4 ms·
Is this the same Scott Adams that claims to have been shadowbanned, without any proof? Might his lower Twitter engagement have something to do with people gett
by vkou 10y ago
Is this the same Scott Adams that claims to have been shadowbanned, without any proof?
Might his lower Twitter engagement have something to do with people getting sick of hearing from him about Trump?
- teddyh 10y agoHow would anyone actually prove something like this, short of getting Twitter to admit it? What he has seen is: > my tweets only go out to a subset of my followers. The rest don’t know I tweeted. My followers tell me this is the case. They have to visit my timeline to see my tweets. What other proof could anyone realistically provide?
- phpnode 10y agoThat is how twitter works - it doesn't show every tweet from everyone you follow in your timeline, it shows a subset based on what it considers most relevant.
- djsumdog 10y agoIt's a bigger problem in general with both Twitter/FB and how they filter the order content is displayed (sometimes called "the filter bubble") in order to drive up engagement and revenue. The average person doesn't care about federated social networks and the average dev or admin doesn't have the time outside of work to setup and maintain one for his or herself.
- Thlom 10y agoThat's why I almost never use the Twitter web site or their app. Too confusing. I stick with Tweetbot which still only shows the complete timeline in reversed chronological order.
- sperglord 10y agoI was not aware the app did that. I'm a little disappointed in the service to learn about this.
- sbierwagen 10y agoGo to Settings > Timeline and uncheck "Show me the best tweets first"
- misnome 10y agoThank you. I hate the web interface because of this, and don't know it was an option.
- sbierwagen 10y agoOnly if you have "Show me the best tweets first" enabled. (It's on by default)
- cookiecaper 10y agoAnd it would be convenient if Scott Adams' political tweets were considered "irrelevant" more often than others, wouldn't it? There were also reports that followers would be automatically unfollowed. They wouldn't hear from Scott for a while, so they'd check and realize he was no longer followed. Maybe they slipped and accidentally hit "Unfollow" while scrolling through their feed one day. Maybe it was a one-time glitch. Or maybe it wasn't. While it's true that such things could easily be imaginary, it's also true that they easily could not be. The idea behind these pseudo-bans is to discourage undesirable users from using the platform, and they do happen on many platforms (can't speak definitively for Twitter). For example, my HN account was intentionally slowed by YC for years. Each page load would take several seconds. When I asked politely if they could lift it after putting up with it for a couple of years, they confirmed it had been intentionally slowed, but couldn't tell why, and graciously agreed to lift the punishment, which I'm still grateful for. :)
- busted 10y agoIt's interesting to me that you probably don't care that this isn't true, nor is it true that Twitter ever decides to not show your tweets to a subset of your followers through a "shadowban". You just say whatever. Doesn't affect you whether it's true or not and if other people believe you, hey that's pretty funny that people just believe things you make up or misunderstood.
- phpnode 10y agoPardon?
- josteink 10y ago> That is how twitter works - it doesn't show every tweet from everyone you follow in your timeline, it shows a subset based on what it considers most relevant. If this is true, this is the same as Facebook does. And for this reason I can't bother checking Facebook any more. Can't see what's in that for twitter? Facebook is not showing me the posts from people I know, but instead advertisement and "reactions" it thinks I may like. Which I give a utter fuck about. It's just another one of those things which just makes me stop caring. If twitter knows what best for them, they should definitely not copy this UX anti-pattern of overruling the users explicit choice (about whose posts they want to follow).
- nerfhammer 10y agoConsidered whether it was algorithmic timeline? I unfollowed him around this time as he was tweeting what felt like hundreds of times a day with tweets that felt very repetitive
- 9935c101ab17a66 10y agoI mean... any proof that isn't anecdotal accounts from non-specific followers? Before we even start considering that though, I dispute the premise — shadowbanning does not mean hiding posts from some users, it means hiding posts from all users. If some of his followers aren't getting his tweets, maybe he's a victim of the algorithmic timeline?
- thedevil 10y ago"Might his lower Twitter engagement have something to do with people getting sick of hearing from him about Trump?" Do you really think the attention he gets on Twitter DROPPED because of him talking about Trump?
- orbitingpluto 10y agoI've stopped reading Dilbert let alone Twitter. Seeing him post pictures of himself acting in the role of sugar daddy to a petulant child-woman is well beyond my initial scope of interest in him. My interest was Dilbert. It was all about making fun of the disconnect between management and employees. Ironically, his public persona is now at odds with the general theme of his work. I suspect his original material is just the byproduct of his initial position and people emailing anecdotes to him.
- Neliquat 10y agoSo you reject the art because of the views of the artist? Have a fun time being able to enjoy anything.
- orbitingpluto 10y agoIf you go to dilbert.com the cartoon comes part and parcel with his blog. This dissuades me from visiting the site. I like Wagner too. But if I had to read an anti-Semitic pamphlet every time I listened to him, I wouldn't put him in my playlist. I think that's reasonable, no?
- thedevil 10y ago"If you go to dilbert.com the cartoon comes part and parcel with his blog." You can see blog titles from his blog if you scroll down and read them. Is seeing blog titles (if you choose to scroll down and then read them) like "outrage dilution" and "Should twitter and Facebook be regulated as entities" comparable to having to read an anti-Semitic pamphlet?
- throwaway91111 10y agoHe's talking about trump? Ye gods, in election season everyone plays politician. Seriously though, why does he think anyone wants to hear his political spew? It's almost as irrelevant as hearing an update from Sam Altman.
- ChrisClark 10y agoHe made a post last summer saying that he has to pretend to support Clinton otherwise when he goes out he'll probably be shot by a Clinton supporter... He's gone a bit off the deep end.