12 ms·
Data from man's pacemaker led to arson charges
- kordless 10y agoIf you have a neural mesh, the state will likely have intent to claim they have access and rights to the date in the mesh, regardless of whether it is in your body or not. There's no way in hell I'm ever hooking a computer up to my brain in this reality.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoWouldn't something like that be encrypted and have a neural password?
- CiPHPerCoder 10y agoWhat makes you think the government couldn't demand the maker of the neural connectors exfiltrate the neural password?
- ceejayoz 10y agoThe fact that this is already a solved problem for iPhones via the Secure Enclave?
- Zombieball 10y agoI'm not convinced it is entirely solved though. Didn't the FBI drop their request to Apple because they found a loophole or security vulnerability that allowed them to accomplish what they wanted? I think at the end of the day, software has bugs. And if you have an extremely well funded and intelligent group (e.g. Equation Group) looking for these holes and keeping them secret for personal use and exploitation rather than fixing them, there are going to be ways for your data to be compromised.
- ceejayoz 10y ago> Didn't the FBI drop their request to Apple because they found a loophole or security vulnerability that allowed them to accomplish what they wanted? The phone in the San Bernardino case was an iPhone 5C, with the A6 processor. Secure Enclave was introduced in the A7. https://9to5mac.com/2016/04/07/fbi-iphone-hack-method-secure-enclave/ https://9to5mac.com/2016/04/07/fbi-iphone-hack-method-secure...
- Zombieball 10y agoAh yes, I forgot this detail. Thanks!
- greedo 10y agoNo, the model of the iPhone the FBI wanted to access didn't have the Secure Enclave.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- digler999 10y agoI agree with you, although you were wrong about that specific Apple case. I don't trust "secure enclave" because it would be too easy for a TLA to infiltrate the chip foundry and backdoor the silicon. they can literally print money, circumvent the constitution using secret courts/NSL's, their resources are infinite. what would stop them from doing this ? Even if you couldn't infiltrate the chip foundry, you could order a bunch of the chips, reverse engineer them, and in a few months, ship a duplicate with a neutered "enclave". Then interdict the shipment to the phone manufacturer (this isn't tinfoil, it's been done) and "supply" them with your version of the "secure enclave". There's no limit to this cat and mouse game.
- ceejayoz 10y agoThat's not really an argument against a neural lace, though. You're just as fucked if you don't get one - they drop child porn on your laptop, or just disappear you.
- Pica_soO 10y agoThere is a even easier way to get somebody finished off.. drop a noisy true crypt container on there cellphone or notebook - if they get searched- they will be held in contempt indefinably for a white noise treasure trove they can not open.
- AstralStorm 10y agoEasy to defend, they have to prove you created said file consciously if the device was ever in the possession of someone else other than police. If they are likely to break the law to tamper with evidence, you've already lost.
- mikeash 10y agoIt's a solved problem the way the laws are currently written. It's not a solved problem if the laws are rewritten to require manufacturers to support a backdoor.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoHow would the maker of the neural connectors get your neural password?
- fenwick67 10y agoThere have been several court cases where the government has compelled people to give up encryption keys in court, I assume this will be no different.
- andreyf 10y agoIf you have something, a court can order you to give it up. If you know something which might incriminate you (e.g. a password), your testimony is protected by the 5th.
- nickff 10y agoPasswords have only been protected by the 5th amendment when ownership of the electronic account/device is unproven.
- BickNowstrom 10y agoFor international laws, see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law Specifically for the US, see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lavabit#Suspension_and_gag_order https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lavabit#Suspension_and_gag_ord... and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Fricosu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Fricosu
- sbierwagen 10y agoImportant to note that this is a legal theory, that is not yet backed up by precedent or statute! The police have successfully compelled password disclosure many times.
- andreyf 10y agoThere has been tons of precedent, on both sides: http://www.zdnet.com/article/florida-court-says-password-disclosure-not-protected-by-fifth-amendment/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/florida-court-says-password-dis... This is the only sane interpretation, though, as people have more and more encrypted devices, it's unreasonable to punish someone for not remembering a password.
- maxerickson 10y agoWhy not build a well regulated state that only uses such powers in narrow circumstances? I mean, you are sort of implying that installing a neural mesh would give you greater exposure to injustice than not doing so, so why not just fight the injustice to begin with? Not believing that such a state is achievable is one thing, but you did say "in this reality".
- koolba 10y ago> Why not build a well regulated state that only uses such powers in narrow circumstances? Because the definition of "well regulated" is highly subjective and any state that's in power would consider its own uses to be with the confines of any circumstance no matter how narrow. The only way to win is to not play the game.
- maxerickson 10y agoNo, the only way to win is to continually work to build a more just society. It may be pragmatic to keep computers out of your brain in the meantime.
- pjlegato 10y agoThe intractable problem is that what constitutes "more just" is highly subjective, highly debatable, and always will be. All historic societies believed they were being "more just" in some sense.
- djsumdog 10y agoI would recommend the book Animal Farm. The revolution was good in every way. It was peaceful and the animals got back control of their lives. But even from that, the pigs convinced everyone they needed leaders. Unfortunately, the pragmatic reality is that no matter how much you try to shape a system of control to be balanced, the people who eventually get into power are the ones that crave it and often don't have much respect for the individual.
- 10y ago
- ajross 10y agoEven in alternate realities, really. There's a Black Mirror episode (a really good one, so no spoilers here) about exactly that scenario.
- phinnaeus 10y agoIs that s3e01?
- Apanatshka 10y agoI think multiple episodes including the season 2 christmas episode comment on brain computer interfaces in one form or another and they all seem realistic and scary to me. Best not use direct brain computer interfaces.
- driverdan 10y agoI'm curious why you called it a neural mesh. I've never heard that term before and some searching doesn't result in anything. Is that something you made up?
- gene-h 10y agoYou are of course assuming the data will be easy to understand. One possibility for a neural mesh is that we emulate parts of the brain in hardware to say add more 'storage.' We don't need an understanding of the 'format' a memory is stored to do this, much in the same way that we can build a hard drive for a computer without understanding the JPEG format. It could be really difficult to extract useful information from such hardware. Let's say we have a brain implant that maps a 3d scene concept to positions of objects in 3d space. So input scene foo gives me baz(1,1,1), bar(1,2,1), quz(1,3,3), etc. Such stored data is next to useless if we don't know what the inputs and outputs map to. We don't know if scene foo is a scene of a desk or a scene of a movie and we don't know if baz is a book, a gun, or an open book, but the person's brain using the implant does. Determining what these mappings are could be very difficult. We may have to expose the implant's wearer to millions of different objects to determine how they what the object tags are.
- ccvannorman 10y agoYour interpretation: data is "next to useless". Plaintiff's expensive lawyer interpretation: "clear, decisive and overwhelming". Hope you have a good lawyer too. I know I'm being cynical when I say this is 2017 and facts don't matter. Yet here we are.
- mywittyname 10y agoAt least police obtained the data through the proper channels, securing a search warrant. I can't think of an argument against this being valid and reasonable.
- jrowley 10y agoI'm curious how a) they determined he had a pace maker b) where they got the idea to check it for data. Pretty wild.
- rbcgerard 10y agoi read another article about this, and apparently he told the 911 operator something along those lines... Edit: "Compton also told the dispatcher he had “an artificial heart.” http://www.networkworld.com/article/3162740/security/cops-use-pacemaker-data-as-evidence-to-charge-homeowner-with-arson-insurance-fraud.html http://www.networkworld.com/article/3162740/security/cops-us...
- temp246810 10y agoExactly - parallel construction is a thing. I feel obligated to mention it every time in these circumstances because even if it doesn't apply in this particular case, people should be aware of how surveillance can affect them even if what the police do is on the up and up on the surface.
- Avenger42 10y agoFrom the article: > Compton, who has extensive medical problems, including an artificial heart implant that uses an eternal pump (I'm fairly certain they meant "external" there.)
- jrowley 10y agoGood pickup. Haha I'd an "eternal" pump would be handy.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wheaties 10y agoI get it but this is some scary stuff that pushes the bounds of ethics. I mean, on one hand we want to prevent insurance fraud because it impacts everyone. On the other, where do we draw the line? Should we even have to consider that a pacemaker could be used to gather data about us before we consent to a pacemaker? It shouldn't. Now it is.
- Avenger42 10y ago> Should we even have to consider that a pacemaker could be used to gather data about us before we consent to a pacemaker? It shouldn't. Your pacemaker gathers that data (exertion history over time) so that your doctor can view it after the fact and ask you "what were you doing last Thursday afternoon? The pacemaker says it was running extra high between 3:30 and 4:30." I think most people would opt into such a device for their own health - in fact, many might wear it on their wrist and pair it with their phone.
- burkaman 10y agoI don't see why this is scary. I think it's somewhat comparable to the police examining his clothes, for example, and finding no traces of sweat or smoke, which would make his story not credible. Or what about looking at how many steps a Fitbit recorded? If the pacemaker had a GPS or something embedded in it, that would be egregious, but a pacemaker collecting data on the pace it's making is expected, and the police should be able to look at it with a warrant. Police can access medical records with a warrant, and this is basically just a very recent medical record.
- grayhatter 10y agoYou don't need clothing to stay alive, nor a fitbit. And medical history can't really be used to indict someone. Where this clearly was. EDIT: can't be used to indict, only as addition evidence for a trial. It's an important distinction, but I'm not sure I think it's okay either.
- burkaman 10y agoWhy isn't it ok? The whole purpose of a warrant is to reveal private information when necessary. I get that medical history is especially sensitive, but I don't see why it should be completely off limits. What if, say, someone claimed to be out of the country for an extended period of time, but their medical history showed they actually required frequent treatment at a local hospital? Should that be inadmissible?
- nkrisc 10y agoI wonder if he had any idea his pacemaker collected such data or that it could be used against him? Should patients be made aware of this risk when they're receiving the devices?
- grayhatter 10y ago> Should patients be made aware of this risk when they're receiving the devices? Yes, if they find out via the internet, instead of the physician; now your patient doesn't trust you as much, and you can't do your job.
- miguelrochefort 10y ago> Should patients be made aware of this risk when they're receiving the devices? What risk? The risk that the truth comes out? Give me a break.
- billmalarky 10y agoDevil's Advocate: Software has bugs, what if the data implicated him but was incorrect? Of course bugs in a pacemaker means bigger problems... but you get my point.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI assume that a reasonable justice system wouldn't sentence someone based on a singular piece of evidence. True facts reinforce each other; false claims oppose the truth. Therefore if the data was incorrect, hopefully there would be other pieces of evidence that would contradict the data.
- PeterisP 10y agoThe possibility of bugs is something that the defence can argue - the court would need to find beyond reasonable doubt that the defendant was guilty. It's certainly not the responsibility of manufacturer to provide perfect or imperfect certainty about the data, but it's the prerogative of the jury to decide the trustworthiness of that data.
- kozak 10y agoThere should be even more stories where data from fitness trackers is used, right?
- nom 10y agoThey can't proof that you were wearing the device at the time of the incident. It's also possible to fake the data, either by letting someone else wear it or by spoofing the bluetooth device itself.
- SN76477 10y agoHow is this not a HIPPA violation?
- _delirium 10y agoHIPPA allows disclosure in response to a court order or warrant (among other things). See here: https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/45/164.512#f https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/45/164.512#f
- 1qaz2wsx3edc 10y agoIANAL nor American but this feels like another thing stepping on top of their constitution, specially the spirit of the fifth: > nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself I can be tried for my data? That's kind of messed up, what if the data was faked, etc.
- rhino369 10y agoOf course you can be tried for you data. Letters, records, etc. have always been used.
- xenophonf 10y agoHIPAA is a federal EDI standard for healthcare providers and insurance companies that includes protections for patient safety and privacy as well as security mandates intended to protect the integrity and availability of the medical/insurance data collection and interchange processes. It has nothing to do with the lawful collection of evidence, and in fact specifically allows that: https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/faq/505/what-does-the-privacy-rule-allow-covered-entities-to-disclose-to-law-enforcement-officials/index.html https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/faq/505/what-doe...
- trekking101 10y agoOne person's metadata is another's data
- vr46 10y agoApart from anything else, there's a delightful irony in that the device that (probably) kept him alive to be able to commit a crime was also responsible for catching him. It sounds as though the doctors' evidence was fairly powerful regardless of the data from the pacemaker.
- jordan9001 10y agoThe Tell-Tale Heart
- 6stringmerc 10y agoYou should take a bow for that one, way to stick the landing.
- chaseha 10y agoExcellent!!
- coreyp_1 10y agoImagine that you are in a car accident (the other person hit you). The insurance company uses your sleep tracker to claim that you were negligent due to not getting enough sleep the night before, and are therefore at fault, so they won't pay. Data is as dangerous as it is helpful. The scary thing is that you cannot control how someone else will interpret your data.
- kitbrennan 10y agoIn your example I think it's right that the driver is found at fault. The effects of sleep deprivation on driving are very well documented and are comparable to drinking. If a driver is not fit to be driving a car, then they are a danger to the other road users and must take responsibility for their negligence. The same evidence could of course be helpful to the driver. If their sleep tracking app shows they are well rested and their phone's use shows no distractions while driving, then they could use that as evidence to fight a charge of driving without due care and attention.
- dionidium 10y agoIt's not as though we can derive some hard cutoff on how little sleep is clearly negligent. We're talking about wide ranges and tolerances for different people in different circumstances. We're in the same situation with alcohol -- how much before you're actually impaired? -- but most states have responded to that reality with laws that prohibit driving after drinking almost any alcohol at all. Are you sure you want a similar situation with respect to your sleep?
- ccvannorman 10y agoI stayed up working until 5 am (I was on a roll). Should I be afraid of driving now? I'm not tired at all. Welcome to the future, where if your habits are abnormal big data can land you in jail for it.
- closeparen 10y ago
- snarf21 10y agoIt seems unlikely that the heart rate data alone would allow for indictment but it was one more piece of data since the suspect was not cooperating. [http://www.networkworld.com/article/3162740/security/cops-use-pacemaker-data-as-evidence-to-charge-homeowner-with-arson-insurance-fraud.html http://www.networkworld.com/article/3162740/security/cops-us...] They found gasoline on his clothing, investigation revealed the fire started at multiple locations and he told 911 that "everyone was out of the house" but was heard over the phone telling someone to get out of here. So he was an idiot and got caught...