11 ms·
Philadelphia Poised to Ban Employers from Asking Hires About Salary History
- tyingq 10y agoPaywalled, so I can't read it. Curious if this would ban asking about even current salary. That will make things interesting in Philly.
- legodt 10y agoTry hitting the "web" button under the link and navigating in through google. If that doesn't work, I made you a pastebin of the raw text: http://pastebin.com/kS5QPEiF http://pastebin.com/kS5QPEiF
- ennuihenry 10y agoIt seems like the WSJ has closed the HTTP Google referer paywall loophole. I've tried a couple of browsers/OSes over the last week and I can't view any articles. TY though for the pastebin.
- jacquesc 10y agoThe trick is opening the search result link in an incognito window (if you're using Chrome). It's a pretty nutty loophole, surprised it's gone on as long as it has.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tabeth 10y agoA society truly run by the people, ala individuals, would have banned this long ago. Just think about it: for an average person, what benefit do they receive by allowing employers to ask about past or current salary information? None. Wouldn't be surprised if there have been measures to ban this that were ultimately struck down by business people. The less information that's shared with employers, the more employers will have to refine their actual process for vetting people. Whether this means more accurate metrics, that correlate to actual employee performance, or something else, who knows. Either way, I believe it's good for the people. However, we will have to be careful, if we go this route, to not slip into nepotism (well, more than we already have).
- winter_blue 10y ago> A society truly run by the people, ala individuals, would have banned this I'm libertarian-leaning, and statements like these bother me deeply. If I'm an employer, why ban me from asking some question to a prospective employee? It's a restriction on the employer's freedom. The job applicant has a right to decline to answer my question (and I have a right to decline to offer a job). Regulating what questions I can ask (i.e. my speech) is a restriction on my freedom. I recently interviewed for a job, and they asked me what (minimum) base salary I was looking for, and I didn't answer their question, and said that I wanted them to make an offer based on what they thought I was worth. As a result, I ended up getting a higher base salary than I'd expected. But that detracts from the main point. The reason I oppose such laws and regulations is that I feel like it's an infringement on personal freedom. Employers are made up of people, and regulating their speech and their actions is a limitation on their personal freedom.
- tabeth 10y agoYou're asking the wrong question. Why allow it? Employers and people are not equivalent in my mind, even if they are the same, legally. Your story is nice, but I've also heard stories where people are rejected immediately because they didn't share. Sure, you could say that people shouldn't work for those companies (and they shouldn't), but not everyone has the luxury of being able to interview anywhere, nor the ability to be accepted anywhere.
- madeofpalk 10y ago> You're asking the wrong question. Why allow it? No, this is definitely the wrong question. Things shouldn't be banned by default and then we debate about why to unban (allow) it.
- tabeth 10y agoNot sure what you're getting at. No one said things should be banned by default. Now that it is up for debate, as you mention, the question still is: why allow it? What benefits does it serve?
- gesman 10y agoAsking doesn't hurt anyone. However giving certain answers could. What prevents employees from claiming that this information is "confidential" (polite version of "it's not your business"). Or outright lying about it?
- Frondo 10y agoMost people want to be helpful, friendly and open. It's how we're generally socialized, and that's normally a pretty good thing. Most people might not be comfortable lying about this. Especially if, in the course of a job interview, they're afraid it could count against them, not to disclose that information. The new employer doesn't need to know it, best to make blanket rule that prohibits them from trying to get it.
- kerkeslager 10y agoAsking hurts the people who give bad answers, which is unfair since in many cases those answers are irrelevant to the job being interviewed for. Claiming the information is confidential may hurt your chances of getting the job, or simply get the "we need this information or we can't continue, sorry, it's policy" answer. Lying about it benefits the liars (assuming they lie intelligently). I suspect that offers are frequently based on previous pay, so simply claiming your previous pay was higher would get you a better offer. Is lying really the behavior we want to incentivize?
- pravda 10y ago>Is lying really the behavior we want to incentivize? Oh gosh. You make it sound bad that way! It's not 'lying', it is 'strategic disinformation'.
- EduardoBautista 10y agoHonestly I have answered slightly under what I wanted to earn.
- gesman 10y ago
- aswanson 10y agoI answer what I deem unethical/ unfair lines of questioning with any answer I feel necessary to advantage myself in negotiating. Others should do so as well.
- jimnotgym 10y agoI have chosen to answer that it is irrelevant. I claim I am not driven entirely by money, and therefore I would consider any offer on its total merits, not just salary. A few employers have taken exception to this, luckily I don't have to move jobs right now. The point is when I was younger I would have told them, under pressure to seem open. Ban it, it is scummy
- hackuser 10y agoAn important detail: Comcast, backed by the local Chamber of Commerce, has threatened to sue the city over this law. On what basis? The corporation's Constitutional First Amendment free speech right to ask the question: http://www.investopedia.com/news/comcast-threatens-sue-city-philadelphia/ http://www.investopedia.com/news/comcast-threatens-sue-city-... Are these the same free speech rights the Supreme Court recently bestowed on the corporations? I remember that at the time legal analysts said it would make it hard to regulate corporations. How can you regulate, for example, what goes in a prospectus issued to shareholders if the corporate has free speech rights?
- Retric 10y agoFree speech already has well known limits. Copywrite is an obvious one. Anyway, salary history's are discriminatory which seems like something that probably already has case law.
- icebraining 10y ago*Copyright Discrimination is, AFAIK, only illegal if it's against or impacts workers on the basis of a few specific issues (race, sex, pregnancy, etc). I don't see salary histories fitting the bill, do you?
- Retric 10y agoConsidering there is a well known gender bias in terms of salary's the connection seems very clear. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/03/20/upshot/as-women-take-over-a-male-dominated-field-the-pay-drops.html?_r=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2016/03/20/upshot/as-women-take-over...
- rhizome 10y agoEconomic status is not a protected class.
- pmiller2 10y agoLook up "disparate impact" sometime.
- hackuser 10y agoMost innovation and progress now is at the city level (I'm not the first to say it). Name the last thing government achieved at a national level in the U.S. - there's health care, but that's now looking shaky. The priority of one major party in the U.S. is to shut down government as much as possible; that party can block progress everywhere but in cities, where they have no power for now. However, they are trying to pass 'pre-emption laws' in many state governments which block cities from doing anything the Republicans in the state capitals don't like. So much for the belief in liberty and local control.
- rayiner 10y agoIf cities and municipalities are our hope for good governance we're are all pretty screwed. Cities across the country basically bankrupt and state and local governance is rife with corruption.
- hackuser 10y agoI don't agree. Is there some way you can back up that claim and be more specific? (Though I think you and I have had this discussion before?) All human institutions are 'rife with corruption' if the standard is some ideal, but until we adopt our computer overlords we're stuck with people. On a relative scale, I don't see them as so corrupt; and I'm not willing to wait in order to make progress. (EDIT: Name the non-corrupt institution that you want to make these decisions.) Most importantly, the cities are getting things done.
- cmdrfred 10y agoI believe state and local governments are unable to run a deficit. If the federal government had to play by the same rules it would be bankrupt as well.
- hackuser 10y ago> I believe state and local governments are unable to run a deficit. That's true in at least many places, but they still can borrow from the future by issuing bonds, or by pushing off massive costs like pensions. They underfund pensions now and let the next mayor/governor deal with it; this process repeats until they can't meet the cash flow needed to pay current pensions and are effectively bankrupt. Remember when Detroit went bankrupt: According to an article I read about it, there were at least two main causes: 1) Going back to at least the 1990s their pensions were overfunded because they would need that money to pay future pensions when the ratio of current workers to retirees would drop. Instead of saving the money, they distributed it to pensioners as a '13th month'. Detroit also invested in some financial engineering instrument sold to them by Wall Street that the city couldn't pay off.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tossaway1 10y agoMassachusetts did this last summer. Seems like a strange trend. Not necessarily bad (though it makes things harder for me as a hiring manager) but I wonder what group is pushing for this. Laws don't tend to get passed unless they're backed by special interests.
- mavelikara 10y agoHow does such a law makes things harder for you as a hiring manger?
- accountface 10y agoBecause you have to get someone all the way to an offer until you know what their salary expectations are. I think it's a good rule, but it is harder for managers. Especially managers who want to find a cheap hire.
- mavelikara 10y agoIf I understand it correctly, the rule does not forbid asking salary expectations up front.
- shostack 10y agoThere isn't anything stopping you from asking expectations. Just history, which removes some of your leverage (arguably a good thing). And people looking for "cheap hires" deserve to be hit hard by this the most IMHO. Leveling the playing field with information asymmetry is a good thing.
- d4rti 10y agoThere's also no prohibition of advertising the job with a salary range, which would also solve the problem.
- tossaway1 10y agoI'd say that preventing potential employers from asking questions about salary while allowing applicants to ask whatever they want is creating, not removing, assymmetry. In both cases, parties are free to refuse to answer questions. One could argue that the potential employer is in a position of power and should therefore be constrained but I don't see that as the case at all these days, at least not in the tech industry.
- jimnotgym 10y agoInteresting that various people here are horrified by restrictions on what you can ask in an interview. In the UK there are various restrictions on what you are allowed to ask, such as a candidates age. Actually the main risk to a business from this is a careless interviewer asking by mistake. An enlightened employer should not find any of this restricting at all. All of the worst interviewers I have faced have always asked about my salary, and recruitment consultants always do (they also tend to lie about your expectations to potential employers in order to get interviews). It is a deliberate attempt to screw you down and is totally unnecessary.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> In the UK there are various restrictions on what you are allowed to ask, such as a candidates age. In the US, asking the question isn't itself illegal, but it's an incredibly bad idea to ask, because discriminating based on the answer is illegal.
- abduhl 10y agoIt's only illegal if they can prove that you discriminated based on their age. This is why companies never tell a prospective hire why they've declined to hire them, instead they just tell them that it's a poor culture fit. Poor culture fits aren't illegal, so you can feel safe not hiring based on culture. Especially if the part of their culture that doesn't fit is a protected class.
- jimnotgym 10y agoAgain, its only an issue for bad companies, with bad employment practices. The rest of us will be unaffected by the restriction
- tabeth 10y ago> Again, its only an issue for bad companies, with bad employment practices. The rest of us will be unaffected by the restriction Don't you feel that this attitude is dismissive?
- gigatexal 10y agoGood. Put the negotiating power back into the hands of the employees. Get an offer. See that it's too low based on previous compensation and then say so. And then proceed from there. I've burned my own ability to negotiate by sharing current salaries before but that was with recruiters.
- logicallee 10y ago[Edit: if a potential employer asked my previous salary] I would have zero qualms (zero) saying any number I wanted. If I was asked for paystubs I would say I'll get them later and add that the number may not have been exact, it could be off substantially I want to be upfront about that. If I have to put a number in a form and sign that I swear it is accurate, I would put an asterisk and explain that it is indicative of what I want them to think. I don't see ethical problems with this behavior. It is practically what I actually would do. If HR absolutely cannot start without my notarized sworn copy of pay stubs then I would not work there, and their loss. For anyone else, HR's job is to find qualified people, they are not going to kick you out once they've started onboarding you. You don't have to lie, but you don't have to answer their questions any more than they have to ask yours about their company - HR doesn't work far from payroll, if as part of your interviews you asked to know the CEO's salary, would they tell you? Or the ratio between then lowest and highest salary at the company? (2.5x, 3x, 5x, 10x, 50x, 100x) Things don't have to be hard and fast. If they don't like how I roll they can hire someone else. If I don't like their level of transparency I can refuse their offer. Plus they're free to fire me if they don't like me. You should answer illegal questions the same way. e.g. in an interview, how old are you. Say whatever you want, just add "I don't like to give am exact age just use that". If they're surprised that a 55 year old shows up too bad for them. Fire you if they don't like it. You're not paid to be 25 and you're not paid to have a certain salary history. You're paid to do a certain job - everything else is just friction. Say whatever you want, as long as you can do the job. Don't lie about degrees or credentials. Don't practice law or perform surgery without a license.
- prostoalex 10y ago> and add that the number may not have been exact, it could be off substantially Beyond pure monetary compensation, there are various non-monetary parameters - quality of health plan, quality and employee cost of dental plan, parental leave policy, 401(k) matching, mobile phone or Internet reimbursement, employer stock purchase plan - that any random number feels like a good ballpark estimate. E.g. how does one value a health PPO with monthly premium $298 per family vs Kaiser HMO at $152 a month? A 5-day vs 3-week parental leave? The answer is highly dependent on personal circumstances, such as distance from home to the nearest Kaiser facility and whether or not someone in the family is expecting. The value of either might be $0 if interviewee plans to stay covered by spousal health plan and does not plan to have children.
- general_ai 10y agoCan we go a little further than this? Can we require employers to post the details of the compensation package that comes with each job? That would save a lot of time for all involved and obviate the need to even ask this question.
- tn13 10y agoNo. It will stop us from bargaining and pushing for biding wars.
- general_ai 10y agoYou'll just front load the "bidding war". You will still be able to negotiate incidentals like PTO, signing bonus, etc. When recruiters from e.g. Japan or some European countries reach out to me it's easy for me to dismiss them out of hand since their comp is stated up front. This is also more fair to demographics which don't like to negotiate, and women in particular.
- iamthepieman 10y agoAll of my employers are already banned.
- jimmywanger 10y agoThere are two things that spring out instantly. First, the motivation is to close gender pay inequality. Assuming such a thing exists (women get paid less for the same job), where is the evidence that this policy would reduce the supposed gap? Second, they're prohibiting you from asking, not prohibiting employers from not choosing you for failing to answer with the truth. It's part of negotiation. Would it be legal to ask "what's the least amount of money we can give you for you to accept the job?" (Which, btw, is the question they're indirectly asking you.) Why are they trying to outlaw negotiation skills for a somewhat unproven premise and an unclear cause and effect relationship?
- hlieberman 10y agoMassachusetts already passed a law that bars companies from asking potential hires about their salary history until after they've made an offer. (The law is signed, but doesn't go into effect until June.)
- otakucode 10y agoIt is bizarre that so many people tolerate this behavior by employers yet also cling to ideas about compensation being linked to the value of the work being performed (things like 'work hard and you will make more'). If compensation is determined based primarily upon the value of the work being done, prior salary could not be more irrelevant. But of course, what people are paid has nothing to do with the value of their work any longer. Computers and software unfortunately make that socially untenable. They make employees so abundantly productive, and increase that productivity so quickly, that it would have to translate into very high salaries and high annual raises for many, if not most, employees. It doesn't take a genius to look at the average profitability of corporations overall since 1980 to see the meteoric rise coupled with total wage stagnation for non-executives. Get 2% more productive, then a 2% raise is acceptable. Get 100% more productive, then a comparable raise is unacceptable. Especially if "the computer is doing all the work."
- cheald 10y agoNobody who actually thinks about salary thinks that salaries are set by the MPL. The ceiling on salaries is set by the MPL. The level is set by the available supply of labor and negotiations during the hiring process.
- FrancoDiaz 10y agoMight as well change the name of Hacker News to Nanny-Stater News. Seriously, twenty-five years ago, real hackers would be laughing at such silly laws. But now we have a bunch of incompetent leftists who can't do anything unless someone makes a law to protect their sorry asses. Just say, "I'm not answering that question". It's that freaking simple. You don't need a law. You statists never think of the consequences of such laws.
- _tulpa 10y agoAnd then lose out to the majority who either don't see how answering the question could be bad for them or just can't see that not answering is an option...
- gdulli 10y agoThat's too bad. My salary history tells a good story about me, that employers have found me more valuable than average. It's a pretty tangible and direct signal. In an interview it's convenient for them to ask and for me not to have to awkwardly bring it up.
- pimlottc 10y agoI should think it would be easier for you to avoid the awkwardness and bring it up anyway than it is for people to resist the pressure of having to answer the question now.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoFirstly, in our land of secret compensation your salary has much more to do with your negotiation skills than it does your performance. Secondly, if you want your potential employers to know anything about you, you just tell them.
- jackbrian 10y ago> Councilman William Greenlee, a Democrat, who sponsored the bill, says the measure wouldn’t prevent employers from setting a fair salary, bar salary negotiations with prospective hires, or keep job candidates from voluntarily sharing their pay history. But if passed, violators who quizzed would-be hires about salary could face fines up to $2,000. Even if passed, the penalty hardly seems disincentivizing.
- douche 10y agoA proportional penalty based on the salary of the position would make more sense. If you're hiring at McDonalds at minimum wage, $2000 is a bigger penalty than if you're hiring an engineer.
- criveros 10y agoI added 10k to my salary last time I was asked.
- jacquesc 10y agoYou may have stumbled upon a solution here. Make it legal to ask the question, but also make it legal to lie about the answer (including doctoring paystubs, etc). Seems like a uniquely libertarian solution.
- aninhumer 10y agoI don't think it really solves the problem. Making it legal to lie means employer can't sue you for fraud, but they can still fire you if they find out.
- shostack 10y agoSpeaking in terms of total comp (including benefits value) is helpful too. Many of them have very real dollar values associated with them.
- jacquesc 10y agoI support this, but I also think employers should be banned from requiring a credit check for employment. There are regulations on discriminating on race, gender, etc. The one missing piece is discriminating against the poor (which indirectly tie back to race, gender). It's still amazing to me that this is a practice that's still allowed for a society that purports to value social mobility.
- danieltillett 10y agoEvery regulatory hurdle to hiring decreases the propensity of businesses to hire marginal candidates. The easier you make it to hire and fire people the more marginal candidates will be given the chance. There is no free-lunch here.
- re_todd 10y agoIt always amazes me when I hear about people asking this question. Don't these hiring managers consider for a second how intrusive and rude it is? Aren't they concerned they may come across as douchebags for asking it? And yet I've been asked this several times by people that act like it's no big deal, like asking how was the traffic on the way in. Are they under pressure from the top? Or are hiring managers in general lacking in scruples?
- problems 10y agoI think it actually plays both ways - it's a way for me to give them an idea of what I'm expecting.
- user5994461 10y agoIntrusive, yes. Rude, no it's not.
- davej 10y agoI'll either politely refuse to answer or if I have thought about it beforehand then I'll give a number that guides them towards the salary I am looking for this time around. I don't really mind the question. It's a little rude and it's only asked to get a gauge of salary expectations so why not ask what the current salary expectations are directly.
- shostack 10y agoI've actually flat out said "that it isn't really relevant, but can you share your range and we'll see if that makes sense once I learn more about the role?" It has worked a few times. Some get surprised when someone tries to flip that on them. The ones that balk get dropped from consideration.
- user5994461 10y agoThey'll always consider the low end of the range while you'll always consider the end. It's not a practical reply.
- shostack 10y agoThat's always a possibility. I usually frame it as something more like "I still need to learn a lot more about this role in order to tell you an amount that would make sense for me, and you still likely need time to learn more about what value I can add. If you can share your range, we can make sure we're at least in the right ballpark, and if it makes sense to move forward I'm confident we can arrive on a comp package that works for everyone." Very often this question gets asked on initial screener calls. They don't know how to really evaluate you or what you bring to the table, and you know whatever high level thing the recruiter was told about the role. The purpose of the call is to determine in the quickest amount of time whether it makes sense to move forward to a deeper, more formal discussion about the opportunity with the people actually qualified to discuss the role at that level (hiring manager, etc.). Make it clear that you are interested in the entire comp package and not just salary. I haven't really had that much resistance to this. At the end of the day it is on you to do your research on what they need to pay you for this to make sense, and be happy with that number. If they won't go for it, you tell them what that minimum happy number is, and if they won't get there one way or another (extra vacation, etc.), then you need to pass (assuming that is a realistic option for you).
- anon31415927 10y agoMost people don't realize that companies can get salary history from a number of sources. ADP actually provides this as a service to larger customers.
- chillwaves 10y agoAre you saying ADP will give my salary information to a company I might apply to? That doesn't seem ethical. Do you have a source on this? I am surprised to hear it.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoWhen you give them permission to run a "background check" on you then they most likely will consult with a database that may have your employment information in it. http://www.annualmedicalreport.com/do-a-total-background-check-on-yourself-annual-consumer-reporting-agency/ http://www.annualmedicalreport.com/do-a-total-background-che... >The Work Number (a service of TALX / Equifax Inc.) – The Work Number is a paid employment verification database operated by the TALX Corporation (owned by Equifax Inc.). The Work Number database contains more than 192 million entries and is used by by over 50,000 organizations to verify employment data... Your Employment Data Report contains (1) employment and income information from your employers who send data to The Work Number, (2) information about lenders, credit agencies, and other verifiers that have received your data, and (3) any messages, alerts, or statements you have requested be put in your data file
- snarf21 10y agoI understand the goal of this law but don't see how it solves it. I usually ask people what their current salary is now. I want to offer them (at least) a modest raise to come here. I want them to be happy and excited. I also want to not waste a ton of time negotiating salary if they want 50K more then I have available in my budget. You are worth whatever you can get someone to pay you. Some people may come in with a lower ask but then you have yourself, are they a bargain or are they just less talented? If they come in high, are they overpriced or are they just that good? I also think this only works for the employee if there is a shortage in this field and employers are desperate (but the market will force those prices up) or if you are trying to just get more than your experience might warrant. Let's say you are a knowledge worker making $80K and hoping to go to $90K. So, in the new rules, the employer asks for your expected salary and you say "give me your best offer". The employer will either get annoyed and work with the candidate that said $85K in response or they low ball you at $60K because they can play games too. You say "no" and they ask what you are looking for, rinse and repeat. It seems like you still end up at the same place with the same result except the negotiation process sucked. As a candidate, I don't see the downside of saying I want X+ dollars. I'd rather know about the job and culture and other things than $5K more or less.
- crdoconnor 10y agoI usually respond to this question with a question of my own: "Are you asking this question because you don't have faith in your own ability to interview and value employees or because you are trying to lowball me?"
- snarf21 10y agoI understand what you are saying but I personally don't think any amount of interviewing will ever tell me exactly how much value an employee will give me in the next year. [Serious] Do you think this is possible? I can think of no way except to put them on a 3 month contract to see what they are really worth and I don't think that is what candidates are looking for.
- 10y ago