3 ms·
Do we have any estimates on how many actual deaths (or sicknesses) occur due to the use of these chemicals? I care because if we can't positively attribute dea
by dekhn 10y ago
Do we have any estimates on how many actual deaths (or sicknesses) occur due to the use of these chemicals? I care because if we can't positively attribute death or sickness to the use of these chemicals, it seems unfair to tarnish them.
- maxerickson 10y agoThat's too low a bar. A lot of the worst environmental mistakes used that approach and it has gotten less sensible as our knowledge of chemistry and biology has advanced.
- dekhn 10y agoI understand the desire to eliminate all health hazards, but that is not economically feasible. Does it not seem reasonable to state that if you cannot find any death or illnes in a chemical, when used for a specific purpose, that is it not reasonable to simply eliminate the chemical? This isn't really abotu advancing chemistry or biology, either. We have a pretty good understanding that these contaminants need to be consumed repeatedly, at high exposure levels, to have a detectable effect. Epidemiology would be more likely to create a compelling for or against case than additional medical research. I mean, I'd have an easier time if you could show at least a compelling argument that harm has been done.
- maxerickson 10y agoSure it is economically feasible to leave the PFOA related chemicals out of fast food wrappers, the big consequence is that the wrappers will be greasier (I guess this might bug people that eat their fries with a fork). I'm not proposing that the safety of all chemicals be proven before they are used, I realize that it is logically impossible. I'm saying that spraying tons of stuff that is chemically similar to known problematic compounds out into the environment to see if it is bad is the wrong approach. Stuff that isn't chemically similar to known problematic compounds? Take a more relaxed approach.
- dekhn 10y agoWhat do you mean by "chemically similar"? I am not aware of this having a meaningful definition when working with toxins, and ... well, I have a PhD in the field.
- maxerickson 10y agoStuff like having functional groups in common, participating in similar reactions.
- dekhn 10y agoWhy do you think that matters? Many things have common functional groups, and in many cases, there are no similar molecules. Functionality doesn't transfer that way (it's a highly non-linear process). As for similar reactions- well, that's nice, but again, just seeing that a molecule participates in some chemistry has little to no predictive ability for health outcomes.
- mikeatlas 10y agoThey're certainly worth tarnishing. Knowledge of PFOA and PFAS is not without science and evidence of it's harm already established. Here are two sites where the chemicals have contaminated groundwater and caused illness in communities. http://healthvermont.gov/response/environmental/pfoa-drinking-water-2016 http://healthvermont.gov/response/environmental/pfoa-drinkin... https://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/13/nyregion/military-base-contaminated-water-in-newburgh-ny-state-says.html?_r=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/13/nyregion/military-base-co...
- dekhn 10y agoThe first link shows contaminated well water at very high concentrations. That's bad. The second link mentions more contaminated water supply, and mentions cancer. I am asking if anybody can directly demonstrate that using this in food liner has an even detectable rate of harm. If it doesn't then there is no reasonable basis, just fear, to remove the chemicals from the liners.
- DanBC 10y agoCould there be harm from removing these particular chemicals? If not, isn't the precautionary principle good? I guess this highlights how poor humans are at identifying and thinking about risk.
- dekhn 10y agoremoving the chemicals would make the food liners not work anymore. then the people who make the liners will find something else. It's not clear there is anything else that works as well, or is as safe. in this case it's almost certainly true that food liners do not contribute enough of the toxin to have an effect- below a certain dosage the body simply mops up all the toxin and there is no cumulative harm. On the other hand where people are exposed to massive amounts, they develop obvious and clear health problems.