4 ms·
> Graham’s understanding of economics is woefully pedestrian, un-researched conjecture. His conceptualization of the economics of exchange relies on a stubborn
by jstanley 10y ago
> Graham’s understanding of economics is woefully pedestrian, un-researched conjecture. His conceptualization of the economics of exchange relies on a stubborn insistence and blind naive trust that the free market is the ultimate solution to which his audience must subscribe. It is distressing that one could allow arrogance to so cloud his judgment that he would embarrass himself by making such claims in an area of study he is clearly lacking any authority on which to speak.
The author sounds rather more arrogant than Paul Graham did. And free markets are the ultimate solution.
EDIT: The more I read, the more ridiculous it gets. The author takes something that Paul Graham said, throws away all of the context, and attacks it as a strawman. The article seems more keen on attacking Paul Graham than making any actual point.
It is also written in a very verbose style that makes it hard to follow whatever argument might be present.
- aleksei 10y ago> And free markets are the ultimate solution. On the subject of arrogance, spoken like a true believer.. There is hardly ever an ultimate solution to anything, and to take an extreme position on matters is almost always harmful. Things are never simply black and white.
- bko 10y agoNot the OP, but I think belief in free markets is not arrogant. In a free market, decisions are made on an individual level with actors affected that know their preferences and needs much better than a central body. I think its more arrogant to suggest that some planning committee would be able to make better decisions for that individual. Of course there are instances where there exists knowledge imbalances and sub-optimal decisions can be made. But the alternative is often no better due to the agency problem of having someone make decisions on your behalf
- amelius 10y ago> In a free market, decisions are made on an individual level with actors affected that know their preferences and needs much better than a central body. The free market is a lot like a mosh pit. Everybody is free to move (in principle), but in the end some may get seriously injured.
- bko 10y agoYou have to compare that to the alternative. Yes, some people will make less than optimal decisions, but the alternative is not perfect
- amelius 10y agoThe alternative is that a regulator puts some safety measures in place, like some fences here and there, and emergency exits. The result may not be perfect, but overall it's a better place to find yourself in.
- stymaar 10y ago> I think its more arrogant to suggest that some planning committee would be able to make better decisions for that individual. Objecting against the free market illusion is not advocating for a planification entity. Free market is a fallacy because there is no such things in the real world. Studying economics with the perspective of free market is like studying mecanics assuming mass-less bodies. It might offer a nice framework (the math becomes really simple) in which most of the problem we face disapear (no inertia, flying cars \o/), but that gives you no help if you want to understand and fix the world we live in. In practice nobody is even really trying to make free market a thing, otherwise you would see politician advocating for bans on price discrimination and investor would stop asking founders what are the barrier that prevents their competitors to get in their market, because both price discrimination and barrier to entries are responsible for «market failures». Is communism/economic planning a good idea ? Of course not. Is free market salvation ? Nope. Hayek had a really good diagnostic of the drawbacks of communism, but he had a totally irrational faith in the free market and this vision is shared by too many people. Unfortunately irrational faith does more harm than good …
- aleksei 10y agoTo be clear, I'm not trying to be for or against free markets, and you make valid points regarding the efficacy of relinquishing power to planning committees. However none of that pertains to my earlier comment. I'm simply making the observation that there can never be any ultimate solution, be it for economics, religion, or choice of wallpaper. There will always be edge cases, and there will always exist a better way, for any given definition of better (whether it be maximizing profits, freedom, well-being etc.). To claim otherwise is arrogant at best, and uninformed at worst.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoFree markets are a useful fiction that was developed around the time of Adam Smith. They are ( I think, anyway ) a demonstrable improvement over mercantilism. We more or less know how, and we more or less know why. The problem with "things that are not free markets" is that we simply know very little about those things, and the learning curve is significant. USAian bulk crops agriculture is not a free market, it mostly seems to work well that way but it started under FDR and only reached its present form after decades of tweaking. In effect ( the theory goes that ) larger price uncertainties will create price instabilities that, net-net, add more inefficiency than pricing things a skosh higher and accommodating overproduction. As political speech, the term "free market" has been rendered threadbare. "Trade agreements" seem to mostly be more akin to Mercantilism than free markets, and so on.
- czep 10y agoThe author, arrogant and verbose though he may be, takes issue with Graham's casual assertion that the best hackers are libertarians, and attempts to deconstrust the psychology underlying this connection. What's so illustrative is how Graham inspires his followers to believe the way he does in order to justify and perpetuate his own wealth. The money quote in my mind is: > It is amazing how well this piece serves as marketing fodder for Graham’s venture capital arm, Y Combinator. His business model relies on convincing hordes of eager young hackers to sign over their surplus labor to his investors. With logic crafted to appeal directly to the introverted minds of recent computer science graduates, he has no shortage of cannon fodder lining up on his doorstep willing to eat Ramen and gleefully line the coffers of his investor’s portfolios.
- jstanley 10y agoBut many of the best programmers are libertarians. At a much higher proportion than in the general population, from my (admittedly not well-recorded) observations.
- czep 10y agoI looked at this very question with the help of the General Social Survey. I found that software engineers tend to hold more extreme political views than the average for the population, but it was equally split leaning to the far right as to the far left. It was a significant effect, but not terribly strong (i.e. just a few percentage points in either direction). Of course, the GSS can't tell you who are the "best" programmers.
- jstanley 10y agoDo you think libertarians are far right or far left? Because I subscribe to something more like this: http://www.littlecamels.com/files/PoliticalCross.jpg http://www.littlecamels.com/files/PoliticalCross.jpg Where libertarianism is on a separate axis to the usual left/right.
- 10y ago
- wavefunction 10y agoFree markets are an unattainable Platonic ideal. Just like perfect Communism, it all begins to get messy and come apart at the seams when you introduce theory to the real world and allow fully emotional, non-market-rational humans as the free agents.
- pja 10y agoAnd free markets are the ultimate solution. Ultimate solution to what? There’s an entire field of economics dedicated to the way free markets can fail to allocate resources efficiently, even when the participants are free agents acting without external constraints. Do you think this work is false? Or do you believe that the inefficient allocation of resources is an acceptable price to pay, because “free markets” are more important than outcomes?