9 ms·
This is really shitty. Regardless of what you think of the immigration issue, blocking legal residents from entering the US is absolutely terrible. It's a contr
by djsumdog 10y ago
This is really shitty. Regardless of what you think of the immigration issue, blocking legal residents from entering the US is absolutely terrible. It's a contract violation from the US government. This order essentially says America doesn't care you're a full legal resident, because you hold a citizenship from this limited subset of countries (many of which we're bombing), you can't come back.
(America is bombing seven countries by the way, in case anyone forgot. Our last president is the first in history to have the US in armed conflict for every day of his presidency. He will not be the last.)
What I also hate is that Uber tries to play the PR game and show themselves as the great guys here. Forget that they pay their drivers peanuts, that drivers have to drive up to 30% more now to make the same wages as just a few years ago, and that many are calling Uber to unionise.
I hate they way everyone is just using people to further their message and forgetting that these are people.
- freddyc 10y ago> What I also hate is that Uber tries to play the PR game and show themselves as the great guys here. Forget that they pay their drivers peanuts, that drivers have to drive up to 30% more now to make the same wages as just a few years ago, and that many are calling Uber to unionise. I hate they way everyone is just using people to further their message and forgetting that these are people. This +100. From what friends who were early at Uber tell me, this is not consistent with his character and feels like a PR grab. This issue is beyond f'd up, and while I guess any attention is good attention if it causes action, I draw the line at giving credit for cheap PR stunts.
- anarazel 10y agoSo what? What'd be right thing to do in this case? I disagree with Uber on a bunch of things, but me judging them to do the wrong thing on some issues, doesn't prevent them doing the right thing on others. By critizing them for doing the right thing you're just disincentivizing from doing the right thing again. I think this line of argument weakens "our" position considerably.
- thatcat 10y agoUbers position on immigration is not relevant to ubers business so it costs them little to take any attention grabbing position they can as that offers the a cheaper marketing model than paying for ads. Ironically trump uses similar strategies.
- anarazel 10y agoAssuming that's the case: So what? They could also do similarly on a lot of other topics, some directly opposing the current statement. I also doubt that opposing positions on one the current government's key issues is actually free. Uber has a lot of local regulatory issues, and complex enough international setup - federal (and some state's) goodwill surely has some affect on Uber's success.
- tedmiston 10y ago> Ubers position on immigration is not relevant to ubers business Are you sure about that? A large percentage of Uber drivers are immigrants.
- crdoconnor 10y ago>Ubers position on immigration is not relevant to ubers business Immigration drives down semi and unskilled worker's wages (which drives up profits). Uber absolutely has a dog in this fight. Arguably the reason why Trump's rhetoric has struck such a chord is precisely because wages have been driven down by (among other things) immigration.
- freddyc 10y agoI realize that the parent comment focused on Uber, but my concern is directed at the personalization of the post. This was posted under Travis' personal Facebook account. It was a statement by him to his employees that he chose to then release publicly (also look at his use of personal pronouns in places). If this were a statement released by Uber I would take less issue with it. I have seen the fallout from friends who personally experienced horrible treatment by the guy, so this fake hero crusade is what I take issue with. Uber paying affected drivers, on the other hand, is fantastic. *Edited for clarity.
- fullshark 10y agoIf you want to build a democratic coalition for action, you have to let in some members you don't see eye to eye with on every issue.
- SwellJoe 10y agoIf they actually follow through on paying their drivers that aren't able to work due to this executive order, it won't be "a cheap PR stunt". But, it could still be a PR stunt. I support tech companies (and everybody else) speaking out, emphatically, against this order, even if I think the company speaking out has kind of questionable moral standing. If only those who are perfect can act against evil actions by our government, then we're in serious trouble. Uber is imperfect. But, if they are sincere, I support them in this. And, perhaps if it comes time for armed insurrection to depose our Vichy regime, we can all hail an Uber and roll up to the revolution in style.
- jessaustin 10y agoThat last metaphor lost me... who are the Nazis, in this allegory?
- KirinDave 10y agoPerhaps in this case we don't need metaphorical Nazis because American politics now has real people pushing an Americanized version of the Nazi agenda?
- dragonwriter 10y agoIf we have a "Vichy regime", then ...Putin's Russia?
- SwellJoe 10y agoI don't think there's a very good direct corollary with historical fascist regimes; comparing the Trump administration and the complicit GOP Senate and House to Nazi Germany doesn't feel quite right. I feel like the GOP is more comparable to the Vichy regime in France: Collaborating with a monster for the sake of personal gain, not because they believe in the values Trump espouses. Any comparison to Nazi Germany and the events that led to the rise of fascism is prone to be reaching; and prone to be dismissed by someone because there are many gaps in the comparison. Likewise, while there are certainly similarities to Italy's Mussolini and Spain's Franco, that's also a stretch. The world we live in is very different from that time and place. Fascism looks different today. So...it's an imperfect metaphor. I merely wanted to poke fun at the craven GOP who have fallen in line behind a man they spent months criticizing and calling out for his fascist traits. Now that he's in a position of power they kowtow to him. More worrying, law enforcement, Customs and Border Protection, and significant sections of the civilian and military government seem to be falling into line behind him rather than pushing back on his unconstitutional and illegal orders, even when I don't think they share his ideals. That's where my Vichy comparison comes from. It's a stretch, I know. But, every comparison to historic fascists is. It doesn't make it less true that our new president is behaving like a fascist, and seems to have significant support. Also, Putin's Russia probably had a hand in putting our new president into office.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- refurb 10y agoblocking legal residents from entering the US is absolutely terrible. Why? It happens all the time, and shockingly, even before Trump got into office. A green card does not guarantee you entry into the US. I was informed of this many times when I entered using one. Leave the US for more than 6 months? You can be turned back (and your permanent resident status canceled). Among other reasons.
- 1024core 10y agoEven citizens can be prevented from coming back. It happened a few times during GWB's reign.
- differentView 10y agoWho was blocked from coming back under Bush?
- saalweachter 10y agoI can't remember the name off the top of my head but I recall a famous "no fly list" story about someone who was prohibited from returning to the US because their name was a potential misspelling of a suspected terrorist's name.
- michaelchisari 10y agoI hate to be obtuse, but this is much more comprehensive. A "no fly list" at least gives you the option of traveling by sea, or flying into Canada or Mexico and coming in through the border. Horribly inconvenient, but not a blanket ban.
- waqf 10y ago> traveling by sea [from another continent] If you have thousands of dollars and a week or two to waste. > Canada or Mexico If you can get a visa for those places. Both of your ideas are things I, as an affluent Westerner, would try if the US government stuck me on a no-fly list, but for the people targeted they may simply not be possible.
- chrischen 10y agoI don't think I've met an Uber driver that was paid in peanuts. Can you cite your sources?
- jodrellblank 10y ago"paid peanuts" is not the same as "paid in peanuts". It's an idiom meaning "paid very little". http://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/paid+peanuts http://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/paid+peanuts
- chrischen 10y agoWell if he doesn't mean it literally, then what's his point? That Uber drivers are not well paid? I've literally mever heard this from an Uber driver or Lyft driver.
- potatosoup 10y agoTrivia: the specific seven countries are ones deemed by DHS to be "high risk" in February 2016, during the Obama administration, so it's not an arbitrary pick by Trump [1]: "Have you traveled to, or been present in, Iraq, Syria, Iran, Sudan, Libya, Somalia, or Yemen..." [1] https://www.cbp.gov/travel/international-visitors/visa-waiver-program/visa-waiver-program-improvement-and-terrorist-travel-prevention-act-faq https://www.cbp.gov/travel/international-visitors/visa-waive...
- grzm 10y agoso it's not arbitrary action by Trump The choice of countries may not be arbitrary. The Executive Order is most definitely Trump's choice. Edit: My parent has since changed the quoted section to "so it's not an arbitrary pick by Trump".
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- geezerjay 10y ago> The choice of countries may not be arbitrary. The Executive Order is most definitely Trump's choice. The distance between declaring a whole nation to be "high risk" and refusing entry to those coming from those "high risk" nations is very slim. It would be understandable if there was any backlash or public outcry against labeling whole nations and all people passing through them as being "high risk", but there was none. As there was zero oucry, this sounds a whole lot more like partisan, kneejerk anti-Trump rants than anything else. Perhaps this is only a wakeup call for americans to take a long hard look at their immigration and foreign relations policies, which have been put in place since the early 2000s. Trump hasn't revolutionized anything. If anything, he is only directing attention to what the US has been continuously doing since then.
- facetube 10y agoIt is arbitrary. He is engaging in collective punishment – holding those hostage who are lawful residents, including those who have already been thoroughly vetted over multiple years. This will result in loss of life, loss of income, and intangible suffering on the part of families and children. Some of those being blocked have specifically assisted the United States in its war on ISIS, and are now under threat specifically because of this.
- trimbo 10y ago> Our last president is the first in history to have the US in armed conflict for every day of his presidency I don't know if this is true. Off the top of my head: Lyndon Johnson.
- smudgymcscmudge 10y agoI was about to make a similar reply, but I was going to say Nixon.
- nickff 10y agoThe Gulf of Tonkin resolution was passed in August of 1964, and LBJ became president in November of 1963.[1] Nixon was the one who quit the war in Vietnam, removing US soldiers from active combat, then from most of the country (which took place 1971-1973).[2] The USA also never passed a declaration of war against North Vietnam, whereas Obama claimed to be operating under the 'War on Terror' declaration for his whole presidency. I believe that Obama also has the record for bombing the most countries, though many drone and bombing campaigns have not been fully disclosed (i.e. the extent of the Phillipines campaign). [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lyndon_B._Johnson#Gulf_of_Tonkin_Resolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lyndon_B._Johnson#Gulf_of_Tonk... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vietnam_War#Exit_of_the_Americans:_1973.E2.80.9375 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vietnam_War#Exit_of_the_Americ...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- CalChris 10y agoGeorge W Bush inherited the Iraqi No Fly Zone with regular bombing sorties from Clinton who inherited it from George H W Bush. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraqi_no-fly_zones https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraqi_no-fly_zones
- plg 10y agoIt's not even citizenship from one of these 7 countries.... it's having been born there even if you're no longer a citizen[1]. [1] https://twitter.com/nadhimzahawi/status/825445925275500545 https://twitter.com/nadhimzahawi/status/825445925275500545
- nrjdhsbsid 10y agoI assume this is because some countries make it really easy to get citizenship. It would be quite a loophole to just hop over to country X for a few months then onto the US
- plg 10y agoUK ??!
- robjan 10y agoIt's not particularly trivial to become a citizen of the UK. It involves living in the country for years and passing a test. This is in line with most other countries.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoThen it would make sense to list those countries' dual citizens or naturalized citizens as ones that would take more scrutiny. But Any country other than the US? Heck, I know what I'm going through with immigration here in Norway, and I have one of the easier immigration avenues - marriage. Work and school are quite a bit more difficult. It usually requires one to live here for at least 7 years first: Marriage can cut that in half. That comes with things like the possiblity of having our house inspected so that the authorities are convinced we are living like a married couple and possible interviews with my spouse. Some countries have a more thorough check. It just isn't the bureaucratic lottery nightmare that it is in the states. That doesn't mean that it is easy, merely better run and reasonable.
- KirinDave 10y agoThis is the crux of the illegality of the procilmation. It's been illegal to use birthplace as grounds to deny immigration since the 60's, largely because of the incredible prejudice we saw towards Asians and Asian Americans.
- nerfhammer 10y ago> What I also hate is that Uber tries to play the PR game What's the point of casting aspersions on Uber's motives here? I'm pretty sure everyone at Uber has lots of middle eastern coworkers. They have every reason to be utterly horrified. Is it possible that they are, in fact, actually horrified and talking about this publicly is not just a part of some cunning scheme?
- joatmon-snoo 10y agoAgreed. I'm not a big fan of the policy precedents that TK has set, and sure, this is probably a publicity stunt, but that doesn't change the fact that this is a vocal, commendable move by someone in a position to drive change.
- panarky 10y agoIt's not "commendable" to play a double game. Kalanick can't claim to "stand up for what's right" while simultaneously joining the administration's economic advisory group. Collaborating with the Trump administration gives it badly needed legitimacy and credibility and facilitates the polices of hate. Collaboration undoubtedly benefits Uber, but you can't call it "standing up for what's right".
- dllthomas 10y ago> Collaborating with the Trump administration gives it badly needed legitimacy and credibility and facilitates the polices of hate. Yeah, before I was worried that the Trump administration was illegitimate, but then Travis agreed to be part of their "Strategic and Policy Forum", and now I'm with Trump 100%.
- joatmon-snoo 10y ago:laughing-and-crying:
- tjmaglio 10y agoThe only way to "stand up for what's right" is to be part of the conversation, not to shy away from it. If TK isn't part of that group, then who takes his place? If you had your way and nobody you approve of politically would have representation. The answers to our problems aren't blatant partisanship, but a robust exchange of ideas. If Trump invites anyone from SV, it'd be extremely foolish to "protest" by taking yourself out of the conversation.
- vivekd 10y agoI was in favor of Trumps election campaign because I didn't think he would actually do anything like this. His position during the election was presented to me as a temporary moratorium on immigration from nations with ongoing conflicts. That's not what we got in having people who are temporary or permanent residents of the United States being at risk of no longer being able to live in America. This is one of the most ridiculous and callous policy positions I have ever seen and I no loner support Trump.
- andrewem 10y ago(Assuming this isn't a troll.) Really? He was quite clear about the actions he planned to take on immigration: "Donald J. Trump is calling for a total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States until our country's representatives can figure out what is going on." (https://www.donaldjtrump.com/press-releases/donald-j.-trump-statement-on-preventing-muslim-immigration https://www.donaldjtrump.com/press-releases/donald-j.-trump-...) His actions since his inauguration are entirely consistent with his statements before the election, on this and many other issues. I'm sorry you're surprised now, but you shouldn't be.
- tim333 10y agoI think a lot of people are kind of surprised, for better or worse.
- vivekd 10y agoThe key phrases there are "until we can figure out what is going on" (suggesting temporary until congress can come up with a new immigration policy) and "entering the country" (not affecting current residents) also his campaign made it clear that this would not apply to all Muslims but only those from regions undergoing conflict which was half true, it doesn't apply to all Muslim countries but the inclusion of nations like Iran which have no current conflicts is also problematic
- nrjdhsbsid 10y agoIt's the same countries Obama's administration identified as high risk last year, so its not totally arbitrary
- nrjdhsbsid 10y agoLegal resident != Citizen. Until you have citizenship you can be sent back at any time for any reason. People get sent back or denied entry all the time for various reasons. What he did sucks but the media is making it out to be a much bigger deal than it actually is. The number of people "trapped" overseas is probably in the hundreds. We're bombing people in almost every country on the list, so I have no idea why this wasn't done years ago.
- tptacek 10y agoNo, you cannot be sent back "at any time" "for any reason" as a lawful permanent resident of the United States. I don't know what made you believe that.
- dudul 10y agoDo you have a green card? Cause I do, and the parent is right. It is not a guarantee of being allowed to enter the US, it can be revoked unilaterally by the government. Of course, in practice it's rarely done without cause (e.g. committing a felony), but in the texts it is clearly stated.
- tptacek 10y agoCongress sets the standards under which a green card can be revoked, not the executive branch on the whim of the President or one of his agencies. The rules are in the Immigration and Nationalization Act. It is a false statement to say that the terms green card holders were here under included "can be sent back for any time for no reason". As a green card holder, you are not a US LPR at the discretion of the President or any of his agencies. You have, in effect, a contract with our country. Congress could change the rules, but until they do, you have substantial rights to remain in this country. Even people without LPR status are difficult for the government to remove. Among undocumented immigrants put before immigration court for deportation, over 70% of those with legal representation prevail in court --- unfortunately, in most places in the US, they have no right to counsel, which is why we should all be sending money to immigration law organizations.
- javiramos 10y agoSo doing and saying nothing would have been better in your opinion? I am glad almost EVERYONE, from my neighbor to the CEO of pretty much every major Co, is speaking out in protest.
- KKKKkkkk1 10y agoWhere is this story about Uber mistreating its drivers coming from? Uber has been successful in attracting drivers because it is paying above-market rates. It is losing billions of dollars by subsidizing drivers and riders. Will all those people criticizing Uber be happy when it shuts down?
- aminok 10y ago>Forget that they pay their drivers peanuts, that drivers have to drive up to 30% more now to make the same wages as just a few years ago, and that many are calling Uber to unionise. Uber can't compete if its workers unionize. Please don't promote the failed anti-free-market ideology of labour unionization, which is based on total economic ignorance and shallow class-warfare cliches that don't conform to the complex reality of economic development and wage growth. If you talk to Uber drivers, you'll see the vast majority are happy with the opportunity to do what theyre doing. We don't need more misguided calls for authoritarian regulatory prohibitions that violate the right of consenting adults to engage in voluntary economic interactions with each other. I know it's not fun to see one's wages decline over a span of a few years, but that is what MUST happen if there is a huge influx of Uber drivers that tilts the supply vs demand ratio. Thinking you can legislate the pain away with mandates is failing to grasp that price is an information signal that tells us about supply and demand and allows the economy to adjust accordingly.
- paganel 10y agoIt's the right of those "consenting adults" (the drivers) to form an Union if they so desire, who said anything about "authoritarian regulatory prohibitions"? The existence and functioning of a free-market doesn't necessarily mean that no trade unions are allowed. Saying that an employer worth billions of dollars and a potential employee worth many orders of magnitudes less than that have the same negotiating powers is ludicrous.
- aminok 10y agoThe only way a union can survive economically is through authoritarian prohibitions against firing people for joining unions. This is because unions provide nothing that has market value. Historically they survived and flourished through illegal trespassing (blocking the company from operating), violence (beating up replacement workers), and eventually by getting legislation passed that imposed authoritarian prohibitions against employers exercising their contracting rights and ending employment contracts with unionized workers or negotiating with non-unionized workers individually (instead of through the mandated collective bargaining track). >Saying that an employer worth billions of dollars and a potential employee worth many orders of magnitudes less than that have the same negotiating powers is ludicrous. That's like saying consumers are helpless against Samsung because Samsung is a multibillion dollar company and consumers are individually worth much less. It's one of those thought-terminating clichés that distills the world into a simplistic class-war narrative. In reality a consumer in a free market has the power to walk away, and choose any better offer that is available to them, and that is all the power they need. Similarly, a person will only continue driving for Uber if no better options are available on the market. And if no better options are available, that means they're getting the market price for their labour. Using price controls to give them above-market wages has harmful second and third order consequences that reduce long-term wage growth.
- panarky 10y agoYes, Trump's executive order is really shitty. It hurts good people while doing nothing to reduce real threats from real bad guys. Kalanick is also really shitty. He legitimizes Trump by collaborating with him. It's complete bullshit that he's going to somehow influence this administration "from within". Kalanick's collaboration does far more damage than any marginal influence he might have. If Kalanick really wants to "stand up for what's right", he should publicly resign from Trump's "economic advisory group" in protest over this latest outrage.
- RodericDay 10y ago> While the cab drivers union was striking in solidarity with protestors at JFK, Uber lifted surge prices to scab for their business. Uber is a parasite, get it out of your life https://www.facebook.com/dan.abromowitz/posts/4414735886905?pnref=story https://www.facebook.com/dan.abromowitz/posts/4414735886905?...
- true_religion 10y ago> Regardless of what you think of the immigration issue, blocking legal residents from entering the US is absolutely terrible. It's a contract violation from the US government. It is. However, its has been done numerous times before. Border Agents have always had the right to detain anyone, and refuse non-citizens entry regardless of Green Card status. People have been stopped at the border, searched, held, then turned away while carrying Green Cards before. That this is happening uniformly to people from 7 countries is new, but that's all that's new.