16 ms·
Android permissions and hypocrisy
- qznc 10y agoMy solution is to use CyanogenMod (now LineageOS) and deny access when apps request it. To applications it looks like they can access my contacts, but if I deny it, they only get to see an empty list.
- emsy 10y agoMy solution is to buy an iPhone. I don't mean that as a snarky response, as I'd very much like to use an Android phone (And if it's just to be able to use Tasker). But I simply don't have time to bother with this stuff anymore, so I pay ~200$ more in exchange for my time (and privacy). Secondly, I don't want to give anyone money that gives a crap about my device's security and privacy. There was a similar article on HN a while ago that came to the same conclusion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13056288 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13056288
- madshiva 10y agoYour solution for what? for privacy? Apple privacy? just nope. Antivirus software are all bloatware, they don't do money anymore then they focus on other things "to secure". Ok. your clipboard can be read by other software (like in Windows ...) then what? just don't copy password. "Yes downvote my comment but don't argue. The solution buy an iPhone is still not valid solution."
- simonh 10y agoYou're getting downvotes for your "LA, LA, LA I'm not listening" attitude. Android and iOS have many very different advantages and disadvantages over each other, but security on iOS is very clearly vastly superior and this has been confirmed repeatedly by top security researchers. Trying to pretend that's not true or pick and choose 'whataboutist' issues and pretend that's all that matters to make false equivalences is really going to wind people up. The expected level of discourse here is quite a bit beyond that.
- yellowapple 10y ago"security on iOS is very clearly vastly superior and this has been confirmed repeatedly by top security researchers" The vast majority of this "superiority" only applies because the iOS ecosystem is a walled garden. Android devices typically allow sideloading, which obviously introduces an additional attack vector; reproducing this on iOS (i.e. by jailbreaking) brings you back to the same attack surface. The other notable difference between iOS and Android security-wise has historically been the ability to selectively accept certain privileges, but recent Android versions have introduced this as well, and even the old permissions model was (and still is) much more up-front and fine-grained about which permissions an app requires. iOS also had (and probably still has) an edge for awhile when it came to OpenBSD-style exploit mitigations IIRC, but Android is getting these too by way of projects like CopperheadOS. Other than those aspects, there are actually very few major differences (last I checked, at least; I haven't really been following the iOS world, so maybe Apple's done some crazy stuff while I wasn't looking) between their security models. Both implement some form of per-app sandboxing, both default to disallowing root access (in most cases, at least; third-party Android distros have a tendency to ship with root access, usually behind some toggle and/or some management app like SuperSU or whatever the latest hotness is), both default to a locked-down boot environment (in order to defend against rootkits), etc. Both have had their share of security-affecting bugs, too. There's no "clearly vastly superior" about it in either direction, at least on a platform level. On an ecosystem level, sure; Google doesn't do quite as good a job as Apple when it comes to screening malware (there have been quite a few notorious examples of this), and the ability to sideload apps (as well as the much easier jailbreaking/rooting situation) means that more malware is actually viable. This isn't a security problem in the sense of the platform itself, but rather in the sense of allowing users to shoot themselves in the foot by installing trojans. Like I said above, these exact same problems happen on jailbroken iOS devices, too (I reckon with a very similar frequency, too, but I don't have statistical evidence to back it up, so take that with a grain of salt).
- jerf 10y ago"Android devices typically allow sideloading," In the context of this discussion, sideloading is irrelevant. We're talking about the default happen-to-everybody case. "Other than those aspects, there are actually very few major differences... between their security models" It's not just about the security model, though. We have some reason to believe that Apple phones may actually be at least partially resistant to law enforcement. I say that not as an encouragement to use them that way, but to point out that's about the highest security bar possible and we at least have some reason to think the latest iPhones get there. (And I am carefully phrasing this as "some reason to believe" and "resistant" because we do not know for sure whether this is the case, and I wouldn't bet that even if the phone can stymie a local police investigation that it would block a full-powered Federal investigation.) We have no reason to believe any Android phone meets this standard of security, nor would the fact that a particular one rose to that standard meant any other ones would. And if I'm pro-anything, I'm pro-Android in general. But that doesn't change the facts.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoI intensely dislike Apple as a company, and I dislike their products, but the honest truth is there is no such thing as a reasonably secure Android device, and I can't fathom recommending one to anyone ever again. After seven years on Android, my recommendation is "literally anything else".
- emsy 10y agoI've stopped liking or disliking companies altogether. I try to look if a company isn't crossing my personal moral boundaries (child workers etc.) and whether it satisfies my needs. Then I buy their product. As for the moral part, Apple is the only company I've heard of that at least acknowledges there's a problem (http://www.apple.com/supplier-responsibility/ http://www.apple.com/supplier-responsibility/).
- jmtd 10y agoI'm trying to determine whether iOS apps could sniff my clipboard, and i haven't proven that they can't; it doesn't seem to be a specific permission that needs to be assigned or can be denied. And thus using 1Password on my iPhone to copy and paste passwords seems to have a bit of a risk to it.
- emsy 10y agoiOS Apps can read your clipboard (But only if the app is open i.e. not in the background, which was possible in earlier iOS versions). I would welcome it if they introduced a permission for clipboard handling. Personally, I use Workflow to clear my clipboard after pasting a password.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- supergreg 10y agoBut can apps sniff in what website or app you are using the password? Either for iOS or Android, if the password are just random strings unique for each site and they can't determine that then the attack vector diminishes.
- bad_user 10y agoA while back you could query the apps currently active on iOS and there was a big scandal that Twitter was doing it, being reported by the media as a secret vulnerability, which was bullshit since that "vulnerability" was fairly well known already and in use by ad platforms. And at a previous company we used it for more than a year I think, before being in the news. I don't know what happened after that, Apple must have closed that loophole and Android requires a specific permission. But there are always vulnerabilities that developers can exploit and you can't trust the OS on this one. Plus it really doesn't matter, because when it comes to security, there's also the issue of the mono-culture and user technical stupidity. We know that many people use Gmail, Facebook, Twitter, etc, most of them reusing passwords across services. And logging the user's copy/pasted texts gives you such a specific dictionary that the probability of getting hacked approaches 1 fast.
- bad_user 10y agoI currently use an iPhone and it too isn't a good privacy solution either. For example my pet peeve is that apps like Waze or Uber are allowed to only request full location tracking, even while running in the background. As a user you cannot restrict location tracking to happen only when the app is running. This is an either-or proposition. Either the user allows location tracking while in the background, or you cannot use the app. And surely you can manually enable and disable location tracking per app, but that's way too cumbersome. Just imagine trying to start navigation while at a red light. Whereas with Android I used to be able to enable/disable location tracking globally, since you get a global shortcut that you can access in a swipe and tap. I also use 1Password as a password manager. Well, iOS has the same problem as Android where apps can read the contents of your clipboard, including copied passwords. And compared with Android it's not common to see password managers use third-party keyboards or accessibility features to side-step copy/pasting passwords. And sure, apps have an API to integrate managers like 1Password or Lastpass, which is nice when it's there and it's surely nice when it works in Safari, but too few apps use it. In other words, even though the privacy/security story is currently better for iOS, IMO it's not that good either and I hope that Apple and Google will work on improving this situation because I'm seriously thinking of going back to a dumb phone.
- cgb_ 10y agoTo be fair, those are app choices to require 'Always' for location tracking. You can most definitely restrict an app to use location only while using - you can't fault Apple or IOS for apps that (unnecessarily [1]) demand more. One thing I really like about IOS is the reminder that an app has been using your location in the background for a while [2] [1] http://www.theverge.com/2016/11/30/13763714/uber-location-data-tracking-app-privacy-ios-android http://www.theverge.com/2016/11/30/13763714/uber-location-da... [2] https://support.apple.com/library/content/dam/edam/applecare/images/en_US/iOS/iphone6-ios9-weather-app-using-location.jpg https://support.apple.com/library/content/dam/edam/applecare...
- zymhan 10y agoBut Apple makes (seemingly) no effort to encourage developers to allow limited location access. Why can't iOS be in charge of when an app uses my location when the app is backgrounded? The reminder only appears once per app, as far as I've noticed. I restored my phone recently for the first time in over a year, and had totally forgotten about the reminder feature.
- cosarara97 10y agoI thought these things were only possible with xprivacy. Which Cyanogen versions have this functionality?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- vmateixeira 10y agoI think I can achieve similar with an Android 6.0+ stock ROM, but still some apps refuse to work and shut down once you reject their access to some resources.
- rasz_pl 10y agobecause Deny is an useless option, there should be return empty/dummy/configurable reply
- izacus 10y agoAndroid 6 and newer has this built in.
- LoSboccacc 10y agoapp can detect if they are blocked and won't start.
- DiabloD3 10y agoThen they don't start, and are uninstalled and reported as broken as a Google Play store review with 1 star, as has already happened to apps that tried that shit.
- LoSboccacc 10y agosee https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.ea.gp.bej3&hl=en https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.ea.gp.bej3... doesn't seem like that at all. 150k installs and 4.5 rating.
- LoSboccacc 10y agoWhy is this getting downvoted? It is a perfect example of an app with scummy permission and a startup block if it cannot access contacts thriving.
- CaptSpify 10y agoThe average user doesn't care about permissions and probably are going to fully allow games like that to steal their data. Then they'll give it a good score in the app-store. Install number and rating aren't good indicators. I think there's an implied user-base here that the "mark as broken" response is going to be useful for, but the vast majority of people won't care.
- rasz_pl 10y agothats an ok example, but check out this one: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.ace.cleaner&hl=en https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.ace.cleane... this is a malware with almost 200K installs and poerfect 4.5 rating. It propagates using spam/pirate sites with misleading "your phone is broken and will blow up if you dont install this" scam https://virtuallyfun.superglobalmegacorp.com/2016/12/07/holy-crap-get-annoying-trojan-attempt-ever/ https://virtuallyfun.superglobalmegacorp.com/2016/12/07/holy...
- LoSboccacc 10y agodamn this should really be in the android os, plenty users have unsupported phones (and cm being discontinued doesn't help, but let's see how lineage goes) it's extremely annoying to get a game and it wont start unless it gets access to your contact list. wtf?
- baby 10y agoI do basically the same thing when an app request some permissions on Facebook. For example if they want to post on your facebook, allow them, but only make them post to "yourself". You can do that in the permission popup when they request access.
- emodendroket 10y agoBut still now you have to trust them too.
- wyldfire 10y agoWow, that's an awesome feature. I really preferred running on the stock image but that's appealing enough for me to consider switching.
- vmateixeira 10y agoHas anyone noticed apps switching from requesting individual permissions to relying on Google Services permissions lately? For instance, Google Maps now need Google Services to have permissions to [1]. This makes it even harder to track which information apps are actually collecting (in case you grant all permissions to Google Services). [1] http://i63.tinypic.com/1zwt91.jpg http://i63.tinypic.com/1zwt91.jpg
- sha666sum 10y agoSlightly tangential, but yesterday my Gmail app kindly informed me that I need to give Google Play Services the following permissions in order for it to function: - Body Sensors - Calendar - Camera - Contacts - Location - Microphone - Phone - SMS - Storage This promptly led me to discover K-9 Mail. Not entirely incidentally, Google's Calendar was so helpful as to suggest that I install Google's fitness tracker to integrate with the Calendar. I politely declined the offer, and installed Etar.
- vmateixeira 10y agoThat's exactly what I mean.
- sha666sum 10y agoI misread your post in haste, sorry.
- vmateixeira 10y agoNo worries :) Any ideas on why are apps swapping to this permission model?
- sha666sum 10y agoSo that I don't make unfounded claims I had to do a bit of research on the Android app permission model. Source: https://developers.google.com/android/guides/permissions https://developers.google.com/android/guides/permissions > Google Play services automatically obtains all permissions it needs to support its APIs--your app won't normally need to request permissions to use them. However, your app should still check and request runtime permissions as necessary and appropriately handle errors in cases where a user has denied Google Play services a permission required for an API your app uses. I'd say this constitutes a loophole in the Android app permission model and Google as well as other app developers have a mutual interest in using it so that their apps get as many permissions as possible. It has practical benefits too, though: querying Google Play services for your location info, rather than independently looking it up, saves battery life. Google certainly has financial interest in it - their position in the middle gives them analytics data and keeps developers dependent on Google API's. I don't think there are many F-Droid apps that are dependent on Google Play services. It's likely also easier for the developer to use Google's API rather than provide their own implementation, which is of course what Google wants. It just comes at the expense of the user. I suppose the solution is to tighten the app security model, at least on an opt-in level, as I can't imagine the average user being interested in being queried for even more permissions. I think apps should require permission to interact with other apps (such as Google Play services), and most of all they should require permission to access the internet. I can't imagine Google championing this cause, though.
- sschueller 10y agoAny app can capture everything you put in your android clipboard and it does not need to ask for permission to do it. So don't copy passwords into your clipboard!
- m_eiman 10y agoCan they access this while running in the background?
- sschueller 10y agoYes, you can write a background service that will be called when there is a change in the clipboard. You can even close the app and it will be restarted in the background when a clipboard change happens. I know this because I wrote an app[1] that does precisely this and looks for a specific URL in the clipboard. I was surprised when I found out I don't need to ask for permission to read clipboard changes. [1] https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.schueller.instarepost https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.schueller....
- m_eiman 10y agoOuch, that sounds like something that should have a permission. Permission for background or programmatic access, none needed to receive pastes initiated by user seems reasonable IMHO.
- dfox 10y agoThat would require reliably deciding whether the action was in fact initiated by user, which is hard in browser environment and probably impossible for android.
- poizan42 10y agoThe answer to that may actually be quite simple: The keyboard app is the one that should be allowed to read from the clipboard. Now can a keyboard spy on you clipboard contents? Sure. But it can also spy on all your keystrokes, so the trust must already be there.
- willvarfar 10y agoMy own muses and solution: http://williamedwardscoder.tumblr.com/post/13316924653/better-permissions-in-android http://williamedwardscoder.tumblr.com/post/13316924653/bette... Basically, back in the Symbian/UIQ days, we worked on this and came up with a way to embed apps within another visually even though they were separate apps with separate permissions. So an app wouldn't need all the internet access stuff just because it embeds ads; instead, an ad-service running on the phone would embed ads in the space given to it by the app. We primarily wanted to show contacts and online status etc inline without each app needing to be able to read your contacts or find out their online statuses. The host app would basically use a UI widget that took a 'url' to what was going to be shown, and apps registered as providers of various url schemes e.g. uiq_contact:phonenumber_goes_here?display_options=whatever
- unicornporn 10y agoSpeaking of security... Did you know you can turn on SSL (for free) for your Tumblr blog these days?
- willvarfar 10y agoHad no idea. Enabled it now.
- pjmlp 10y agoSymbian/UIQ, already had quite a good security model specially since S60 3rd Edition, pity Android devs not followed up on it.
- digi_owl 10y agoFrankly i will eternally be puzzled why Symbian was dropped like a hot potato when iPhone and Android entered the scene. It was almost as if the American tech press was completely unfamiliar with the mobile world outside USA (never mind being stupefyingly in love with Apple), and thus they praised iPhone like something unique in the mobile world when it launched. The real puzzler though is that the rest of the world's tech press parroted that message like they believed it, when they should have known better.
- ade2 10y agoIsn't this solved with run-time permissions model since android 6? Customers can be informed before requiring individual permissions, in a context where it is understandable, such as requiring WRITE_EXTERNAL_STORAGE when saving a picture. Am I missing something?
- mjg59 10y agoIt's not obvious to users that READ_PHONE_STATE means the ability to obtain your IMEI, and if an app just exits when you deny a permission (or lies to you about why it needs it) what do you expect most users to end up doing?
- ade2 10y agoYou're right. But it's worth considering that most people don't know or care what an IMEI is, and even less so would they understand the consequences of sharing it with an app. Most users will probably indeed grant the permission when asked, but the choice is there, rather than requiring ALL manifest permissions to install and run the app, so it's a lesser of two evils, imo.
- izacus 10y agoThe user-facing text for READ_PHONE_STATE is "Read and control phone status __and identity__". How more obvious do you want it to be? And I expect users to uninstall the app or live with the consequences. Because what other option is there? If you want a kindergarten OS where a corporation prevents you from running apps according to their daily whim and maximization of profits - get an iPhone. Apple will protect you by making sure you run only kids friendly apps which only work with their dongles and hardwares. And that's ok, but we do not need two operating systems with same limitations that only differ in branding. In corporate controlled Apple world, things like Linux do not exist.
- mjg59 10y agoI only know what "identity" means in this case because I've read the SDK docs. There's any number of things that phone identity could mean other than IMEI. (Before you accuse me of just wanting to restrict what people can do with their devices, I'm on the board of directors of the Free Software Foundation - I am very, very interested in ensuring that ultimately end-users are able to do whatever they want to do with things that they own. But that's not incompatible with the OS being designed to do its best to ensure informed consent for whatever an ap wants to do)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- zschneider 10y ago>Why does Kaspersky want the ability to record audio? Why does it want to be able to send SMSes? Why does it want to read my contacts? Block unwanted phone calls and SMS texts, filter out dangerous links and sites >Why does it need my fine-grained location? To find your lost Android phone or tablet >Why is it able to modify my settings? To be able to remove viruses and other threats from smartphones and tablets --- I can't even open this website with Noscript because of Cloudflare. Why do you need to stream all your unsecure (I'm talking about js, not https) user traffic through 3rd party providers?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dovdovdov 10y agoAndroid (or anything Google) means close to zero privacy.
- catwell 10y agoThis is not specific to Android, it is basically the antivirus industry in general. "Let's ask every possible permission and inject code everywhere in the OS so we can prevent other applications from doing so." I am usually for modularity, but I think this kind of security is part of the OS' job, and we have to move to security models where third-party AVs do not exist. Of course, this is not just my opinion, see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13082832 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13082832 in particular.
- nezo 10y agoThere really is a lot of things to improve about permissions. Like Apple and Android's default camera apps requesting access to camera... really? Or contact app asking permission to list contacts (on android at least). Setting up a new phone or tablet is like dismissing 99 dialogs every time. I indeed hope in the future there will be a better balance between user experience and user privacy.
- mysticmarvel 10y agoHow often do you upgrade or purchase a new Apple device? Once per year? I'll take one instance of setting up permissions for stock apps (Many of which I don't use) over granting them unfettered access to my data and device services any day of the year. For instance, under no circumstances do I want Location Services enabled for: "App Store, Camera, Facebook, Messages, Siri, Twitter, HomeKit, Location based Alerts or Ads or Suggestions, WiFi Networking, Frequent Locations, Diagnostics and Usage, or Popular Near Me. I'd be happier if I could disable location access by modem too (GPS, Bluetooth, and WiFi) but it isn't that granular.
- ClassyJacket 10y agoAlso Apple has a backup system that happens every night automatically. So even if you buy every iPhone that comes out you don't have to set up permissions again. (I may be wrong, someone correct me if I am).
- nezo 10y agoOffer a device to a novice and watch him/her panic over the incredibly huge amount of popups. (I saw my mom) How frequent do I buy a new device shouldn't be a reason for onboarding to be such a hassle. Of course location is a good exemple of permissions you don't want to give to every app, but I gave example of apps asking for obvious permissions. Camera app (Still love this example, sorry) ask access for camera, and oh storage... really? Both of them are really obvious. I don't know anyone using camera just to see the preview, but maybe.
- neurostimulant 10y agoGiving the camera app access to location data is useful though. If you do that, the photo app can automatically group your photos by location/city, which is very useful if you take a lot of photos and travel a lot.
- Sephr 10y agoWith a title like that, I was assuming that this post would have something to do with the hypocrisy surrounding android's audio capture permissions. Want to make a WiFi-based audio adapter and support Android (without requiring root)? Too bad. Only the Chromecast app is allowed to request permission for system audio capture.
- Searle 10y agoA friend of mine and I wrote an app which you can use to find apps without suspicous permissions before installing: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=de.steppicrew.saferplay https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=de.steppicrew.... We didn't do any marketing because we just scratched our own itch, but I always use it when seaching for a new app. Doesn't solve the problem, put makes it manageable.
- StrLght 10y agoSome apps prefer to declare more permissions than they need because adding more permissions would stop app from autoupdating – user will need to manually confirm new permission when updating in Google Play. Android 4.X is running on nearly one third of the Android devices and there are apps with old permission model (eg. Snapchat), so that's still a thing in some apps. I am not defending Meitu and Kaspersky though. Be careful installing new apps and look at apps' permissions.
- crististm 10y agoThe law of unintended consequences is at work here as well :)
- Tepix 10y agoIt can fail both ways: On the one hand you may not install an update because the app wants more permissions than you consider acceptable. On the other hand you may not install the app at all if it asks for too many permissions during the initial install.
- giancarlostoro 10y agoI usually refuse to install apps that ask for the wrong permissions. Some apps literally display static offline content and ask for permissions, while I've installed games that never need any permissions (I guess outside of the basic ones for writing to disk).
- StrLght 10y agoWhile I agree with you I also think that sadly average person doesn't really care about permissions at install time simply because there're lots of them. But app update is different -- there're usually 1-2 permission(s) added with update so there's huge chance that user will notice it and think about why these permissions are needed.
- martijn_himself 10y agoI'm in the market for either a iPhone 7 or OnePlus 3T, with the latter running OxygenOS, which is based off Android Nougat I believe. Do concerns around Android security apply to all Android devices and versions or are there exceptions?
- BoorishBears 10y agoAndroid's main security issue is systemic and applies to all phones and all versions. If tomorrow morning a new major version of Android fixed every deep seated security issue there was, it'd still be years before it had a sizable marketshare.
- martijn_himself 10y agoI guess this is the answer most users will be looking for. I really like the proposition of the OnePlus 3T and I appreciate the ability to load other ROM's but I'm really just looking for the best baseline secure environment that doesn't require me to either be super vigilant about installing apps or aggressively manage permission on a per-app basis.
- pgaddict 10y agoAFAIK OxygenOS is more about optimization than about security, but I might be wrong. There's CopperheadOS and also SilentOS, both Android-based, the formed being open source and working on the Nexus phone. Don't ask me about how good they are or how they compare to each-other though. In general, there are vast differences between devices - various vendors often add various applications that you might easily put into the malware category. I'd say that if Android, go with Nexus phone.
- aianus 10y agoOnePlus 3T has an unlocked bootloader, you can flash any ROM you want.
- fjorn0 10y agoCopperheadOS is trying at least. https://mobile.twitter.com/CopperheadOS/status/787357257029685248 https://mobile.twitter.com/CopperheadOS/status/7873572570296...
- titraprutr 10y ago" ... this is the sort of thing that capitalism is inherently going to end up making use of." I just stopped reading after this.
- kaoD 10y agoWell, isn't it true? Nowadays users (and their data) are the means of production and capitalists are using it to their advantage. Libertarian appeal to consumer responsibility is too idyllic. Consumers are mostly not responsible and often misinformed and easy to manipulate.
- titraprutr 10y ago"capitalists are using it to their advantage" yes, this is true but by the same token you can say that socialists use this data to better target users with their socialist agenda. My point is, there is no need for introducing this type of "innocent" remarks because it only creates more hype around the whole capitalism vs. socialism thing.
- kaoD 10y agoThen say that. "I stopped reading" comments are not constructive. They lack content and can't be argued with.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ercu 10y agoAndroid permissions are full of bugs. Even they prevented call recording on Android 7, apps on google play can overcome this by directly communicating with drivers.
- bambax 10y ago> The moral here isn't that Kaspersky are evil or that Meitu are virtuous. It's that talking about application permissions is difficult Maybe. Or the lesson could be: the fewer apps the better.
- ungzd 10y agoDo newer versions of Android ask for permission on first use of every such feature? Or it was Cyanogenmod feature?
- rhodysurf 10y agoYes they do
- wruza 10y agoI still wonder why Android does request permissions before application was run. Apple does it when app actually tries to use AB, location, camera, microphone, etc. You know the context of requirement then and are able to tell whether it is really required (and turn it off later). On Android you just blindly accept it, and app is free to go anywhere, anytime. Maybe I'm wrong and it got better now, but my recent experience with friend's Android was exactly as described. We got a couple of new contacts in address book and actively prevented sending sms to China from boiler-info app. Wtf?
- izacus 10y agoYour "recent" experience is a few Android releases out of date.
- wruza 10y agoProbably right. That was a year ago, and idk whether phone was up-to-date (though it was 'new'). Relatively cheap phones take no updates, is that still true?
- relics443 10y agoAndroid uses runtime permissions since marshmallow, but the app has to support them otherwise it falls back to granting them all at install time.
- wruza 10y agoThat way android is stuck with tons of 4th-party software publishers that are not even professionals in programming. Stores are full of working evolutionlessware. Why don't they just present "ok/nope" dialog and fail a system call after "nope"?
- relics443 10y agoIt's not that simple. The app I work on now is pretty complex, and the only way we were able to get runtime permissions in normally was to commit to a complete rewrite of the app (that wasn't the justification for the rewrite). It's just not always the highest priority.
- creativityland 10y agoThere was a long discussion about this on /r/android. https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/5oyvun/psa_dont_install_the_meitu_photo_app_its_sending/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/5oyvun/psa_dont_in...
- jjuel 10y agoThose Kaspersky permissions look like permissions on the payload you can create with Metasploit...
- scarface74 10y agoSolving the issue that was mentioned about how to give an app developer a unique id for a device and still give the user privacy was solved problem with Windows Mobile before the first iPhone came out. The OS would give a developer a unique identifier for only their app that was different per app.
- balladeer 10y agoI stopped using TrueCaller because not only this app gets everything out of your phonebook, it puts it on the web for others to see. And that's exactly how you see other's contact details too. Uninstalled after deactivating my account and then used https://www.truecaller.com/unlist https://www.truecaller.com/unlist but my number is still listed.
- jugbee 10y agoHi, i would like to draw the attention of you, the people with more expertise than I to another app that at least for me is more terrifying Xiaomi Mi Fit (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.xiaomi.hm.health https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.xiaomi.hm....), because it also takes all the intrusive permissions (modify system settings?!), but also takes all this info and combines it with your health data. Furthermore it is very hard to find it's privacy policy (I may have seen it once during registration in the app and it said "it's scattered around the terms and aggreements). This comment may be burried, but I hope at least someone, who's better in this than I will check it
- neurostimulant 10y agoModify system settings permission is needed when your app needs to change network state. Previously using the Change Network State permission was enough, but since Android 6 it's no longer suffice. I imagine that app probably need to access the watch accessory over Bluetooth and need that permission to make the Bluetooth turn on automatically.
- vicnov 10y agoEveryone just need to read a bit more about Kaspersky family. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natalya_Kaspersky https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natalya_Kaspersky For example: she [N Kaspersky] believes that all personal data, such as search history, geolocation, contacts, correspondence, photo and video materials, should belong to the State.[11]
- coolspot 10y agoAnd Eugene Kaspersky himself has ties to KGB/FSB. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugene_Kaspersky#Alleged_affiliations_with_Russia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugene_Kaspersky#Alleged_affil...
- stolk 10y agoIt doesn't always have to be like this, on Android: https://twitter.com/BramStolk/status/421750337750327296 https://twitter.com/BramStolk/status/421750337750327296