5 ms·
“Last-Place Aversion”: Evidence and Redistributive Implications
- marchenko 10y agopapers like this indicate that the public discussion of economics should not treat social concerns like status-consciousness and envy as insignificant outliers to rational self interest
- mlinksva 10y agoNon-paywalled copy http://www.hbs.edu/faculty/Publication%20Files/The%20Quarterly%20Journal%20of%20Economics-2014-Kuziemko-105-49(2)_20215a4d-e73b-48e9-8de7-f6862054e552.pdf http://www.hbs.edu/faculty/Publication%20Files/The%20Quarter...
- mlinksva 10y agoI've only skimmed, but it seems the redistributive implications are that people who think they are close to but above last place are less likely to support redistribution which could raise the level of those in last place. They don't mention possibility, but I suppose something to further research is whether redistribution which compresses but may not change ordering (eg everyone gets same amount or discount through goods available to all, basic income, monopoly busting) suffers from the same lack of support from those near last place. Another implication of last-place aversion not mentioned could include lower class support for oppression of outgroups.
- trhway 10y agoas the saying has it - when running away from a bear one doesn't have to run fastest, only to run faster than the slowest in the group. Any improvement to the position of the "slowest" would mean principal/total change for such second-to-last, and thus is feared and opposed. Brexit, 2016 US elections, whole Russian domestic politics - just a few among recent/current examples driven by such a fear.
- whack 10y agoThe part that I found most interesting: "Last-place aversion suggests that low-income individuals might oppose redistribution because it could differentially help the group just beneath them. Using survey data, we show that individuals making just above the minimum wage are the most likely to oppose its increase. Similarly, in the General Social Survey, those above poverty but below median-income support redistribution significantly less than their background characteristics would predict." Sounds exactly like the Republican playbook for winning rural below-median-income voters. Bring up the "welfare queen moochers" bugbear as often as you can, and paint them as the primary beneficiaries of the social safety net.
- keithpeter 10y agoReminded me of 'differentials' when I was a spectator in wage negotiations decades ago. Deals would get difficult if the smallest change to the differences between a labourer and a very semi-skilled occupation.
- ars 10y agoI read it quite differently. This is economically logical for them: By keeping minimum wage low[er] they can afford things made by those earning less than them. If minimum wage went up, their wage is unlikely to go up as well, but their costs would go up, so their effective income will be lower. > Sounds exactly like the Republican playbook Instead of insulting those you disagree with, how about understanding them instead?
- whack 10y ago> This is economically logical for them: By keeping minimum wage low[er] they can afford things made by those earning less than them. The study is based on lab psychology experiments, where none of the economic effects you mentioned exist. Participants choose gambles with the potential to move them out of last place that they reject when randomly placed in other parts of the distribution. In modified-dictator games, participants randomly placed in second-to-last place are the most likely to give money to the person one rank above them instead of the person one rank below. Last-place aversion suggests that low-income individuals might oppose redistribution because it could differentially help the group just beneath them. All of the above suggests/demonstrates that people near the bottom, have a psychological aversion to policies that would help those at the bottom, regardless of rational-self-interest. Also, there's nothing insulting in pointing out the connection between this study's conclusions, and Republican political-strategy/voter-behavior. If you think this behavior is perfectly logical and rational, I don't see why you would consider this connection to be insulting in the first place.
- oh_sigh 10y agoI had a surprising conversation with a Chinese H1B holder at my job. Her argument against Trump was that, if Trump kicks out all of the illegal immigrants in the US, then legal immigrants with mediocre English and non-white skin will become the new low people on the totem pole, making her life harder.
- NPMaxwell 10y agoThis is part of why I have hope for basic income. Everyone is lifted the same amount. People who got ahead by keeping their nose clean and working hard are still ahead.
- capitalsigma 10y agoYou think wages wouldn't go down to compensate? Especially minimum wage jobs?
- jasonmp85 10y agoPeople in minimum wage jobs are _already_ being subsidized by the government. Walmart holds training sessions for new employees to help them apply for food stamps, Medicaid, and public housing. The slack is either picked up by public debt or private debt and the lower the minimum wage is, the more business get to skate by on the largesse of the federal government. So, no, minimum wage jobs wouldn't go down (they couldn't at any rate, without concomitant changes in law), and it's entirely possible the federal burden would be _lower_.
- noonespecial 10y agoI think that they would not necessarily go down. They might go up. If much of the working poor no longer had to desperately work multiple Mcjobs just to feed their kids they might take fewer of them (especially the particularly miserable ones) and spend more time at home. Employers would be forced to pay more and make working conditions better just to get those positions filled. Basic minimum income is loaded with unknowns. There really is no way to know the ultimate results without trying it. Lots of us are starting to think it's worth a try. We've tried worse.
- NPMaxwell 10y agoYou mean near-minimum-wage jobs: would employers lower pay for near-minimum-wage jobs to minimum, because employees would be willing to take the pay cut since it is balanced by the basic income? That's a good question with an empirical answer: What happened in Alaska when the pipeline payments started? I'm sorry I don't know. I'm also not sure how a drop in near-minimum-wage pay plus the basic income would feel to workers in those near-minimum-wage jobs.