11 ms·
I guess we should have voted harder? 'Cause voting is the answer to problems with elected governments, right? Right?
by jessaustin 10y ago
I guess we should have voted harder? 'Cause voting is the answer to problems with elected governments, right?
Right?
- rayiner 10y agoThat's a bit of a straw man. Nobody says voting will get you the government you want. I can't get any of my liberal friends (core Hilary voters) to care about surveillance. To the extent they're nervous about surveillance as a general concept, they trust Obama has struck the balance necessitated by what he knows about threats to the country. Not everyone should vote. If your views are substantially outside the mainstream there is no point in voting.
- eternalban 10y ago> Not everyone should vote. If your views are substantially outside the mainstream there is no point in voting. That's funny. Reminded me of this: https://twitter.com/sinderbrand/status/819315489021325312 https://twitter.com/sinderbrand/status/819315489021325312
- dack 10y ago> If your views are substantially outside the mainstream there is no point in voting. There's still a big reason to vote: pick the candidate with the least amount of problems that has a chance of winning. But I do agree that voting is usually too-little-too-late if you don't already have the majority of voters knowing about your cause.
- r3bl 10y agoYes, in a classical two-party system, voting for lesser of two evils is the only option. But in the US, there's also the question in which state you live in. For example, there's no point voting Republican in California, nor Democrat in Texas.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoThere are several Republican enclaves in California (particularly in rural areas) just as there are several Democratic enclaves in Texas (particularly in urban areas). I live in Ithaca, NY. That means we have a very, very liberal municipal government, gerrymandered-to-shit knucklehead (mostly) Republican legislative representation in Albany and DC, and a moderately liberal governor (Cuomo). These layers matter. But if you don't mind tyranny then by all means don't vote.
- ptero 10y agoI wonder if it would be better if voting cost a small amount of money, say $50 (everyone can easily afford to save $50 once every two years). That would encourage those who choose to vote to research the issue (if they care enough to pay $50 they likely care about the choices).
- pjc50 10y agoYou know why voting taxes were ruled unconstitutional, right?
- zeroer 10y agoI don't.
- tangent128 10y agoThey grew out of Jim Crow laws: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poll_taxes_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poll_taxes_in_the_United_State... (In addition, imagine an interest group instituting a "we'll pay your poll tax for you!" campaign, but only in counties carefully selected for demographics.)
- zeroer 10y agoYea, but the racist origins are not an explanation why poll taxes are inherently unconstitutional. I feel like there's a step missing in the explanation.
- djsumdog 10y agoThere is a deeper problem here, and it's that voting in America doesn't provide the citizens with evenly distributed representation. I'm not talking about the electoral college. I'm talking about first past the post. In Australia, you literally cannot throw your vote away. It's order of preference with instant run-off. Maine just passed ranked voting laws for their state, and I'm curious to see the effects. The US is an Oligarchy. Some people are really angry right now, because their stawperson didn't get elected. But they weren't angry for the past eight years of domestic spying, predator drones and kill lists. This anger only helps solidify the rule of the elite, because it keeps Americans fighting each other, and not the war industry or the banks or various other entities that can basically get their laws passed no matter who is elected. http://fightthefuture.org/articles/the-fallout-of-american-anger/ http://fightthefuture.org/articles/the-fallout-of-american-a... I really like the EFF, and I'm glad they're fighting for our rights to speech and privacy, no matter which party is in office.
- emdowling 10y agoPreferential voting is a bit useless in a presidential election isn't it? With only two major candidates, wouldn't that result in someone getting like 90%+ of the vote? Side note: As an Australian, it absolutely blows my mind that voting is not compulsory in more countries. I have no idea why voting isn't compulsory, like taxes.
- embwbam 10y agoWith preferential voting we would have more than two candidates. FPTP causes the two party system
- djsumdog 10y agoI used Australia as an example, and yes, I have several Aussie friends who say, "Well we pretty much have a two party system now." Do you have any insight as to why this is? Do people just not mark more than one or two preferences, given that they have more choices? I understand the "big" parties work hard to get there, and they'll work even in the limits of a system to stay on top. I also had Australians tell me about the "top" and "bottom" of the ballot. The bottom can have a long scrolling amount of entries, and Australians who care will go to various websites where they can input their issues, get a list of which MPs agree, print out this list and take it into a voting booth to see which parties they should vote for. O_o I've been told most Australians only fill out the top.
- maxerickson 10y agoNot everyone should vote. If your views are substantially outside the mainstream there is no point in voting. Voting pragmatically in local elections likely still makes sense even for people with extreme views. A few of the races are likely to be close and have candidates with disparate viewpoints.
- djsumdog 10y agoYears ago I volunteers to work on a local campaign to help a candidate. I use to think local elections were different as well, but during that time I realized local elections are pretty much just as screwed up as elections on the state/national level. It all comes down to money, advertising and building a narrative. People don't pay attention to what mayors actually do, plus a terrible mayor can live off the planning of the previous administration for most of their term in office (and thereby take credit for things they didn't touch).
- maxerickson 10y agoNone of that means that it isn't worth showing up to vote against an obviously terrible local candidate.
- mindslight 10y agoI'm not aware of any elections where you can "vote against" a candidate.
- maxerickson 10y agoA semantician strikes again! If you are actually confused about my meaning I'd be glad to explain further.
- mindslight 10y agoI'm not confused about your meaning, but disputing such characterization of the situation. A vote for a candidate is a vote for that candidate, an endorsement of their subsequent actions. Don't get tricked by subjectively slightly "less worse" candidates.
- ForrestN 10y agoIt is also possible to care deeply about privacy, to be frustrated to no end by this area of policy under the Obama administration, and to still have voted for Hillary, say. The problem with a two party system dominated by a president is that many important issues bundled together. Democrats let me down on privacy, but the new Vice President's signature policy focus is persecuting gay families like mine. I just want to say that we can vote even while agitating within our own parties and social groups for improvements on privacy.
- rfrey 10y ago"Not everyone should vote. If your views are substantially outside the mainstream there is no point in voting." Voting outside the mainstream over time (for some definition of "substantially outside") can normalize and legitimize viewpoints that would otherwise be regarded as fringe forever. We've seen that with the Green party here in Canada. That said, I agree (if you think this) that the fetishization of voting for the sake of voting is pretty naive.
- antisthenes 10y ago> Voting outside the mainstream over time (for some definition of "substantially outside") can normalize and legitimize viewpoints that would otherwise be regarded as fringe forever. What's the scale of the timeframe we're talking about here? Doesn't seem like the Green Party in the US has a chance of getting normalized on a scale of 2 generations (~50 yrs), based on the past history of voting. Having people vote based on the idea that at some point in the future, possibly not in their lifetime, their viewpoint may (or may not) become mainstream/legitimate is absurd. People are not that far forward thinkers.
- jessaustin 10y agoIf we're lucky and the news media gets completely destroyed by the Internet (which process has certainly begun) whatever replaces it probably won't be as unified in reinforcing the two-party hegemony. I think that's the biggest factor in people not even considering a vote for even the milquetoast alternatives that we got this last time around. Every time the "other" candidates get a mention, it's to poke fun of them for some geographical error. ("She flew to the wrong city!" "He couldn't find Aleppo on a map; doesn't he know we'll have to bomb that city soon?")
- rfrey 10y agoMy perception is that the Green party went from lunatic fringe to "why aren't they in the official debates" in three election cycles.
- meanduck 10y ago> Nobody says voting will get you the government you want. That is the point. Vote is increasingly becoming deselect method (Govt that is least bad) than select.
- krapp 10y agoThe fact of the matter is - voting did work, for Republicans and the right wing. This environment of abridged civil liberties, police militarization and increased surveillance is what many Americans wanted, post 9/11. Donald Trump's election signals a successful vote for more of the same - although one that assumes, in ignorance, the commonly held belief that Obama as a Democrat weakened and undermined the surveillance state and that a corrective policy shift to the right is necessary.
- Steeeve 10y ago> This environment of abridged civil liberties, police militarization and increased surveillance is what many Americans wanted, post 9/11. No. Nobody wants to live in the iron curtain. This is an absolute and total failure of leadership, from the Bush administration through the Obama administration. 16 years of inexcusable failure. (It probably goes back even further) People with bombs have not created fear, politicians have.
- pjc50 10y agoPeople wanted "abridged civil liberties, police militarization and increased surveillance" applied to other people. The whole thing relies on "othering". America has long been happy to have a more violent police force and higher rate of imprisonment than other countries so long as that violence is directed against nonwhite people. It seems people imagine that they'll be the priviliged ones behind the iron curtain; the neighbourhood informers. (This is also why e.g. HOAs have such oppressive rules, they're aimed at eradicating "difference" and a form of soft-redlining)
- soundwave106 10y agoUnfortunately, in the USA, if you ask the question directly, you will get a surprising amount of people who support our current government surveillance: 42% in this 2015 Pew poll. http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/05/29/what-americans-think-about-nsa-surveillance-national-security-and-privacy/ http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/05/29/what-america... An interesting add-on to this is to poll about how one feels about Edward Snowden. The result is that the majority view him negatively. (http://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2015/04/21/edward-snowden-unpopular-at-home-a-hero-abroad-poll-finds http://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2015/04/21/edward-snowde... and http://www.newsmax.com/Newsfront/edward-snowden-rasmussen-poll-hero-russia/2016/09/23/id/749866/ http://www.newsmax.com/Newsfront/edward-snowden-rasmussen-po...) So unfortunately there is a pretty significant group of people that are okay with increased surveillance. Note that from what I see, this divide doesn't appear to be traditional US liberal/conservative. In fact, if anything, the divide carries more of a generational rift, where older people are more okay with surveillance than younger people are. (The USA Today poll on Snowden mentions this, and there is also this: http://www.people-press.org/2013/07/26/few-see-adequate-limits-on-nsa-surveillance-program/#age-and-views-of-civil-liberties-govt-surveillance http://www.people-press.org/2013/07/26/few-see-adequate-limi...) For those concerned with digital privacy and rights, I guess the question would be how to counter this narrative of fear that from my viewpoint drives these sort of opinions.
- dragonwriter 10y agoWrong. Voting is one of the most basic and fundamental forms of engagement when there are elections available, but far from "the answer" to problems with government. Very often combinations of other forms of activism, whether directly in the electoral process (working campaigns, actually running for office, etc.), or less directly related to the electoral process specifically (public lawful protest, various forms of direct petition), and even outside the formal bounds of the law (civil disobedience as protest, for instance) are necessary to address some problems with elected governments, and, many of those (even voting) often require substantial organizing, mobilizing, and communication to spread ideas to work effectively. And whichever combination of methods is needed also often takes many years to be successful.
- rayiner 10y agoThe simpler solution would be simply to break up America into a bunch of smaller, more ideologically homogenous countries. (Federalism isn't the answer, because Maryland won't put up with Alabama making abortion illegal while flying the same flag.)
- caseysoftware 10y agoBased on the 2016 electoral map - or indeed, almost any from the last 20+ years - the ideologically homogeneity isn't a regional thing but a city vs rural thing. Take the largest ~20 cities in the US and they would be city-states while literally everything else would be a single country.
- maxerickson 10y agoIt's also more like 60-40 40-60, not 90-10 10-90. That is, there are cultural differences between the city and rural majorities, but neither group is particularly homogeneous.
- rayiner 10y ago87% of Maryland lives in an urban area, versus 48% of West Virginia. Maryland would drift way to the left if it wasn't forced into political compromises to accommodate other states.
- burkaman 10y agoWhat do you mean by "the answer"? Are you not able to do more than one thing?
- SmirkingRevenge 10y agoI've more or less come to believe that voting - at least on the national scale - doesn't really function the way most like to think - that its some noble expression of the will of the people (even presuming that the will of the people is rational in the first place - more than likely it isn't). Voting, combined with checks and balances, term limits - is more of a hamster wheel for power seekers. The combination of those things makes power really difficult and costly to attain, transient, and limited (hopefully). And it helps ensure that power transitions peacefully, more or less. Its less about the actual candidate, and more about churn.
- BeetleB 10y agoNot sure why you're downvoted. I've lived in multiple countries, including a dictatorship and a very corrupt democracy. The dictatorship was definitely preferred to the corrupt democracy - nothing worked in the latter. It was just deadlock after deadlock. The US isn't as bad as that very corrupt democracy, but I do not share many people's views that when a country switches to democracy things will improve. There are far too many factors in play, and people voting is only a small factor amongst all of them. The culture of the people probably matters a lot more than whether they get to vote or not.
- frabbit 10y agoI like this idea. However, it seems to me that it keeps _individuals_ churning through the powerful offices of state yet ensures that those individuals are only only drawn from a particular _restricted group_. That's the reason for the animosity to Trump. Within that restricted group he wields more power with fewer ties than other group members. If he were one of the usual oligarchs who has to compromise with the investment banks and lobbyists for powerful special interests he would be more controllable. But who knows what someone with their own resources might get up to.
- nabla9 10y ago>I guess we should have voted harder? 'Cause voting is the answer to problems with elected governments, right? No. Where you you get that idea? This is how you answer the problems in representative democracy: 1. You pick a party that has change to get representatives. You don't have to like it, it's a not beauty contest[1]. You just pick a party. 2. You join the party as a member. 3. You influence the issues inside the party. You join with the same minded people in the party. You recruit more same minded people. You push your agendas and your candidates inside the party long before any elections. You push them into councils and work groups. You push them into campaign committees and party chairs in multiple level. 4. When elections come, you vote. But that's just small part. --- [1] People who bitch and moan how it's dirty and they don't like any party that is in actual position of power. Boo hoo. Get over it and get dirty. It's fight for power, not beauty contest.
- javiramos 10y agoYou missed the 'Starting a Super PAC' part!
- danjoc 10y ago>But TV said all I need to do is vote. I think you just unboxed jessaustin's point.
- jessaustin 10y agoActually that's a fairly common refrain here on HN as well. I'm glad to have short-circuited that somewhat on this thread, to the marginally more plausible "all I need is to be very active in political campaigns and fundraising" alternate narrative.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoBut who has the gumption to bother with all of that palaver. I'm no political activist, my expertise lie else where. Surely at least some of us should be able to just vote occasionally.
- 10y ago
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoMaybe government isn't where the answer is going to come from. Maybe we should stop placing our hope in the government. As a Christian, this makes perfect sense to me - hope should not have been in the government in the first place. But even if you're not a Christian (or any kind of a theist), if you look at the situation honestly, it seems pretty clear: Hope is going to have to come from somewhere else. The government isn't going to provide it. Sure, they sell hope. That's what their campaign says. But they don't actually deliver what they sell.