30 ms·
Trump Is Right: Silicon Valley Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Immigrants
- Apocryphon 10y agoThe title is a bit overly-polarizing; Prof. Matloff has been an outspoken critic of H-1Bs for quite some time, and only mentions the president once in the article. The actual EO isn't even out yet.
- ones_and_zeros 10y agoSince it is an OpEd, the title is chosen by the editor not the author.
- jordanb 10y agoSince it's huffpo they're probably AB testing several headlines to find the one with the most clickbait.
- d--b 10y agoI agree, this issue has been around for quite some time, but is just a matter of adjusting the application of a policy that has been abused. This issue has nothing to do with joblessness in the Midwest (and is certainly not of the same scale), that is mostly due to the departure of big manufacturing companies to foreign countries. This is what Trump was talking about: blaming immigrants and corporations for the loss of low-skilled jobs. No one in America cares that overpaid software developers loose their jobs to H1B workers...
- conjectures 10y agoIf you're going to do policy advocacy, it's a good idea to do it before the EO gets issued.
- PoarNeemn 10y agoOfcourse Trump is right, cucks just don't want to admit it
- youdontknowtho 10y agoBlind squirrel finds a nut sometimes...
- rdtsc 10y agoWhat do you mean by that?
- ars 10y agoSo when he does something you disagree with, he's evil? When he does something you agree with he's still evil, he just did it accidentally? And this is your chosen approach regarding people who disagree with you?
- zzleeper 10y ago> Their lobbyists claim there is a “talent shortage” among Americans and thus that the industry needs more of such work visas. This is patently false There is no way SV would have grown to what it is now without foreign talent. So the shortage has been real for the last 30+ years. Not sure why this point is still controversial. > most Silicon Valley firms sponsor their H-1B workers, who hold a temporary visa, for U.S. permanent residency (green card) [...] sponsorship renders the workers de facto indentured servants; though they have the right to move to another employer, they do not dare do so, as it would mean starting the lengthy green card process all over again. Then the problem might be with how long the gov takes to process these things, and not with the H1B visas? > the H-1B program is an enabler of rampant age discrimination in the tech industry [...] Almost all the H-1Bs are young Younger people are more willing to move to another country. Also, many students apply for an H1b after their F1 runs out, so of course you get younger people. And this is just from the first page. I feel like the author is just throwing every possible argument against the H1B, instead of making one good coherent point. =/
- ones_and_zeros 10y ago> There is no way SV would have grown to what it is now without foreign talent. So the shortage has been real for the last 30+ years. Not sure why this point is still controversial. Is this a fact or a feeling? Economics allows us to directly measure these things and the price of labor hasn't gone up in the last 30 years at rates indicating a shortage with executive pay and corporate profits at all time highs. > Then the problem might be with how long the gov takes to process these things, and not with the H1B visas? I think his point was the visa system is designed to take advantage of the inefficiencies in the bureaucracy to the benefit of the employer. > Younger people are more willing to move to another country. Also, many students apply for an H1b after their F1 runs out, so of course you get younger people. If the H1B visa didn't exist there wouldn't be as many foreign students. You should read his blog, he makes repeated coherent arguments against the H1B visa system and its detrimental effects on the employment outlook for older citizens. He is a CS professor at a respected US university and has an interesting perspective.
- yummyfajitas 10y ago
- at-fates-hands 10y agoHaving worked in a ton of different large corporations that have large H1-B employee populations, I can say this is completely true from my experience. In the last three places (including my current employer) there were huge swaths of H1-B's from India. After some long lunches and happy hours, I found out that a) they're being paid significantly less than I was and b) two of the three companies wouldn't sponsor them to stay at the company and come on as an FTE. This meant several trips and back and forth between the states and Bangalore to get a new visa, then turn around and try and find a new gig somewhere. For the developers who were single it wasn't a problem. Those workers with families, it was quite stressful to have their families moving back and forth on a regular basis and not having the stability of knowing they had a gig lined up or not. Toss in the fact getting these visa's are incredibly competitive and I can only imagine the stress involved.
- untog 10y agoJust as a counter-point (not saying your experience is incorrect at all), I've worked in the US on an H1B and was compensated very well, as were my co-workers. The system allows abuse, but doesn't guarantee it. I do wonder if the employees you mention know that an H1B is transferrable between employers. It's a time consuming process, but I'd love to see more people take advantage of those who abuse the visa by getting one, then immediately transferring it to an honest company that pays a fair salary.
- t1o5 10y ago> H1B is transferable between employers Its not easy as it sounds. Being a single that time, I have transferred my H1B myself and it was a nightmare. I had sleepless nights and uncertainty. My GreenCard process was reset. Any H1Bs who knows about the system really well will not risk transferring because of the risks to their green card process. There is no honest company which pays a fair salary for H1Bs. If you see the data from here: https://www.foreignlaborcert.doleta.gov/performancedata.cfm https://www.foreignlaborcert.doleta.gov/performancedata.cfm I have a huge circle of friends in many companies. We discuss our salaries and issues openly. Not one of them says that they are paid equal to their American colleagues. Moroever the promotions and salary raises goes to American colleagues, while the H1Bs bears it all to support the family with the income where his/her spouse is not allowed to work (H4 visa)
- TheRealDunkirk 10y agoTo me, this seems related to the 97 IT companies filing an amicus brief in the travel ban court case...
- yummyfajitas 10y agoI'll just suggest that it's probably a great time for tech companies to open a Bangalore or Gurgaon office. Bangalore in particular is a good choice - the people are smart, the infrastructure is good, and it's a very pleasant place to visit. Perfect weather all year and the best breakfast in India. Also a very strong tech culture; second in the world to SF, in my view, and without many of the social pathologies [1] that seem to be threatening SF. Rather than fighting with the legal system to replace one or two of your overpaid employees, you can replace entire divisions. It's certainly an investment of effort but it's well worth it. Plus if you need foreign talent, as long as you pay $25k/year the visa is more or less guaranteed. If the US wants to be uncompetitive, leave the US. [1] Meritocracy is still considered a core value and a great thing. There's a lot less xenophobia - while many in US tech harbor negative feelings about immigrants "who took our jorbs", I've literally never seen the same negativity in the Indian tech scene.
- garyfirestorm 10y agoBangalore Valley!
- falsestprophet 10y agoIn fairness, "expats giving us jobs" is hardly the same thing.
- pscsbs 10y agoYou must be joking about the infrastructure. Moving even a few kilometers can take hours due to all the traffic and lack of public transportation.
- dominotw 10y ago>can take hours Bunch of my friends suffer from a chronic cough and throat irritation from being exposed to traffic everyday. Not to mention the psychological fatigue that totally saps you before you even get to work. There is no way to escape constant air and sound pollution.
- 10y ago
- thecardcheat 10y ago> The industry lobbyists’ ace-in-the-hole argument is that if they can’t hire more H-1Bs, they’ll ship the work overseas. But for projects on which H-1Bs are hired in the U.S., face-to-face interaction (between themselves and their American coworkers) is crucial. That is why employers bring H-1Bs to the U.S. in the first place rather than sending the work abroad, where the wages are even cheaper. Considering the growth of tools that facilitate working remotely, and the flexibile schedule pursued by many software engineers, the willingness to ship jobs overseas is hard to merely cast aside. Visa workers should absolutely be paid a fair wage, and it seems a realistic side-effect that there may be a shift in the type of roles offered to visa employees vs. overseas when the cost of in-house now represents a premium on the foreign employee.
- mdorazio 10y agoKeep in mind, though, that a lot of H1Bs are being used as replacements for a typical IT department, not as the type of staff you could easily offshore, even with remote working technology. For example, at a Fortune 100 company I did quite a bit of consulting for, fully 60% of their IT staff was Infosys and Congnizant H1Bs. You could make the argument that some portion of those positions could be offshored, but realistically no large company would do that - they want people on-site too much. I don't think the rise of tools is really changing this mentality fast enough to make remote/offshore work a real possibility here in the near term.
- drabiega 10y agoI suspect that instead of shipping work overseas, you'd simply see a relaxation of attitudes on remote work. The US already has a large base of engineering talent that is willing to work for less but either won't or can't relocate to a tech hub. (Often because if they relocate to you they're going to want more money because of cost of living differences.)
- valuearb 10y agoThere is a significant advantage in doing the work here, but they'll still do some work overseas. And they'll start their own companies overseas and compete with us.
- master_yoda_1 10y agoI totally agree with the article.
- t1o5 10y agoex H1B here. Yes Trump is right.(though I do not like him personally, he is right in this matter) Most of the corporate America is exploiting H1B workers. I have worked in one of those firms and I have friends in many other firms. These are not Indian body shops, these are American companies. Everyone's topic of discussion when we hangout is how our H1B visas were being exploited and there is nothing we could do about it. We were bound to the employer with no hopes of promotion and the long wait for GreenCard (10 years). H1B has become a system to pay lower wages than a skilled visa. How can it be a skilled visa, if the visas are allocated based on lottery ? So we decided to do something about our situation. We started foraying into the immigration systems of other countries and we decided to use the express entry system of Canada. So we all applied for it ourselves, got evaluated for our skills & degrees and now I am happily typing this as a permanent resident from Canada. Express Entry System - http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/express-entry/grid-crs.asp http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/express-entry/grid-crs.asp
- garyfirestorm 10y agoThat is amazing! However I would like to point out, H1B is not only for Silicon Valley. There are many automotive companies which require foreign talent in specialized fields. Very smart people with multi-disciplinary knowledge are nowhere to be found in auto sector. Signal Processing and vibrations and programming and control systems understanding etc. is required to deal with things like active noise control which is now a need in auto sector. The Canadian Automotive R&D is not as good as in US. Also, there's no way we can work remotely. So our fates are still determined by 'lottery based skilled visa' allotments.
- t1o5 10y ago"lottery based skilled visa" sums it up. I am not assuming that you are in Detroit. I used to work remotely for an Automotive company in Detroit for their telematics unit. Some colleagues I know commute from Windsor.
- orcdork 10y agoLottery based skilled visa means that there's many more skilled people on the other side, and less spots for them. Unless you have a way of quantifying extremely small differences in skill (and keeping the process balanced), I don't see how you feel a lottery is unfair.
- program_whiz 10y agoOk what's the suprise here? If you give companies a chance to get cheaper "mostly the same" labor without a downside, or maybe with the upside they can't leave, they're going to take it. That's why I do believe globalization and the availability of huge amounts of cheap unregulated labor does hurt American jobs and industry. Its not xenophobia, its just common sense. I think if you look past any ideas of racism, xenophobia, etc, you'll see that in plain economic terms, Trump is right -- but it applies to every industry, not just SV. Imagine how if this is applicable to something requiring the skills of software development, how much more so it would be true of some low-skill job.
- d--b 10y agoIt's not obvious at all. Shipping lower skilled jobs to other countries mean higher margins for US companies. Which is good in itself for the US economy. Buying manufacturing from other countries means it's easier to sell stuff to them as well, which is also good to US economy. The fact is that the US has a very good overall economy, so maybe one has to look at the issue of redistribution of wealth for instance. Economy-wise, the problem is a lot more complex than what you make it appear. You can't just say: economically speaking it makes sense to close the borders...
- HillaryBriss 10y ago> Shipping lower skilled jobs to other countries mean higher margins for US companies. Which is good in itself for the US economy. US companies and the collection of US voters are different. Their interests do not always coincide. One might say that higher margins are "good for the US economy", but that doesn't mean they're good for every person participating in the US economy -- which is what the US voter cares more about. It's important to recognize that US Companies, to a great degree, are owned by shareholders. It is the shareholders who receive the profit. The fact that Walmart sells goods manufactured overseas, giving it higher margins, has allowed various members of the Walton family to become billionaires. But someone working as a Walmart greeter probably sees very little benefit. And, of course, the now unemployed US manufacturing workers/voters do benefit a little from Walmart's lower prices as customers. But, it's reasonable to question whether such workers are better off unemployed, even if they are able to buy cheap products from Walmart.
- gcb0 10y agotrump is rigth and wrong. the visas are abused. seen it first hand. but it can also be fixed by removing the artificial wait for some nationalities. doesn't he want to repel tons lof laws. here's an opportunity to solve both at the same time. creating yet more legislation and rules will make the problem worse.
- patrickg_zill 10y agoIt's not only SV, it is also the firms that supply telecom engineers under contract to the big mobile operators and related, such as Nokia, Ericsson, T-Mobile/ATT/Verizon/Sprint etc.
- ansy 10y agoCould H-1B be more effective? Yes. It could definitely be more fair to the visa holder and do a better job of attracting and retaining the most skilled workers. But I also think it's totally wrong to say we don't have a technology labor shortage. The best evidence of this are the salary numbers for people with math and science degrees. It's not because physics and math suddenly got more valuable. It's because tech is so starved for labor it's hiring people from different disciplines to do the job and it's actually brought the average salaries in line with CS and engineering graduates. Also, even if we had an adequate national labor supply, the job opportunities are not distributed proportional to population density. The density of technology jobs is highly concentrated in a few parts of the country, but we are producing qualified engineers everywhere. And not everyone is willing or able to move.
- chroem- 10y ago>But I also think it's totally wrong to say we don't have a technology labor shortage. The best evidence of this are the salary numbers for people with math and science degrees. It's not because physics and math suddenly got more valuable. It's because tech is so starved for labor it's hiring people from different disciplines to do the job and it's actually brought the average salaries in line with CS and engineering graduates. This series of claims is so different from the reality that myself and many others have observed that I don't even know where to begin. Physics graduates are literally jumping off of buildings because of how poor their employment prospects are. Can you provide any sources for the statements you just made?
- ansy 10y agohttp://www.payscale.com/college-salary-report/majors-that-pay-you-back/bachelors http://www.payscale.com/college-salary-report/majors-that-pa... #11 Physics & Mathematics $56,200 starting, $111,000 mid-career Compare that to Computer Science # 5 Computer Science (CS) & Engineering, starting $71,200, mid-career $116,000 Also, I work with and have interviewed many people with physics and math degrees. Granted, there's some sampling bias going on there. But the ones I know didn't really have prospects actually using their degrees in their respective fields unless they got a phd and went into academia. So they all went into tech one way or another.
- sulam 10y agoSpeaking as someone who has hired H1-B's in the past, there really do seem to be two tiers. There's the companies/organizations that are truly abusing the system and then there are the traditional tech companies who are happy to hire anyone qualified, no matter where they are from, and pay and promote them the same as other employees. They also sponsor green cards. Competition between these employers has gotten to the point where they mostly all do the sponsorship immediately, too, reducing the time the person is "stuck" in the job to around a year (not great, but not horrible -- most people are "stuck" in their job that long so that they will at least vest some of their stock-based compensation). One example: I hired an engineer who I'm going to anonymously name Bob. Bob was at Yahoo and on an H1-B. Yahoo was his first employer in SV, he had gone to CMU. He interviewed reasonably well, not amazingly, but had experience and interest in a specialty that many people aren't interested in. At the time we were trying to take a team of these people from 2 or 3 engineers to 20, so we were pretty excited. Bob also got an offer from Netflix. Netflix, if you don't know, gives offers that are basically "all-in" -- you can take the entire offer as cash, or you can parse it out and use some of it for health care, stock, etc -- your choice. The end result is that matching Netflix offers is very expensive. We mostly matched the Netflix offer (we felt our stock was going to have more upside -- which ended up being very true). I had to do extra work for this person to get them hired above and beyond what I'd have to do for an American. Then I had to do even more work to get the employer part of the green card process started. I had to help them navigate getting required documentation from Yahoo. Bob got promoted on a similar schedule to other people and as far as I know is still happily employed, now with a green card application that will transfer with them to any other employer they move to. I would have _happily_ hired locally, and in fact most of the people I hired for that team were US citizens, Bob was one of 3 H1-Bs. He was from India, another was from Singapore, and the third was from France. They were all very talented engineers and any company would hire them in their specialty in a heartbeat. I find it hard to say the workers in either of the two camps are particularly exploited (at least once they're in the country -- I've read ugly things about how they go into debt to be able to get these positions in the first placed). They are being paid fair market value for the work they are doing. The money they're making is far in excess of what they earn elsewhere -- that's why they go through the lengths they go through to get these jobs in the first place. If they have the ability to get hired at a more traditional tech company, that company will take over sponsorship of their H1-B with very little complication -- demand is effectively infinite for good engineers who are happy to work.
- t1o5 10y agoWhoever argues that H1Bs are paid handsomely, have a look at this data disclosure for 2016 H1B wages (137 MB) from DOL. You can find all the details of companies that exploits the workers with some MS Excel wizardry. https://www.foreignlaborcert.doleta.gov/docs/Performance_Data/Disclosure/FY15-FY16/H-1B_Disclosure_Data_FY16.xlsx https://www.foreignlaborcert.doleta.gov/docs/Performance_Dat... The companies exploit a loop hole called "Pay Ranges" if you see the excel columns - WAGE_RATE_OF_PAY_FROM & WAGE_RATE_OF_PAY_TO, rather than a single absolute WAGE, the companies can legally pay any salary in that range. That's where Mr Trump needs to "patch" the system, raise the minimum WAGE_RATE_OF_PAY_FROM.
- CodeSheikh 10y ago"..the company can’t prevent the departure of Americans.." this is part of the problem. I have seen people (especially young ones) jumping ships in less than six months from startup to startup in SV because of the competitive market salary. Even though larger companies can take this hit but for a startup of <10 employees this can prove to be very detrimental. I agree that Indian consultancies have been abusing the H1B program for a while now, and even though American companies pay them same or actually more (consultant hourly rates are always on the higher end), these consultancies keep the lion share to themselves and pay minimum to the consultant. The problem is not just with immigrants (both educated from US colleges and brought in by the Indian consultancies) but also nomadic nature of young American tech labor. Should there be some sort of collateral such as one year contract? Probably not a welcoming idea in a free market of USA.
- mavelikara 10y ago> Should there be some sort of collateral such as one year contract? It would be a fair deal if employers also agree to let go of employee only with many months of severance payment. Also, startups using vesting schedules to incentivize people to stay.
- CodeSheikh 10y agoAgree. It should be a two way street.
- mavelikara 10y agoMy point is that we got where we are today when employers started violating their end of the contract and employees slowly got wiser of the shift. To unsettle the status quo, the employers have to do some disproportionate show of good faith and win the trust of the employees.
- afastow 10y agoThe solution is not making it harder for US citizens to move around(which is basically impossible anyway), it's making it much easier for H-1B workers to move around so everyone is on the same playing field. The ability to move quickly from company to company is not a bad thing. I don't believe it causes startups to fail, it just accelerates the process for ones that already weren't going to make it. Few people want to jump ship if they believe their startup is going to be successful. If after six months though they feel that it's not going to make it there is no reason to wait to go down with the ship.
- relics443 10y agoI think an issue lost in the discussion is that citizens are losing jobs because of this. I'm all for the plight of the immigrant, but as an American, my concern is first and foremost with my fellow countrymen.
- d--b 10y agoYou really think there is not enough jobs for American software developers?
- CodeSheikh 10y agoIf you are a decent software developer there is a guaranteed job for you, unless you code in COBOL or FORTRAN. Heck, people are jumping ships and we hire people from English or Humanities background who go and do 6 months intensive coding boot camps. Wake up and go find opportunities for yourself. Jobs don't come to you. Get yourself out there and be known. Put your hobby projects on Github. Attend Meetups and network with people. People hire a lot at tech meetups.
- Apocryphon 10y agoI thought that COBOL devs have guaranteed jobs, given the startlingly number of legacy systems out there that urgently need people to maintain them and prevent our nation's aged banking databases from collapsing.
- halflings 10y agoWhy would Americans lose jobs over this? I can understand the "immigrant tech workers are the reason we don't have higher salaries" argument, but not why somebody would actually lose their job over this (since salaries have to be the same, and if you accept that salary you would cost less to the company since you don't require paperwork, lawyers, relocation)
- valuearb 10y agoHiring H1B visa holders creates jobs in america. The product created by the one I hired employed 20 people in high paying jobs. There are multiple billion dollar companies in SV employing thousands of americans founded by H1B holders. Do we want those companies to have been built in India?
- Johnny555 10y agoThe author seems to disregard studies that don't back up the claim: Academics with industry funding claim otherwise, but one can see how it makes basic economic sense...
- rhapsodic 10y agoThe hubris and self-righteousness of SV billionaire bully-boys has reached the point where I'll favor practically anything that takes them down a peg. I'd love to see the Republican controlled federal government treat them the way the Democrats have treated, for example, the gun and coal industries. If a gun manufacturer should be held liable for the results of people misusing a gun, then why shouldn't Airbnb be held liable for harm people may suffer as a result of renting or leasing through Airbnb?
- okreallywtf 10y agoSo by that you mean, propose changes but then never have any of them implemented in any way and be blocked entirely by an obstructionist opposition party? I'm not sure thats what you really want.
- rhapsodic 10y agoWould you mind phrasing your question a little more clearly, please?
- okreallywtf 10y agoI'm just confused as to what you actually want to see happen to the SV bully-boys. The democrats (as far as I can tell) have had little to no actual effect on coal or guns but your comment makes it sound like they've been able to rein them in or bust them up or something. I was kind of making a joke because to me the democrats have been largely ineffective against coal and guns. Thats not necessarily their fault, to me they have generally proposed pretty measured policies (even if some peoples rhetoric is bombastic) that end up being totally rejected by the republicans and my guess is that is NOT what you want to see happen with SV.
- rhapsodic 10y ago>I'm just confused as to what you actually want to see happen to the SV bully-boys. I'd love to see the value of their businesses destroyed through zealous over-regulation. I'd love to see the IRS target them for audits the way Obama's IRS targeted conservative groups. I'd love for them to be criminally prosecuted, and -- dare I dream? -- jailed for any violations of the tax code that might be uncovered. That would wipe the smug off their faces. The political left in America no longer employs persuasion as their primary means of gaining and maintaining political power. Instead, they attempt to inflict social or financial punishment on their political enemies to shut them up. Recall the reaction when Peter Thiel had the audacity to support a presidential candidate they opposed. Google [memories pizza] for another example. So if that is how the game is played these days, then I want the right to use the same tactics against the left, and inflict massive pain on them until they offer a truce. I'm basically an Adam Smith free-market libertarian. I think the country, as a whole, would be better off if the cap on H1Bs was lifted entirely. Productive, tax-paying, wealth-creating people would flood into this country and enrich it. But politics is war these days. And Airbnb is more than just an enterprise, it's a wing of the Democratic party. So I think the Republicans should, to paraphrase Obama, "punish [their] enemies and reward [their] friends."
- deepnotderp 10y agoSilicon valley companies rarely bring in H-1Bs as a cheap replacement, the consultancies like Accenture, Tata, Disney, IBM, etc. do, but hey f*ck it, blame silicon valley....
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- afastow 10y ago> EB sponsorship renders the workers de facto indentured servants; though they have the right to move to another employer, they do not dare do so, as it would mean starting the lengthy green card process all over again. Increasing H-1B pay would be a step in the right direction but I think the green card policy is the biggest thing that needs to be fixed. H-1B workers should be fast tracked for green cards instead of having road blocks put in front of them. By definition they are skilled workers that the US doesn't have enough of so why would we ever want them to leave?
- convolvatron 10y agoidk, if you have an underclass thats forced to work for you for substandard wages due to externalities, that seems worth hanging on to. i think the most dangerous ideas distorting the software market is the fiction that every team is the best that was ever fielded, and that development takes such unique skills. you're hiring a web dev - stop turning people down because they aren't Guy Steele.
- okreallywtf 10y agoTrump may be "right" about this topic but he's massively wrongheaded about the solution. Making America the place the worlds best and brightest used to want to go is not going to solve this problem - regulation to protect visa workers is. I have a number of friends I went to school with now working on H1B Visas who want to make a life here and worked very hard to get here and I hate to see them indentured to their sponsors. I don't know anyone I went to school with that was even remotely competent that couldn't get a job even in my home state, let alone nationwide (and this isn't even from a big or well known program). Maybe the demand for H1B visas would go down if the playing field was leveled but who knows? This doesn't validate his actual ideas whatsoever, many people see this issue as a problem but I would like to see some actual reform instead of just pouring gasoline on the problem and lighting a match.
- chuckcode 10y agoMy experience has been that my H1-B coworkers don't get paid as well as US counterparts sand that there is significant friction for them to change companies or even get a big promotion if they are in process of applying for green card. Rather than adding more rules to an already difficult process though I think the best solution would be to allow people with H1-B to easily change jobs after some period of time at the original sponsoring company (e.g. 6-12 months). That way it would be harder to pay below market rates and would be much more dynamic than having the government trying to estimate what the prevailing wage should be. I get really frustrated though with most articles on the H1-B visas which either seem to be bashing immigrants or imply that somehow more government regulation will help the situation. In my experience growing up in the US we are incredibly lucky to have such talented people coming here to work and they have contributed incredibly to the tech companies in the US which are really one of the few bright spots in the US economy. Some of the smartest and hardest working colleagues I have grew up in other countries and we are lucky that they have come here to build the US economy.
- thewhitetulip 10y agoTrue, I read somewhere that majority of scientists are immigrants, heck, even Donald Trump's grandpa was a German Immigrant!
- niceperson 10y agoSilicon Valley Using H-1B Visas to ~~ Pay Low Wages to Immigrants ~~ give immigrants jobs
- myf01d 10y agoTrump asks the right questions: the danger of globalism, incredibly high global debt, the danger of radical islam, the overestimation of Russia's danger on the US and EU, the questionable usefulness of NATO, the economic manipulation by China, he just has the wrong answers.
- woah 10y agoThe danger of radical Islam?? That one's in the mix just for an extra dose of racist nationalism. They'll stop fighting us once we stop occupying their countries.
- myf01d 10y agoRadical islam is the real danger on the west, I come from a middle eastern country and as an ex-muslim I know very well the danger of the islamization that has been going on in western Europe throughout the past 3 decades.
- MrZongle2 10y agoWell, I'm sure that won't stop many "enlightened" individuals from lecturing you. Unfortunately.
- Analemma_ 10y agoThe flu kills more people every week than "radical Islam" has killed in the last decade; but yes, keep telling us how much of an existential threat to Western civilization it is. Us "enlightened individuals" are lecturing you because you are terrible at evaluating risk and are afraid of your own shadow.
- myf01d 10y agoThe flu also killed more people than the Jews killed by Hitler during that time. High blood pressure killed more than the two combined. Nice logic you've got here.
- tejasd 10y agoI do believe H1-Bs were used to pay lower wages (more so because of being tied to the employer for long periods of time in the Green Card Process). However, in my observations and experiences, the last few years (i.e. the years when H1-Bs were allocated by lottery), due to the scarcity of H1-B visas, employers started paying a premium for employees who already had an H1-B visa and the skills necessary, because they could switch jobs immediately (as opposed to having wait 1+ year to hire someone from abroad and wait/hope for them to get through the lottery). What made it even better was that thanks to legislation by the Obama administration, your spot in the Green Card line was now portable, i.e. even if you switch employers, as long as the new employer files a green card application, you still retained your position in the line. As you can see, the theme has been giving more leverage to H1-B employees as opposed to the employers - and that is what the American immigration system desperately needs. In the end it's only going to protect American workers.
- ryanmarsh 10y agoThe thing that kills me about this whole debate is the flyover states are full of smart hard working people who had the misfortune of ... I shouldn't have to explain this. These people could be trained too. Every enterprise client I've had for the past 5 years has H1B's doing minimal coding tasks on enterprise COTS software like PEGA or Informatica. Those skills don't take 4 years to train people for and they pay a liveable wage.
- pmoriarty 10y agoOh that vicious liberal media. They're really sticking it to him, aren't they?
- buckbova 10y agoFind another positive story out of the two dozen Trump hit pieces http://www.huffingtonpost.com/ http://www.huffingtonpost.com/.
- sodafountan 10y agoYou do realize that half of the reason this post is noteworthy is because it's so out of the ordinary that The Huffington Post agrees with Trump right?
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y ago> overestimation of Russia's danger on the US and EU Depends what you mean by “EU”. Western Europe? Sure, Russia maybe isn't a big deal for them. But the Baltic states, which are EU and NATO member states, understandably consider their next-door neighbour a huge threat.
- myf01d 10y agoWhat would a big country benefit from invading its weak neighbor in the 21st century? Putin isn't an angle but he is surely not Europe's or US' enemy like the liberal media is trying hard to push that narrative. Many of the Baltic states are inexplicably pushing the west towards a pointless conflict with Russia. It's just like Georgia in 2008 or maybe even like Poland with Nazi Germany in late 1930s.
- tdeck 10y ago> What would a big country benefit from invading its weak neighbor in the 21st century? You're asking this as if it didn't already happen in Ukraine.
- Simaramis 10y agoIsn't it true that Ukraine has never been an independent state except since the fall of the USSR? In its history? Except for 2 weeks after WWII? It has always been a fertile land, agrarian, impossible to defend due to no natural boundaries, its people of fiercely independent mind, yet, having been rolled over by Poles, Russians, Vikings, Norsman repeatedly and periodically throughout history? That would be the context. I would even go as far as saying that Donbass and Crimea are not to be counted as Ukraine, historically?
- svachalek 10y agoSo, it's not aggression if everyone else does it?
- 10y ago
- HillaryBriss 10y agoPart of the compensation is the possibility of permanent residency in the US. This is quite valuable. The employer does not actually pay for that benefit.
- plandis 10y agoIt's not all of tech companies. Even if you bump up the minimum without proof to $130,000, the biggest tech companies are already paying over that to H1-B's.
- hfourm 10y agoforeign service markets become more attractive, americans again lose jobs to outsourcing, will be interesting to see how this plays out. I certainly think in the short term it will be better for the American worker (in terms of employment, mobility, higher wages), but long term?
- joeblau 10y agoI actually saw this with a few of my colleagues that worked at Amazon. There was one superb engineering — one of the best Android developers I've ever worked with. Our project ended and, I had the freedom to leave Amazon and jump to another company (which I did), but he was stuck. He ended up having to move his family from SF to Seattle just to keep his job all in hopes that he didn't screw up his H-1B visa process.
- dhruvrrp 10y agoThe discussion about H1Bs is getting dominated by SV. The brunt of the changes are gonna affect other industries, for example, someone i know is currently doing a masters in biotech at a really good research university, and she is really scared about the 130k lower limit for H1B applicants. According to her, even postdocs in her field don't make that much! If the new H1B system passes as is, then its gonna cause a massive brain-drain in most fields that are not SV tech related.
- xamuel 10y agoEver tried hunting for a job in academia? There are hundreds of super-qualified U.S. candidates for every opening. If your friend's so amazing she beats all of them, 130k is a steal.
- dhruvrrp 10y agoYou do realize that the average salary of a tenured professor in the US is around $100k right? It goes up to $200k for some private universities but I would say 100-150k is what most top public universities pay. So 130k is a shitton of money in academia. Ignoring all of that, average salary of a senior biomedial engineer is 90k. The rest of the USA doesn't live in the 100k++ bubble that is SV.
- dxhdr 10y ago> The discussion about H1Bs is getting dominated by SV SV dominates the H1Bs: http://www.myvisajobs.com/Reports/2017-H1B-Visa-Category.aspx?T=OC http://www.myvisajobs.com/Reports/2017-H1B-Visa-Category.asp...
- dhruvrrp 10y agoBut it doesn't. The problem is Indian outsourcing sweatshops. Why does everyone else have to suffer because of them? https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/11/06/us/outsourcing-companies-dominate-h1b-visas.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/11/06/us/outsourcin...
- dleslie 10y ago"We have a Talent Shortage" is industry slang for "We are unwilling to train paid apprentices."
- ocschwar 10y agoWe can discuss the economics of the H-1B visa program at such a time as we have a president who's capable of discussing the economics of the H1B visa program. Right now, however, we have an administration that's intent on ratcheting up ethnic tensions, and there's 100% probability that they will use the H1B debate as a pretext for casting aspersions at the entire Indian nation, including Indian-descended natural born Americans. I'd rather keep on earning my H1-B depressed wage rate for my job than risk yet another hit against my country's credibility thanks to president banana's divide and rule strategy.
- spoiledtechie 10y agoThe HP is reporting on something positive about Trump? I just saw a Unicorn! Wow.
- valuearb 10y agoWhen the SuperCollider project shut down I was fortunate enough to be able to use H1B hire a japanese physicist who worked on it. Cost $20K IIRC. One of best hires I ever made, his work ended up creating about 20 high paid permanent jobs in our company. I would have happily given him citizenship, was just glad he didn't end up working for our over-seas competitors.
- ehosca 10y agojust make the H1-B visa transportable (not tied to an employer) and the problem fixes itself.
- e40 10y agoI think big companies do abuse the system, but I manage a small company and in 30+ years we've used H-1B's 3 times. Each time it was to get someone that we could not find in the US. Yes, we are a small company (~30 people) and in a niche market, but each time, the person we found was 10x better than the nearest candidate. And each time we paid the person as well as we paid US employees.
- DVassallo 10y agoH1-Bs are not unfair to Americans, even when abused. All this talk about protectionism and fairness is really bizarre to me. Thought experiment: Imagine if Canada found a cure for cancer but chose to sell it to Canadians only. Would that be fair? Would it be fair to Americans that can't get access to it? Job protectionism makes some people entitled to jobs based on random circumstances at birth. How can rational people think that _this_ is fair?
- vpl0512 10y agoThese are witch hunting cases. Why didn't government took action against these companies who are buying services from companies like TCS, HCL? Why demonizing younger and talented foreigners and enforcing hypothesis based on these 5% wrong cases? Where is your study when these people get selected in touch interviews at places like FB, Google, Linkedin? Branding H1B people as "Cheap Labor" is an old fashion and the saga continues at alarming rate.
- frankydp 10y agoH-1B and J-1 consulting and labor firms are far more nefarious than people probably think. Most of my personal experience is with J-1 pimps. These "firms" import seasonal labor and directly collect wages from the hiring company. The catch is as old as markets, as they usually debit housing, food, and fees that are grossly outside of true cost, but allow for just enough origin country adjusted income to still make sense for students to keep signing on. I have dealt with these firms from Eastern Europe and South America, with both operating on the razors edge of indentured servitude. These exact same practices dominate the H-1B program. The most effective change to any of these programs, outside of just volume, would be the direct to employee payment requirement or minimum percentage. That change would force the either higher salaries in order to maintain the labor firms margins, or the labor firms would have to eat the cost to keep the prices down. Enforcement would have to be extreme. As the nature of the relationship between the firm and the visa holder is already indebted, and there would be lots of opportunity for harassment and coercion of the visa holder to fork over more of their paycheck. Addition: Another solution may be a visa marketplace that the government would run, to connect employers and visa seekers directly and eliminate the middle man.
- danenania 10y agoHow about simply allowing H-1Bs to change jobs if they get an offer from another company, and giving them a sufficient window to find something new if they leave their current company? The no-recourse indentured servitude relationship that makes people dependent on a company for their residency takes away all the employee's negotiating power. If we could change this, I expect that wages would begin to even out.
- tkahnoski 10y agoThey can. It's just painful and depending on the competency of both companies legal counsel, it can take months. We've had employees accept offers with a start date, only the visa transfers weren't finished yet so they started MONTHS after the expected start date.
- 10y ago
- ChicagoDave 10y agoI can't count how many colleagues I've talked to that are in a stuck-employer situation. Some are happy, but some are miserable. I'm also aware that some of the people with H1-B's are family members that actually don't know anything about technology and don't belong in any job anywhere in technology. I'm also aware (being 53) that my livelihood is directly tied to the number and type of H1-B visas in the U.S. I can't stand Trump, but on this issue he has a valid beef. It's all a cluster-F and the system should be changed to treat foreign workers well and to make sure U.S. workers have opportunities.
- rarec 10y agoWhen you've got a few bad actors abusing the system, all pay for it. There's a reason we can't have nice things.
- brendangregg 10y agoThe article mentions reseting the green card clock as a way to render workers de facto indentured servants, but unfortunately that's not the only way. One immigration lawyer explained this all to me as "cost effective employee retention". Fixing salaries is good, but I wonder about fixing immobility as well.
- MaysonL 10y agoOf course, Trump hired quite a few H1-B workers himself: http://money.cnn.com/2016/03/18/news/economy/trump-maralago/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2016/03/18/news/economy/trump-maralago/...
- ojbyrne 10y agoJust to be precise, those are H-2B visas (it says that right in the article) which is a different program. https://www.uscis.gov/working-united-states/temporary-workers/h-2b-temporary-non-agricultural-workers https://www.uscis.gov/working-united-states/temporary-worker...
- general_ai 10y agoThe real news here is that HuffPo agrees with Trump. I thought their editorial policy was to interpret everything Trump says in the most low-IQ and paranoid way possible. Someone needs to call them and ask if everything is OK.
- Chris2048 10y agoCheap labor isn't the only issue here. Wage theft in the form of capping competition is the big issue. Assume the rate of salary change dS(t)/dt is propotional-to/a-function-of (average_labor_demand - average_labor_supply) Now, if you keep topping up supply from overseas, salary never increases as much as it might, as such it is limited - as such, salary rate increase is also capped; and it's not employees can have any relief from a lack of demand, other than maybe fewer visas, but I doubt there would be many lobbyists for that... complaints about unemployment or lack of jobs falls on deaf ears - ears stuffed full of money by happy employers...
- okreallywtf 10y agoJust to play devils advocate, wouldn't it eventually even out then because high demand and lower wages here would mean that other countries with a tech sector would have high wages and would then be more appealing, which would encourage H1B visa seekers to consider going elsewhere or would even lure more talent from the US overseas. Granted, like many market-based arguments I make a lot of assumptions about how easily people can move around. Immigrating is hard and once you've immigrated successfully you may not be willing to take the risk of ending up back in the repressive regime you came from (hence, a lot of the issues we have right now) and people in the US may not be nearly as willing to leave the US and go elsewhere. But theoretically (if not in reality) more mobility and access to labor is a good thing.
- Chris2048 10y agoThis would work if all countries were equally desirable, and capable of supporting the same economy. Maybe the US is competing with Europe? But at the moment US salaries are considerably higher.
- strainer 10y agoBy way of an unrealistic formalisation there you actually assumed that salaries are determined exclusively by labour supply and far more predictably and linearly than possible. The complexity of the economy, greatly confounds simplistic formulas.
- tn13 10y agoH1B employees being exploited works in Murica's favor. It means American companies are more competitive at the expense of some Rajesh from Chennai. This is something Trump should love. Even if American companies are paying lower wages I don't see the problem. It helps American companies make more profit and lower prices for American consumers. Something that we all must cheer. Some people argue that it lowers the wages of neo-native people. It is good too. We all would love a cheaper electrician, cheaper plumber, cheaper burger flipper, cheaper doctor what is so wrong with cheaper coder ? It benefits the entire society.
- reddytowns 10y agoIf Rajesh from Chennai is sending all his money back to Chennai, Americans won't have the funds to benefit from the lower prices. You can see a just released Hollywood movie in the theatre for $3 in Indonesia, that doesn't mean it's better to live there.
- tn13 10y ago> If Rajesh from Chennai is sending all his money back to Chennai, Americans won't have the funds to benefit from the lower prices. LOL! That is mistaking money for value. If Rajesh sends the money back to Chennai it will very likely increase the value of money for Americans which affects the poorest of poor in a very good way. I would however worry more about Rajesh maxing out his credit cards and then catching flight to India. :P
- lgleason 10y agowanna know why tech companies are anti-Trump and against his immigration ban? Because they actually care about immigrants and human rights or because it will affect their bottom line. Hint, follow the money.....
- mseebach 10y agoEvery time the topic comes up, I wonder how many of the HN'ers who are cross at H-1B workers because they are depressing wages are intellectually consistent (and honest) enough to accept that this position is part and parcel of the same system of nationalist thought that leads to a wall to Mexico and steeply increased tariffs on chinese import; of "America First"? If you find yourself reconciling the idea of protecting against wage competition from H-1Bs, but are in favour of continued undocumented immigration from Mexico (or at least opposed to taking any substantial measures against it), in favour of NAFTA remaining in place and in favour of continued trade with China under current conditions, I'd be very interested in understanding how you model that? (There is also a critique around the specific rules of H-1B being unfair to the worker, mostly around restrictions on changing employers. I agree with most of that and don't think it inherently incompatible with other views on immigration and trade, pro or con.)
- droopyEyelids 10y agoThe wall equivalence makes sense to me, but you're stretching the analogy to include tariffs on foreign made goods. With illegal immigration (wall) and H1B, you're describing the creation of a second class of workers within a country that depress wages within that country by having a separate, unequal workforce. With foreign made goods you're describing a situation where workers from different countries have different protections, but those protections are consistent within the country. Thats a big distinction to obliterate.
- BrooklynRage 10y agoProtecting against wage competition for H-1Bs: More money for me (U.S. citizen / permanent resident tech worker). In favor of free trade: Cheaper goods for me. It all boils down to "which collection of policies help me maximize my stuff?" Most people seem to take a more pragmatic approach, valuing tangible things over intellectual consistency.
- kofejnik 10y agoor maybe intellectual consistency inevitably leads to maximising value for oneself
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nostrademons 10y agoIt's worth putting in a shout-out to Lofgren's H1B bill: https://lofgren.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID=398125 https://lofgren.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?DocumentI... Far from "emasculating" it like the article suggests, the "bucketing" system in Lofgren's bill is designed to put upward pressure on all wages, including those of American citizens. The way that it works is that positions paying in the top 2/3 of the average wage for their geographical area will get priority over those that pay only the average wage, regardless of how much they pay their H1Bs. (And within the bucket, they get priority based on how much more than the prevailing wage they pay the H1B worker.) This prevents companies from bidding up the price of their H1B workers only, and forces them to raise wages for all of their American citizens as well in order to take advantage of the market-based allocation of H1Bs.
- verst 10y agoI'm a big fan of her bill for the above (market-based) approach and other reasons: - F-1 student visa becomes dual-intent. This is huge! Essentially an employer could now sponsor permanent residency directly out of a PhD program (or even college assuming sufficient work experience for employment-based immigration). No need to first get a H-1B. - It appears that switching employers while on the H-1B becomes easier (the new employer must only submit the Labor Condition Application). This will provide mobility to H-1B workers and therefore not suppress wages. - 20% of H-1B visas are set aside for startups and small businesses, and to prevent these from becoming subsidiaries of outsourcing firms the H-1B holder may not be working at a 3rd party worksite for more than 30 days. - H-1B dependent companies (8 H-1Bs if < 26 employees, 11 H-1Bs if 26-50, 15% of workforce if 50+) either must prove that no US citizen is being displaced, or they must pay at least the dependent company exemption minimum salary of $130,000. Note: I'm a former Math & Comp Sci (double major) international student (F-1 visa) from a top tier school, then H-1B, permanent resident, and this week (!) will become a citizen. Bill Summary: https://lofgren.house.gov/uploadedfiles/high_skilled_bill_sxs_and_analysis_-1-2017__final.pdf https://lofgren.house.gov/uploadedfiles/high_skilled_bill_sx...
- garyfirestorm 10y agothis week* unless trump does something to this process ;) just kidding. congrats!
- serge2k 10y agoI miss waking up in the morning and checking the news and not seeing some story about how horrible the H-1B is and how I'm stealing an american job for a shitty wage. Such a nice thing from a site that freaks out if you call someone illegal instead of undocumented. So much love for immigrants, except lets still shit on them because DEY TOOK R JOBS.
- darioush 10y agoAnother category of immigrants who'd benefit from such a situation is the "grad student visa" students. The US academic system (in STEM) has for too long relied on "free labor" of hard working, poorly treated grad students from countries like India, China, and Iran (paid minimum wage, often not adjusted for high living costs of cities like LA or Seattle). US students often don't go to grad school because as engineers they'd earn a lot of money and are less susceptible to being poorly treated by their boss. The visa is technically non-immigrant, but students often then get H1B jobs (yay for more abuse). The whole thing is a travesty. This is pretty much exploiting other countries for natural resources, except instead of resources we exploit them for talent.
- Nano2rad 10y agoIndian companies start subsidiaries in US so that they can send invitation to workers in India so they get H-1b visa. The companies requesting H-1b visas have to be American, Indian companies or companies working for contract to US companies should not be allowed to request H1-b visas. THe US IT workers also have to change; they have to accept some work will be outsourced and their job is now more like participating and controlling outsourcing for their employer.
- scottlocklin 10y agoPeople seem to have arguments about this based on 1) H1Bs depressing the prevailing wage (true if you believe in classical supply and demand) 2) overall economic utility; aka the economy does better/worse because of more H1Bs (I don't really care, but I guess someone might) One thing which gets left out: H1Bs are more compliant employees, because their employers have them over a legal barrel. They have a much harder time leaving their employer than a citizen does, and they're a lot less likely to complain if they're abused. Turnover is hugely expensive to a software company; between that and the "costs" of having an employee with civil rights; well, not all employers are bad actors, but the temptation has to be there. I've certainly seen this at work in various places. It's pretty rotten. I mean, obviously many consider it a good trade, but it isn't exactly humane. Social costs like this are often left out of economic considerations. Who cares if your GDP goes up if we end up living in a dystopia as a result?
- myrandomcomment 10y agoSo logically I can agree with this however in practice at my startups this is just not true. Maybe it is because we never got that big before I went to do the next startup. I left at around 500 people in the last big one that IPO'd. (They are now over 3K - I was in the 1st 30). At my current startup we are ~50. In both startups finding qualified engineers was the issue always. We did not care if where they came from, just that they could pass the interview process. We would interview 250 and maybe find one person. The goal was top 1%. I once asked the VP of Software if we could make it the top 5% and he said "can you tell me how to tell the difference between the top 1% the top 5% vs the rest? 1% is simple, anything below that you make mistakes." For the 1st ~250ish people the difference between top 1% and the rest was huge and those top people made a world of difference to the success of the company. I guess if you are a company with 1000s then the H1-B money game makes more sense. For a small startup, it is the talent that counts, not where they are from.
- DesiLurker 10y agoformer H1B & like any red blooded liberal, a Trump critic. However, on this particular matter I agree with the man. H1B is basically indentured servitude for employer. Its not just that you get paid less salary & bonuses it also reduces the bargaining ability when looking for potential opportunities as there is a lengthy transfer process that requires new employer to spend money. Another practice that I have seen happen lately is (atleast common in employers like amazon etc) is that the younglings that get hired on H1B get a fairly low level position like engineer-I. they are then told that they are ineligible for green card processing until they get to next level. so in effect they are either working 60+ hours a week eyeing for that promotion or just burning their early years out of scarce 6 years limit. Honestly I dont know how is this legal. then there is matter of green card processing and prio date regression which is a whole another can of worms. IMHO at the salaries most young indians are coming to valley and given the rise of startup ecosystem in india, its almost not worth it especially if you look at cost of living here. One more thing, often immigrant managers who themselves have hone through the process or are aware of intricacies are the worst exploiters as they know when employees are most vulnerable. Lastly, Dont even get me started on the 'consulting' micro body shops that do shit thats clearly illegal & would land the employee is fair bit of trouble if detected. I definitely have to applaud trump for doing something about this even if under the guise of xenofobia. that said 130k limit will definitely have effect on the small body shops that are exploitative as hell. there is one positive thing that happened in last few years which should be preserved, its the ability for dependent spouse (H4) visa to find employment. the wifes that come over here are fairly well educated & have carriers of there own. they often fall into isolation and get depressed due to lack of social circle & opportunities. I wish that still remains viable.
- diebir 10y agoAnecdotally, as a former H1-B worker, I would not say I was underpaid or the employer ever exploited the fact that I was on H1-B. From my standpoint it has always been a fair deal. Okay, the gist of the article is that H1-B should require higher salaries (in the 75th percentile). This would have the effect of cutting off younger and less experienced workers. The problem here is that more experienced and older people are less likely to want to move. In other words, this would mean that the US tech would lose out on the potential talent. Again anecdotally my current tech org is 60-80% foreign born. It is also one of the most selective places around. Would it be like it is without H1-B program? I doubt it. So perhaps the system needs tweaking, specifically in the area of making the system work faster and being less arcane. I highly doubt this is what's going to happen. Ten years from now we'll be having the same conversation, as we were ten years ago (I have been watching this since '99).
- nmb1 10y agoBut, the protest is because we are "a refugee" ... http://www.theverge.com/2017/1/28/14428262/google-sergey-brin http://www.theverge.com/2017/1/28/14428262/google-sergey-bri...
- Qub3d 10y agoHuffPo says trump is right? People must be having a snowball fight in hell right now...