5 ms·
If this tickles your fancy, you should check out "Adventure of English" and the eponymous BBC documentary. https://www.amazon.com/Adventure-English-Biography-L
by adamnemecek 10y ago
If this tickles your fancy, you should check out "Adventure of English" and the eponymous BBC documentary.
https://www.amazon.com/Adventure-English-Biography-Language/dp/1611450071/ref=as_li_ss_tl?sa-no-redirect=1&linkCode=ll1&tag=akhn-20&linkId=751fd57f001259dfcc7bdd02c67406be https://www.amazon.com/Adventure-English-Biography-Language/...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ihoYL-dUK1g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ihoYL-dUK1g
Did you know that just about every English word that contains the letter combination "sk" is from Old Norse? Skin, sky, ski, skill, skid, skull, skip, skirt etc. Skim isn't though.
Until reading this book I never truly realized what sort of a Frankenlanguage English really is.
- pluma 10y ago> from Old Norse Isn't that just a fancy way to say they're from Old English (Anglo-Saxon/Englisc)? This shouldn't be too surprising considering the other main influence of the English language was Old French and the letter combination "sk" is far more common in Nordic languages than in French.
- adamnemecek 10y agoThis is what wikipedia has to say on the topic "In addition, numerous common, everyday Old Norse words were adopted into the Old English language during the Viking age." I think I understand what you are hinting at but regardless, I'm leaning towards no, it's not just a fancy way of saying that.
- kagamine 10y agoIs that what wikipædia has to say? I am fluent in Norwegian but moved to Norway as an adult from the UK and I still struggle with the words for shirt and skirt which are skjørt and skjorte, the sk is more of a sh sound, but the vowel in the middle I still cannot get right, those øs just don't fly with my accent. Interestingly, in Scotland a lot more 'Norse' persists than in English with typical examples including kirk for church, pronounced shirk in Norwegian, and bairns for child much like barn in Norwegian. Other examples I can think of, not just in Scots but in English too, include tor for tower which is tårn in Scandiland (Google translate doesn't recognize tor as an English language word, even though it is used to describe towers all across the UK).
- pascalmemories 10y agoPart of the reason I love watching Scandinavian TV is to listen for snippets that sound just like Scottish-variant English (Scots is something else and neither are to be confused with Scotch). To my ear the snippets even sound like they're said in a Scottish accent and emphasizes that there's no such thing as a 'pure' language as they all have elements of others which have migrated in. I would be interested to see if there was a correlation between the linguistic mix and the DNA origins of these populations - perhaps a cool hypothesis/experiment for someone.
- tyfon 10y agoThere is actually quite a debate around this now. Modern english is much closer to "scandinavian" than old english in sentence construction, so the new thesis is that old english words were adopted by the norse rulers into the norse/scandinavian language. It has later been "perverted" by the french ;) However I do not think this theory would fly in England even if the logic is sound due to nationalistic pride. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/11/121127094111.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/11/121127094111.h...
- jacobush 10y agoSounds strange to me that Danish rulers would import back sentence construction with such gusto all the way back to eastern Sweden? Is it not more likely the Danish sentence construction filtered down into common English with time?
- tyfon 10y agoI am a bit stuffed today due to a cold, what I tried to explain is that there is no "Old English" in modern english. It was wiped out during danelaw and replaced with scandinavian. They did however adopt local "Old English" words into scandinavian and eventually it evolved to modern english. Scandinavian languages did not change due to this. Read the article, they explain it much better than me ;)
- jacobush 10y agoNow that makes sense.
- arnsholt 10y ago> However I do not think this theory would fly in England even if the logic is sound due to nationalistic pride. Also, most linguists who are experts in the history of English (Faarlund is an expert on Norse, not English) tend to border on the dismissive when considering Faarlund's theory of English as Norse dialect.
- Svip 10y agoThe Anglo-Saxons lived in England before the Vikings arrived. So no, they are two distinct languages. The Angles and the Saxons came from Northern Germany, long before the Vikings decided to invade. The Viking invasion was significant, heavily influencing English society and language. Many old towns in England still have the old Norse town ending -by. Effectively, there are three main sources for English: * The Anglo-Saxons, arriving around the time where the Romans left. * The Vikings, arriving around 800-1000. * The Normans, arriving around 1066. Not that English haven't changed significantly since then, but these three periods represent the largest number of words increases. The other changes have primarily been spelling.
- jacobush 10y agoAlso remember the Normands spoke not only French but some kind of Norse. Still in Normandy there are Norse/Scandinavian names for places. Besides, Saxon and Norse languages must've been pretty mutually intelligible, even today German and Swedish is pretty similar even with a millennium or two apart.
- stan_rogers 10y agoThere were a lot of cognate words and similar grammar, but genders and inflectional endings didn't match well at all. That drove the dramatic simplification of English grammar, for the most part. As for the Norman influence, it was mostly vocabulary... but changing the languages of documentation to Latin (mostly) and French (in law, for the most part) left English a lot of room to progress away from the Old English that was, by that time, already playing the same sort of role that Latin did in the Early Romance period - it no longer reflected the language that people lived in.
- jacobush 10y agoHaha, so Saxon and Norse cancelled each others' grammar out? :)
- theandrewbailey 10y ago> There were a lot of cognate words and similar grammar, but genders and inflectional endings didn't match well at all. That drove the dramatic simplification of English grammar, for the most part. It's why English nouns lost their masculine and feminine grammatical gender. The people who used both languages had more important things to worry about.
- stan_rogers 10y agoNo. For instance, shirt is from Old English, while its cognate skirt is from Old Norse. We gained quite a bit of vocabulary from the Danelaw, and lost a lot of the grammatical complexity (gender and inflection) at the same time. Apart from vocabulary, French barely touched the English language; it was the Vikings that messed things up terribly by settling in with the common folk up north.
- jacobush 10y agoAnd many "french" were from Normandy i.e. barely reformed Norse. Just look at the name "nor man dy".
- mnw21cam 10y ago> Until reading this book I never truly realized what sort of a Frankenlanguage English really is. "The problem with defending the purity of the English language is that English is about as pure as a cribhouse whore. We don't just borrow words; on occasion, English has pursued other languages down alleyways to beat them unconscious and riffle their pockets for new vocabulary." - James Nicoll https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Nicoll https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Nicoll
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- DonaldFisk 10y agoIf it wasn't, it might look like this: https://msburkeenglish.files.wordpress.com/2010/04/uncleftish-beholding-aka-atomic-theory.pdf https://msburkeenglish.files.wordpress.com/2010/04/uncleftis... Other "Frankenlanguages" include Japanese, Tagalog, and Maltese.
- jdmichal 10y agoNote that this wouldn't remove Norse influences, since Norse is also Germanic.
- kagamine 10y agoHalf of those words make no sense in modern Norwegian. A run through of the list and their approximate pronunciations in English would be: Skin: shin never heard this said, GooTranslate gives "full" but "full" is "hel" in Norwegian sky: she meaning sky (the vast expanse above your head) ski: shee meaning ski like a plank of wood strapped to you foot for travelling on snow. skill: sheeel to divide or separate. Bears no relation to English that I know of. skid: sheed not a word I know in Norwgian skull: shool again, not a word I know in Norwegian, the word for skull is 'hode' skip: ship a thing that floats and is bigger than a boat. skirt: sheert not a word, but probably from skjørt meaning the same.
- admax88q 10y ago> sky: she > ski: shee > skill: sheeel For a moment there I hoped you were just going to keep adding e's to as you went down the list.
- kagamine 10y agoIt's quite hard for me to get across the slightly differing sounds as it'snot my native tongue. That is why I used "approximation" in my comment, but yes it does seem like an ever lengthening ee sound. The rule is that if the vowel is followed by a double consonant it's a short vowel, single consonant means long vowel, so bil = beel and bill = beeel. But as a non-native it can be very hard to distinguish during a conversation and I am often misunderstood. In fact, I'm not even sure I have the rule the right way around :(
- tallanvor 10y agoWell, couldn't you use skalle for skull? Or hodeskalle? I'm not a native speaker, but my understanding is that hode is more general than the skull.
- kagamine 10y agoHa, yesterday I even saw a sign over a low door upon which was written "skall skall ikke". So yes, you are correct with skalle. I have a terrible memory.
- amyjess 10y ago> Did you know that just about every English word that contains the letter combination "sk" is from Old Norse? Skin, sky, ski, skill, skid, skull, skip, skirt etc. Also, skirt and shirt are doublets. Skirt comes from Old Norse, and shirt is native English, and they both come from the same Proto-Germanic root.
- mason240 10y agoThere is a great podcast you might like on the subject: The History of English Podcast https://history-podcasts.com/history-of-english-language-podcast https://history-podcasts.com/history-of-english-language-pod...