in temperature, depending on the type of scales)? Velocity/mass is far more intuitive than pressure/force even if they don't apply exactly the same in all cases. It's about what works easiest for the users of the system.
- Dylan16807 10y agokg/N varies, but by less than your normal margin of error. That's vastly different from deciding to use newtons to weigh "kilograms indicated" on your trip to mars when they give a vastly different number.
- NamTaf 10y agoMy point was that we don't weigh ourself in 'newtons' despite that being what we are actually measuring. We make some reference conversion to a much more intuitive unit, kilograms. We rely on the fact that it's a pretty constant conversion between the two. Is this really much different than that? I don't think so. The aerodynamics of the plane (stresses on the structure, performance of the aircraft w.r.t. stall, etc.) all remain ~constant for a given IAS which is why it's used. We're just making a dynamic pressure measurement and converting it to a speed in such a way that it factors in all the environmental conditions that influence what we actually care about - how the plane responds in the air.
- sokoloff 10y ago"KIAS" is literally "knots indicated air speed" "KTAS" would be "knots true air speed" It's no more a clue than "mph" would be a clue for "miles per hour", IMO
- sk5t 10y agoYes, my suggestion is that KIAS is an okay UOM, and knots is inappropriate/confusing. However, unlike the xkcd strip about HO model trains, I'm not ready to mount a ferocious defense with regard to this thing I just heard about.
- djrogers 10y agoThat's not correct. At 33,00 ft, Mach 0.9 is about 600Kts, the altitude charts don't go high enough for Mach 0.9 to be 358Kts - by that point yo haven't enough air to transmit sound. And if you're implying that 358kts indicated could be 600kts actual with the right tailwind - that's true, but it still wouldn't be Mach 0.9, as the speed of sound applies only to airflow over the airplane. No matter the tailwind, the airflow will remain subsonic. If this weren't the case, passenger liners could go supersonic with a 200kt tailwind all day long...
- mikeash 10y agoIt has nothing to do with wind. 358kts indicated at 30,000ft translates to about 670kts true airspeed, for example. It's purely a result of how airplanes measure speed. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indicated_airspeed https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indicated_airspeed
- jsmthrowaway 10y agoNeither is this. An airplane measures indicated airspeed by sampling dynamic pressure. This happens to be useful because it has a direct correlation to various important V-speeds, such as the speed where a wing in a certain configuration generates enough lift for forward flight and so on. This is why an aircraft's V-speeds are given in KIAS. (Put another way, you get the density altitude calculation for free by relying on IAS, as the airplane gets more "inaccurate" with altitude but in actuality "accurate" from the perspective of fluids traveling over surfaces.) As an airplane gains altitude, IAS dramatically falls versus true airspeed due to this measurement artifact. Complicating this calculation for someone approaching it physically, as you have: by regulation all aircraft calibrate to the same altimeter pressure (29.92 inHg) beyond 18,000 feet. If you think about this physically, that means a whole bunch of airplanes indicate 35,000 feet but in actuality linger around 34,000 or 36,000 or something depending on the actual atmospheric pressure. That also affects how airspeed is calculated, meaning you can't say "well, at 33,000 feet, Mach 0.9 is blah." That computation is a little more nuanced based on the way aircraft sensors are set up and, until computers, required a whiz wheel. 'mikeash is correct, here. You're correct for TAS. IAS is a weird aerospace-specific thing where it's actually helpful to be wrong. I know. To the point of the article, too, the computer worked to avoid exceeding Vne and probably started intervening after passing Vno, which are both figures given in KIAS because both rely on how thick the air is. (Everything in this comment applies to subsonic flight, and the entire calculus changes when you're >=Mach 1.)
- DonaldFisk 10y agoThin and very cold air. The altitude was 33000 feet (FL330). Assuming a ground temperature of 15 celsius and a drop in temperature of 2 degrees per 1000 feet gives an OAT of -51 celsius. My flight computer converts 358KIAS @ 33000feet @ -51celsius to 620KTAS, which is Mach 0.94. FL = flight level (hundreds of feet) KIAS = knots indicated air speed KTAS = knots true air speed OAT = outside air temperature