4 ms·
At least police obtained the data through the proper channels, securing a search warrant. I can't think of an argument against this being valid and reasonable.
by mywittyname 10y ago
At least police obtained the data through the proper channels, securing a search warrant. I can't think of an argument against this being valid and reasonable.
- jrowley 10y agoI'm curious how a) they determined he had a pace maker b) where they got the idea to check it for data. Pretty wild.
- rbcgerard 10y agoi read another article about this, and apparently he told the 911 operator something along those lines... Edit: "Compton also told the dispatcher he had “an artificial heart.” http://www.networkworld.com/article/3162740/security/cops-use-pacemaker-data-as-evidence-to-charge-homeowner-with-arson-insurance-fraud.html http://www.networkworld.com/article/3162740/security/cops-us...
- temp246810 10y agoExactly - parallel construction is a thing. I feel obligated to mention it every time in these circumstances because even if it doesn't apply in this particular case, people should be aware of how surveillance can affect them even if what the police do is on the up and up on the surface.
- Avenger42 10y agoFrom the article: > Compton, who has extensive medical problems, including an artificial heart implant that uses an eternal pump (I'm fairly certain they meant "external" there.)
- jrowley 10y agoGood pickup. Haha I'd an "eternal" pump would be handy.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThis was the reassuring part to me. Hey they can get a warrant to download your vehicle's "black box" history too. It would have alarmed me if they simply told the pacemaker service provider "this is a person of interest, give us all your data on them, oh and you can't tell anyone about this or we'll bring you up on treason charges." That is the kind of stuff that really bothers me.
- grayhatter 10y agoSame reason they can't make a spouse testify against you. The chilling effect would be problematic. (Or, if you want something more medical, why Physicians or Psychiatrists can't be force to testify against you.) As a former medical person, and a current tech person; I'm sitting here wondering how I could write software that would allow me to get the data to help and protect my patient's health, while still protecting/limiting the data from things/actions like this one. When helping my patients to make the decision of whether or not to have a pacemaker installed, I don't want them worrying if it's ever going to become evidence against them at some later date.
- mywittyname 10y agoI know that spousal privilege is codified into law, which got me thinking if there are similar protections between doctors and patients (like there are with attorneys). It looks like some countries have protections between patients and doctors, but not the USA. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physician%E2%80%93patient_privilege#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physician%E2%80%93patient_priv... I agree that this information should be protected, but it looks like we will need additional laws to grant these privileges.
- djsumdog 10y agoThere are exceptions to patient privilege. Most states have laws regarding ongoing abuse or abuse of a minor which must be reported by doctors.
- grayhatter 10y agoSure, because someone is actively being harmed, or will be harmed in the future. (and is injury that's not easily recouped, i.e. abuse of a minor could be a life long injury, where insurance fraud is build into the cost of premiums)
- jokoon 10y agoPeople dislike government but love their technology. So it makes sense for them to not like when government uses technology.
- Someone 10y agoI can, maybe. Is that pacemaker legally part of that man's body? If so, wouldn't this be requiring a man to testify against himself, and would a search warrant be appropriate? I don't think you can use one to force a DNA or HIV test, for example.