10 ms·
This article basically repeats old economic saws of dubious validity. The counter argument is Warren Buffett. Last I looked at it (going back to his Buffett Par
by valuearb 10y ago
This article basically repeats old economic saws of dubious validity. The counter argument is Warren Buffett. Last I looked at it (going back to his Buffett Partnership days), he beat the market every year but one for his first 30 or 40 years. Even better, he was beating the market by an average of 20% a year during his partnership days, and something like 10% a year during his first 20 years running Berkshire Hathaway.
It's not only statistically impossible for Buffett to be a fluke, it's statistically impossible for him not to possess a a skill providing a substantial edge in market investing. Not a "1% a year" type skill.
Nowadays and for the last 20 years or so, Buffett has been managing hundreds of billions of dollars. The immense size of his portfolio restricts his opportunities to a far smaller pool of potential investments and his edge over the market has clearly declined because of that restriction. But he's still beating the market the vast majority of the time.
- solipsism 10y agoIt's not only statistically impossible for Buffett to be a fluke I'm curious, do you have any evidence of this? "Statistically impossible" means "zero probability". If that's really your argument then you need to back it up. Perhaps you mean, "improbable"?
- ahelwer 10y agoObvious counterpoint: it's statistically "impossible" for Buffett specifically to beat the market in the way he has. Is it similarly impossible for some person to beat the market in the way he has? Let's call this hypothetical individual Warren Buffett.
- valuearb 10y agoRead super investors of Graham Doddsville, Buffett wrote it and demonstrated there are dozens of value investors with similar results to him, and they all adopt an extremely similar strategy but apply it in very dissimilar investments. And the coin flipping paradigm is wrong. The odds of beating the market by 10%+ a year is not a 50-50 proposition. It's more like a 1 in 10 chance. So re-run your stats with Buffett going 50 for 53 on 1 in 10 shots.
- codecamper 10y agoIt helps if you start investing when technology was a novelty. In the 60s!
- erikpukinskis 10y agoTechnology is still a novelty. We've barely dipped a toe in the digital age, the vast majority of changes are yet to come. We probably haven't written 1% of the software we'll be using in 20 years.
- jacques_chester 10y agoIt's worth pointing out that Buffet doesn't invalidate the weak efficient market hypothesis (the usual contender), because he generally doesn't like to trade in the open market. His preferred approach has always been to buy entire companies, usually private companies, outright. Where there is no highly liquid market, there cannot be an efficient market in the theoretical sense. He prefers to invest when it is actually possible to possess information or insights that have not been widely distributed to other potential buyers via public disclosure. There is a similar dynamic at work in real estate, where local knowledge allows outsized returns to some participants. The main source of free cashflow for Berkshire Hathaway has always been insurance, itself a risk-based industry. His main advantage has been to rigidly underwrite for profit, not for volume, giving access to cheap float. None of these things are easily duplicated by regular folks and their advantage diminishes sharply with scale, as Buffett himself has warned Berkshire Hathaway shareholders for year after year. I admire him and I think he's a useful foil to purely statistical views. But I also think luck plays its part. He's flubbed billions of dollars on both foreseeable (textiles) and less foreseeable (airlines) events.
- valuearb 10y agoYea, he built an amazing track record well before he started to buying businesses outright (and in dollar volume he's spent far more on public companies than private). His preference for buying companies instead of shares only came around later in his career, and solely due to the massive size of his portfolio that his success created. He didn't get into insurance until about 20 years after he started investing. His greatest returns were before it. Buffett/Graham believe in concentrated portfolio, not having too many positions in your portfolio, because if you have more than 20 or so positions its difficult to know any of them well. So this means when his portfolio grew in size, he started losing opportunities in the public markets because many companies were too small for him to buy enough of to have a reasonable position. So he ended up investing in larger cap companies, and buying smaller cap companies outright. And his biggest flub wasn't textiles or airlines, it was maintaining Berkshire Hathaway as his investment vehicle. He gives a free ride (no fees) to investors on half his results, and because of the double portfolio size restricting his investment options, his returns are lower. He would have had a substantially higher returns if he just invested his own money, or if he had kept running an investment partnership and taking fees. He's cost himself at least $100B in personal wealth. But despite his very infrequent mistakes, he's beat the market by well over 10% a year during his investment career, and there is almost no luck in that.
- gcb0 10y agoyou just confirmed what keeps people from uderstanding this truth: confirmation bias. you just picked one person out of billions of investors. what is more improbable? that he is flipping a coin 40 times and got head all the time or that billions of people cant see what he sees? also, buffet is the perfect example of why you should not invest, as he beats the market by not investing in the market.
- valuearb 10y agoBuffett has always invested in the market. The last half of his career he has made many private investments, but his fortune was built on public stock market investing. His average returns with the Buffett Partnership were in excess of 35% a year. That's not coin flipping. The odds of a 35% return when the stock market is returning 10% is probably closer to one in a hundred. doing that for a decade straight is insane. Then follow it with 40+ years where he beat the market every year but a couple, and not barely crushing on average by over 10% year (probably 10-1 against each year), even when handicapped by an enormous portfolio. (1/100)^10*(1/10)^40=?
- hrzn 10y ago> what is more improbable? that he is flipping a coin 40 times and got head all the time or that billions of people cant see what he sees? Actually, the probability of getting a head 40 times is 1/2^40, which is 1 in about 1.1 trillion. If we assume there are 1 billions investors overall, the probability that at least one wins 40 times (which is the probability that one or several Warren Buffet could appear by luck in this simple model) is about 0.00091. So yeah, in this particular phrasing of the question, with this model, the less likely option is to flip a coin and get head 40 times and the more likely option is that there is something else, like talent.
- felipemnoa 10y ago>>Actually, the probability of getting a head 40 times is 1/2^40, which is 1 in about 1.1 trillion I bet that the odds of beating the market 40 times are even worse since it is not a simple binary choice. The better analogy would be to choose the correct face of a 6 sided dice 40 times in a row, or even better a 100 sided dice. Calculate the odds for that! (I'm too lazy to do it myself)
- Applejinx 10y ago"It's not only statistically impossible for Buffett to be a fluke, it's statistically impossible for him not to possess a a skill providing a substantial edge in market investing. Not a "1% a year" type skill." No. It's statistically impossible for him to be the NORM, or some sort of aspirational figure. Statistics is exactly how we can measure how much of a fluke he is, and how lucky he's been. Give him 2% for ultra-talent, and another 5% for trading on the fact that he's Warren Buffett, and he's still a fluke. He is just able to put a thumb on the scales for personal/emotional reasons: implying to people like you that he's not a fluke. The odds of him being in that position are very long odds, and he lucked out and has taken advantage of it. If you run a lottery and draw one ticket, that's long odds but by definition one person will have won.
- Godel_unicode 10y agoAnd if you give him 10% for ultra-skill? What about 20%? Statistics tell you he's an outlier. It tells you nothing about why, however.
- dsacco 10y agoOkay, and what is the point of statistics as a discipline if you don't use it and make up percentages for arbitrary assessments?
- ____nope 10y agoBuffet doesn't claim it's impossible to beat the market. He only says that the vast majority of investors cannot pick individual investments accurately enough to beat a diversified, low-cost index fund in the long term. There are a bunch of caveats in here, namely LONG TERM – you might get lucky and strike it rich once or twice, but you are very unlikely to have those lucky investments pan out over decades. Yes, Buffet is incredibly skilled. Buffet actually claimed once that he was born with a preternatural ability to invest in companies. The whole "you can't beat the market" quote is meant more to say that we mere mortals are to Warren Buffet what normal people playing pickup basketball are to Michael Jordan.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cmdrfred 10y agoIf the majority of investors "beat the market" wouldn't that just become the market?
- jbpetersen 10y agoSurvivorship bias?
- ____nope 10y agoA better way of saying it is that the whole of investors are better at accurately predicting the value of a company than individual investors. Which sounds almost like a truism when you put it in those terms.
- DoodleBuggy 10y agoDubious validity?? Participate in the market and try to replicate what you think are dubious counterarguments with achievable and repeatable results. People like Buffet and Einhorn are extreme anomalies. So much so that they are legendary, they are that unusual. There are only a small handful of legendary investors throughout history for a reason.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- olvar_ 10y agoNot only that, but it fails to consider that many times, a large wealth, is not built with an extra 1% per year, but by one large hit. People have failed 20 years to then become rich on one good idea. You could call it luck, but to be realistic that's not luck, that's perseverance, work ethics and commitment to do something important. I agree we need to look for a way to build a more even play field and remedy the atrocious way we assign resources, but claiming that people that work hard to make a difference are just "lucky" is a terrible way to do it.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoIt's luck but in the sense of that Seneca quote: "Luck is what happens when preparation meets opportunity"
- ImTalking 10y agoI don't like those quotes (like 'the harder I work, the luckier I get') because 'luck' by it's very definition is random. We had a horrible situation in Melbourne yesterday where some nutbag drove his car down a busy sidewalk killing 4 people. It was luck (very bad luck) that those people were there in that moment and killed. That's luck. And btw, my partner and kids were there only 5 minutes before.
- jondubois 10y agoThere are plenty of people who disagree about Buffet - Nassim Taleb who wrote "Fooled by Randomness" is among of those. Out of all the people who started investing in stocks in the 50s, it's not surprising that at least one of them turned out to be among the richest people in the world and kept getting it right every year. If you have enough people throwing coins, you're going to get some people who keep getting heads over and over. Those few people who have a superior coin-tossing technique are probably not going to end up anywhere near the top - This is especially true if you believe in the rhetoric that people of high talent are "very rare". The sheer masses acting out of randomness will always beat out the few "very talented" individuals. In "Fooled by Randomness", the author alludes to the idea that the top people at any given time in any given field often got there through very little talent - It just happens that their approach was a good fit for their field at that particular time - As soon as some "black swan" event happens (and they always happen, eventually); these people tend to lose everything very, very quickly. Also, the reason why Buffet gets it right most of the time these days is the same reason why George Soros gets it right most of the time; whenever either of these famous investors buys any stock, it becomes big news then all these other wealthy investors follow suit - Soon enough you have half of humanity rooting for/against that specific company/security so anything they do becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.
- pedrosorio 10y ago"If you have enough people throwing coins" How many people do you need for a "Buffett or better" event to have > 5% probability of happening?
- taeric 10y agoIf you consider that there is a chance a flip will give you another hundred flips for free... And that can compound. It probably isn't as unlikely as you think. There is a good Euler problem on investing showing that odds based investing can be relatively easy. Of course, many things including granularity of bets, floors, ceilings, and fees complicate matters considerably. But, a relatively few big wins can give you a lot of slack.
- winter_blue 10y agoAnother example is Renaissance Technologies. Their Medallion Fund has averaged 80% returns. If you put $1,000 in the fund in 1988, it would've become $13.8 million by 2016. See: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-11-21/how-renaissance-s-medallion-fund-became-finance-s-blackest-box https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-11-21/how-renai...
- erentz 10y agoThis seems like some form of the lottery fallacy: that because an event occurred (some guy beat the market over a long period of time), it must have been the result of some forces (his skill) overcoming luck.
- ImTalking 10y agoI'm sure it has been quite a few years since Warren Buffett has made investment decisions on his own. Now he will have quite an intellect behind him.