5 ms·
Hmm, So it doesn't bother you that this "investment" doesn't have any relation to building productive enterprises of any sort? One might might think that the
by joe_the_user 17y ago
Hmm,
So it doesn't bother you that this "investment" doesn't have any relation to building productive enterprises of any sort?
One might might think that the nastiness of 2008 would wake people up to the idea that markets can generate destructive speculation as well as constructive investment. But fixed ideas mostly resist reality.
And contrasting the NYSE profiteering to high frequency profiteering is kind of false argument. It's more a matter that deregulation has been a disaster and the situation cries for a modern version of re-regulation - except that the inmates are still well in control of the asylum.
- kjhgfghjk 17y agoAnd you picture the other traders physically on the NYSE as the bank manager in "A Wonderfull Life"?
- snewe 17y ago> So it doesn't bother you that this "investment" doesn't have any relation to building productive enterprises of any sort? As the article points out, these firms provide liquidity which makes trading faster and cheaper. Theoretically, more liquidity should also make it easier to move capital to the most profitable enterprises.
- milkshakes 17y agoAs the article points out, these firms provide liquidity which makes trading faster and cheaper. Theoretically, more liquidity should also make it easier to move capital to the most profitable enterprises. Actually, the article suggests that the firms pulled out of the market, and that their actions amplified the crash. HFT is a zero sum game, and these firms just demonstrated that they exist to extract value from the market, not provide it liquidity. [edit]:Though there are obvious differences, I feel like HFT in general is just another form of side betting, alarmingly similar, in principle to CDOs and other derivatives, in at least a few ways. They're exotic, and theirfore unregulated, they dwarf and therefore distort "real" market activity, and they appear to provide value, but the geniuses behind them underestimate the risk because they can never account for all the possible black swan events. When "real" markets depend on these educated guesses, and the guesses turn out to be wrong, the real markets suffer. Sure we know how to create fancy new financial products to back up these guesses, and exploit the leverage provided by developments in math and computer science, but the fact remains that we still can't even identify, let alone account for what we don't know. The good news is that because these particular bets are shorter term, in this case the immediate damage is reversible, though their were definitely consequences that were irreversible, and if we keep allowing our equity markets get pushed around by HFT, the next time the system hiccups, the irreversible consequences may spiral out of control. But I don't have a very deep finance background. I'd love to hear thoughts from some people who do.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoActually, the article suggests that the firms pulled out of the market, and that their actions amplified the crash. Without high frequency traders, the market became far less liquid. This was considered a bad thing by almost all involved. It's almost as if high frequency traders are actually providing a valuable service for the rest of the world! Also, HFT is not very vulnerable to "black swan" events. HFT doesn't usually use leverage, there are very few counterparties, no leverage, and almost no contagion.
- milkshakes 17y ago>Without high frequency traders, the market became far less liquid. I totally agree. >This was considered a bad thing by almost all involved. What I'm trying to propose is that the regulators involved in overseeing markets are becoming more and more out of touch with the techniques being used to improve their efficiency. What's important for long term economic health does not align with what is important for short term market efficiency. And as a result of this, the long term economic policy cannot keep up with the increasing degree to which short term regulation can affect markets. Yet long term economic health has an impact on other metrics of "utility" beyond itself, and we're in trouble if the power of the people in charge of making the rules can't address the needs of the people who depend on them. In other words, our regulators actions are predicated on the assumption that we knew how to improve the efficiency of the equity market. Lately, the influence they have on the markets has been increasing, but the amount of oversight they have been subjected to is decreasing. The skills that are relevant to getting politician into office are diverging from the skills and attention that are required to selecting these regulator in the first place. The politicians wind up screwing the people who both elected and depend on them. -- Let's consider the current, using arbitrage to improve the market's liquidity case, as an example. The most effective arbitrage techniques are made possible in part by simultaneously exploiting developments in computer science theory with those financial theory, and combining our improved ability to process this newly discovered information with our improved ability to implement our improved knowledge. In other words, in this case our increasingly sophisticated understanding of finance and computer science is what allowed us to more efficiently implement and test our hypotheses in the first place. Previously we used CDO's to improve our ability to assess risk. We did this because we assumed that assessing risk was important to the efficiency of the markets. However, CDOs were made possible by developments in financial theory and implementation, as well as statistics, and the politicians in charge of influencing our dependance on ability to improve this sophistication were out of touch with the long term effects that their decisions have.
- wisty 17y agoIn other words, HF traders are a cludgey hack around stock exchanges that were designed on principles that were developed in Victorian era trading floors. Removing them won't fix the underlying problems.
- grandalf 17y agoWhat are the underlying problems?
- anigbrowl 17y agoI don't mind the speculative aspect of it so much - there's legitimate economic reasons for that to exist, and fills an important market function - but I do have misgivings about trades being filled algorithmically rather than by decision of a human agent. On the other hand I'm not sure how you police it, because some home-investor with a trading program that kicks in and saves him from losing several thousand while he's in the bathroom is engaging in algorithmic trading too, and I wouldn't deny an individual investor such safety mechanisms.
- IsaacSchlueter 17y agoHow much more do the typical "real" investors know about the products they invest in than the computer programs? In other words, if we rule out insider information, isn't all trading, on some level, "algorithmic"? The real-ness comes from the financial statements of the corporations being invested in.
- anigbrowl 17y agoEr...I think that's a rather strained construction. By 'algorithmic' I mean 'executed by a computer without human confirmation at time of execution,' rather than the general application of a methodology.
- grandalf 17y agoAre you serious? The idea that speculation is bad dates back to old and embarrassing ant-Semitic rhetoric. Speculation is an inevitable property of markets and is indistinguishable from more "concrete" behaviors such as hedging. Suppose a farmer buys rain insurance but not hail insurance. He's hedging one and gambling on the other. Yet he bought no contract for the latter. Such transactions do help build productive enterprises, as they help with price discovery of the shares and add liquidity (which makes the investment more sound for everyone).
- pook 17y agohttp://mises.org/daily/320 http://mises.org/daily/320 a history of speculation and a rebuttal of many of its disparagements
- _delirium 17y agoThat does come from mises.org, though, and sort of says what you'd expect the Mises Institute to say about speculation. Which doesn't make it wrong, but does mean you're getting one particular side of a long-running debate in economics (roughly, the Austrian-School side). There are a lot more perspectives in the literature: http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=%22role+of+speculation%22 http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=%22role+of+spe...
- grandalf 17y agoSearch this doc for "speculators" to see where this is really coming from. The modern arguments against speculation are just echoes of this. http://www.jrbooksonline.com/Intl_Jew_full_version/ij23.htm http://www.jrbooksonline.com/Intl_Jew_full_version/ij23.htm
- _delirium 17y agoIt surely doesn't come from that, which you must know is a kind of lame slander, the usual "the Nazis did [x], so you're a Nazi" non-argument. General attacks on speculation and finance go much further back than anti-Semitic worries about "Jewish finance", to long before the medieval era when European Jews became associated with finance--- the Jewish scriptures themselves, and writings of the early Christians, both have a bunch of attacks on finance in them. Surely the Talmud itself isn't anti-Semitic? And a modern quantitative understanding of the role of speculation is pretty unconnected to Jews (most financiers are atheists or Christians, anyway).