3 ms·
I find it hard to accept the "you must be 7ft tall to play basketball" story about why people become good at something. My own view is more something like what
by lordnacho 10y ago
I find it hard to accept the "you must be 7ft tall to play basketball" story about why people become good at something.
My own view is more something like what bodybuilders say. Some people find it harder to grow than others, but everyone can do it. And people who put effort into it will definitely be separable from people who don't, regardless of endowment.
Now as for who gets to be written into history books, there's a fair bit of randomness about that. A hard working person can well find that the only phd advisor who will take them wants them to work on some dead end. Or you may work on something hot, but other people will know it's hot, too, and they may well beat you to publication. Doesn't make you any dumber, but your name will not be enshrined in that theorem.
There's also a necessary confluence of factors that depends very much on your parents, specifically whether they figure out how to manage your development. Look at the current first-in-most-people's-minds genius, Terence Tao. Not only did his parents figure out that he was good at math, they somehow got him the right guidance. I'm guessing very few parents, even quite well educated ones, would know what to do if a guy like that turned up in their house. There's also the sheer randomness of whether you'll end up doing things that encourage the kid. Most parents, myself included, have very little idea of how to get a kid to do what's good for them. You laugh, unless you are a parent.
- ZeroFries 10y agoIsn't a part of a person's endowment their ability to work hard and put in effort where it's required, when it's required? The 7ft tall thing is an example of an easy to see factor, which some people have, and some don't. In reality, as you say, there are unlimited factors going into a person's greatness (or lack-of). By the way, there was a study where, given the same weight lifting program, a couple people gained tons of muscle, most gained some, some gained none, and a few even lost muscle. Not everyone can gain appreciable muscle, and not everyone can get good at math (although most can, and the average person underestimates their ability to do so).
- ktRolster 10y agothere was a study where, given the same weight lifting program, a couple people gained tons of muscle, most gained some, some gained none, and a few even lost muscle. Not everyone can gain appreciable muscle This is a non sequitur. A reasonable follow-up study would try to figure out why those people didn't gain muscle, and how that can be changed (the first things to look at would be diet and sleep. If they're not getting enough food, of course they will lose muscle).
- sn9 10y ago>Isn't a part of a person's endowment their ability to work hard and put in effort where it's required, when it's required? No this is largely a malleable set of traits. Good teachers can frequently change them in whole populations of students.
- ZeroFries 10y agoGood nutrition can frequently change the height of whole populations. Yet, we say height is part of a person's endowment. One might say potential is largely determined at birth, but how that potential unfolds is determined over the course of an organism's life.
- sn9 10y agoYes but in even the most developed countries, nutrition isn't an issue but sufficiently good educational environments aren't. We're still barely tapping into people's potential, but people still act form arguments on the assumption that we are.