12 ms·
House Passes E-mail Privacy Act
- msravi 10y agoDoes this also encompass the providers' "reading" emails to place appropriate ads and/or services? For example, I noticed recently, that if I have a hotel booked, Google "reads" my email and annotates Google maps with the dates of my booking. Does this act apply only to the government's access to email or also the provider's? Edit: Also, does the government need a warrant only for US citizens' accounts or for anyone's emails stored on US servers?
- foota 10y agoSounded like it was just about government reading based on the earlier conversation.
- rtkwe 10y agoThat functionality is one of the big reasons I love GMail. Automatically pulling out flight, hotel, and package information is really convenient.
- twsted 10y agoIt is often convenience versus privacy. It's unfortunate (in my opinion) that most people choose convenience, without realizing that value of privacy.
- vectorjohn 10y agoPrivacy has literally no tangible value to most people. It's just a warm fuzzy to a few, and a practical value to even fewer. Convenience on the other hand has obvious value to almost everyone.
- ozi 10y agoWe seem to be fast approaching a time where people realize they want their privacy. Saying you don't care about privacy because you have nothing to hide is like saying do you don't care about free speech because you have nothing to say.
- qball 10y ago>Privacy has literally no tangible value to most people. It's just a warm fuzzy to a few, and a practical value to even fewer. There is evidence showing the cost is real, though it's difficult to put a pricetag on missed opportunities. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13571554 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13571554
- Buge 10y agoGoogle has to be able to read your emails, otherwise they wouldn't be able to index them for you to search through. Or do spam detection.
- mc32 10y agoIf your company is using google apps, this would be one of the things of concern. How could you ensure none of your trade secrets are unintentionally leaking via meta data, etc... Unless every account is self-contained and isolated and encrypted at rest and they don't retain a master/admin key.
- stuckagain 10y agoLeaking to whom?
- mc32 10y agoI'll leave that up to your imagination. Additionally, imagine you have an email archive policy but occasionally you need to have some messages deleted, for compliance reasons, do they get deleted from all places they existed in google infrastructure? Are that henceforth irretrievable by google?
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoYou should never assume this. If compliance and assurance that nobody can read your emails is important, you shouldn't be hosting them on Gmail.
- stuckagain 10y agoAre there legitimate cases where compliance requires deleting materials? That sounds like compliance avoidance, not compliance itself.
- mc32 10y agoIf your legal tells you the legal from another entity wants their correspondence deleted, for some valid reason, you are compelled to carry that out.
- rpedela 10y agoOnly government.
- jimbo999 10y agoYou have opted in to that "reading" of your email as a convenience to yourself. Any purpose a government puts to that "voluntary" disclosure remains to be seen.
- dgoldstein 10y agoDefinitely this only applies to government (esp law enforcement) requests. Re: does it just protect US citizens or everyone's emails: dunno. That's a great question. My guess is that it's aimed at US citizens but I imagine agreements like privacy shield may extend those rights to some non citizens. IANAL though and am mostly speculating.
- Veratyr 10y agoHow though is Google parsing your email and annotating Google Maps any different to simply showing you the email in your inbox? It's providing you alone with another way to read your own email.
- hendersoon 10y agoThis bill is great in that email stored on your ISP's (or Google's) servers is treated identically to that on your computer at home-- they need to get a warrant. That's a great step forward. It isn't BS. However, it doesn't address intercepting and recording communications in-transit, which is extremely commonplace these days. Technically american intelligence agencies need a warrant to eavesdrop on american citizens. But in practice, they can get around this by recording _everything_ (full take), indexing it, and limiting their searches against communications by US citizens where they either talk to a foreigner or match a search query on a nefarious keyword. [1] They wave away violating the 4th amendment of the US constitution by saying that copying, storing, indexing, and searching through US citizens' private information is OK as long as a human doesn't read it. "Full take" sounds incredible-- it entails recording and retaining EVERYTHING passing through the internet. But we know it's possible. Snowden revealed that the UK GCHQ has been doing it since at least 2013 with their Tempora system [2]. Snowden also revealed the NSA's very similar XKeyscore system. At the time of his leaks, the NSA did not do Full Take... but that was several years ago. It's very reasonable to assume that everything, EVERYTHING, you do on the internet is recorded and stored by the government. This bill does not address that. That's why it's absolutely critical that everything you do is end-to-end encrypted. These government agencies have the resources to crack most encryption, too [3] but at least you aren't making it trivial. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XKeyscore https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XKeyscore [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tempora https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tempora [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullrun_(decryption_program) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullrun_(decryption_program)
- jcranmer 10y ago> However, it doesn't address intercepting and recording communications in-transit, which is extremely commonplace these days. MTA<->MTA SMTP transmission is increasingly SSL these days, and end-user MUA<->MTA transmission has pretty much been entirely SSL for a long while. Google cites about 80-90% of its MTA<->MTA transmission is encrypted (https://www.google.com/transparencyreport/saferemail/ https://www.google.com/transparencyreport/saferemail/).
- hendersoon 10y ago
- filka 10y agoSo Hillary is not going to jail after all? So sad!
- teekert 10y agoI'm not fully aware of the inner workings of American politics, but, did Trump have any role in this? Edit "The House has acted to protect Americans' privacy. Now it's up to the Senate and the President to do the same." Ok, so he might kill it yet. I'm curious how this will end.
- kijin 10y agoIf there is enough political will in the House and Senate, they can override even the President's veto. I wouldn't count on that happening anytime soon, though.
- typetypetype 10y agoFor what it's worth, this bill passed the house unanimously (aka veto proof).
- burkaman 10y agoIt did last year too, and then the Senate blocked and essentially killed it with amendments.
- hendersoon 10y agoIt's only been two weeks and the thrust of the law is directly contrary to his goals of ends justifying the means, protection at all costs, so I doubt that very much.
- hnal943 10y agoCongress makes laws. The President can try an persuade, but the ultimately can only either sign the bill or not.
- chinathrow 10y agoCtrl-f "National Security Letter" 0 results found.
- elif 10y agoI think this comment is down-voted for its terseness, but I think this is the most important point in the comments. National Security Letters and FISA court rulings create a legal mechanism to circumvent this entire bill and any other form of legislative or judicial oversight. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_security_letter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_security_letter https://www.theguardian.com/law/2016/oct/19/aclu-fisa-court-surveillance-laws-classified https://www.theguardian.com/law/2016/oct/19/aclu-fisa-court-...
- linkregister 10y agoI feel that the inclusion of NSLs is almost outside the scope of the bill. Furthermore, inclusion of prohibitions of NSLs would likely doom the bill. In this case, perfect would be the enemy of good. NSLs are a worthy topic for a bill in its own right or as an amendment to the next FISA reauthorization.
- elif 10y agoIMO, a bill titled "No one is allowed to murder" while actually only preventing Alice from murdering, and permitting Bob to continue his (more prevalent) murder spree, is a net loss. It is the false illusion of safety, which is more dangerous than a known threat.
- linkregister 10y agoStopping Alice from murdering is more dangerous? Interesting. (I don't agree with your analogy but I'm playing along)
- hendersoon 10y agoNSLs theoretically aren't valid for content that requires a warrant. Of course they do whatever they want and it's a secret court so citizens don't have the opportunity to debate it.
- e40 10y agoI have a hard time believing that the House would make this such an early part of its business without there being some exigent need. I wonder what scandal they are trying to forestall? I'm 100% serious. Every move they've made so far has been from a playbook. I doubt this one was done for the people.
- josteink 10y ago> I have a hard time believing that the House would make this such an early part of its business without there being some exigent need I'd like to picture it as if someone suddenly realized that giving the government too much power is a bad idea in case the wrong kind of person (Trump) gets put in charge. I like that thought. You're probably right though...
- burkaman 10y agoThis bill was originally introduced in 2013 and unanimously passed the House last year, it isn't new. It got blocked and then weakened in the Senate last year, so they're just trying again. In general I think the House is less theatrical and scripted than the Senate. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Email_Privacy_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Email_Privacy_Act
- un-devmox 10y agoThanks for the link. Interestingly in 2015, AG to be Sessions introduced an amendment that "would have exempted federal agents from the requirement to secure a warrant if the government asserts that an emergency situation exists." The bill was then withdrawn from consideration. Is there something similar attached to the current version?
- burkaman 10y agoNo, this bill is essentially identical to the version that was sent to the Senate last year. You can compare them here: https://www.congress.gov/114/bills/hr699/BILLS-114hr699rds.pdf https://www.congress.gov/114/bills/hr699/BILLS-114hr699rds.p... https://www.congress.gov/115/bills/hr387/BILLS-115hr387ih.pdf https://www.congress.gov/115/bills/hr387/BILLS-115hr387ih.pd... The only differences I saw are that it's now a BILL instead of an ACT, and they added the word "and" in one spot. As far as I can tell the amendments were not actually voted on last year; the bill was preemptively withdrawn because the sponsors thought passing a bill with the amendments would be worse than not passing it at all.
- miguelrochefort 10y agoWhat year is this? How come are people still expecting privacy? Don't you realize that privacy is unsustainable and selfish?
- eutropia 10y agoI'm not giving up my privacy until governments give up theirs.
- warent 10y agoGood answer :)
- miguelrochefort 10y agoThen why do you insist on having a government?