6 ms·
The only reason to have nuclear weapons is a deterrent, but how do we modernize our nuclear systems for Safety and Security without escalating tensions?
by exabrial 10y ago
The only reason to have nuclear weapons is a deterrent, but how do we modernize our nuclear systems for Safety and Security without escalating tensions?
- EGreg 10y agoTweet about it. Then Putin will say it's no big deal. And in fact you can make a deal trading nuclear disarmament for lifting sanctions.
- lostlogin 10y agoAnd the invaded stay occupied?
- loafa 10y agoIf you're talking about Crimea then... well yeah, wasn't that going to happen anyway? Not sure why Trump gets the blame for things that already happened on Obama's watch.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoBecause politics. Nobody cares about facts or things making some sort of sense. All that matters is a good soundbite.
- lostlogin 10y agoWho's blaming Trump for Putin's invasion?
- marcosdumay 10y agoThe people that usually push that line. They are mostly blaming Trump for Obama not stating WWIII. I dunno what they really expect. There is a huge pile of problems anybody must settle before the US can demand Russia to free the Crimea (and one of them is actually establishing that Crimea wants to be freed).
- lostlogin 10y agoWow, that's a low bar. So as long as you can demonstrate that the population likes an invasion after fact, it's all ok? It's also ok to solve problems separately, they don't all have to be solved at the same time or in a particular order.
- marcosdumay 10y agoThere was a plebiscite before the invasion. You have to show it was rigged (probably was, but I know nothing). I don't think anybody even tried.
- macintux 10y agoTrump gets the blame for saying idiotic things about it ("Russia's not going into Ukraine") and laying out the red carpet for Russia to do similar things to our NATO allies, not for the Crimean occupation itself.
- PerfectDlite 10y ago> well yeah, wasn't that going to happen anyway? Same "peaceniks" attitude was expressed about Hitler anschluss. We all knew what happened next.
- loafa 10y agoSo what do you want to do? Start WW3 against Russia? Because that's the other option here.
- PerfectDlite 10y agoReally? Do you see no other options? Like, you know, sanctions?
- PaulKeeble 10y agoThe Russians built the largest nucleur weapon of all time just a year or two ago. Its hardly an escalation when other countries are doing the same thing.
- arethuza 10y agoIf your thinking about the "Tsar Bomba" that wasn't really a weapon and it was exploded in 1961: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsar_Bomba https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsar_Bomba [NB And making really big H-bombs isn't that difficult or indeed very useful other than for bragging rights - which was the point of this device].
- biaib 10y agoI think he was talking about this one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RS-28_Sarmat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RS-28_Sarmat
- grw_ 10y agoI think it's more likely to be this: https://www.brookings.edu/blog/order-from-chaos/2015/11/18/russias-perhaps-not-real-super-torpedo/ https://www.brookings.edu/blog/order-from-chaos/2015/11/18/r... Interestingly, it appears to be propaganda only intended for internal consumption in former USSR.
- ivan_gammel 10y agoThat's minor PR event which likely purpose is to send some message to the West, while also delivering some "good news" to the audience of state TV. If you'll ask anyone in Russia, noone will remember it. Meanwhile, RS-28 is real and Russian Strategic Nuclear Forces do perform the upgrade of the whole triade at this moment.
- grw_ 10y agoI agree- weapons that actually exist are of far greater significance to this discussion. I just thought this was a better fit to the GP's original comment than the other suggestions posted.
- zigzigzag 10y agoIt is probably a question of money. The testimony of the leaker is full of references to the Americans supposedly doing things better and more professionally. If true, that is surely a funding issue.
- lithos 10y agoAn American officer isn't really allowed to blow off concerns (at least from a nuke) like they did in that rant. They actually can't if they want to keep their job. This rant pretty much falls into what every sailor that hates their job dreams about doing. Though they normally end up sadding out before it gets to this point (using real or fake psychological issues to disqualify themselves).
- gech 10y agoAd hominem
- lithos 10y agoI put a good amount of thought to think of a direct comparison to the IT world. As it stands right now "everyone knows" that IT companies are skirting and breaking the law(s) when it comes to data collection and retention. It's just that it's such a huge and intentionally opaque subject that it's impossible to make good laws or even enforce them. Now let's say you have an almost senior person at one of the big 3 (or whatever number it's at now) that decides they're going give to high ranking elected officials every bit of data the company has them, their spouse, and their children (say Germany since their laws are pretty strict and have cultural history behind their laws) who that data has been sold to, how it's used, and similar. Then further more gives hints that there is knowledge inside that the company knew it was/might have breaking/broke x laws. The first thoughts are going to be fanboy/hate, there are better ways to do this, why are they even keeping that job, and similar. Also seeing how IT people react to sexual harassment claims I expect attacks that are just attacks. Rather than answering what can be of the question, and attempting* to satisfy some curiosity (which I attempted to do). *rather horribly now that you've pointed it out. And sadly falling into other bad practices to explain what I see in the link for this post .
- Arizhel 10y agoI think it's a question of numbers: if you're building a bunch of new ones and keeping the old ones, your absolute number of deployed weapons goes up, and raises tensions. But if you build a bunch of new ones and simultaneous retire, and remove from service, a bunch of old ones, so that your deployed number is the same, that shouldn't raise tensions at all. It's hard to imagine how other nations could object to "we're replacing a bunch of old and possibly dangerous weapons with new ones that are much safer so we don't have to worry about having a horrible accident".