3 ms·
This is actually not a bad study. First, the bad stuff: - Only 50 participants (they waffle about power, but its unconvincing) - Over analysis of such a small
by disgruntledphd2 10y ago
This is actually not a bad study.
First, the bad stuff:
- Only 50 participants (they waffle about power, but its unconvincing)
- Over analysis of such a small dataset (they report testing lots of issues, and they presumably did a bunch more tests).
On the good side:
- They showed a 1pt improvement on a good measure of intelligence (raven's matrices), as a result of a differing recruitment strategy (scroll through the paper, there's a half-page image showing these).
- All of the experimenters were blind to both study purpose and condition (which is sadly rare in psychology).
- This is a really interesting effect. It would be one thing if it were a social measure, but raven's matrices are an IQ test.
This would seem to support the notions around malleable intelligence (Carol Dweck et al), and is an interesting experimental effect.
That being said, the sample size was really small, and I probably won't believe this until I see it replicated a few times (though I've seen similar placebo effects on IQ tests before in past research, which I always thought sounded more like stereotype threat).