4 ms·
Is the problem that statistics are losing authority, or that everything connected with the elite is losing authority? From what I see, just about every class of
by lordnacho 10y ago
Is the problem that statistics are losing authority, or that everything connected with the elite is losing authority? From what I see, just about every class of experts is less trusted now than a few years ago. Economists, scientists (climate change), doctors (vaccines), and so on. Statistics are used to back up every quantitative thing that's ever been studied, so of course that quantitative element sometimes comes under scrutiny as well.
As for statistics as a national health monitoring system, it is a victim of regime shift.
You collect the statistics that seem relevant when you are setting up the collection. You look at things like money supply, unemployment, GDP and manufacturing jobs because they seem to make sense at the time. Whatever models people are working on seem to want those numbers, so those are the numbers you collect.
Unfortunately, it's hard to model things for which you have no data. Social science is especially messy, and so there are many ways things might interact, but haven't yet, and some of those things will be a surprise to you, with the added problem that the confounding variable is one that you haven't collected, because you didn't think it was important.
This regime shift, which causes a new way for the numbers to be generated, is to be expected. Why would the economy grow for hundreds of years, like it has, in the same way? Looking at history, it hasn't. The structure of the economy changes, as you would expect from any ecology that isn't in equilibrium. And "The World Economy" has been growing for hundreds of years.
One example of numbers changing meanings was in the Economist the other day. Manufacturing is not what it was. A lot of builders of equipment now make money maintaining equipment or training people to use it. For instance I was surprised to find out a professional coffee making machine is actually not just a thing a coffee shop buys. They lease it, and along with the lease comes training for baristas. Something that would skew figures.