3 ms·
BART: Walk-left, stand-right ‘rule’ wears out escalators
- Neliquat 10y agoMaybe, since this is a standard wherever there are esclators or moving platforms, the manufacuturers hold some blame? It seems optimizing for that behavior would be simple.
- brudgers 10y agoI think it's more a matter of timeframes. Escalators have been around since the end of the 19th century, and it has taken about a century for humans to develop 'laws of the road.' But as the article shows, facility owners have not yet adapted to the change in human behavior and facility owners are who buys escalators. And few bureaucrats, whether in San Fransisco or China, are going to go out on a limb and demand an unproven asymmetric escalator design. So for manufacturers there's no demand and there will not be for several decades at best...escalators are long life cycle equipment and an asymmetric escalator doesn't pay for itself through energy savings and the increased maintenance costs of asymmetric ridership aren't high enough to justify a swapout...even if a bureaucrat could get the budget to cover initial cost, which most can't.
- keyle 10y agoThis is a perfect example of UX side effects! Was never designed to be used that way but somehow through humans every day use it's become a thing. There is ample opportunity to make this better. And sadly in 10 or so years, you will be fined for using the wrong side...