11 ms·
Snowden released a large volume of information to well qualified journalists who very carefully combed through the data to find the things most relevant and imp
by colechristensen 10y ago
Snowden released a large volume of information to well qualified journalists who very carefully combed through the data to find the things most relevant and important for the American public to know. Information that was legitimately classified and had no whistleblowing value simply wasn't released.
Manning released a large volume of information to the public en masse with no regard to it's whistleblowing value. Some of that information was dangerous and harmful.
Manning's battering ram is much different than Snowden's scalpel, even though their base motivations had a lot in common. Snowden knew what he was doing and did it with great care and consideration. Manning was suffering from some serious mental health issues and did something foolish with questionable value at best.
- mhurron 10y ago> Some of that information was dangerous and harmful. So dangerous and harmful that it harmed no one.
- y_u_no_rust 10y agoI don't know about that it added a lot of confusion and fueled a bit of the Arab spring and the offshoot situation in Libya not fully of course but and it's hard to quantify it also deeply damaged americas ability to respond to the events correctly
- criddell 10y agoDangerous and harmful to the US government?
- rbanffy 10y ago> Manning released a large volume of information to the public en masse No. She leaked the documents to Wikileaks, who decided to publish them uncensored. She had no control over what Wikileaks would do. Other media outlets opted not to release information they considered dangerous. And, as @mhurron pointed out, there is no record of someone who was harmed by that information being released.
- hendersoon 10y agoThere is no record of any individual being physically harmed, but the leaked diplomatic cables were highly embarrassing, hurt the interests of the US, and were completely unjustified. They weren't exposing malfeasance or war crimes. They should not have been released. Manning did it wrong, Snowden did it right.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Manning did it wrong, Snowden did it right. AFAIK, both Manning and Snowden released large quantities of information without reviewing all of it in detail for public interest vs. potential harm, and released it not to the public but to third parties that managed public release. The difference is that Manning released it to Assange and Snowden released it to more responsible journalists.
- hendersoon 10y agoYes, that is completely correct. Snowden released his information to journalists who carefully vetted each item for newsworthiness with the participation of the US government. Then that data was parceled out over many months, so it would remain in daily news cycles and continue to generate commentary over that time, staying in the public's mind. Manning gave her data to Wikileaks, who posted it online in its entirety.
- lern_too_spel 10y agoWhen did The Guardian or the South China Morning Post vet anything with the US government?
- stevehb 10y agoThe Guardian ran everything by the US government first before publishing. Every responsible journalist does. They're looking for a response or comment to the story, to make sure they didn't get anything wrong, and to see if there's a any reason to withhold details (a reason beyond "It's classified so don't"). In fact, in Greenwald's book No Place to Hide, he describes how they held off publishing for several days while waiting for a response from the government. Greenwald was so frustrated with the delays that he considered quitting the Guardian and going on his own. I think that's the idea that eventually turned into The Intercept.
- SCHiM 10y agoAlso the article states tat manning tried to approach the NYT and washington post, but was refused/ignored.
- nerfhammer 10y agoManning made some very haphazard attempts to contact journalists within the span of a day or two, seemed highly frustrated when she didn't get a response right away, and declared the matter impossible and gave up.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- RogueIMP 10y agoWell spoken, and spot on!
- 794CD01 10y ago>Snowden released a large volume of information to well qualified journalists who very carefully combed through the data to find the things most relevant and important for the American public to know. Information that was legitimately classified and had no whistleblowing value simply wasn't released. This is a poor defense of Snowden's actions. If it was given to a journalist who wasn't authorized to have that information, it was "released" in the only sense that is legally relevant, even if the general public doesn't have that information. Imagine saying what you just did, but replacing "journalist" with "KGB agent".
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hendersoon 10y agoIt's also untrue. Snowden leaked huge masses of data to those journalists. He didn't pick and choose what to give them beyond the most cursory of glances. The second half of your post seems to be arguing about the word "release" versus "leak". The former is a superset of the latter, both are accurate. Certainly nobody's saying what he did was legal.
- anon363764 10y agoIt's morally-consent now to offer Snowden an immunity deal in exchange for inventorying what was taken. Without meaningful whistleblower protections, the deep state remains deeply corrupted.
- hendersoon 10y agoI completely agree, but Snowden won't get a pardon for one simple reason-- it would look weak to do so. Commuting Manning's sentence is magnaminous. She endured 7 years of torture in solitary confinement, tried to suicide several times, and plead guilty in a court of law. Snowden GOT AWAY. And he went to Russia, where Putin granted asylum as a giant "screw you" to the US. So yes-- we do have a moral imperative to pardon Snowden, just as much as Manning. But we won't do it.
- panarky 10y agoToo much talk about motivations and conscience. Great evils are perpetrated through good intentions and lofty ideals. But it's clear to me that actions of both Snowden and Manning were moral but illegal. Regardless of motivation, they both exposed serious crimes. We are all better off because of the risks they took, and there was very little damage to offset the obvious benefits. The moral yet illegal is exactly what commutation is for. Kudos to Obama for exposing himself to vicious criticism to do the right thing.
- grandalf 10y agoNone of this matters. What matters is the crimes committed by US officials when they illegally classified much of the information in the first place. Of course Manning (or anyone who leaks) is likely to be an imperfect messenger. It's silly to focus on those details when there is a much bigger issue at stake. FWIW I wish all of the Snowden data would have been given to Wikileaks. I have great respect for Glenn Greenwald, but the government has utterly failed to respond to the leaks in an appropriate way, which suggests a great lack of respect for the rule of law and the American people. Instead, they pretended it hadn't happened and that no excesses occurred. I think several top level officials should have been removed and imprisoned and we should have seen footage of all the computers being carted out and put up for sale so that the money stolen to build the apparatus could be reimbursed to taxpayers.
- macspoofing 10y ago>Snowden released a large volume of information to well qualified journalists who very carefully combed through the data Snowden stole a huge amount of highly classified information and gave a tiny amount to journalists to comb through. Now we only have his word that none of it went to Russian intelligence though all signs point to the contrary.
- nfoz 10y agoWe have "only the word" of everyone with security clearance that they are not leaking secrets to foreign agents. You don't have to be physically present in Russia to provide the Russians with intelligence. I don't know why it makes any sense to assume that Snowden is leaking any more than what he gave to the journalists. His entire mission was out of loyalty to the American public, he did not intend to end up in Russia, and he wants to return to the US. America is keeping him out because they will not guarantee him a trial that meets his criteria of fairness/openness.
- macspoofing 10y ago>We have "only the word" of everyone with security clearance that they are not leaking secrets to foreign agents. Don't be dense. Those other agents didn't make off with 1.7 million highly classified files, flee to China and then arrange a defection to Russia with Russian officials. >I don't know why it makes any sense to assume that Snowden is leaking any more than what he gave to the journalists. Because he has stolen much much more than he gave to the journalists and the stolen data was much more extensive than domestic surveillance programs. >America is keeping him out because they will not guarantee him a trial that meets his criteria of fairness/openness. I'm sorry the law doesn't meet his criteria.
- Fnoord 10y agoHe went to Hong Kong. In parent we can see you conveniently call that China, but that isn't the same. Besides, we have his word, and two (or three) witnesses who saw him destroy the content of the SD card.
- willstrafach 10y ago> Information that was legitimately classified and had no whistleblowing value simply wasn't released. This is not true. Aside from the domestic surveillance disclosures which lead to reform in that area, most of the Snowden leaks do not appear to have any sort of whistleblowing value. Recent example of info release with no whistleblowing value: https://theintercept.com/2016/12/29/top-secret-snowden-document-reveals-what-the-nsa-knew-about-previous-russian-hacking/ https://theintercept.com/2016/12/29/top-secret-snowden-docum...
- mcv 10y agoI agree that Snowden did it about as well as you could possibly hope for a whistleblower exposing classified information. Manning meant well, but was naive and sloppy. Assange started out with good ideas, but seems to have gone mad with power after the Manning leaks. Still, some of the stuff that Manning and Assange leaked, did need to be exposed. It should have been handled more responsibly, but it still needed to be done.