3 ms·
I don't get the criticism against the judge or the ruling. Frankly, the arguments presented by Resource.org seem to be unpersuasive (the claim that these standa
by icebraining 10y ago
I don't get the criticism against the judge or the ruling. Frankly, the arguments presented by Resource.org seem to be unpersuasive (the claim that these standards are "discovered facts" is just insulting to the engineers that worked on them) and completely unsupported by the law. It's not the judge's fault that your Congress and other governments have sold you out. Go sue them for enforcing laws you can't read.
- oxide 10y agoI'd love to. oh, maybe we can use one of those automated lawyers! Do they support 'government sold you out' suits yet or is that a couple years off still?
- pas 10y agoStandards shouldn't be copyrightable. Or they're not standards, they're just secret handshakes (or whatevers, after all you can't really talk about parts of it, because all of it is just dry quantitative stuff - yet not simple facts to share) that allegedly work. Also, does ISO pay the C++ standards developers? And how much is the market for C++ standards? (Yes, compiler vendors are usually big firms/organizations, but I doubt all the money paid for the standards so far would be enough to cover all the expenses of the various working group meetings involved.) And sure, the tools of the trade argument is valid, you don't get hammers for free if you want to build a house (or just fix up something), but we can make the mental categorical distinction between information that gains value as more and more people has access vs information that loses value as more and more people has access (trade secrets, hence the licensing cost of patents).
- snowwrestler 10y agoI think we need to be careful to distinguish between copyright and access; they're not the same thing. For example open-source software is protected by open-access licenses, which in turn rest on the concept of copyright. We don't need to abolish copyright to establish a right to open access.
- DannyBee 10y ago"I don't get the criticism against the judge or the ruling." It's actually directly contrary to rulings in other states, circuits, etc. Even the supreme court has held, consistently, since 1888, that the law is free. 'the authentic exposition and interpretation of the law, which, binding every citizen, is free for publication to all, whether it is a declaration of unwritten law, or an interpretation of a constitution or a statute' Banks v. Manchester (128 U.S. 244, 1888) I don't think this could be more clear. An argument that you get to lock it away by incorporating by reference is patently absurd and directly contrary to this. You don't get to say "page one of georgia annotated code: for the text of pages 1-100000 of the georgia code, please see 'the real georgia annotated code', published by forprofitco," But that's just what is happening, since these standards are not "voluntary", but binding law that you can be charged with crimes or sued for violating. If they wanted to charge money, they have a simple solution - don't make them law, don't charge people for violations, etc. " Frankly, the arguments presented by Resource.org seem to be unpersuasive (the claim that these standards are "discovered facts" is just insulting to the engineers that worked on them) and completely unsupported by the law." Except they (and others) have repeatedly won in pretty much every other case. This is in fact, the first case i'm aware of that they've lost (or that others have lost in similar situations). Frankly, the idea that you can sue people or charge them with a crime, for a law they have to pay to read is insulting to everyone, and very clearly not constitutional. As mentioned, there is a simple solution - if you want to charge, don't give them binding force of law. You don't get to have your cake and eat it too.
- icebraining 10y agoBut that's my point - the question in this trial wasn't whether the State can use closed standards as law, but whether someone can violate the copyright of these standards just because the State refers to them in the law. Frankly, the idea that you can sue people or charge them with a crime, for a law they have to pay to read is insulting to everyone, and very clearly not constitutional. My point exactly! They should be suing the State for doing that! Not trying to invalidate some company's copyrighted standard.
- DannyBee 10y ago
- naasking 10y ago> (the claim that these standards are "discovered facts" is just insulting to the engineers that worked on them) As an engineer, I don't see why. Discovery is still hard and valuable work. I personally also think the use of terminology like "discovery" rather than "invention" reinforces that you don't have some divine, exclusive right to control what you've created, but that discoveries are to benefit all of humanity. The government gives you a time-limited exclusive license as a reward for taking the risk and doing the hard work to make these discoveries.
- icebraining 10y agoThat's the point - the government doesn't give you a license for discoveries, only for creative work. The EFF et all weren't trying to rename the term, they were claiming that these standards were merely uncreative "discoveries", unlike every other copyrightable work.
- naasking 10y ago> That's the point - the government doesn't give you a license for discoveries, only for creative work. Creative work is a discovery, and this is trivial to see: you can write a program to enumerate all possible English texts, and so discover every possible written work that has, can or will ever be made. So it's more correct to say that the government gives you a license for certain kinds of discoveries, and the EFF are saying that this sort of work does not belong in the protected category. That's not entirely unreasonable from what I can see.
- marcosdumay 10y agoI'm not following this line. Copyrights are never about facts, and always about their presentation. If the facts are discovered or invented shouldn't have any importance.