10 ms·
Why was the Zimmerman Telegram so important?
- danieltillett 10y agoThe thing that most amazes me about the Great War is how so many fought and died to prevent the EU [1]. 1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Septemberprogramm https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Septemberprogramm Edit. It seems my brevity has caused some people to miss my point (or maybe not). I am lamenting the huge loss of life that flowed from the Great War that was fought trying to prevent the creation of the EU. On a personal note my great uncle died in the Great War and the effect this had on my family is still with with us to this day.
- emj 10y agoYour comment is short and slightly offensive, but sure there's some truth to that the diplomatic/economic European Union could have happend faster if people just hadn't warmongered so much. The people living there were, to put it midly worse off, but I'm sure the leaders thought it was a great idea to expand their culturaly influence just a little bit too far. But is unification really always the answer?
- danieltillett 10y agoThe history of Europe in the 20th C. is really the long march towards a EU with Germany at the heart. It is more than a shame that so many died to end up exactly where we would have been if the Schlieffen Plan had worked [1]. 1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schlieffen_Plan https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schlieffen_Plan
- tallanvor 10y agoRight... Except, of course, that the EU is a voluntary union rather than an attempt at conquest.
- danieltillett 10y agoI think you should ask the Greeks how voluntary the EU is these days. I am actually not opposed to the EU, I am just making the point of how little wars or personalities matter in the end.
- tallanvor 10y agoYour comment about Greece can easily be turned around: ask the British how voluntary the EU is.
- danieltillett 10y agoI think the British are about to find out. I am glad I am not British.
- ggame 10y agoI would not be supprised if Teresa May was placed in power with the express goal of fumbling the exit.
- moomin 10y agoHanlon's Razor applies here. (As does, since it's pretty clear our government doesn't know what they're doing, Occam's.)
- ggame 10y agoNot disagreeing... would the Peters principal also apply? Intentionally hired to be incompetent that would also imply malice? Those involved may have the best intentions, so no malice, and we're back to incompetence. Either way, if I were in charge and I needed someone to fumble it I would have picked her. That mail campaign asking people to self identify for deportation was the most anti Brexit thing I could imagine her doing.
- osullivj 10y agoAnother way of putting it: German history since 1870 is series of attempts to recreate the Holy Roman Empire. Bismarck & the Kaiser's Second Reich, Hitler's Third Reich, and now the Merkel led EU imposing the ECB facilitated Eurozone diktat. To paraphrase von Clausewitz: finance is the continuation of politics by other means. Hence Merkel's ability to remove uncooperative heads of govt in Italy & Greece in recent years.
- cstross 10y agoIf the Schlieffen Plan had worked, the Germany that emerged victorious would be unrecognizable — an authoritarian monarchy with a rubber-stamp house of representatives that had demonstrated decisively that militaristic aggression got results. There would still — probably — have been a round two in the 1930s or 1940s; WW1 was in some respects a revenge fight for the Franco-Prussian war of 1870-71. But without the gridlock of the western front to force the hothouse development of new weapons and tactics, the military tools of that second conflict would be much closer to those of our actually-existing WW1; that is, I don't believe we'd have ultimately avoided the bloodbathe of trench warfare — we'd just have postponed it (and retarded the development of civil aviation as an accidental side-effect). The real question is whether the ancien regime would have survived (no collapse of the monarchies; the Hapsburg, Wilhelmine and Romanov dynasties survive into the second half of the 20th century, and those guys called Lenin and Trotsky and Hitler are just fringe radicals) and if so, what the consequences would have been further down the line. One thing's for sure: no European Convention on Human Rights! (Source: lots of speculation here, but I'm an SF author with a track record in alternate history and this stuff is meat and drink ...)
- danieltillett 10y agoWhile I agree with you that that this is a really interesting topic to think about, I don't agree that Germany (Prussia really) would have remained an authoritarian monarchy with a rubber-stamp democracy. There was already a cultural shift before the Great War towards greater democracy and human rights - the war can be seen as the last gasp of the dying monarchies to hold onto power in the face of this movement. We also would not have had the singular individual who was Hitler and all the damage he did. I think we would have ended up with something very close to a full intergrated EU economically dominated by Germany with a few internal borders shifted around and a declining U.K. outside the EU.
- cstross 10y agoI suspect a declining UK facing a continental hegemonic superpower — anathema to British foreign policy going back half a millennium or more — would not have gone down quietly. And with an overseas empire behind it, the result could well have been an even more ruinous escalation of the Dreadnought Race of the 1900s, possibly leading to a full-blown naval war and/or British attempts to overturn the post-Schlieffen War settlement. Whatever, it would have been messy — very messy. (However, the move towards social democracy in Germany was a thing pre-war, and if anything it was the capitulation to nationalism of the moderate left that opened the door to the radical left and communist fringe across Europe; it's interesting to speculate where things might have ended up if the standard bearer for hardline socialism had been someone like Rosa Luxemburg rather than Vladimir Lenin.)
- aaron-lebo 10y agoWarfare is much more economic in nature these days. One of the reasons we don't go to war as much is because if you have the economic clout it's much easier to dominate nations and less destructive to boot. The EU is a remarkable construct, and obviously in its roots has the desire to prevent conflict. At the same time, there's plenty of parties that can use that same construct (and have) to dominate in other ways. If you are an unscrupulous German leader of industry, the ability and desire to gain more power is not so different from Krupp or other German businesses serving the Nazis. They are different in kind and end results, yes, and this economic warfare is kinder and more acceptable to peace. At the core, though is domination. The OP's comment is offensive because it is so short, but he's right in that Germany dominates the EU, for good and bad.
- ggame 10y agoWarefare has always been largely economic. It's what you are fighting for, it's how you win. See Sun Tzus Art of War for an early example of military focus. Because of the well known destructive nature of war; more wars have been fought to prevent future wars than have not. E.g. The war to end all wars (WWI) The EU was intended to cause the economic and political crisis we are seeing. A shared currency among such different exonomies is fatally flawed and requires a superstate solution - which was actual goal. Citizens would not knowingly vote for this, but as democracy in Europe is seen as a war risk, it is considered proper to suppress it. Of course this effort to prevent future wars will inevitably lead to a future war. Thus, I consider the break up of the EU as the only path to preventing war. Either way we're entering interesting times.
- pjc50 10y ago> but as democracy in Europe is seen as a war risk This is conspiracy-theory garbage.
- jessaustin 10y agoThis is the second time in this thread you've dismissed others' arguments in abrupt emotional fashion. Please let us see your work.
- ggame 10y agoI second your statement. The EU is another attempt at a global power structure that has been going on since people were people. It's most recognizably German, and once the realities of governing a superstate are take into account, this was how I imagine a post WWI German victory to look.
- pjc50 10y agoThis is highly offensive and will no doubt be flagged off HN soon. The EU as it presently stands is extremely different to the empires of the early 20th century. Declaring that people who fought in the Great War were fighting to "prevent" something completely different that came 50 years later is highly offensive to their memory.
- danieltillett 10y agoRather than being offended about a historical statement, what were the German war aims in 1914? Why did the British Empire enter the war? The British didn't die in their millions to defend the neutrality of the Belgians.
- WildUtah 10y agoWhy the EU was necessary: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=37iHSwA1SwE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=37iHSwA1SwE To divide and disunite Europe and make a complete pig's breakfast of the continent.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- aaron-lebo 10y agoInteresting article, though the answer in the title seems pretty obvious: Germany was offering a previously hostile neighbor of the US land as long as they'd enter the war. No matter whether that was transmitted in secret, in the open, or through diplomatic channels, that's virtually a declaration of war. Even without unrestrained submarine warfare, that alone might have been enough to bring the US into the war in 1915. It took some restraint from Wilson to prevent an earlier entry, anyway.
- mafribe 10y agovirtually a declaration of war. Have you reflected properly on why Germany felt a need to defend itself against the US?
- jessaustin 10y agoSilly Germans. Don't go to war with opponents you can't beat without closing down all international trade. Because you can't actually close down all international trade. USA's external actions in that time frame were much more defensible than they have been since then.
- chiph 10y agoBecause they were already in a stalemate with France, the UK, and Russia. And their allies the Austro-Hungarian Empire were more concerned with Serbia and Italy than France, etc. So this was a move intended to counter the US should we enter the war ("give them something besides Germany to worry about" was likely the thinking)
- ap3 10y agoThey basically needed a WW2 Japan in WW1
- mikeash 10y agoWhat's your theory for a reason that absolves this? Or did I misunderstand your implication?
- bainsfather 10y agoCode interception and breaking. Cutting undersea cables. Parallel construction. Carefully managed release to manipulate public opinion. It's nice to have an inside view on an intelligence coup - albeit from 100 years ago.
- dx034 10y agoIt somehow shows that what we see at the moment isn't new at all. Yes, there is a different scale of information gathering, but that's just because there's more information flowing. 100 years ago it was very hard to communicate over a distance without traffic being intercepted, and the same is true today. That doesn't mean that we shouldn't try to make communication more secure, but it indicates that we are not heading towards an ever worse surveillance state.
- sametmax 10y agoI find it scary. If they could do that 100 hundred years ago, what are they doing now with the added century of experience and the new tech ?
- pif 10y agoI find it reassuring. If we could do that 100 hundred years ago, what are we doing now with the added century of experience and the new tech?
- sametmax 10y agoThe benefit of experience and tech is diluted among the public, but concentrated in corporations and govs. The will and ability to use and understand them even more.
- bainsfather 10y agoI agree with all of that, apart from your last conclusion. The British intelligence service was, it appears, acting logically given its motivations and capabilities. It achieved the outcome it wanted. Note that the motivations do not always align with what is good for Britain (nor, rather obviously, other countries) - see e.g. Iraq intelligence. From what is visible (e.g. Snowden data), GCHQ continues to do the same thing. But it has vastly greater capabilities, both in collection and analysis. This means we have been heading towards an ever more capable/powerful surveillance state.
- noir-york 10y agoThanks for posting this! That knowledge is power is not in doubt. We in the West would be fools to hamstring our own intelligence services in their mission to defend national security. Is privacy important - absolutely - but the correct mechanism to protect not just privacy but against abuse is not to reduce the agencies intel capabilities but strengthen our democratic means of oversight.