4 ms·
Oracle maintains a database of personal information for billions of people. The US corporate surveillance web is rich in complexity. Before we judge China, le
by TaylorAlexander 10y ago
Oracle maintains a database of personal information for billions of people.
The US corporate surveillance web is rich in complexity.
Before we judge China, lets make sure we know what we're comparing them to.
I highly encourage anyone interested in the subject to watch this talk from last month's Chaos Computer Club Congress.
"Corporate surveillance, digital tracking, big data & privacy:
How thousands of companies are profiling, categorizing, rating and affecting the lives of billions"
https://media.ccc.de/v/33c3-8414-corporate_surveillance_digital_tracking_big_data_privacy https://media.ccc.de/v/33c3-8414-corporate_surveillance_digi...
https://youtu.be/kd6NKvwQVbM https://youtu.be/kd6NKvwQVbM
You say the Chinese system is sinister because they force you to use ID cards. In the US corporate surveillance system, they can track you without ID cards.
- 20andup 10y agoYup. Here's the thing too. When people troll online, they think hiding behind an alias is enough. You can still be traced back. I am sure the government keep tabs of all your history, even if you are not a person of interest at the moment.
- ralfd 10y agoI would say that forcing someone to use an universal ID provides a way stronger and more reliable form of tracking, than a wibbly wobbly system which needs thousands of marketing companies which maybe fulfill their corporate promises and maybe not.
- 20andup 10y ago"wibbly wobbly system which needs thousands of marketing companies which maybe fulfill their corporate promise" I am afraid that's not how it works. This is not how the government tracks you. The mirror all traffic going brought your internet service provider, that's it. Then it's just a google search to see what websites you have visited. https://www.ixmaps.ca/nsa.php https://www.ixmaps.ca/nsa.php Government ID or not, you are being tracked quite easily by the government.
- simonh 10y agoThe concerns about US/Western surveillance is that it could lead to routine direct abuses and active intrusions into daily life. It's important that we use the political and legal protections we have to limit the risks this raises. In China they have routine direct abuses and intrusion into daily life right now and are expanding it as fast as they can. There are no legal protections and the risks are already happening. If you can't see there's a difference there, I can't help you.
- TheRealDunkirk 10y agoI'm not sure what sort of legal protections you think Americans have, as it would seem that any 3-letter agency can get an order to force private companies to hand over any data they have about any number of individuals based on the rubber stamp of a secret court which forces the company to stay silent about the activity. I'm absolutely certain that the NSA has precisely the same granularity of data on US citizens as described in this article. The US government is just smarter about hiding that fact, lest there be a second revolution. Another decade or so, and it will be so prevalent everywhere else that they'll start operating in the open, just like the Chinese.
- wu-ikkyu 10y ago>The concerns about US/Western surveillance is that it could lead to routine direct abuses Curious use of the word "could", as it seems to imply such abuses have not already occurred and been exposed without legal recourse.