7 ms·
Romania is developing its own culture of protests
- PunchTornado 10y agoIt is always a bit awkward to stop a protest once you achieved your primary goal. You are now a lot of people in the streets, with a lot of power, the government backs off. Should you ask for more or stick to the original requests that are now satisfied?
- Sylphine 10y agoOur president Claus Iohannis has started a war with the winning party PSD. He encouraged people to protest against PSD and now supporters of PSD are protesting against Iohannis. I'm ashamed by my country but hey it could be worse.
- ropiku 10y agoI wouldn't put it like that. He encouraged anti-corruption protests, it's just that PSD decided to support corruption. Nobody is protesting the election results. The people continue to protest the current government because they showed themselves to be untrustworthy. They backed down right now under pressure but who says they won't give another executive order in the middle of the night when no one is looking ?
- Sylphine 10y ago"He encouraged anti-corruption protests." This executive order was talked about with ECHR and Italy had a similar project this has nothing to do with corruption. source: http://www.echr.coe.int/Documents/Speech_20170127_Raimondi_JY_ENG.pdf http://www.echr.coe.int/Documents/Speech_20170127_Raimondi_J... http://www.reuters.com/article/us-italy-drugs-law-idUSBREA1B1FF20140212 http://www.reuters.com/article/us-italy-drugs-law-idUSBREA1B... "they won't give another executive order in the middle of the night when no one is looking ?" It has become self evident to me that we need a Donald Trump so maybe our fellow Romanians get back into reality. EDIT: P.S. The echr source talks about the problem but discussion have taken place. Also i it find a bit alarming that the case creation rate has increased so unpredictably. I quote "Firstly, with regard to Hungary and Romania, for which the number of cases increased by 95% and 108% respectively in 2016". What does this suggest? I remaind you that 2016 was a year in which Iohannis's technocratic government ruled
- rootlocus 10y agoAre you comparing abuse of political power and stealing public money with "selling, cultivating or possessing cannabis"? Because, if we want to relax jail sentences, corrupt politicians should not be the first ones to benefit from it.
- adrian_b 10y agoThe increase in the number of ECHR cases during a year suggests absolutely nothing about the government of that year. Almost all such cases are about trials that have a long history. Trials that have begun 10 years or more ago and that are not solved yet, are not uncommon. So whatever abuses are the subject of complaints, they might be the fault of a government of many years ago. As ECHR is reached after exhausting all other means, it is almost impossible for an ECHR case to refer to an abuse happened during the same year.
- petre 10y agoItaly. Another country previously ran by the Mafia.
- lexama 10y agoThe protests are not about president Klaus Iohannis, are about how the government tried to steal in the middle of the night, like thieves after they said they wouldn't pass that law. Of course the president is biased toward a side, but he didn't send people out on the streets. People were already there and some of them weren't even keen on the president.
- cmarinas 10y agoYeah, right... The government passes an emergency ordinance quietly during the night, aimed at saving the party's leader, and you blame the president. IOW, people shouldn't think for themselves because there are leaders elected to do just that. What I'm really ashamed of is that there are still many Romanian citizens who think that leaders are allowed to steal as long as they give a little bit in return (for those who were old enough in December '89, any similarities to "give them another hundred lei..."?).
- CrystalLangUser 10y agoMy parents fled Romania. What is the significance of that phrase?
- garrettgrimsley 10y agoDuring Ceaușescu's final speech he offered to raise the salary of workers by 200 lei per month to placate the rebelling crowd. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ceau%C8%99escu%27s_final_speech https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ceau%C8%99escu%27s_final_speec...
- petre 10y agoOnly you had nothing to buy with 200 lei aside from vinegar and bean jars or maybe save for a Dacia for which you'd have no gas because it was rationalized.
- chimen 10y agoFunny that you're doing politics on the internet but fail to write your president's name correctly. The president has nothing to do with the issue discussed by the way.
- sysdyne 10y agoThe so called president deserves only a impeachment and while you are at judging other people read the ordinance. http://www.dreptonline.ro/legislatie/oug_13_2017_modificare_lege_286_2009_codul_penal_lege_135_2010_codul_procedura_penala.php http://www.dreptonline.ro/legislatie/oug_13_2017_modificare_...
- chimen 10y agoDon't copy paste. This is the 2nd time you answer me with this link and same words. Are you at work?
- stefantalpalaru 10y ago> Claus Iohannis The most ridiculous adaptation I've seen so far. The guy's name is German and it was originally spelled "Klaus Johannis". During the presidential election, he changed his last name's spelling to "Iohannis" to make it seem more Romanian, even though the German minority in Romania has always been held in high regard (yes, positive ethnic stereotypes do exist). I guess the next step would be "Claudiu Ionescu" :-)
- nonick 10y agoActually, his name was always Iohannis, because in the communist period (when he was born) the state would try and romanize all foreign names. I know quite a few Hungarians in my home town who were given untranslatable Hungarian names just to avoid having their name translated to Romanian. The same happened during the Austro-Hungarian rule of Transylvania (<1918) but, of course, the other way round. Back to the President, indeed he used Johannis before the election because his family has always been called like that. Since going into the election campaign he switched to the official spelling that would appear on the ballot and in all the documents that he signs.
- RodericDay 10y agoIs this really awkward in practice, or are you imagining so as an observer trying to make sense of protestors?
- Sylphine 10y agoI think its awkward in both positions but the protesters have objectives. The "Victoria" protesters want to see the government formed in January to resign and the "Cotrocenii" protesters want for President Claus Iohannis to resign.
- rocgf 10y agoYeah, but I think you left out the fact that, at its peak, there were 300k "Victoria" protesters and 3k "Cotroceni" protesters. The "Cotroceni" protests are a joke.
- Sylphine 10y agoYou seem to forget that we live in a representative democracy. When the government was formed (PSD + ALDE) in January it won by a majority and there are no reasonable facts on why the government should resign. I want to remind you that when the "Colective" horror happened the government resigned (PSD) but when a similar incident happened in the USA the president or any government official didn't resign. If you think that we are more advanced than the american democracy then you sir ignore certain facts. source:http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2016/12/04/oakland-warehouse-fire-ghost-ship/94950350/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2016/12/04/oakland...
- fa17 10y agoRight, there was a protest in Chennai not a month ago to lift ban on Jallikattu(a local sport) and the local Govt passes a law in a week to allow this. but the protesters refused to leave the place(beach) after all the demands were met and eventually it got ugly, a police station was set on fire and the Govt had to use force.
- baby 10y ago> Jallikattu (a local sport) Holy shit, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w_bOtexFNXo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w_bOtexFNXo > a Bos indicus bull is released into a crowd of people and multiple human participants attempt to grab the large hump of the bull with both arms and hang on to it while the bull attempts to escape. Participants hold the hump for as long as possible, attempting to bring the bull to a stop. In some cases, participants must ride long enough to remove flags on the bull's horns. I love learning about new sports like that. More: * Zurkhaneh, weird workout in Iran https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BTHvXX-Qicw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BTHvXX-Qicw * Kabaddi, amazing game where you have to make the other fall :D https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RSnP9z99I9M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RSnP9z99I9M
- glenneroo 10y agoDon't forget about Bo Taoshi: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D4OV-2uTFeg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D4OV-2uTFeg
- antognini 10y agoThere was a nice article about this in the Economist a week ago: http://www.economist.com/news/asia/21715686-why-indian-judges-must-bow-bovines-ugly-row-about-sacred-cows http://www.economist.com/news/asia/21715686-why-indian-judge...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- laughingman2 10y agoBut there were few police men burning vehicles which they blatantly deny as being "morphed". Seems like the govt wanted to smear bad name on the protest
- lifty 10y agoWhile the original reason that kickstarted the protest was a shady law passed through an emergency ordinance (not sure if that's an English term), the problem itself is much bigger. People are dissatisfied that the new government is trying to reduce the effectiveness of certain anti corruption institutions, which have aggressively processed corruption cases for the past couple of years. This has caused a lot of desperation among public sector workers, from low level counsel positions up to the highest parts of the government. I see this as a potential inflection point for Romania and I am curious which way it goes.
- rootlocus 10y agoThis sounds silly to me. Is it awkward to seek medical treatment after numbing the pain? Is it awkward to want the cure for the disease after treating a symptom? To the people, achieving the primary goal is like stopping the bleeding from a gunshot wound. It's the first step in preventing something worse from happening, but it's not the last step in the fight against corruption. The bullet is still inside.
- GoToRO 10y agoPrimary goal was not achieved. They patched the original buggy law with another buggy law. When the second law will be invalidated, the first will take effect.
- oblio 10y agoTo be honest I'm quite proud how the protests went. More akin to Ghandi's protests than to rioters burning cars. It's going to be a long struggle but thankfully the groups most supportive of populism and therefore corruption are older (>50).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- chimen 10y agoYes. It's obvious we're leaving behind the old generation which loses it's grip. There's also the faint rising of a counter protest with a majority of old people and I'm certain they're being lied to or paid to go on the streets. The balance is obvious though and I'm proud of the outcome so far.
- chrishacken 10y ago> and I'm certain they're being lied to or paid to go on the streets You realize both sides use this argument? It's not that either side is being lied to or paid; some people simply have different viewpoints on issues, as hard as that is to believe.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- marcosdumay 10y agoAnd some people are lied to and paid. It's hard to see the difference from a distance, but as a general rule, always suspect the group that is in favor of the government. Even more if the protest is about investigating corruption.
- burkaman 10y agoNo, don't suspect anyone without evidence. You should always approach people with respect and engage with them as an individual who disagrees with you, unless you have a good reason not to.
- baby 10y agoIt's interesting that you currently have one of the largest "political" peaceful demonstrations in the world right now in Korea and in Romania and not many people are talking about it. (I'm happy to see this bit of news on HN.)
- mtgx 10y agoMost of the media is only interested in covering "violent protests" so they can help their buddies in power by discrediting the protesters. Those who watched the U.S. elections closely in 2015 and 2016 already know the media had zero interest in covering real issues, and they would much rather do a one-day marathon about Trump calling someone a pussy. And now the same media blames the Russians or whoever that Trump is in power, even though they are the ones making him a TV star with their non-stop coverage of him.
- baby 10y ago> Most of the media is only interested in covering "violent protests" This is sadly true. I saw one popular video being shared on facebook, targeting a more American audience, and they would only show violent videos from the protests (which have been overwhelmingly peaceful).
- fennecfoxen 10y agoIf you think, as you seem to imply, that most of the media wants to help Donald Trump by discrediting his protestors, then I am shocked, because that would mean that most of the media wants to help Trump. However, I have no idea what rational argument could persuade you otherwise, as there is surely AMPLE evidence out there of animosity between the two and a loathing which both sides have freely admitted to.
- jpkeisala 10y agoI agree but perhaps its about to change. I am sure individual journalists will continue to hate what he represent but maybe in the boardroom they have already seen how just to analyze his tweets sells papers and clicks more easily than anything else.
- delegate 10y agoWe're seeing another "social media revolution" - fuelled by Facebook (et al) on one side and old-school TV stations controlled by local oligarchs on the other. Young, high tech, well-dressed, global 'hipsters' who live online versus older people, mostly rural, former communists, peasants or factory workers, who have no hope of adapting to the new incomprehensible tech world around them. People from the first group work mostly at multinationals or are entrepreneurs/artists/etc while the second group live on state pensions or have administrative roles offered by the ruling political party - the modernised communists. First group are people who've tasted freedom and are trying to live 'independent' lives, while the second group cannot imagine living without a strict social hierarchy, in which one must do what he's told - vestige of the communist system, in which everybody had his 'master'. The second group has had numerical majority in the December elections - because of better mobilisation, so they elected the party who promised them higher pensions and other populist dreams.. We've seen this phenomenon play out in many countries already. So far these protests have been peaceful - these young people know how to behave peacefully in crowds - after having enjoyed themselves at massive festivals and concerts that have invaded the post-communist Romania in the last decade or so. Let's hope that they stay that way - there are some evil slogans being shouted on both sides, but so far the youth has had the upper hand, combined with the moral handicap of the second group - turns out not all of them want to save the criminals and corrupt oligarchs from prisons. What's next ? The crowd won, the government withdrew the controversial ordinance, but how will they be able to continue business as usual now that they've accepted their own incompetence just one month after taking office ? Will they do another stupid thing and have the crowds 'fix' it for them ? If this happens, then why not actually implement it in software and avoid massive mobilisation risking all kinds of crowd-related dangers ? Unfortunately this is where Facebook falls short - it's good at creating massive crowds - but stops being useful once crowds are in place. I think it's up to Romanians now to invent a new system of government, where the crowd can have a voice without filling the streets every week. Representative democracy is unable to cope with the new technological realities so I think it's time to move on to the next level of governance. Time to move the government into the smartphones - replace Facebook with 'Society OS' (or extend Facebook to include it). My biggest hope is that the transition to this new society will be peaceful and devoid of violence.
- 10y ago
- samsonradu 10y agoI had a very positive feeling about the people's atitude and what they achieved by protesting, considering that the government did a terrible thing from all points of view. There was probably no other way to roll it back but for how things went. However I'm concerned though that the majority of people misuse their voting power and make bad choices. It happened that the oposition wanted to stop this and all the media was encouraging people to go out and protest. Think what happens when both parties/coalitions agree on a bad law/resolution and it all goes under the table. Point is this is not the way to go on the long term. We were lucky this time but it's gonna fail soon. We need to educate people better in hope that they will cast their vote properly.
- rumcajz 10y agoDirect democracy could help here. Ask people whether they want to decriminalize corruption and even those who voted for populists are going to say no.
- paulnechifor 10y agoAre you sure about that? The president did trigger a referendum on this, but the ruling party jumped the gun and passed (and now revoked) this law before the referendum question was even finalized. The referendum will still go ahead. Even if you phrase the question as "Do you want to decriminalize corruption?", or a more probable "Do you agree with softening the legislation toward combating corruption?" a significant amount of people will say yes, not because they think corruption is good, but rather they've been lead to believe that the National Anticorruption Directorate is biased toward PSD (the successor to the communist party). (Small note, the two main networks saying this are Antena 3 (whose owner is in prison and would have benefited from this law) and Romania TV (whose owner is on the loose and on Europol's most wanted list).)
- petre 10y agoThe Anticorruption Directorate is not biased. They just happened to catch more criminals out of PSD simply because PSD is ridden by criminals. It is the party of the former communist secret police and their friends, disguised as socialists.
- jjawssd 10y agoThe very first question people should be asking is if these are organic protests or part of something bigger.
- alexgotoi 10y agoAs one of the firsts protestants, I can tell you that is an organic one. Everyone is sharing the same scope: fight against corruption in RO.
- subpixel 10y agoI just watched and enjoyed Cristian Mungiu's latest film (Graduation) about a parent who gets caught up in government corruption while trying to ensure that his child gets a chance to leave the Romania for college. Two thumbs up. https://www.theguardian.com/film/2016/may/19/graduation-review-cristian-mungiu-romania-cannes-2016 https://www.theguardian.com/film/2016/may/19/graduation-revi...
- padrian2s 10y agoHello World! From Romania. I am 37yr old and for the last 13yr software developer. That's why I'm writing on HN, my primary SRC of information for the last 7 yr. First of all, please look at Romania, look what we are doing and for what we are fighting and do a _replicate_ on your Country IIf your Gov does not respect your primary rights or you feel that your nation is going into the wrong direction. (America, Poland and Hungary, can YOU hear us?) Also, what is important, we, people from RO Street, fully support European Union. The most important Peace Project ever created. We Love EU. Please fight for EU, do not let anyone tear us apart. We must remain strong to our European culture and principles. I do apologize if my message is too political with respect to HN nature. We know that America is 1st. But, can we say... Romania 2nd? Best regards!
- petre 10y agoThere's even a game: http://psdinvaders.com/ http://psdinvaders.com/