11 ms·
This made me realize how little innovation there is in the browser space today. Opera used to innovate extensively before the sale, and it looks like at least t
by StavrosK 10y ago
This made me realize how little innovation there is in the browser space today. Opera used to innovate extensively before the sale, and it looks like at least they're trying to keep doing it. I'm also hopeful for Vivaldi. Chrome and Firefox are completely stagnant, unfortunately.
- KevanM 10y agoWhenever I've jumped ship, I've jumped to a simpler or faster version because the advances (at a perceived performance loss, or further UI changes). Opera used to be really fast, but then it started to come with lots of other useless tools (email, bittorrent client tool) and try to be an internet package So I jumped to Firefox which was simpler and Thunderbird was a separate client. Then that started to be clunkier, so I tried Chrome, which was faster. Much like laptop getting thinner, the gains are in the wrong area. What I want is a fast, secure browser that can remember history and bookmarks - everything else can be an add-on.
- Kostic 10y agoI am really blown away by Vivaldi but I can't, sadly, start using a closed source browser. Browsers are an important (maybe the most important) programs today. I simply can't allow myself to get locked into a closed source browser today.
- lexnova 10y agohttps://vivaldi.com/source/ https://vivaldi.com/source/
- draw_down 10y agoBoy oh boy, I dunno about that, particularly Chrome.
- problems 10y agoHonestly, I wish Firefox was more stagnant and less "let's clone Chrome's every misfeature, who needs the ability to modify the browser UI?".
- kk_cz 10y agoCall me an old fart, but I am completely satisfied with the way Firefox works now, at least in terms of UI. Sure, replace Gecko with Quantum if you will, upgrade the javascript engine, but please don't fuck up the UI.
- digi_owl 10y agoMore like before tossing Presto and reskinning Chrome. That said, this is perhaps the second time i have seen them unveil a concept browser for an Apple platform. Really goes to show how big a fixture Apple is in web development. But then i hold that this can be attributed to when web development moved from the computing department to the media production department. As the latter had been a Mac stronghold since the intro of the original Mac in combo with Apple's laserwriter printer.
- skykooler 10y agoIt's not just for Mac. On Windows or Linux, the page title is "Opera Neon concept browser for Windows".
- pawadu 10y agoOff course Firefox is stagnant. The the Mozilla board is floating in money and has no reason to change things. The little work that gets done is done by skunkworkers, volunteers or third party projects. edit: see for yourself https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10101637 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10101637
- V-2 10y agoI used Vivaldi for a couple of months. Plenty of goodness, and one major showstopper: it's slow. It's so very sluggish and slow. Something as trivial as tearing a tab off a window would take several seconds. Switching between tabs was laggy as well, once there were many. Every other browser felt blazingly fast after that. That's a pity since this type of issues usually indicates some deeper design problems that won't be easily fixable.
- emptyfile 10y agoYes opening a new window is at least 3x slower than Chrome and tearing off a tab is like... a 2 sec delay. But honestly I have no problems with "regular" browsing. The features are good enough to live with the slowdown, as others have said Vivaldi can never be as fast as Chrome.
- StavrosK 10y agoReally? I'm on Vivaldi right now and everything is instant. I'm using it over Firefox just because how much faster it is. It's as fast as Chrome for me.
- febed 10y agoYep, this is exactly my experience with Vivaldi. The feature set is really good, but I wish the performance was as good as Chrome.
- Mithaldu 10y agoVivaldi is a layer of Javascript on top of a cut-down chrome. You're right. It can't ever be faster than Chrome, nor really fast, for that matter.
- NoGravitas 10y agoChrome is semi-stagnant because it's dominant, which means not much drive to change. I wouldn't call Firefox stagnant. It's just got E10S (multiprocess). The Quantum project promises to gradually improve both speed and stability (and consequentially security). They are working on replacing the traditional Firefox extensions archetecture with WebExtensions. Fennec (Firefox on Android) is an underappreciated gem. I'm playing with Vivaldi now. It's nice, it's fast, there's a fair amount of UI innovation. But underneath, it's just Blink, so it's hard for me to get that excited about it.
- tornadoboy55 10y agoA lot of major extensions still turn off e10s, so no, it isn't here yet.
- StavrosK 10y agoWhy do you care what the rendering engine is? It's literally the least exciting part. I never said "man, I wish this rendering engine ran different code". I've frequently said "I wish mouse gestures worked as well as Opera's did". Fennec is pretty great, yes. I've been using Firefox on ideological grounds for years, and it's getting harder and harder. I currently have a tab open that will just keep loading forever every time I load the browser, taking 100% CPU, until I go and press escape to stop loading. It's slow as hell and frequently freezes. Ideology can only take you so far if the product is a piece of crap.
- atomicfiredoll 10y ago> I never said "man, I wish this rendering engine ran different code". Then I guess you were never an IE6 user.
- gcp 10y agoCan you file a bug on this with the URL causing the problem? The tab not loading fully isn't necessarily our fault, but of course it shouldn't use 100% while doing that. The rendering engine is fairly important for apparent speed and smoothness (e.g. with scrolling). These are issues where Firefox was traditionally not rated highly.
- snowwolf 10y agoAhh, the paradox of being the market leader. Remember when Chrome tried to innovate with how we use bookmarks? [1] People cry out for innovation, but then freak out when said innovation happens. This is why disrupters are so successful - they can do something crazy and people will try it out and think - this is amazing. Because the mindset/psychology is that this is something new. But the market leader implements exactly the same thing and people won't give it a chance because it's a change and they can't handle change. But I actually disagree that they are stagnant. They may be hesitant to change the UI, but there is a lot happening under the hood to make them more secure, faster, standards compliant, stable etc. [1] http://www.omgchrome.com/new-bookmark-manager-chrome-disabled-how-to-get-it-back/ http://www.omgchrome.com/new-bookmark-manager-chrome-disable... Edit - Adding an example of recent Firefox innovation being rejected https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/hello-status https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/hello-status
- erpellan 10y agoThe solution is not to try to disrupt the main product but to artificially compete with it. Google could release a new, unbranded browser with all the experimental features. Early adopters would flock to it, the comfortable majority would happily stick with what they know. Win win.
- nialv7 10y agoExcept now Google would have to maintain TWO massively complex project. Also they kind of just did what you suggested with Duo,Allo and Hangouts.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThey only will if it proves worthwhile. Also, it can reuse components from Chrome where possible.
- flukus 10y agoYou can also make things optional and opt-in (at least for existing users). With browsers they can be extensions too, no need to shove it in everyone's face.
- zzzcpan 10y ago> how little innovation there is in the browser space today That was the purpose of Chrome, I believe, to monopolize the browser market and make it very expensive for others to compete and innovate google's business model out of existence.
- pvg 10y agoWhat does that even mean? They're sparing a potential competitor the entire R&D cost of a modern, cross-platform browser. I don't think Google developed Chrome out of sheer altruism but it's probably cheaper now to compete in the browser space than ever. It's unlikely to be profitable, though, in itself.
- sydd 10y agoThat means Chrome is a very important strategic asset for Google, perhaps their most important one that end users can run. Imagine there was no Chrome and say FF held 70% of the browser market share. They'd would hold Google by the balls, and could do stuff like: Nag the user to use their search engine/mail suite, have bugs that kill Google products, delay features that'd be very important to Google (e.g. webm),...
- pvg 10y agoI don't think that addresses my question. How did Google developing Chrome 'monopolize the market' or make it 'very expensive for competitors', the claims the person I'm replying to was making (if I understood them right, which I wasn't entirely sure of to begin with)
- gcp 10y agoit's probably cheaper now to compete in the browser space than ever In the browser space, yes. In the API and platform space, no. Every other browser has already resigned to just "do what Chrome does" instead of expecting Chrome to confirm to the standards as written. Do you not see how this is a huge hedge for Google? You control the platform and APIs, you rule the world. Microsoft used to understand this very well. On top of that, if you have to compete in the browser space by forking off of Google's rendering engine and web platform, you're always going to be behind.
- gcp 10y agoDo you think users necessarily want much innovation in browsers? What do you think would happen if Google changed the Chrome UI (the little there is) around? Non-user visible innovation in browsers does happen BTW. But you dont't see it :-)
- zzzcpan 10y agoNothing would happen, as long as they have UX professional on the team, who won't let them do stupid things like removing a backspace keyboard shortcut and not leaving options for those who got used to them.
- gcp 10y agoThese are indeed all things that have had great impacts on the respective browsers' marketshare. /s
- mathw 10y agoIt's a real shame they didn't have a UX professional on the team to tell them not to include backspace as a shortcut for back in the first place. Although I believe that was Microsoft's fault, but Google shouldn't have copied it. I've lost more data to that than any web browser bug over the years. Fortunately Chrome had an extension that let me turn it off!
- StavrosK 10y ago> I've lost more data to that than any web browser bug over the years. Is the back that backspace goes back, or that the browser doesn't store text you've typed in a textarea?
- iopq 10y agoThe browser does store the text in the text area, but the text area disappears when you reload the page because you need to click a button that adds that element to the page.
- onion2k 10y agoThis made me realize how little innovation there is in the browser space today. I don't think that's true. There's lots of innovation, but it's in things that aren't necessarily obvious to the end user until there's decent levels of adoption by developers. Websites can access gamepads, advanced hardware-accelerated 3D, bluetooth, accelerometers, different layout engines, P2P data sharing, push notifications ... the UI that doesn't change very often, but that's only a tiny aspect of what a browser is.
- colept 10y ago> but it's in things that aren't necessarily obvious to the end user until there's decent levels of adoption by developers Which ironically doesn't happen until browsers agree on innovation.
- mbesto 10y agoI don't need my browser to "innovate". It just needs to continue doing it what it does best - consistently render a presentation layer. All of the innovation should be under the hood (which it appears Chrome/Firefox have been doing)
- rospaya 10y agoSo you don't use bookmarks or tabs?
- 0xCMP 10y agotabs, but I use https://pinboard.in/ https://pinboard.in/
- domenukk 10y agoWhy do you need bookmarks, either you google it again or can access it through some kind of chat... Tabs are nice though
- yoz-y 10y agoOr use the browser history/read it later system
- lsh 10y agoin vivaldi you can ctrl-d to bookmark then shift-tab to set a shortcut name in future you can just ctrl-t then shortcut name to go straight to bookmark. yeah, it's bookmarks under the hood, but being able to just go 'ctrl-t' then 'webmail' or 'workmail' or whatever saves the convolutions of smartcomplete and autocomplete and displaying history or suggestions and such in the url bar.
- aroch 10y ago^d in Firefox and Chrome also bookmarks the page Both Firefox's awesomebar and Chrome's omnibox let you go to a shortcut by typing its name
- 10y ago
- colordrops 10y agoThere's very little _user interface_ innovation in the major browsers today.
- elzi 10y agochrome's dev tools are anything but stagnant but the browsing experience has not innovated much.