7 ms·
The psychology of why we're irrationally more scared of terrorism than guns
- kgwgk 10y ago> (between 2005 and 2015) 301,797 people in the US were shot dead Somewhat misleading, given that most of them shot themselves.
- PerryCox 10y agoYeah I would be very interested in seeing what the statistics are without counting suicides as being "shot dead".
- CalChris 10y agoFrom the CDC, .326 * 33,599 or about 10,953 firearm homicide deaths in 2014: Firearm—In 2014, 33,599 persons died from firearm injuries in the United States (Tables 18 and 19), accounting for 16.8% of all injury deaths in that year. The age-adjusted death rate from firearm injuries (all intents) did not change significantly in 2014 from 2013. The two major component causes of firearm injury deaths in 2014 were suicide (63.5%) and homicide (32.6%). The age-adjusted death rate for firearm homicide decreased 2.8%, from 3.6 in 2013 to 3.5 in 2014. The rate for firearm suicide did not change. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr65/nvsr65_04.pdf https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr65/nvsr65_04.pdf You should understand that firearm-related injuries will be proportionately worse. Moreover, toddlers kill people at the rate of about 1 per week which is significantly greater than terrorism deaths except for 2001 (2908 with 9/11) and 1995 (171 with Oklahoma City). https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/10/14/people-are-getting-shot-by-toddlers-on-a-weekly-basis-this-year/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/10/14/peopl...
- IshKebab 10y ago100k people is still pretty terrible.
- alyandon 10y agoWho do they pick when they conduct these surveys? I don't live my life any differently regardless of the relative threat of terrorism vs vehicle accidents vs any other violent crime vs getting struck by a meteor. Am I really that much of an outlier? Edit: For those that are downvoting me - I live in a large urban area with large urban area related crime problems that actually has had a terrorism related incident. Mind providing an explanation?
- bluedino 10y ago>> It asks 1,500 adults what they fear most. Ask 1,500 citizens in Baltimore, St. Louis, Memphis...
- ch4s3 10y agoHaving lived in Baltimore for 7 years, I was far more afraid of crossing the street than guns per se as the violent crime was fairly localized until about a year before I moved. That said, guns ranked far higher than terrorism, which is basically down at the bottom of my list with bears and being crushed by vending machines.
- notadoc 10y agoYou probably don't watch enough cable "news" where fear and outrage keep you glued to the screen.
- maxerickson 10y agoTerrorism is presently a major political issue. People probably don't live their lives any differently because of it. Many do support shaping government policy around to an extent that is not easily justified by data.
- kj01a 10y ago>Am I really that much of an outlier? No. Most people just live. They go to work, they go home, they sleep, maybe have a few drinks on the weekends, but their lives are not driven by fear of some nebulous thing like guns or terrorism. As a general rule most people's lives are not affected by the scary things on the news, save for the content of their facebook timelines.
- jplasmeier 10y ago> jihadists killed 94 people inside the United States between 2005 and 2015. During that same time period, 301,797 people in the US were shot dead > Americans are more afraid of terrorism than they are of guns, despite the fact that guns are 3,210 times more likely to kill them Er, that's not really how probability works. Sure, it makes some sense but as was pointed out, most of those people shot themselves. Since I don't intend on shooting myself, the probability of me being shot is immediately a fraction of the number quoted in the article. I'm not afraid of guns because I have the privilege of living in a safe area. I'm a lot more scared of the immediate threats to my well-being, which seem to be distracted drivers [0] and slipping on ice [1]. Admittedly I closed the article after this butchering of statistics, so I don't know if the rest of the article is as misguided. [0] - There have been several instances where I walked out into a crosswalk but stopped because I could see a car approaching but not slowing down, with the driver staring at their lap. [1] - I live in Ohio. It snows a lot, but people don't shovel their sidewalks. People walk on the snow and compress it into ice (combined with freezing temps at night) which can persist for a week. EDIT: Stats folk: is there a term for this? It seems similar to a Bayesian Fallacy but I'm not sure that's exactly correct...
- Xylakant 10y agoActually, suicide stats indicate that "I do not intend to kill myself" is not how it works. In general, suicidal episodes seem to be short and having access to means to kill yourself increases the chance you'll actually do that. Not having the means available increases the survival rate - even small barriers like selling painkillers in smaller boxes show significant reduction in suicide rates. Another considerable factor are accidents - nobody intends to kill himself in a gun accident either, it just happens. So I think it's quite correct to include those numbers in the risk profile.
- jimmywanger 10y ago> In general, suicidal episodes seem to be short and having access to means to kill yourself increases the chance you'll actually do that. Well, in the moment you still do mean to kill yourself.
- jnardiello 10y agoAs a EU citizen living where guns are essentially banned (in 30yrs I've seen a gun only once - excluding law enforcement) I'm equally scared by both guns and terrorism. Just to outline that the feeling mentioned in the title can be different given your background and social environment.
- nadezhda18 10y agoyeah, agree with you I am from Canada and I am more scared by guns than by terrorism even given that just several days ago, we had one such attack on our soil. A terrorist attack for me is like a lightning strike. Seems to be deadly but not very probable. Meanwhile, living among people who casually own guns (like in US) is like living in a place where everybody has untamed wild tigers and bears at home. Unpredictable, dangerous, not very smart. It's a real day-to-day threat to our lives.
- bryanmgreen 10y agoProbably because we use guns to "defend" and express our freedom and terrorism only attacks our freedoms. No one ever says "hey, I want to be a terrorist." Instead they're using their violence to support a personal righteous cause. Terrorism happens to people - it's not something people do.
- coldtea 10y agoA great example how, based on your readings of the data, you can lie or present any case with statistics... First of all, among the gun deaths there are people that shot themselves, and also people shot in gang shootings and such (where, if you're not in a gang you're not that affected). So the number is somewhat inflated (of course still bigger than terrorism). Second, people fear going into violent neighborhoods with gun crime (say Compton at night), a hell of a lot than they fear terrorism. They might agree when asked in polls that "terrorism is a great threat", but they sure as hell as pragmatically more concerned with areas with violent crime, and avoiding them in their day to day lives. Third, as people in certain places have witnessed, terrorism can be a constant source of death and horror, with multiple incidents per year, or even daily if a country goes sour. Just because it hasn't happened in some place, it doesn't mean it's impossible to happen (e.g. if there's a sizable militant islam population in the US). Fourth, terrorism can also bring much more horrible outcomes than the regular gun death, even more than a mass shooting. Some crazies can kill literally tens of thousands via some (not that elaborate) plan. And while it might not always be possible to predict or prevent such a thing, one can still fear it (and fear to further stir the conditions that might make it happen). Fifth, do the people that are OK with guns believe that if there was strict gun control gun related crime would go down? Or do they believe that criminals will be the only ones with access to guns (bought illegally of course)? If the latter's the case, then it makes sense to be OK with guns, as they see them as something they can use to protect themselves against violent crime and that the criminals will have anyway. And of course nobody realistically believes that they'll snap and kill their spouse with that gun (or vise versa -- as it often happens). It's more realistic, in that sense, to fear terrorism than yourself.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoI think you're wrong about point 4. Could you outline such a plan? As a counter-example: CIA trained operatives with decades of experience and a 20+ person team launching a coordinated attack could only kill 3,000 -- and that was only because of underlying weaknesses in our security policy. The 9/11 attacks were so easy to counter, they didn't even work through one full morning. (By which I mean, 25% of the planes were downed before reaching their targets.) Reinforced cockpit doors and changes in passenger/crew behavior means that a repeated attempt likely would result in 0 deaths.
- juskrey 10y agoTerrorism scales, it is fat tailed distribution (9/11 again, anyone?). Cancer, guns and car accidents - no. Article is plain bullshit.
- roywiggins 10y agoA 9/11 every year still wouldn't make terrorism more dangerous than guns, by my reckoning. That's only a few thousand a year, gun violence kills tens of thousands. Unless you work in a tall building of course...
- juskrey 10y agoI think you don't understand what "to scale" means.
- lwkl 10y agoIt's funny I was talking to a friend and she said she's terified when driving through france because of the terrorists. So she drives non stop till she is in spain. And she is so sad about it since she loves france and can't go there anymore. It seemed so out of the world to me, since it never occured to me that I will be the victim of a terrorist attack. And even if: what happens happens. No reason to stop going on with your life. I have to say the only news I read are tech news. The rest I get from colleagues at lunch. And sometimes I skim through the newspaper and read some articles that really interest me.
- IshKebab 10y agoYour friend is an idiot.
- Tycho 10y agoJournalists really need some guidelines on how to report on statistics without veering into nonsense.
- mindcrime 10y agoBeing scared of guns is irrational. Being scared of some people with guns is rational. Being scared of terrorism makes about as much sense as being scared of dying from a lightning strike. It could happen, but it's so unlikely there just isn't much point spending any time thinking about it.
- cooper12 10y agoLeave it to HN to completely ignore the point of the article and nitpick statistics. Guns kill more people than terrorism, period. Regardless of the actual numbers, the article's point still stands.
- grzm 10y agoPlease don't generalize HN like this, particularly as you choose to participate in the community. If you have specific criticisms, please address them civilly.
- cooper12 10y agoI'm not generalizing, the proof is right in this thread, the top comments are all focusing on the specific numbers and completely missing the point. And that is a specific criticism.
- grzm 10y agoNo subset of commenters represent all of HN. There are a wide variety of positions held by members of the HN community. Failing to recognize that is just as much "missing the point" as that of which you accuse these commenters. No matter how wrong you think others may be, please take extra care when commenting on contentious topics.
- morganvachon 10y ago> Guns kill more people than terrorism, period. People with guns kill more people than terrorism. Guns aren't sentient (yet). Guns are inanimate tools; it's a people problem, not a tool problem. Just as you wouldn't say that cars kill people and try to ban cars when it's actually irresponsible drivers (drunk, inattentive, etc) that cause the accident, you can't blame an inanimate object for what its user does with it. Shifting the blame is a political maneuver as old as mankind.
- cooper12 10y agoYou're only proving my point by nitpicking further. Pedantry isn't a virtue, especially in assuming I'm so stupid as to anthropomorphize a piece of metal or trying to utilize a political maneuver. Focus on the article instead of nitpicking.
- erikbern 10y agoThere's some rationality to people's fear for terrorism. The impact of a terrorist attack is probably exponentially distributed, like an earthquake attack. Saying no one has died in earthquakes in SF in the last 10 years is not relevant. Or pandemics – people are afraid of the next Ebola for the right reasons. The 1918 influenza killed 20-50M people.
- AstralStorm 10y agoThat was after the World War and resulting starvation though.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dclowd9901 10y agoEveryone here is trying to tackled the stats of gun deaths, but I'm really floored by a survey that shows Americans are more afraid of losing guns than loved ones.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- yummyfajitas 10y agoI think the real issue here is that perceptions of many of these risks is as much a matter of tribal identity as anything else. For example, liking guns is a tribal value of "team red" - therefore viewing it as dangerous is as much an attack on "our team" as it is a rational assessment. This behavior is hardly limited to "team red". Tolerance of gay sex is a tribal value of "team blue". Yet it turns out M2M gay sex is between 15x and 200x as dangerous as gun ownership. How many people are remotely aware of this? https://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2016/are_gays_or_guns_more_dangerous.html https://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2016/are_gays_or_guns_mor... People suck at risk assessment in general. Apart from scoring cheap points for our team, why focus on terrorism and guns specifically?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Pocketsnakes 10y agoTerrorism is a murderous act. "Guns" is not.