4 ms·
>I guess we should have voted harder? 'Cause voting is the answer to problems with elected governments, right? No. Where you you get that idea? This is how yo
by nabla9 10y ago
>I guess we should have voted harder? 'Cause voting is the answer to problems with elected governments, right?
No. Where you you get that idea?
This is how you answer the problems in representative democracy:
1. You pick a party that has change to get representatives. You don't have to like it, it's a not beauty contest[1]. You just pick a party.
2. You join the party as a member.
3. You influence the issues inside the party. You join with the same minded people in the party. You recruit more same minded people. You push your agendas and your candidates inside the party long before any elections. You push them into councils and work groups. You push them into campaign committees and party chairs in multiple level.
4. When elections come, you vote. But that's just small part.
---
[1] People who bitch and moan how it's dirty and they don't like any party that is in actual position of power. Boo hoo. Get over it and get dirty. It's fight for power, not beauty contest.
- javiramos 10y agoYou missed the 'Starting a Super PAC' part!
- danjoc 10y ago>But TV said all I need to do is vote. I think you just unboxed jessaustin's point.
- jessaustin 10y agoActually that's a fairly common refrain here on HN as well. I'm glad to have short-circuited that somewhat on this thread, to the marginally more plausible "all I need is to be very active in political campaigns and fundraising" alternate narrative.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoBut who has the gumption to bother with all of that palaver. I'm no political activist, my expertise lie else where. Surely at least some of us should be able to just vote occasionally.
- mjburgess 10y agoChanging the world requires caring enough to do something. We'd be in a much worse situation if a friday afternoon's clicktivism wishes were the governing force of western civilization.
- jessaustin 10y agoSome people think that "do something" means coloring within the lines like 'nabla9 suggests above. Other people don't think that.
- nabla9 10y agoYou should both color within and outside the lines. But people who live in democracy complaining that the system is corrupt and not using the system to correct itself are deluding themselves. There will never be better system that distributes real power without coercive action , corruption and dirty politics.
- logfromblammo 10y agoAs an occasional tabletop gamer, I can often conceive several different winning strategies just by reading the rules of the game. In the game of American representative democracy, I would not recommend your strategy. It's playing for 2nd place. If you truly believe what you said, you should be recommending that people act to corrupt a public official in a manner that provides some leverage to them, personally. Alternately, poach the blackmail material from someone who already has leverage.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoThat strategy will increase your power, if it works. But it carries much higher downside risk...
- meanduck 10y agoYes who needs better and more correct code for critical missions, If we all shout loud/longer enough we would win.
- Rickasaurus 10y agoI wish this was the top comment. So true.
- meanduck 10y agoBut what you gain from being politically active is the right to not be abused, at the loss of productivity. Its lose-lose situation.
- logfromblammo 10y agoMy commitment to a personal code of ethics is the only thing that stops me from becoming a monster. You have no idea what runs through my head sometimes. No idea. If I ever decide to get "dirty", it won't be to your benefit, in any way whatsoever. If I can't obtain power fairly and rationally, I am very unlikely to use it fairly and rationally. I'll use it to screw you over and make myself and my allies rich on your suffering. That's what people with power do now, and I have observed it to be a successful stratagem so far. The government is running out of opportunities to present arguments against the possibility of me forming or joining a rebellion composed of strange bedfellows. Every time it changes policy to become more hostile to traditional American ideals, it is prying another board off the portal to the abyss. Don't tell me to stop watching the circuses and go join one. I'll just nail down the tent flaps and set the big top on fire. If you don't want me to be a walking time bomb, stop tolerating blatantly unethical behavior in your government and your political parties. Now. For me, it is a beauty contest, and the loveliest of the pageant participants is, at best, a "4". And for some reason, the crown keeps getting taken by someone who is a "1" or a "2". Perhaps I have just lived too long in places with notoriously corrupt government.
- marcosdumay 10y ago> I have observed it to be a successful stratagem so far. On a short time, yes, seems to be very successful. Over a few generations, a less greed "leave some money on the table" approach seems to beat it every time.
- marrs 10y ago> Don't tell me to stop watching the circuses and go join one. I'll just nail down the tent flaps and set the big top on fire. But you won't because your peers will put the fire out before it has a chance take hold and then they'll kick you out. In a mature democracy, no one person can attain enough power to do any long-term damage (at least relative to any other system). In the USA, a president has limited powers and a limited time frame within which to wield them, after which he will be kicked out, whether he was doing a good job or not, so your analogy isn't really working. > For me, it is a beauty contest, and the loveliest of the pageant participants is, at best, a "4". And for some reason, the crown keeps getting taken by someone who is a "1" or a "2". Perhaps this is because it isn't a beauty contest for the rest of the people.
- marcosdumay 10y agoThat, of course, is way more effective when there are more than 2 viable parties.