4 ms·
This could potentially be a good thing. The budgets we currently see when the public sector is involved are borderline vulgar. Most of these projects could be
by ThomPete 17y ago
This could potentially be a good thing.
The budgets we currently see when the public sector is involved are borderline vulgar.
Most of these projects could be made for 1/10th of what they are currently being made for.
By being forced to cut spending perhaps the governmental institutions will start to listen to more lean oriented approaches.
Unlikely, but possible.
- gaius 17y agoIt's a weird and emotive thing. One thing that is very risky in UK politics is cutting NHS spending. It is the amount you spend that the unsophisticated electorate judges you on, not the results. So New Labour spent GBP 20Bn on IT systems that don't work and no-one wanted anyway and were lauded for it. The Tories could slash that in an instant, but then they'll have to deal with accusations of "cutting the health budget".
- ThomPete 17y agoI agree and think it's like that in most European countries. Someone (normally the opposition) complain that the government isn't doing enough for the schools where to the government answer we spend X amount of money on this. There are however times when this backfires. When some long awaited and praised system goes 300% over budget, at least in Denmark it's not going down well with the public. Another area that no country yet seem to have solved satisfactory is the digitalization of patient journals. But the main problem there seem to be incompatibility between different divisions which I have a hard time believing can be that difficult to solve. Anyway it sure is quite sad to see how bad the government is at running IT projects. Although large corporations don't seem to be doing much better. It needs to be solved.
- gaius 17y agoReally we ought to have two healthcare budgets, "services" that delivers actual healthcare and "support" that does the IT, manages the carparks (another controversial thing in UK politics, believe it or not), does the paperwork and so on. Then you would have an absolute defence against accusations of "cutting frontline services". It is a fiction maintained by the NHS bureaucracy that any cuts must affect the frontline. But the NHS has more managers than beds...
- arethuza 17y agoSomeone was pointing out to me that the NHS bureaucracy will probably cut front line services first - to try and reinforce this view. It's such a crying shame - the NHS frontline staff can be utterly wonderful, I just hate the layers of parasitical managers gaming the system of daft metrics to get their bonuses.
- nradov 17y agoI have participated in some of the same international healthcare IT standards bodies as UK NHS staff, attempting to resolve those incompatibility problems. It really is that difficult to solve. Unless you've worked in the industry for years it's hard to appreciate how complex the data is, and how many different forms it can take. In most cases these aren't accidental differences, they're driven by real requirements for patient care.
- ThomPete 17y agoOk Can you give some examples of the difficulties?
- arethuza 17y agoIts a classic mistake to try and make a large IT system meet all the individual requirements of a large heterogeneous organization - witness many ERP disasters. You have to rationalize the processes in an organization then make them use the same systems. In fact, I've seen scenarios where having totally inflexible IT systems was actually a bit of a blessing - there was no endless wrangling over requirements, people were told "you are going to use this and like it" and they had to change their processes to fit in with the systems. I wouldn't have believed how well this can work unless I had seen it happen in a fairly large multinational.
- nradov 17y agoIt doesn't work in healthcare (at least not in the US). If you tell doctors "you are going to use this and like it" then many of them will pack up and go to a more flexible clinic or hospital. It's impossible to ram anything down their throats.
- arethuza 17y agoCan't see why we couldn't do that with the NHS - it's all state owned and paid for directly by taxes. It should be there to provide healthcare, not to provide comfortable careers for managers.
- acg 17y agoI heard something recently from a colleague about one of these NHS systems. The consultants that were brought in advocated that the system be written in COBOL and with similar technology. Whether this is true or not it. It would be easy to imagine that the wrong technology decisions can be made to make the work roll on for years. With the way the world works now, much of these systems could be put together from fixed priced components built under tender.
- ThomPete 17y agoChosen framework certainly is a major problem but even bigger. Unrealistic scoping of the project. Most governments believe that they can simply will a successful solution into existence. Instead of thinking how they would like the system to be used they should think about how to get to a point where the system is used and then expand from there. What a wonderful world it would be if they actually learned to think like entrepreneurs. Start simple, stay simple Add as the needs arise Don't do everything that is possible only what is necessary Think how not what Make it for the actual citizens rather than for some political goal. And for @#((@# sake. Lets get all the data available, yesterday!
- gaius 17y agoIt is also a problem of self-identifying politically as a "progressive". They kinda have to go for anything that's shiny and new. Whereas conservatives (note the small c) say if it ain't broke, don't fix it. In the specific case of healthcare, look at Matrons on the wards. Yes it reeked of old-fashioned attitudes, but the Matrons ran a tight ship. Now we have outsourced cleaners with the lowest bid and MRSA epidemics. All because New Labour wanted to sweep the 1950s under the carpet.
- acg 17y agoI'm not sure that New Labour really identified themselves with being progressive until they felt they needed to attract would-be liberal voters. Labour might have had some progressive policies but was supposed to be a blend I thought: hence the "Third Way". I found that Labour took an utterly unprincipled bid for power at the end, dropping many of the principles on which they were elected while simultaneously accusing the other parties of the same. What an irony labour spokespeople accusing the liberals of having no principles, when the Liberals are the true progressives. The cynical way that the public has been mislead is unbelievable. The public ought to be treated like shareholder, instead they were treated like fools. Expenses is not the only reason for loss of faith.
- arethuza 17y agoI don't know your definition of vulgar - but as far as I am concerned most of the projects are obscene. You have the naive amateurs that seem to run the higher reaches of the civil service trying to handle voracious monsters of consulting companies and getting reamed in the process. And nobody really cares as it is "only taxpayers money". Very few things make me really angry - this whole mess is one of them.
- ThomPete 17y agoPeter F. Duckert calls this the Pork-Barrel State. This is when the fiscal state has no discipline. The government spending becomes the means to buy votes. This was seen probably most obviously when Chancellor Helmut Kohl bought the votes of the former East Germany by promising them beyond what the state could deliver driving germany into one of it's worst crises since the thirties. He has some really interesting ideas on how to solve many of the problems we face today IMHO.
- arethuza 17y agoI could at least understand (while strongly disapproving) of simple buying of votes through spending taxpayers money in the right areas - I'm from Scotland. However, none of these projects made any sense from that perspective. Massively overpaid consultants probably don't vote Labour anyway (even New Labour) and there weren't that many of them. Simplest answer I can come up with is that the people who commissioned and ran these projects were, in the best British tradition, bumbling idiots.
- gaius 17y agoLondon is a bubble politically speaking, and can be an echo chamber. Many of these consultants probably were Guardian-reading champagne socialists.