7 ms·
Consider Proudhons famous "property is theft" for a moment. His point is that enforcing property rights explicitly deprives others. If something is scarce, the
by vidarh 10y ago
Consider Proudhons famous "property is theft" for a moment.
His point is that enforcing property rights explicitly deprives others. If something is scarce, then the moment I wall it off, others become poorer for it.
Sometimes that may be worth it: the deprivation of others may be small, and the benefits to the individual of being able to wall something off might be high.
Even the vast majority of anarchists and communists would draw a sharp line between private property + the "means of production" vs. personal property. To put it rather pointedly: Pretty much everyone agrees that granting every random stranger the right to use your toothbrush deprives us of more rights than it provides us.
Where exactly the line goes on what should be shared and what should not is one of the major differentiating factors of political ideologies, but that there is a line is recognised by every present-day government in the world.
The enforcement of exclusionary property rights might enhance everyones rights and freedoms when what is walled off is so common that there is no perceptable increase in freedom from protecting part of it or when the benefits of exclusionary access are large enough to overcome the downsides, and it might enhance some peoples rights all the time, but it may also cause a drastic, profound reduction in the rights of many once something is scarce enough that allowing some people exclusionary control of it has the potential to significantly deprive others.
To take an extreme example: If all the resources you could have used to obtain food belongs to someone else, you've just de facto lost the right to live and having a de jure right to life does not help you.
This also acts as its own counter-example: If you don't have right to control your own wealth, then the ability to eat depends on the willingness of socity to let you.
And therein lies the problem with looking at a right to controlling your own wealth: Depending on how the society you happen to live in today is structured in terms of your ability to obtain wealth, and who has ownership, you may have more de facto rights with a right to control your own wealth or more without it. And that structure can change, and suddenly reverse the effect.
In other words, a "right to control your own wealth" does not provide a universal good, but one that is conditional on circumstances. That is my biggest problem with considering it as suitable to be a human right.
- aminok 10y ago>His point is that enforcing property rights explicitly deprives others. If something is scarce, then the moment I wall it off, others become poorer for it. That makes absolutely no sense. That's like saying preventing people from feasting on your flesh makes them all poorer. I'm using an extreme example to demonstrate the absurdity of the argument that enforcing exclusive control over abundant and practically free natural resources that you've appropriated and applied work to in order to turn it into something highly valuable (whether that be soil, water CO^2 and sunlight that you converted into food and then into bodily mass, or sand that you melted into silicon and turned into a microprocessor), deprives others of their rights.
- mox1 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reductio_ad_absurdum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reductio_ad_absurdum
- aminok 10y agoReductio ad absurdum is a valid form of argument.
- smhost 10y agoThe resource has to belong to the public to begin with. Your body belongs to you exclusively. We can play your game the other direction. If using "practically free" natural resources doesn't deprive you of your rights, you would have no objections to a company rolling into your neighborhood with bulldozers and taking all of the nutrient-rich soil so that they can turn it into something highly valuable and sell it to other people. You would have no objection to a company like Nestle claiming ownership of a local river and prohibiting nearby residents from drinking from it.
- aminok 10y agoBut your body came from natural resources initially. If you do not have a legitimate right to appropriate natural resources and make exclusive use of what you transform said resources into, it follows that you cannot have a right to your own body. I have no problem charging private entities rent for the appropriation of natural resources. What I have a problem with is demanding a share of the private property that they fashion out of those natural resources. From a public standpoint, it should make no difference if someone appropriates a ton of iron ore and places it in their living room as a collector's item, or if they use it to create a supercomputer. They should pay the same fee to the public in both cases, since it is the natural resource usage that should be charged, (and that the public has a legitimate right to charge a fee for), and not their private actions upon that material. But current tax laws, and Proudhon's argument which the parent comment cites, delegitimizes the value that one adds in the process of creating the latter.
- 10y ago
- Neliquat 10y agoThe lack of freedom to submit, or not, to what basically amounts to socialism, instead of being able to choose the use of your labor or its rewards, is in essence its own slavery. I feel his argument was a utopian and philosophical one, and is quite hard to consider practically, hence the other replies less articulate indignance to the idea.
- meanduck 10y ago> Consider Proudhons famous "property is theft" for a moment. > His point is that enforcing property rights explicitly deprives others. If something is scarce, then the moment I wall it off, others become poorer for it. I keep hearing this argument. And its so obviously illogical. Establishing the concept/law of property and property ownership is probably the first thing a society does as soon as it gets formed.
- kmm 10y ago> Establishing the concept/law of property and property ownership is probably the first thing a society does as soon as it gets formed. And so are autocracies, inequality between genders, slavery, feudalism, rule of the strongest etc... Private (not personal) property doesn't a priori have to be more of a natural law than any of those.
- aminok 10y ago>Private (not personal) property doesn't a priori have to be more of a natural law than any of those. Private property is every bit as natural as personal property. Both are enforcing exclusive usage of some part of the natural world for one's own self. Both are required for one to be able to enjoy the full value that they create through their own efforts. The personal/private distinction an arbitrary one with no philosophical basis. It's purely done for sophistry.
- kmm 10y agoWhen enforcing the access to scarce natural resources or paying someone only part of what their labor is worth, you're enjoying more than just the value of your own efforts. It is way less natural that owning a toothbrush or a laptop. I can image a society where the first is considered ridiculous. The second, not so much
- aminok 10y ago>When enforcing the access to scarce natural resources We could require all owners of property to pay rent for their use of natural resources, at a rate commensurate with the value of said natural resources, and there would still be trillions of dollars worth of private property, and socialists claiming a right to an equal share of it based on some contrived justification. >or paying someone only part of what their labor is worth, you're enjoying more than just the value of your own efforts. If someone voluntarily gives you more labour than what you pay them for, that's still a voluntary transaction, and anything you earn from that labour is legitimately yours. If you build me a shed in exchange for $1, because you're such a generous guy, I still have full rights to that shed. Of course in most cases people do not accept a job that pays them below market rates. I assume you're implying that profits are the surplus value of labour that is unfairly provided to employers, which is simple Marxist ignorance. Profits are the compensation the employer earns for the organisation and capital they provide. Labour is worth whatever its market price is, not whatever revenues are generated in enterprises where it's employed. It's sad that I have to debunk 150 year old Marxist fairy tales on hackernews.
- jonathanstrange 10y agoExactly. Resources are limited, so a person's rights to personal property must always traded-off with others persons' rights to live in dignity or being able to live at all. Otherwise you'd have to accept the case that the personal rights of property of a few can essentially deny the right to live in dignity or live at all to others whenever resources are distributed in an extreme way to only those few. In case you're interested, there are quite elaborate theories of distributional justice. For example, New Theory Of Fairness And Social Welfare by Marc Fleurbaey and Francois Maniquet is a very good recent book on the topic, if you're fine with a decent amount of economic apparatus.