6 ms·
Interesting how all the climate change deniers come out of the woodwork whenever stories like these are posted, even though HN leans fairly heavily liberal and
by mikeash 10y ago
Interesting how all the climate change deniers come out of the woodwork whenever stories like these are posted, even though HN leans fairly heavily liberal and extremely heavily scientific the rest of the time.
Is the HN population actually like that, or are these people trying to push an agenda and otherwise not participating in the site? Either way, I sure wish we could discuss these things instead of getting bogged down in "it's all nonsense" every time.
- marcosdumay 10y agoThe answer is in their comments history. I've seen both cases. Even people with completely reasonable histories.
- nickff 10y agoMost topics on HN have people staunchly defending different camps; this is just an obvious one. As an example, Signal is very controversial, so there are a few people who say it's great for privacy, and another group that say it's misleading and less secure than it appears. Full disclosure: I don't have a position on Signal, but I'm a big fan of Moxie. How would you "discuss these things" without having different points of view? Should we all just post 'this climate change is even worse than I thought', then respond 'I knew it was this bad, see my post from 2 years ago'?
- mikeash 10y agoThere are plenty of things to discuss within the broad camp of "accepts that climate change is real and a potential problem." For example, the severity, the cause of individual events, the best responses, the potential dangers in the future, etc. Instead, we just get these condescending posts completely dismissing any notion of climate change at all. I do not see this phenomenon with other fact-based topics discussed here. When there's a story about vaccine, we're not flooded with people telling us how vaccines are full of toxins and don't prevent disease. When there's a story about genetics, we're not flooded with people telling us that evolution is a hoax. Physics stories don't get flooded with comments pushing Time Cube or whatever. Yes, we do get some comments like that, but not many. Sure, something like Signal is controversial, but that's something that's naturally based on opinion. Dissent about the tradeoffs of something like Signal is quite different from dissent about the reality of climate change.
- nickff 10y agoSo if I just say that whatever I believe is the 'reality of _", the conversation should switch to the potential ramifications of the ideas I believe? It seems like you are just saying that we should discuss the issues you (or some arbitrarily selected group of your choice) believe to be contentious issues. If you have some non-viewpoint-based standard for what is a legitimate topic of debate, I would be happy to see it.
- hnhg 10y agoHe's saying that discussing a scientific theory requires more than just "my opinion is that it's all bunkum."
- nickff 10y agoWhat type of refutation is expected when debating the validity of a theory? What is the standard for a qualifying theory? Even if you have a high standard in the first case, and a low standard in the second, I can find a citation for almost any proposition, but there's usually no point to doing so because the people you argue against will just find a different paper to support their prior beliefs.[1] My basic issue is that it seems mikeash is trying to impose their arbitrary standard on others. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Hume https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Hume
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoUltimately it doesn't matter because equating opinions to actions is like debating the difference between a recipe and a steaming plate of risotto. If you want to help prevent climate change, put up solar panels, get an electric car and hook it up to a renewable grid, eat less meat, fly less, whatever, just do something, because arguing with strangers over the Internet changes nothing at all. My comment has no effect on climate change either.
- hnhg 10y agoI guess more than just saying "this is bunkum" - I'm talking about examining the evidence and analytical techniques on both sides and engaging in debate rather than shutting the other side down, etc. Just citing stuff is a superficial level of debate, but for non-experts like us maybe that's all we can muster. In that case, we have to acknowledge that.
- diogenescynic 10y agoBig Oil companies fund climate skeptics and hire public affairs companies who pay people to promote those views online. It may or not be happening here, but it's definitely a thing: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/dark-money-funds-climate-change-denial-effort/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/dark-money-funds-... and: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/feb/21/climate-change-denier-willie-soon-funded-energy-industry https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/feb/21/climate-... and: https://thinkprogress.org/denier-bots-live-why-are-online-comments-sections-over-run-by-the-anti-science-pro-pollution-crowd-a15af62c5c13#.dsxa8fbcg https://thinkprogress.org/denier-bots-live-why-are-online-co... and: http://www.computerworld.com/article/2485252/social-media/are-online-comments-full-of-paid-lies-.html http://www.computerworld.com/article/2485252/social-media/ar...
- jbattle 10y agoHonestly I think HN draws a crowd that leans contrarian by nature. A lot of people here like a good argument and like to feel they've arrived at conclusions on their own brainpower, no matter how popular or unpopular. (There's a tempting trap that holding an unpopular opinion is validation you are thinking for yourself)
- mikeash 10y agoThere is definitely a strong contrarian theme in the tech community in general.
- rndmize 10y agoIn the case of this particular article, it looks like most of the denial posts are a single account (sameoldsameold, 2 hours old currently). Since all the posts by that account are now marked flagged/dead, and the account climatedenier is less than ten minutes old and is already posting along the same lines, I'd guess its the same person. Unless this person is tremendously emotionally involved in the idea of climate change, I don't see why an average HN reader would spend this much time on a single thread or create new accounts to post. It leaves me feeling like this is the efforts of a publicity firm or something similar - I remember reading some years back (well before the recent drama) about Russian government-run media control orgs that hired people to post comments to promote their view or damage opposing ones with bad arguments. Years before that, there was similar material from SF-based firms doing manipulation on reddit and digg. No reason to assume this no longer exists imo.
- abduhl 10y ago"Accusations of astroturfing or shilling without evidence are not allowed on HN. Rushing to that as an explanation is, invariably, evidence of sloppy thinking—or maybe non-thinking, of the kind that political passion leads us all to." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13345070 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13345070
- timthelion 10y agoI've long been thinking about creating an army of bots to promote my views on HN. Now I'll definitely do it!
- woodandsteel 10y agoBut in this case evidence was presented that the person is a shill, and in addition there were fact-based arguments against the position advocated by the alleged shill. Seems what you are saying is that we shouldn't be allowed to defend ourselves against shills by any means.
- Florin_Andrei 10y ago> HN leans fairly heavily liberal and extremely heavily scientific the rest of the time. HN also has a strong libertarian bias. There's some correlation between subscribing to that type of dogma and being an active climate change denier.
- cmurf 10y agoI think there's a stronger correlation for religious people being active climate change deniers. Surely the creator would not destroy EVERYONE all at the same time?! That would be capricious and unfair! But I admit I can't think of a purely free market solution for avoiding climate change, and perhaps as libertarian types haven't figured out how to innovate those incentives they just have to deny it's not real rather than admit the free market isn't going to innovate those incentives and arrive at a correction on its own before it's too late. The reality is, it's already too late. Now we're in the position of having to manage the consequences of our failure: soft landing vs hard landing.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> I think there's a stronger correlation for religious people being active climate change deniers. Surely the creator would not destroy EVERYONE all at the same time?! That would be capricious and unfair! Climate change won't kill everyone at the same time, though.
- cmurf 10y agoFair point. But then, so the story goes, God sent the flood no doubt killing most of humanity all at once in a rather capricious and vindictive act of collective punishment (and mass murder). So there may be some cognitive dissonance going on in more than one way.
- DrScump 10y agoHN also has a strong libertarian bias. Having a sizable libertarian presence is not the same as having a "strong libertarian bias".
- creaghpatr 10y agoConsider Jessica Livingston's The Sound of Silence essay that was posted this morning