11 ms·
Silicon Valley Takes a Right Turn
- mst 10y agoAugh. URL in /opinion/ fails to consider that you're going to donate more money to the people winning because you get more influence per dollar that way, decides to blame "tech has decided the republicans are more in line with their interests". Well, yes, in so far as "their interests" involve actually getting things done rather than blaming everybody else for not doing. Can I have a new left wing please? This one appears to be broken :(
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoWe aren't going to "get" a new left wing anytime soon. The neoliberal turn that most left-wing parties took was a direct result of the collapse of social democracy and citizen involvement in he 1970s, which resulted in the neoliberal market politics commonly attributed to Bill Clinton and Tony Blair. If you want a new left wing, make it happen. Join a local board. Run for local office. Take part in your community. Be a part of something. But don't expect reading news or commenting on forums to change anything. After all, the shift from active citizen to passive consumer is what got us in this mess in the first place. Adam Curtis has several phenominal documentaries regarding this shift over time. Particularly, "Century of the Self", "The Trap", and most recently, "HyperNormalization."
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>The neoliberal turn that most left-wing parties took was a direct result of the collapse of social democracy and citizen involvement in he 1970s, which resulted in the neoliberal market politics commonly attributed to Bill Clinton and Tony Blair. Oh come on. We all know that's not true. The citizens didn't turn neoliberal or particularly apathetic; the politicians did under the advice of economists who pushed neoliberalism as the solution to the oil crisis. >If you want a new left wing, make it happen. Join a local board. Run for local office. Take part in your community. Be a part of something. But don't expect reading news or commenting on forums to change anything. This I can agree with! Not just that, but provide names of organizations pushing a more "Old Left", social-democratic agenda. I belong to the first two of these as a dues-paying member and a volunteer, and we've been gaining hundreds of new members since the election. It's honestly like waking up from a bad dream: all of a sudden, the bread-and-butter issues (wages, housing, health-care, civil liberties) matter again, and the culture wars are getting sidelined. * Democratic Socialists of America * Our Revolution (started by Bernie Sanders) * Socialist Alternative (more "party-line", worse at returning people's calls) * The Berniecrats Network * /r/Berniecrats and facebook/Berniecrats * Jacobin magazine and its associated reading groups For those looking for a more decent right-wing as well, I recommend Reason magazine, the Washington Monthly (especially this one, it's a hidden gem of a magazine), the Libertarian Party, the works of Henry George, and GK Chesterton's "distributivism".
- chillwaves 10y agoSocialist Alternative seems like an overall self-defeating org (due to ideological purity) and powerless outside of the Seattle area and a few other metropolitan hubs (speaking as a former member). I find Our Revolution and former Bernie organizers to be the most practical and promising group for affecting change.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoI'm a dual-listed DSA and Our Revolution member, and I can kinda agree with that. My personal politics are left enough for DSA, and it is a multi-tendency organization that's willing to include ideological social democrats. But if you don't have enough detailed political education to say, "I'm a social democrat or a socialist and I know why", but instead just think, "Inequality is too much, there are too many people homeless, hungry, or without health-care for such a rich country, and I wish the politicians would respond better", you should maybe stick with Our Revolution. I also definitely have a bone to pick with the people claiming we're gonna totally obtain third-party electoral successes Real Soon Now. Yes, the Democratic Party has been rubbish to us. It has been the "graveyard of social movements". But we've also run a hell of a lot of social movements (like Occupy Wall Street, for instance) that had a whole ton of radical spirit, chic, and ideology, but had zero power analysis and zero affirmative program. Our Revolution and Bernie's rejuvenation of social democracy through taking over the Democratic Party, while it's lost its back-bench, from the bottom up, does actually promise a strategy for obtaining real power that's suited to our historical moment. Just my thoughts. Don't mind me. I'm no longer sober.
- 464192002d7fe1c 10y ago> Can I have a new left wing please? This one appears to be broken :( I've been saying this since basically after Obama was elected. I was a HUGE supporter of his, even in the democratic primaries. I donated to him, I was running local groups that were canvassing and phone banking to get him elected. I was ecstatic when he got elected (though I viewed it as a foregone conclusion, I didn't think McCain had a chance). When it came to the governing, I was not really impressed. Basically from day 1, everything seemed stuck. He got a few things done (ACA though that's of dubious benefit, and was done in such a way that it became a political punching bag and can't get any reforms), but mostly in the first two years. After the 2010 midterms, this shit was just complete gridlock. You can blame whomever you want for the gridlock but a good leader builds compromise and ends gridlock. I think there are two good examples of this. First, after sandy hook Obama promised that he would pass gun control legislation. Now, I do not agree with lots of things that he would like to do with such legislation, but, I do agree that there are some changes required. He has basically failed to pass any legislation around gun control and his response to that isn't to propose new legislation that can pass congress. His reaction was to go on national television and cry (literally) about his failure to pass gun control legislation. I'm sorry, I don't want a damn leader who CRYS about their political failures. I know dead children is a sad subject, but, this is ultimately a political failure. The 2nd one is Guantanamo. When he was campaigning one of his promises was to close Guantanamo, bring prisoners home and try them for their crimes. After 8 years, that has not happened and its become so politically untenable that he's basically letting these people out, without trying them at all. It is a mind-boggling Withdrawing from Iraq/Afghanistan was another campaign promise that I was personally invested in too, but that is a far more complex one and though he doesn't get a pass from me on that as I have personal losses there, I acknowledge that its more complex. I do not agree with lots of things that (old) republicans did (though I am hopeful about the new republican party of today), but they get shit done. They wanted to block (stupid) gun control legislation, they did. They wanted to block returning Guantanamo prisoners to the USA, they did. Sometimes doing something, even if its not perfect, is more important than doing nothing, especially when you don't have a crystal ball and don't know what exact result specific actions/legislation will have. Move fast, break shit.
- bojl 10y ago
- brighteyes 10y ago> Augh. URL in /opinion/ fails to consider that you're going to donate more money to the people winning because you get more influence per dollar that way, decides to blame "tech has decided the republicans are more in line with their interests". The article provided many more things in support of its point, such as * Surveys with startup founders on their politics. * In-depth analysis of both PAC donations - which your criticism might apply to - and individual donations - which it does not. * In-depth analysis of the changes that typically happen to a company like Amazon or Google that begins as an innovator and ends up being one of the biggest corporations, and threatened by things like antitrust, which naturally lead it to favor Republican positions on those issues.
- rampage101 10y agoGood to see most of the CEOs have come to their senses and are going to put the business before their political beliefs.
- ryandamm 10y agoPersonally, I don't think that's "good." I remember fondly Tim Cook's response to an activist investor about why they support environmentally sound policies: "When we work on making our devices accessible by the blind, I don’t consider the bloody ROI,” Cook said, adding that the same sentiment applied to environmental and health and safety issues. [1] Personally, I think there's a higher system of value than corporate profits and share price. But that's a first principle argument. Conveniently, I happen to believe that purely shareholder-value-maximizing behavior rarely fails to build long term value, so I'm having my philosophical cake and eating it, too. But when push comes to shove, we do things for reasons beyond profit. It's pretty hollow otherwise. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2014/mar/03/tim-cook-climate-change-sceptics-ditch-apple-shares https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2014/mar/03/tim-cook...
- rampage101 10y agoYea, maybe we can get more guys to go full retard like the GrubHub CEO lol... You got to be delusional to think Apple is helping the environment.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y ago> full retard Stop that.
- ryandamm 10y ago> You got to be delusional to think Please stop that, too. It's not an argument.
- RandomOpinion 10y agoNot to rain on your worldview or anything but I must point out that one of the requirements for being in upper management that's public facing is the ability to say just about anything with a straight face. ("Courage" anyone?) The fact that Tim Cook came up with a good (from a PR perspective) response doesn't say anything about the actual motivation.
- home_boi 10y agoPAC: A political action committee (PAC) is a type of organization that pools campaign contributions from members and donates those funds to campaign for or against candidates, ballot initiatives, or legislation Tech companies have been annoyingly left for a very long time. I'd like to see more parity. It becomes annoying to have people make questionable political statements (especially HR) and not have the ability to speak up without being called names.
- ryandamm 10y agoOddly enough, it's on tech-oriented sites like this one that I hear the most chatter about universal basic income or post-work societies, and grappling with the very disruptions of the social fabric that tech development creates. Perhaps this shift is partly a seismic realignment; traditional left-right divides don't fit as comfortably as they used to, as issues move faster than constituencies and demographics. Or maybe just corporations, like people, get more conservative when they're richer. Possibly out of cynical self-interest.
- cderwin 10y ago> Or maybe just corporations, like people, get more conservative when they're richer. Possibly out of cynical self-interest. In the case of people, this is a popular misconception. Democrats are funded by more billionaires than Republicans, are in control of a majority of the wealthiest congressional districts, and among people earning more than $200,000 the presidential vote was very evenly split. http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/article/2014/jun/23/do-many-billionaires-support-democratic-party/ http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/article/2014/jun/23/... https://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/07/opinion/how-did-the-democrats-become-favorites-of-the-rich.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/07/opinion/how-did-the-democ... http://ijr.com/2014/02/116056-wall-street-bankers-top-donors-agree-democrat-party-new-party-rich/ http://ijr.com/2014/02/116056-wall-street-bankers-top-donors... http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/11/08/us/elections/exit-poll-analysis.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/11/08/us/elections/e...
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoDemocrat versus Republican makes more sense as urban versus nonurban than anything else.
- ryandamm 10y agoVery true (and parent makes a really good point, also). I do wonder: rather than a single axis, how many would be appropriate? If you did PCA on... well, some crazy mishmash of factors -- demographic, political, socioeconomic, geographic -- what would be the eigenvalues of today's US politics? (And what's the minimum sensible number of values to capture the range of experience?) Man, I can just hear my cofounder exhaling in frustration, at such an ill-posed problem, and abuse of terminology... and no doubt there are real, quantitative answers to some of this (and PCA is probably naive compared to... latest whiz-bang etc)... But still.
- pipio21 10y agohttps://fivethirtyeight.com/features/nearly-all-of-silicon-valleys-political-dollars-are-going-to-hillary-clinton/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/nearly-all-of-silicon-v... http://www.businessinsider.com/silicon-valley-donors-favor-hillary-clinton-over-trump-2016-11 http://www.businessinsider.com/silicon-valley-donors-favor-h... Here is what Paul Graham and Sam Altman had donated to: https://blog.dcpos.ch/silicon-valley-political-contributions https://blog.dcpos.ch/silicon-valley-political-contributions
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- skwirl 10y agoThe NY Times article says up front that tech companies donations in the Presidential race went overwhelmingly to Clinton. It's the House and Senate races where the rightward shift has occurred.
- earthly10x 10y agoWell, we experienced a black swan event and maybe even the first shoe to drop. Some of us are just capitalists and capitalists are able to do this: - Adapt. Even though it seems like we're all in a boat thats capsized and the stove is above your head along with the sing while the cups are floating in the water and in the dark, there's now new opportunity across the board. - Make an observation on a "product" and then take that "product" off the table of a competitor and do it better. These are the rules. In 2020 the "product" could be this new incoming administration.
- _yosefk 10y agoBrendan Eich's donation of $1000 in support of Prop 8 ended his career at Mozilla, making a tech employee donating to Trump an obvious potential career-ending move. It's not very surprising that they didn't. An interesting question is whether their family members donated to Trump what was actually the tech employee's money.
- cderwin 10y agoPart of me wonders if the whole deal with Brendan Eich is a problem with tech or a problem with California. Would the same thing have happened if Mozilla operated out of New York or Seattle (let alone Denver or Austin)? And if not, at what point do the particular nuances of SV (such as political intolerance) become a burden not worth tolerating within the tech community?
- guildwriter 10y agoI can't speak to other states in the nation, but I don't think this is a problem that is isolated to tech specifically within CA. One of the things I learned from my time in an ultra-liberal high school in the Bay Area was to keep my mouth shut and my head down if I had a differing opinion. To set the background, my high school invited prominent speakers from time to time to speak about various issues. Not a single conservative voice ever came to talk to us. When the case for the Iraq War was being debated in public, the school invited a panel of speakers to debate the topic in front of us. They didn't invite a single person in favor of the War. When they invited Daniel Ellsberg to speak, he went into a long profanity punctuated rant about GWB which ended with the entire auditorium (including all the teachers and administrators) standing on their feet to applaud him for minutes. This is just a small sampling. It was around that time that I began to realize how bad the indoctrination was and started reading other points of view. When I began expressing those views to share what I had learned, I started getting a lot of funny looks or outright hostility. I remember as a member of student government, I was part of a meeting to discuss changing or adding anything to the student handbook. I mentioned that rather than a focus on racial diversity, that perhaps we should readjust the focus to include a diversity of views as well. The dismissive reaction from everyone including the chairman of the school cemented in my mind where everyone truly stood. It is hard to express how frustrating it is to be surrounded by people who claim to be inclusive and open minded, yet are utterly unwilling to seriously entertain any point of view that comes in conflict with theirs. The totality of their certainty and the violence with which they express it is right on par with the kind of fanaticism you see in deeply Christian communities.
- suryacom 10y agoI'm an H1-B visa holder living and working in USA for past 10+ years. I cannot express how much happier I'm to see the Tech industry being on the wrong side of the presidential election. The out going administration had sold us (and indirectly hurting American workers) with the "Indentured servitude rules" to benefit the Tech companies and immigration attorneys. Here is an example, where every year, tens of thousands of legal immigrant kids getting deported because legal immigrants followed all the laws. Instead if we had not, and our kids were in illegal status, then Obama administration's DACA would have saved our kids. Just read the 1st two paragraph of this article: https://www.cato.org/blog/congress-should-help-young-legal-immigrant-dreamers-too https://www.cato.org/blog/congress-should-help-young-legal-i... [Note: there are tons of other examples I can provide, where it is more beneficial to claim to be an illegal vs trying to be legal status] P.S. the fwd.us, a tech industry backed non-profit organization would never speak about our issues; but would bend over backward to prevent illegals from deported (check their twitter handle "FWD_us" if you don't believe). Btw- I have nothing against illegal immigrants; but it hurts to be disadvantaged after following every impossible immigration rules for past 10+ years.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deyan 10y ago>The out going administration had sold us (and indirectly hurting American workers) with the "Indentured servitude rules" to benefit the Tech companies and immigration attorneys. The part that says "the outgoing administration" is demonstrably false. The facts are that the immigration policy of the US has not changed much under Obama (with a few notable exceptions like Cuba but that is not really related to the tech industry). Please stop spreading FUD. The immigration policy is nonsensical, but Obama has little to do with it. Perhaps the only legitimate criticism you can make is that he was not able to reform it properly.
- suryacom 10y ago>The part that says "the outgoing administration" is demonstrably false. That is not correct. The G. W. Bush administration, just before leaving the office, gave all the legal immigrants "Job Mobility" (i.e., their H1B visa was not anymore tied to the employer). It is minor and easy step President could take under his executive power.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoTo tech employees of corporations whose upper management and/or shareholders have donated to Republican interests: how do you feel about that? If you vote Democratic and contribute to Democratic campaigns, how do you feel knowing that your work directly produced profits which could be used to significantly outspend you and your like-minded colleagues? I rejected the Valley years ago because I saw the direction it was going in. I would like to hear from the people who are still there.
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> how do you feel knowing that your work directly produced profits which could be used to significantly outspend you and your like-minded colleagues Like I live in a democracy? If you are scared shitless of the opposition there's a problem with the checks and balances (or your understanding of them). Democracy requires tolerance of disagreement.
- GrinningFool 10y agoIn my opinion, Silicon Valley is pragmatic and always has been. The contributions seem less likely to be party-based and more likely to be based on the specific types of legislation they'd see advanced. Sometimes that will fall left, and sometimes right. Further, if the party likely to win is the right, they'll find candidates within that party to support. Had it been going the other way, then candidates in the left would have gotten that support. Alternatively, the author is accidentally correct. As business grow, they tend to get more benefit from right fiscal policy than left.
- RichardHeart 10y agoI'm so very tired of the left/right analogy. Please describe your politics as well as you do your sandwich toppings. They're likely similar in quantity. To put Trump and many other republicans on the same "right" is more absurd than ever. I made a video about it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- benkarst 10y agoThe influence of tech companies isn't measured in how much they donate to each party (as the article suggests) so much as it is how they use their powerful technology to influence public opinion and collude with politicians in private.