4 ms·
Realize the article is written by Andy Pasztor. If there is ever a negative SpaceX angle, he'll find it. I'm not disputing the factual content of the article,
by Robotbeat 10y ago
Realize the article is written by Andy Pasztor. If there is ever a negative SpaceX angle, he'll find it.
I'm not disputing the factual content of the article, nor do I have reason to believe he's paid off to do hit pieces, but it's important to realize he almost constantly has a chip on his shoulder with respect to SpaceX.
Another thing to keep in mind: SpaceX produces more liquid rocket engines than any other domestic provider by a VERY large margin.
- crikli 10y agoWell said. This smells like a hatchet piece put together by the gray hairs at StratCom who've continued to be incredulous that a private enterprise can put things in orbit and have hoped for SpaceX to fail from the outset.
- planteen 10y ago> incredulous that a private enterprise can put things in orbit What's with this commonly repeated narrative that SpaceX is the only private company in space? I think the formation of ULA between Boeing and Lockheed was garbage as much as the next person. Just like Boeing buying McDonnell Douglas was garbage. But look at a list of rockets to take something to space and they are all private (ULA, Orbital, and SpaceX). SpaceX plays the game just like everyone else. They hire the retired generals from the military. They bid on government launches. They use government ranges for launching.
- kevin_thibedeau 10y agoAll of the incumbent's R&D was paid for by US taxpayers. Their bloated pricing is a product of not having to compete commercially on cost. SpaceX has to seek business where the opportunities are. They in turn plow their profits back into the business rather than waiting for the next handout.
- sidlls 10y agoAnd what R&D do you think SpaceX is built on? I'll give you a hint: you mentioned it in your comment.
- xenadu02 10y agoThat doesn't explain why ULA has such insane launch costs. It's a classic government fleece job. They've been stealing taxpayer dollars because they could. SpaceX is charging a fraction of the cost. ULA has been paying lobbyists and trying to squeeze SpaceX out of bidding. It has been purely due to the hype around SpaceX that they were not successful.
- planteen 10y agoWhy the government let Boeing and Lockheed form the ULA is beyond me. The US used to have 3 solid launch providers and went to 1. I'm glad we're back to 2 with SpaceX. We were handing lots of business to Arianespace.
- chriskanan 10y agoIn another article [1], the GAO says that they cannot talk about any information in the report because it is still in preparation and has not been publicly made available, so others cannot even verify the claims of the author. The preliminary report must have been leaked to the author of the WSJ article. [1] http://www.theverge.com/2017/2/2/14490946/spacex-rocket-engine-safety-defect-congressional-investigation-wsj-report http://www.theverge.com/2017/2/2/14490946/spacex-rocket-engi...
- mevile 10y agoIt's good to have someone who's skeptical and willing to travel beyond the spacex fever the tech press is infected with to report on things with a critical eye. This seems like a totally valid article, and as long as the facts are correct as reported it doesn't really matter who the author is.
- djmdjm 10y agoAgreed - the criticisms here are pure ad hominem. If there is a problem with SpaceX components, then that is surely more important and relevant than who wrote the article publicising it.
- rosser 10y agoPointing out an author's bias isn't fallacious. Using that bias to disregard facts is.
- linkregister 10y agoExcept that the journalistic track record of an author is additional information. Imagine a person who you know to have a large bias against something. Now imagine they tell you a narrative about that thing. You, being a reasonable person, would use greater scrutiny about that narrative than someone who you know to be uninterested or even marginally interested in the subject. I agree that the public has an interest in finding out about issues in the rockets its government purchases. The above commenter isn't saying "disregard, it's the anti-SpaceX guy!" It's just more information. Gathering information has a cost; and we can't all fully research every opinion. I didn't downvote you; it's a reasonable argument to make, and I don't mind giving the counter-opinion in the least.
- conistonwater 10y agoGenerally speaking, not wrt this article, I want to point out that usually the definition of bias is that it's unreasonable—if the concerns are reasonable, then it's not bias. So you can't look at someone, see that they write negative articles, and conclude bias. That's not enough information: you still ought to establish whether they got it wrong (especially in an obvious or lazy way), and only then conclude they are biased. If someone keeps writing negative/positive articles, and you don't know if they're right, then you also don't know if they're biased or not. Since I don't see anybody pointing out what's obviously wrong with these concerns, I feel safe to assume it's not biased. Figuring out if an argument is biased is at least as hard as examining the argument on merits, and usually much harder. So I think that the commenters were right to call out the ad hominem.