16 ms·
Iceland knows how to stop teen substance abuse
- tn13 10y agoThe last time I checked Iceland's population was 323,002 mostly homogeneous racially similar people in geographically and economically similar region. Good for Iceland that their teenagers don't smoke as much. But there is little information for other countries in there. Smoking is going out of fashion pretty fast in USA too. http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2016/12/13/teens-drinking-smoking-drugs-study/95349684/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2016/12/13/teens-d...
- sean_patel 10y ago> Smoking is going out of fashion pretty fast in USA too. Source? Yes, Smoking traditional tobacco is going out of fashion pretty much around the world. It's been replaced by the increasing popular E-Cigarrettes / "Vaping", which is also Tobacco and poses the same health risks as traditional tobacco. Especially very prevalent among-st Teenagers and young people. Heavily marketed by Big Tobacco as "Safe". Sources: 1) CDC: Tobacco Use Among Middle and High School Students — United States, 2011–2015: https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/65/wr/mm6514a1.htm?s_cid=mm6514a1_w https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/65/wr/mm6514a1.htm?s_cid=mm... 1) England: Smoking rate continues to decrease while vaping gains in popularity http://www.vapingpost.com/2016/09/22/england-smoking-rate-continues-to-decrease-while-vaping-gains-in-popularity/ http://www.vapingpost.com/2016/09/22/england-smoking-rate-co... 2) The good news is that cigarettes are out these days. The bad news is that tobacco is still in. http://www.teenvogue.com/story/vaping-tobacco-popularity http://www.teenvogue.com/story/vaping-tobacco-popularity
- jdminhbg 10y ago> poses the same health risks as traditional tobacco I'm sorry, what? It may pose health risks, but I have not seen anything remotely resembling evidence it poses the same health risks as smoking or chewing.
- saiya-jin 10y agoburning leaves doesn't produce same amount of harmful stuff as vaping (which still isn't healthy, but com on, lets use some common sense here)
- voxic11 10y agoYou sound like the US government, somehow redefining the word tabacco to include things which have nothing to do with tabacco.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ThrustVectoring 10y ago>E-Cigarrettes / "Vaping", which is also Tobacco and poses the same health risks as traditional tobacco. This is wrong, and absolutely harmful information to spread. Cigarette smoking causes cancer through burning tobacco plant matter, a process that releases a variety of toxic chemicals. Vaporization of e-liquid does not burn tobacco plant matter, and thus doesn't have the same issues. E-liquid is basically nicotine, glycerol and/or proplyene glycol solute, and flavoring. Nicotine replacement products aren't associated with cancer risk. The solute is much the same stuff as in asthma inhalers. There isn't really good research for the flavoring, but it's generally ingredients that are recognized as safe to put in food. Overall, vaping is likely at least an order of magnitude safer than smoking. Probably two. That's not anywhere near "the same health risks as traditional tobacco." I'm personally more worried about spending lots of time near busy roads. If a policy causes X more people to vape per person that no longer smokes, X would have to be at least 100 for me to think it's a net negative.
- manarth 10y agoNicotine replacement products aren't associated with cancer risk There is evidence that Nicotine replacement products do increase the risk of cancer. Every source I've read says that the risk is less than smoking cigarettes, but vaping (for example) is still an increased risk over not using nicotine at all. Current NHS advice puts vaping at 95% less risk than smoking, which is to say an increased risk (5% of the smoking risk), compared to not vaping. - https://www.nhs.uk/smokefree/help-and-advice/e-cigarettes https://www.nhs.uk/smokefree/help-and-advice/e-cigarettes - http://scienceblog.cancerresearchuk.org/2009/04/24/can-nicotine-gum-cause-mouth-cancer/ http://scienceblog.cancerresearchuk.org/2009/04/24/can-nicot... - http://www.nhs.uk/news/2009/04April/Pages/NicotineGumCancer.aspx http://www.nhs.uk/news/2009/04April/Pages/NicotineGumCancer.... - http://www.cancer.net/navigating-cancer-care/prevention-and-healthy-living/stopping-tobacco-use-after-cancer-diagnosis/health-risks-e-cigarettes-smokeless-tobacco-and-waterpipes http://www.cancer.net/navigating-cancer-care/prevention-and-...
- ThrustVectoring 10y agoYeah, the research on nicotine replacement products isn't very mature. The links you gave are interesting, but more along the lines of "nicotine can do the same sort of things to mouth cells that happens when you have mouth cancer", not "we took a look at X number of people and looked at mouth cancer incident rates". The NHS advice is interesting, thanks for contributing it. It's a good sign that I'm on the right track - I put it at "one to two orders of magnitude", or to use the same units, 1% to 10% of the cancer risk of cigarettes. The NHS is likely biased towards saying things cause cancer (because incentives - nobody causes a ruckus if something they thought causes cancer is safe, but everyone gets way riled up if something the NHS thinks is safe causes cancer). So my updated belief is now that vaping causes less than 1% of the cancer that smoking does, per user.
- civilian 10y agoVaping is safer: https://wallethub.com/blog/is-vaping-bad-for-you/23907/ https://wallethub.com/blog/is-vaping-bad-for-you/23907/ Conflating tobacco with nicotine is also a bad move.
- sean_patel 10y agowallethub.com link? Really? Ever heard of Astroturfing? The Big Tobacco and Vaping Lobbyists have tons of "blog posts" and "research" news that "debunk" all the bad things about Vaping and Smoking. Required Viewing: Astroturf and manipulation of media messages | Sharyl Attkisson | TEDx https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-bYAQ-ZZtEU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-bYAQ-ZZtEU
- civilian 10y agoI'm familiar with the idea of astroturfing. I majored in biochemistry. And while I haven't read the research, it seems fairly straight-forward. Nicotine and some flavors are dissolved into food-safe glycerin. Then that mixture is raised to a temperature where it becomes a gas, but not a temperature high enough for it to burn. Then it is inhaled. If you compare that to smoking--- a cigarette actually _burns_, and during that oxidation process it'll make thousands upon thousands of variants of chemicals. And because they've been oxidized, they're more reactive. I'm not saying vaping is safe. But I'm saying that it's obvious that it's safer than cigarettes. You should also check out this. I am open to the idea that vaping might be _as bad_ as cigarettes, but currently the evidence shows that they're way better, and can be a good tool for quitting. https://www.gov.uk/government/news/e-cigarettes-around-95-less-harmful-than-tobacco-estimates-landmark-review https://www.gov.uk/government/news/e-cigarettes-around-95-le...
- sean_patel 10y ago> I'm not saying vaping is safe. But I'm saying that it's obvious that it's safer than cigarettes. Agreed. Saying something is 'safer' than something else, doesn't make the original thing 'Safe'. Vaping causes Cancer, so does Tobacco smoking. All of you are saying "Vaping is Safer because it isn't AS BAD AS smoking Tobacco". Agreed. But another way of saying is "We think Vaping is Safer because it causes Cancer in 20 years, whereas Tobacco smoking is will cause Cancer in 10 years"
- Zigurd 10y ago"mostly homogeneous racially similar people" Arf. Arf.
- legodt 10y agoI appreciate your joke but I don't think the HN populace gets the full context because there are a couple of steps that need to happen to connect the parent quote and your punchline.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tritosomal 10y agoJust spell it out. D-O-G W-H-I-S-T-L-E
- legodt 10y agoI've been seeing you around HN a lot recently and I've gotta say with your -5 points and all you are winning my heart
- tritosomal 10y agoHa! I just noticed this. My comments don't karma whore, and I'm not interested in appeasing the whims of the mods. It doesn't do the community much good to pull punches, if that means putting a diplomatic muzzle on valid points and opinions that contrast with a preferred norm.
- Zigurd 10y agoIt is appalling that calling out an obvious dog-whistle phrase is either not understood or unwelcome here. This is what leads to "race realism" becoming an acceptable topic in some circles.
- prodontilate 10y ago
- edejong 10y agoI think it's rather peculiar to come to the conclusion that there is little information for other countries. 1. Using various policies, Iceland has been able to strongly reduce the amount of substance abuse in their country. 2. Other countries suffer from substance abuse as well 3. The article notes that the method is mostly data driven. This implies similar methods should apply to different countries. How do you come to the conclusion that the information presented in the article is not applicable to other countries? Why would a racial dissimilar, larger and heterogeneous population not benefit from a data-driven approach to limit substance abuse? I'd go the opposite way: because the populations are larger, noise has less influence on the data-driven approach and tests can be accelerated.
- harry8 10y agoWith a population as small as iceland's there is no such thing as anonymity. Maybe these policies would work in a small town without much population turnover? Cultural context of cultural policies is actually really important. What works in Japan might not work in Springfield. Data driven is very good though, the temptation to reclassify failure as success on such problems is extremely high, unfortunately - and I am absolutely not being critical of those who are genuinely making the attempt to improve socail conditions - it's a human failing we all have. The road to hell is paved in good intentions etc. etc.
- jameshart 10y agoIf you're trying to argue that Iceland's population is therefore just not culturally predisposed to juvenile delinquency, underage drinking, smoking, or drug abuse, you must have missed the part where Iceland started out with high measured levels of those things, then staged interventions, and wound up with low levels of those things.
- flubert 10y agoDon't forget to mention the religious diversity, where only 71% of the population belongs to the official Luthern Church of Iceland, while the heathens of the Free Luthern church in Reykjavík and Hafnarfjörður only comprise 5% of the population. http://px.hagstofa.is/pxen/pxweb/en/Samfelag/Samfelag__menning__5_trufelog/MAN10001.px/table/tableViewLayout1/?rxid=39377d4c-13a5-43f6-af24-6663ca48c5a3&displaypanel=savequery1 http://px.hagstofa.is/pxen/pxweb/en/Samfelag/Samfelag__menni...
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoThis sounds like the old, worn-out argument that "we're too big and diverse to have nice things like the Nordics". With that can't do attitude of course things will never get fixed in the US.
- forkandwait 10y agoThis argument is more palatable than the truth it masks, which is that we are unwilling to spend money and time making nice things like the Nordics do, and many wealthy people like it that way because it keeps their taxes low.
- dinkumthinkum 10y agoI invite all of you that hold this position to travel across the country and do in-depth qualities one studies with interviews, surveys, actual population observations and see if these very simplistic ideas still hold true. How's that for data?
- tn13 10y agoI never mentioned "can't do". We cant do it the Nordic way. End the drug war is a simple solution to all of America's drug problems. American politicians and prison-industrial-complex likes drug addicts. That is why USA has a drug problem.
- bussierem 10y agoThey cut smoking/drinking by providing facilities for after school programs for kids to sign up for, which presumably a large portion have been told to go by their parents (probably to stop them from smoking/drinking). I know this observation has zero bearing on the data presented, but I also noticed that not a single child in those photos has anything resembling a smile. NONE of them look happy to be there.
- arethuza 10y agoMaybe it's a cultural thing but I don't always associate smiling with "happy". My wife were looking at some old pics of our son and we commented how happy he must have been in one of them because of how serious he looked! NB I'm in Scotland, which does have a bit of a reputation for being a bit dour. ;-)
- tqkxzugoaupvwqr 10y agoThe photos in the article are not shot in-the-moment. The children pose in front of a camera, probably with lighting around. They don’t smile because they are in a kind of serious setting, look into a camera and do not interact with anyone. Edit: Maybe the photographer is bad at soliciting emotions from his subjects.
- fedorarer 10y agoPlease dont't base your worldview on american customs. In some countries, doing a forced smile for photos just isn't a thing
- flukus 10y agoI want to move there. Everyone assumes my lack of smiling means I'm not happy.
- Kluny 10y agoIt's a cultural thing. They think smiling for cameras is weird.
- jacobolus 10y ago
- saiya-jin 10y agovery contained and rather unique place. very little of their success is transferable elsewhere though. it's easy to police borders of a super tiny country in the middle of atlantic ocean, not interesting place for smugglers. (been there, and apart from Reykjavik whole island is almost completely empty with tiny closed villages here and there). > A law was also passed prohibiting children aged between 13 and 16 from being outside after 10pm in winter and midnight in summer. totalitarian approach, could be successful but also strapping every kid to the bed would prevent drug consumption. its a question how far will state go to remove freedom to protect citizens.
- jameshart 10y agoWhat does border policing have to do with the article?
- legodt 10y agoIt's trendy right now sneak that sort of dog whistle racism into any discussion of social policy successes in northern european countries.
- Gargoyle 10y agoThe rest of that sentence indicates it has to do with smuggling. In other words, given the border situation, there should be less contraband availability. And so presumably less abuse of controlled substances. I'm not sure it really is a major factor, but it's a valid point to raise.
- jameshart 10y agoAh, but this is not a comparison study between Iceland and other countries, this is a comparison between Iceland today and Iceland in 1998. So the 'smugglers did it' hypothesis must be that 20 years ago, Iceland was larger and located closer to major continents, making it a better target for smuggling contraband, but that volatile icelanic geology has moved it out into the north atlantic and led to the reported changes in juvenile delinquency and substance abuse. Possible. We should conduct further studies to eliminate this confounding factor.
- kelvin0 10y agoTL;DR: Idle kids 'waste' their energy getting into self destructive behaviors. When the youthful energy is focused on a useful and valued skill, the chances of addictive behaviors is significantly lowered.
- edejong 10y agoTL;DR 2: Using a continuous and meticulous data-driven approach, Iceland was able to positively exercise large-scale social change.
- akjainaj 10y agoWell, "large scale"... it's a culturally/racially homogeneous country of a little over 300k people. Whatever works there will probably not work anywhere else
- edejong 10y agoPlease edit for typos and grammar fixes. Don't change the content.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- obmelvin 10y agoThe exact solution may not work, but the overall approach to finding a solution very well could. I also somewhat disagree with the notion that systems working in smaller countries cannot work in larger or more diverse countries (esp. regarding free education the US). It may be really, really damn hard, but such is the price of advancement of society.
- akjainaj 10y agoI think "stopping substance abuse" and "free education" are very different problems. The first one is completely social, at least, while the second one has a strong economical component.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Gargoyle 10y agoThis article says there are only 49 places to buy alcohol in Iceland, which does seem like it could make it much easier to control. https://warontherocks.com/2015/09/your-guide-to-drinking-in-iceland/ https://warontherocks.com/2015/09/your-guide-to-drinking-in-...
- funnyfacts365 10y agoOh man. And then they drink 'till comma whenever they get out of the country, because alcohol it's so expensive in Iceland. How do I know? Married to an Icelandic woman, have seen my fair share of drunk Icelandic people when they come to Portugal on vacation, and do they get wasted...
- flukus 10y agoIt seems to scale too, when rich Saudis are on vacation...
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoIt's a very tiny country, population 300k.
- xiaoma 10y agoWhy does that matter? Does the size a country have much of an impact on how they deal with fat, sugar, caffeine or legal substances from a health standpoint? If not, then why would it affect illegal ones?
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoI would expect that the number of anything (including alcohol stores) would correlate with population size, no?
- mjolk 10y agoThat article is communicating a false impression -- 49 is not a very large number, but that's more then enough liquor stores ("vinbudins", similar in function to Sweden's "systembolagets") for a very small country. Additionally, that's just take-home liquor; Iceland has many bars and restaurants, as well as many places that sell low-alcohol beer.
- tristor 10y agoInteresting report. I wonder how they motivated kids to attend the after-school programs? It doesn't really talk about that extensively. At least for me, I used to attend an after-school program and a major motivator was being able to spend time doing things with girls I liked. The party scene at that time mostly was a proxy for the same thing. Giving teens a chance to socially and romantically interact outside of the structure of school might be all that's needed to get people to show up and participate. I pretty much agree with their conclusions though from my own personal experiences. The most trouble I've gotten into in my life, even as an adult, was out of boredom more than anything else.
- r00fus 10y agoI thought that's something that churches try to monopolize.
- tristor 10y agoWell, religion and the church have been successfully used for centuries to control people, provide a moral compass, and give teenagers and children a place to interact with each other outside of the rigors of daily life. So, yeah... Basically.
- r00fus 10y agoWell what I guess I'm saying is that this phenomena of having the government provide such places ... competes with a main focus of churches - and in the US, churches have large political power. I guess I don't see such a solution being feasible here for that reason.
- mahyarm 10y agoCould you find towns or regions of 300k in the USA with a similar lack of teen substance abuse too?
- tribby 10y agothis is an interesting question. without any data to back it up, my suspicion as an american is no, I would guess you'd have to look at much smaller towns to find an area like that.
- haser_au 10y agoFor kicks, I looked for one. I got as far as Anchorage, Alaska. In 2012, ~35% of "youth" have consumed alcohol in the past 30 days Research: http://justice.uaa.alaska.edu/research/2010/1010.voa/1010.04.youth_alcohol_access.update.pdf http://justice.uaa.alaska.edu/research/2010/1010.voa/1010.04... List of Cities: https://ballotpedia.org/Largest_cities_in_the_United_States_by_population https://ballotpedia.org/Largest_cities_in_the_United_States_...
- stillsut 10y agoBYU and the surrounding "culture" - no drugs, not even coffee!
- mundo 10y agoAll of the pessimism ("This only worked because Iceland is so small/white/etc, it would never work in the US") in this thread baffles me. Are there a lot of other wildly successful approaches we should try first? Did you not read the bits about the Icelandic approach working well in other cities? If anything, it sounds like the lesson here is that what worked so well is not just the approach, it's the implementation. (It's not like "build a sports facility" or "pass a curfew" or "encourage parents to spend more time with their kids" haven't been tried in the US) What I took home is that those same approaches which have had limited success when done on a small scale work a lot better when they're well-funded and taken seriously and used consistently for a long time.
- edblarney 10y agoSure, but Iceland is so very different from America in so many ways, that it's fair to point that out. Alcohol for example - there was never any taboo about drinking in Iceland. It was never seen as a justice issue before or after the program. Also - the communities as a whole were never failing. You had 'decent families', decent municipalities etc.. I'd imagine, in most of America where there is decent governance, decent jobs, good families: there is not a massive problem with smoking and alcohol. There might be issues with marijuana and hard drugs possibly, both of which represent a different kind of issue entirely. To me - the 'Iceland' solution seems pretty straightforward on the scale of 'social malaise' to deal with. 14 year olds getting drunk and smoking - just by 'cracking down' a little bit on under-age serving, liquor stores/cigarettes - changing a few laws, trying to change social norms - you'd likely be able to move the needle a bit. A more integrated social program would yield even better benefits as we see. But imagine an Aboriginal community trying to do the same thing: there is usually a lack of coherent leadership, lack of basic justice and trust in the justice system, lack of funds, and much deeper social problems (incidence of rape is through the roof, there's a lot of violence, suicide etc.), there's poverty, joblessness, and very few have any hope for the future. Now that puts alcohol abuse in a different category. If there were 'normal suburbs' in America with vicious underage drinking and smoking problems, I'd say Iceland provides a good solution. Outside of that, I think it's much more complex.
- 10y ago
- Analemma_ 10y agoOy, this thread. I've griped about this before - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12864151#12865128 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12864151#12865128 - we really need a snappy name for the "I know it works in every other country, but it can't possibly work in the US" argument-slash-fallacy. It's not inherently wrong and it can be true, but it's used so reflexively and across so many different domains (drug use, public transit, taxes, guns, health, voting, labor rights) that I have to think it's more of a thought-terminating-cliché to shut down any discussion of the topic than an honest attempt to find a solution. People just don't want to think about it, and it causes a ton of cognitive dissonance to see that a solution they politically dislike can work, so they jump to this.
- netsharc 10y agoYou can probably call it racism...
- Analemma_ 10y agoI figured my comment was inflammatory enough as is so I didn't mention it, but yes, that is probably part of it.
- markdown 10y ago> "I know it works in every other country, but it can't possibly work in the US" The 'murican bigness' argument.
- flukus 10y agoYou'd think there was only one level of government.
- 8421504 10y agoI imagine that family-centrism makes it much worse for the minority who have abusive narcissists for parents.
- _archon_ 10y agoThis is a problem in every society, and must be addressed in a different way. If the role of government is to provide its children with a fundamental understanding of themselves and how to manage their individual motivations, perhaps the resulting adults will be better equipped to rise above their parents' shortcomings? Strong family and team dynamics will pull how healthier people live into stronger contrast in such a situation.
- anotheryou 10y agoI'm so glad I had just 6 hours of school per day. While I did play in a music schools ensemble, I'm much more fond of the time I spent in bands and esembles away from schools hierarchy and with people I especially cared about. Same goes for doing art and programming founding a venture for concerts and so much more...
- prog_1 10y agoDoesn't anybody have a problem that the nature of their approach is first and foremost prohibition?
- _archon_ 10y agoIt would appear that the nature of their approach is first and foremost to ensure that any change they make is data-driven best practice for the situation at hand. In iceland, it included prohibition of purchase by minors and provision to minors by adults. More importantly, their changes created a situation where children were more likely to spend more of their time with adults who cared about them, in an active and engaged society. Curfews make me uncomfortable, but I can see that this encourages children to be in safe places overnight. Prohibition makes me uncomfortable, but it makes consumption more expensive and difficult, so child users will be less likely to become addicts. Widely available after-school classes and programs... have no downsides other than cost, which (it would seem) are clearly worth it. Where does best practice lie? If I were to start a civilization from scratch, I think I would use this model as a strong data point when organizing how education and the laws pertaining to youth were concerned. I have some more libertarian leanings than some of the implementations presented can accommodate, but perhaps if I were an Icelandic teen I would direct my frustrations on a hobby or class I picked up because my government mandated that I have access to it if I wanted to.