6 ms·
I've said it before and I'll say it again: A big part of Fitbit's problem is the poor hardware quality of their products, especially considering the high price.
by CydeWeys 10y ago
I've said it before and I'll say it again: A big part of Fitbit's problem is the poor hardware quality of their products, especially considering the high price. A lot of people, me included, will never buy another Fitbit after having been burned.
Their warranty only lasts one year, yet I've had to replace both Fitbit devices I've had twice within that one year. I'm now Fitbit-less because the latest, a Charge HR, failed for the third time, and it's out of that one year warranty.
To give you an idea of how bad the Charge HR is, its charging plug attaches with metal prongs, but it plugs into a slim plastic housing that is only glued to the rest of the device. The obvious result is that the plastic housing eventually gets pulled off with the plug. That's how two of my three Charge HRs have died. It'd be like if your laptop were ruined within four months because the power cable pulled off an essential piece of the laptop housing rather than detaching cleanly, and now it won't attach in order to charge. The third Charge HR bricked itself during an unprompted firmware update, which started randomly and then I guess got interrupted midway through when I moved my phone too far from the device. It never recovered.
I don't know what the hell they're optimizing for over at Fitbit HQ, but they're trying to sell $10 throw-away quality devices for >$100. It's outrageous. I actively discourage everyone I know from ever buying anything from them, and many other people I know have also completely sworn them off for the same reason. Their product just sucks.
- wccrawford 10y agoYup. I've owned quite a few of their devices, and every one of them died within 3 years. Previously, though, they were pretty good about replacing them even if they were out of warranty. I often eventually upgraded to the newest, knowing that I didn't really have to worry about the hardware, as they had great customer service. Last time I had one die (it literally fell apart, the glue letting go) they told me that they have changed this policy and are no longer doing that. I now wear a Withings activity tracker watch. I haven't had it long enough to know how long it'll last, but I know one thing: When the band broke, I was able to buy an after-market replacement cheap and put it on myself. This was not possible on most Fitbit devices.
- nemild 10y agoIs your experience emblematic of the that for most customers? Some of the things you mention seem like fundamental design flaws, so I'm curious if most customers have issues?
- moonka 10y agoWe had similar issues with my wife's charge. To Fitbit's credit, they were happy to send out multiple replacements, but my wife got tired of it and stopped using it after the 3rd replacement starting showing the same issue. By contrast, I have an old Fitbit One which still works well after all these years, but it's just a simple pod as opposed to a wrist band.
- ben_jones 10y agoCouldn't such a lenient return policy signal that these devices really are being marked up a ridiculous amount? I.e. $10 devices going somewhat unfairly for > $100 as mentioned above?
- reitanqild 10y agoCould also just be that they care about their customers or at least their reputation even if they failed to create the product they wanted to create in the first place.
- theli0nheart 10y agoBeen using Fitbit devices since 2010, and using a Charge HR since it came out. Never had a problem like OP's.
- CN7R 10y agoI've had mine for more than a year and a half -- my charge hr hasn't failed yet. But my cousins' have, which leads me to wonder what if the issue is user-caused.
- 10y ago
- drewg123 10y agoI think this is a problem with wearables in general. All in all, I've never seen a wearable last more than 9-10 months. I'm not that rough on them either. My MS Band 1 lasted ~8 months before it suddenly died. MS replaced it. I then borrowed a friend's Band2 which had already been replaced 4 times. It died twice for me. MS replaced it once, then issued a refund check when they ran out of stock. And then there is the Moto360 sport I had that went into an endless bootloop after ~9 months. My wife's ChargeHR had a physical failure of the band after 9mo, and the same exact issue happened again last week. I now have a Polar M600 and my wife has a Samsung Gear Fit2. Hopefully at least one of them will last more than a year!
- anonyfox 10y agomeanwhile I'm still in love with my perfectly working apple watch (1st gen). There was (and is) laughter about the topic and apple doing it, but really, this $300 device integrated in my daily life to the point of missing it when not wearing. Plus, it is way more than "just" a fitness wearable. Where I live (northern germany) I see more and more people silently migrating to one, it is even impossible to get a watch at any local retailer now, sold out everywhere.
- ProfessorLayton 10y agoMy anacdata: My 1st gen Apple Watch needed replacement due to faulty band-locking mechanisms (New OEM Apple bands would slide right through instead of locking). The good: Apple replaced it no questions asked. The bad: It took 4-5 weeks to send me a replacement. Interestingly, I didn't miss the watch at all while it was out for a replacement. Honestly, I don't find it that useful, I got it because I wanted a new toy. I will admit that the latest WatchOS makes the slowness a lot more tolerable, but still painful.
- pivo 10y agoI had no interest in an Apple watch but after getting one for Christmas this year it took me just a few days to fall in love with it. I now feel very foolish for how much I've spent on various FitBit devices that constantly failed.
- breck 10y agoBut this is endemic to the industry. I still caution fitness band buyers that they should consider themselves early adopters who should expect some troubles while the quality evolves. I owned a Microsoft Band 1 and Microsoft Band 2 since the day they came out. My Band 1 broke twice in two different ways, and my Band 2 died 3 times. Microsoft replaced them free of charge every time, which was great. So in 2 years with the Band I had 5 devices die on me. Other than that it was a terrific device. Microsoft isn't coming out with a Band 3 so the last time it died they replaced it with a FitBit Charge 2, which I'm enjoying so far, and the design seems more resilient than the Band (though time will tell).
- rconti 10y agoYup. I went through about 3 or 4 Nike Fuelbands too. On my 2nd Charge HR.
- CydeWeys 10y ago> I still caution fitness band buyers that they should consider themselves early adopters who should expect some troubles while the quality evolves. I don't buy this. Many, many millions of fitness brands have been sold, for combined billions of dollars, over a good number of years. We are not on the startup upswing anymore. I'm not quite expecting perfection yet, but I am expecting them to not outright suck. The construction methods are clearly inferior -- the damn things just fall apart because they are glued, rather than using fasteners. They are making low quality, designed-for-obsolescence junk. Many of the flaws, like coming up with a good band that attaches around your wrist and doesn't break, were solved in wristwatches over a hundred years ago.
- test1235 10y agoGlad to see I'm not the only one with that plastic housing problem. Once that comes off, you pretty much can't charge your device. I superglued mine back on, but it's just asking for trouble having to do that so close to the connectors.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sahaskatta 10y agoI had a Fitbit Flex. I had the band tear 3 times last year. Fitbit replaced it for free each time. Eventually the little device inside stopped holding a charge. They replaced that for free too. I decided to upgrade to the Charge 2 for 2017. Last week the heart rate sensor stopped working. I've been using it for exactly 4 weeks. They are replacing it for free. I'm a bit shocked at the number of defects.
- s_kilk 10y agoI'm on my fifth fitbit in about 10 months. After a few weeks, like clockwork, the rubber housing will start to peal away from the display, eventually leading to the glue coming unstuck and the housing bubbling up. Needless to say, I'll not be bothering with fitbit again.
- dmurray 10y agoIf it's needless to say, what changed for you since the 4th one broke?
- s_kilk 10y agoI should clarify, I'm on the fifth warranty replacement. I'll not be replacing it once the warranty runs out in march.
- benley 10y agoIf you're using a Charge HR, I'd suggest checking out the newer generation of devices. The Charge 2 and Alta are way better designs. The entire category of problem you're experiencing will not exist in those. ... and I say this as one of the people that fitbit just laid off today, for what it's worth. They're actually pretty good products now.
- arafa 10y agoMy Fitbit won the prize for being the only hardware/software to blue screen my Windows computer in at least a decade. It actually took me a few hours to figure out what was happening because I never suspected simply plugging in that device could do it. Sure enough, after 5 minutes or less it would hard crash my computer. I promptly gave it away and will never buy another one. I read some Amazon reviews where people talked about being on their 8th Fitbit and decided they have a real problem.
- Analemma_ 10y agoIsn't that more a Windows problem? An OS should never crash entirely because a device was plugged in. Fitbit probably should've caught that in testing though.
- nradov 10y agoIt also could be a defect in the host computer's USB controller. Sometimes those issues have to be fixed in firmware; the OS isn't necessarily to blame.
- overgryphon 10y agoDevice drivers run in kernel mode and can bugcheck the machine. Microsoft can certainly provide tooling and help device driver writers write reliable drivers, but the device is still responsible for it's driver.
- planteen 10y agoYeah exactly I've had Linux drivers cause kernel panics a number of times.
- Analemma_ 10y agoMy understanding is that Windows supports user-mode drivers and Microsoft strongly encourages not writing kernel-mode drivers unless absolutely necessary. If Fitbit did that anyway though then it's definitely their fault.
- 10y ago
- thearn4 10y agoYikes, I just picked up a FB Charge 2. I like it so far. Disappointing to hear that it may fail prematurely.
- johnward 10y agoSo far the Charge 2 is holding up well for me. I had problems with the Charge HR. Keeping my fingers crossed. Though I did manage to scratch the screen not a week after buying it. The only other issue is that I'm starting to realize that step tracking isn't really that valuable. At least I get some benefit from heart rate and sleep.
- sophacles 10y agoMost of the metrics with my Charge and now Charge 2 are inaccurate for any purpose other than trending info. Same with the Aria scale for Body fat %. They are not horribly inaccurate, just not terribly accurate. They are at least consistent however, and the graphs are useful to make sure my exercise, weight, etc are trending right. For me, that's enough - I want to be fit and healthy, I'm not trying to be highly tuned and in peak fitness. Those who are would probably want to look at other products.
- thearn4 10y agoI can see that, and it does match my expectations at least. It somewhat gamifies the process of me getting up from my desk every so often to walk around the lab complex.
- vpribish 10y agoI went through 3 charges in 13 months - two had the band delaminate and split, one bricked during a firmware upgrade. Warranty replacement was fine in that first 12 months, just a week or two to get the replacement. The final one they just offered a discount on a new purchase. At this rate it's more like you are leasing their band a year at a time. I'm done.
- CydeWeys 10y agoI had one brick during a firmware upgrade too. It wasn't even a firmware upgrade I started! It just started upgrading automatically and then died, for who knows what reason. It could've been as simple as it has no error recovery whatsoever and I moved my phone away from the band during the process (because I didn't know it was even happening).
- johnward 10y agoI've had quality issues but every time I was sent a replacement promptly. I get the devices via my employers wellness plan so I'm not sure if that is some trigger for their support team or not. I'm a firm believer that the charge hr had a major software flaw that caused it's battery life to halve but Fitbit will never admit it. After a certain firmware version the battery life was terrible. The fitbit support forums show the same trend.
- nradov 10y agoPerhaps the reason people commenting here have had so many problems with Fitbit devices is that they actually use them. From what I've seen, Fitbit's target market is primarily overweight people who don't really exercise much and leave them on the shelf. Garmin fitness trackers have much higher build quality and seem to have a fairly good reputation among athletes. But they cost several times more than a Fitbit.
- CydeWeys 10y agoI have a Garmin Forerunner 10 which I haven't had any real problems with yet. I will say this about it, that makes me trust it infinitely more than any Fitbit I've ever had: It's built like a watch. A cheaper digital watch with a rubber band and plastic screen, granted, but still a watch nonetheless. And when you're not using it as a GPS tracker, it just functions as a normal digital wristwatch. How we managed to go from watches, which are a solved problem and just work, to shitty fitness trackers that break in an embarrassing number of stupid ways, I'll never know. All you had to do was take a normal running watch and add sensors to it. But nope. Instead we got all these inferior bands that break constantly because they're literally glued together. My Garmin, meanwhile, is held together with four tiny metal Torx screws. The difference in quality, and how many corners are cut on fitness bands, is so immediately obvious that it just screams out at you.
- paulddraper 10y agoSeconded. People who know what they're doing buy Garmin watches. Highly recommend.
- jotjotzzz 10y agoUgh, unfortunately, this is true. My Fitbit started peeling after less than a year. They replaced it with a brand new Fitbit. And now this new Fitbit is also peeling. They didn't make these to last at all! If you're using this every day like a watch you will encounter this problem. However, I like the product but man the quality sucks. I wouldn't buy it again but unfortunately not a lot of great alternatives out there now.
- stcredzero 10y agoI've said it before and I'll say it again: A big part of Fitbit's problem is the poor hardware quality of their products, especially considering the high price. A lot of people, me included, will never buy another Fitbit after having been burned. This is an opportunity for Apple. They could come in with an "express sport" offering at under half the pricing of the current Apple Watch, optimized as a watch, fitness monitor, listening to media during your workout, and for only charging once a week. (I'm thinking around $120) The selling point would be that you'd pay more than a Fitbit, but you'd get better build quality, experience, and support.
- ben1040 10y ago>A lot of people, me included, will never buy another Fitbit after having been burned In my case, getting burned was quite literal. I had a Fitbit Force and was one of the thousands who wound up getting a chemical burn on my wrist from wearing the device. It took about six weeks for it to subside. Fitbit's response was sub-par. They finally did recall all the devices, but it took them way too long to admit a problem existed and to act on it. They initially dismissed the whole thing as potential sensitivity to metal, when clearly something different was going on. A TV station spent a year filing FOIA requests with the CPSC, etc trying to chase down what happened. The best they could come up with was that perhaps trapped sweat in the charge port could get converted to sodium hydroxide when you plug in the charger, and that would imply that you got a lye burn on your arm. http://abc13.com/technology/possible-cause-of-fitbit-rashes-uncovered/760009/ http://abc13.com/technology/possible-cause-of-fitbit-rashes-... The burn that I had was definitely localized right to where the charge port would contact my wrist.
- okreallywtf 10y agoI think its worth pointing out that when most people say "hardware" when talking about the fitbit, we're talking about the band, charge port etc and not the electronics (which is usually what I'm talking about when I use the word "hardware"). I think we've all had the same experience with the band/casing (personally mine haven't lasted long enough to have issues with the charge-port. Currently mine is wrapped up with tinfoil tape which is doing a good job of keeping my 2nd warrenty charge-HR alive). As far as the electronics hardware I don't actually have much of an issue. Some recent update required location for syncing but after I read into it it sounded like it was actually a google/android issue, not fitbit. I won't go as far as you to decry fitbit but they waited far too long and lost far to much goodwill on an issue as simple (seemingly) as the freaking band.
- nindalf 10y agoMy fitbit charge HR stopped syncing and I could no longer update the firmware. It became useless so I had to dump it on the shelf and forget about it.
- rconti 10y agoMy charge HR's body is screwed together with 4 small torx screws. I don't see how the charging plug could pull any glued plastic apart. That said, I did have an issue with the band just above the screen starting to delaminate. Heard they'd send me a new one so I made a claim and got a new one. For $150, does about what I'd expect, and is about as durable as I'd expect.
- CydeWeys 10y agoLook at this image: https://cdn3.pcadvisor.co.uk/cmsdata/reviews/3585633/fitbit-charge-hr-heart_thumb800.jpg https://cdn3.pcadvisor.co.uk/cmsdata/reviews/3585633/fitbit-... See the black band that wraps around the charging port? There's no screws in it. It's simply glued on. The charging cable uses metal prongs to attach into that port, and over time, it will eventually defeat the glue and pull the black band off the Fitbit entirely. Then you can no longer attach the cable to charge it. I've heard of lots of other people who've experienced this same problem. It's a bad design flaw.