9 ms·
Former employees sue Microsoft after developing PTSD
- wccrawford 10y agoIt's a shame anyone has to do jobs like these. But forcing people to do it? (I assume the alternative was not to have a job there at all.) That's ridiculous. I also tend to believe the former employees about the rest of the working conditions. At the very least, the employee has a clear history of having problems with the work, and the company should have been better about handling this. There's no way they could fail to foresee that this work could have terrible effects on someone's mind.
- abstractbeliefs 10y agoWhile this case is really tragic, and improvements can be made, I don't think it's fair really to say these people were _forced_ to do this work. You say that the other option was to not work at Microsoft, well, this means they aren't being forced. They had the choice to not work that job role. Workers are not entitled to shop around within a company for a role that suits them, and companies are not obliged to offer the job role that an employee wants.
- paulcole 10y ago> companies are not obliged to offer the job role that an employee wants Now go over to the "open office plan" comments and watch developers act like they're being tortured if they have to sit next to someone who might talk and it's their god-given right to demand a soundproof private office. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13373526 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13373526
- hackits 10y agoI wouldn't say not obliged, entitled to a position. They advertised for a position, you convinced them you're a fit for the position. They've chosen you out of a pool of candidates that suites the job. They offer you a employment contract detailing the role, and responsibilities. You accept said contract and term's or write counter proposal. After accepting the position you shut up and do your job you where hired to do.
- st3v3r 10y agoBecause no company has ever been less than truthful when describing a role and it's responsibilities.
- colemickens 10y agoMaybe you should re-read the article and you'd realize it was NOT a job they signed up to do. If only people read the articles instead of leaping to defend face-less huge corporations.
- hackits 10y agoWhats so hard to grasp? Some people seem to be jumping to conclusion on this. You're hired for a position that is detailed out in your EMPLOYMENT contract. If you get to your job and find out you have to kill kittens instead of the job description YOU'RE choosing to carry out the task. No one is forcing you to do it. On moral grounds and ethical ground I would resign instantly and contact the authority of the kind of material stored on the server.
- colemickens 10y agoNot going to repeat myself about whether it's a choice. There's better comments in this thread. >and contact the authorize of the kind of material stored on the server. Uh, I don't think you understand how this works. I'm sure if you tell the FBI that Microsoft works to remove child pornography from OneDrive and report the offenders they're going to say "Okay...?".
- hackits 10y agoYou're hired for a position to perform administration of OneDrive accounts. You're not hired to remove `Child pornography` from one drive or look at that shit. Its night and day that it's completely out of scope of the job description. The next step is simple you talk with your manager that the content viewed is out of scope of the scope of works in the contract (border line criminal material) that you refuse to view the content during the course of your work.
- EnFinlay 10y agoWorkers are entitled to their safety, which is why OSHA and similar things exist. Blue collar situations are very similar to this, and I'm sure no one would defend a woodshop that had bandaids instead of hand guards and eye protection. When a job has risks the company is responsible for proper mitigation and control.
- hackits 10y agoI don't know how they could be `forcing` people to do it. Last time I checked you have your own agency and can decide to stay or leave on moral grounds. I would imagine that interviewee's will be acceptance of your role change if they understand you required part of your job to view questionable material.
- serge2k 10y agoWhat do other companies do with people who have to evaluate content like this?
- mcphilip 10y agoSome outsource the problem: https://www.wired.com/2014/10/content-moderation/ https://www.wired.com/2014/10/content-moderation/
- bbcbasic 10y agoSad, but unsurprising.
- danso 10y agoVerge had a pretty good longform article on it: http://www.theverge.com/2016/4/13/11387934/internet-moderator-history-youtube-facebook-reddit-censorship-free-speech http://www.theverge.com/2016/4/13/11387934/internet-moderato... edit: Sorry, it's an article about how other companies do content moderation, but not a huge focus on how they accommodate the workers who do it.
- belltaco 10y agohttp://gizmodo.com/5936572/the-worst-job-at-google-a-year-of-watching-beastiality-child-pornography-and-other-terrible-internet-things http://gizmodo.com/5936572/the-worst-job-at-google-a-year-of... http://www.buzzfeed.com/reyhan/tech-confessional-the-googler-who-looks-at-the-wo http://www.buzzfeed.com/reyhan/tech-confessional-the-googler...
- ZenoArrow 10y agoIt's a problem for multiple companies. Some seem to offer counselling. I think the YouTube approach of only offering yearlong contracts is probably a sensible one, though you'd hope there would be some sort of support programme for ex-employees also: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/19/technology/19screen.html http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/19/technology/19screen.html "Flagged videos are then sent for manual review by YouTube-employed content moderators who, because of the nature of the work, are given only yearlong contracts and access to counseling services, according to Victoria Grand, a YouTube spokeswoman." Also, I know this is going to be an unpopular opinion but, it's this kind of problem that puts forward the strongest case for increased online surveillance. I understand it's unfair that everyone will be punished for the actions of a few, but I'd rather be under surveillance than have more damage to the personal lives of these content moderators. Maybe we just aren't yet mature enough as a species for the fully open web we used to have.
- Havoc 10y agoI wonder about people that take these jobs & keep them until burn-out. It's a little like I don't do darkweb stuff because I know I likely won't cope with it. And I don't clean skyscraper windows because I know I don't do well with heights. So it's a case of "Well what the f did you expect?". None of that excuses MS not providing support certainly but realistically these people signed up for something that is pretty much traumatic by definition. Now if MS pitched the job as rainbows & sunshine that's a different story...then they should get sued to hell...
- cududa 10y agoWorking on a comment from my perspective, having known a number of folks on a team that handled these sort of matters, so not going to respond to each point. >"these people signed up for something that is pretty much traumatic by definition." They had no choice in joining the team, reread the article
- electic 10y ago> None of that excuses MS not providing support... I am not sure what the point of your entire comment is. You can't compare fear of heights to watching child porn, murder, rape, and other horrific crimes all day. Almost 99.9 percent of the population is going to develop psychological issues. MS should have provided support knowing what this role entails, they didn't. So here is the suit. [1] [1] https://www.wired.com/2014/10/content-moderation/ https://www.wired.com/2014/10/content-moderation/
- DanBC 10y agoAnd when some bits of MS provided support (take extra time off) other bits of MS were disapproving when the men used that support. > Supervisors authorized him and others to leave work early when they broke down or became overwhelmed by the trauma associated with viewing the depictions. Leaving early on occasions of breaking down was part of the ‘Wellness Plan.’ However, Mr. Blauert was criticized in employment reviews for following his wellness plan.”
- 10y ago
- zitterbewegung 10y agoA lot of people here are taking the position that they weren't "forced" to do it. I think this is a incorrect framing of the problem. I would take the concept that they experienced a workplace injury and weren't informed of the scope of danger that it may pose. Sure everyone has the right to refuse to do a job but changing jobs requires the resources to do so. If you have some type of leverage such as a house or bills to pay then thats an issue. The other problem is how do you perform this moderation? Possibly you could restrict the amount of time someone is exposed to this and then change people out once they have reached some type of exposure but thats primarily speculative.
- RangerScience 10y ago> experienced a workplace injury That sounds like the correct framing. If you think about physical dangers, these are "well understood and handled". It's not just a question of accurate danger assessment, there's also the assumption that the safety equipment provided is sufficient, that the exposure levels are within tolerance, etc. It's just that instead of dosemeters and hazmat suits, it's, say, minutes of content and job-provided therapists.
- TheOneTrueKyle 10y agoYou don't deserve a job, nor is anyone holding a gun to your head. You chose to have kids and a mortgage. I currently work at a giant corp and I see this mentality everywhere and I see nepotism in action because of it. I need to find a new job. What I don't have to do is hang around. (Assuming these people knew what they were getting into)
- Clubber 10y ago>You chose to have kids and a mortgage. So did your parents. Would you wish this upon them?
- TheOneTrueKyle 10y agoSee my other comment about my parents. They sacrificed money and I don't talk to them. And yes I do. I had a shitty childhood though. Edit - also my parents never had a home and a mortgage...
- akjainaj 10y ago>Soto claims he was assigned to the team and didn’t have any choice in the matter. Of course you did. You could've walked out. You simply chose a paycheck over your sanity.
- colemickens 10y agoSo if your boss came to you and said "look at disturbing child porn content all day or lose your ability to provide for your family", you wouldn't have a problem with that or try to seek legal action? The amount people around here try to defend companies and exploitative practices will never cease to amaze me.
- RangerScience 10y ago"You made the choice" is ignoring the people who make the situation in which you make that choice.
- komali2 10y agoIt appears that part of the lawsuit is that Microsoft didn't adequately prepare them for the job. I highly doubt they realized what they were getting themselves into from the start. Furthermore, when it comes to employment lawsuits like this, "didn't have any choice in the matter" is the equivalent of "could have quit instead of doing this." Quitting your job to avoid something your company wants you to do is not a valid answer - the company should not be asking you to do whatever that thing is. Hence, the lawsuit.
- philip1209 10y agoAs a thought experiment, screening for this role from Microsoft's side has to be really difficult. It's a job that needs to be done to protect their users and reputation, but it sucks. If you interview somebody for the position and they're actually enthusiastic about it, that would probably be a huge red flag. I can't imagine a good solution besides machine learning.
- SandersAK 10y agoIt's a little disheartening that people on HN fail to understand that some people don't have a true choice sometimes when it comes to a job. I'm not posting this to shame anyone, but I would ask that before you say things like "well just quit" or "it's on them when they made the choice," consider that not everyone in the world can make the same choices you can, or have the resources, or know-how to make those choices. Self-reliance is obviously important, and something that our community values, but I think being empathetic to those who either cannot or don't know how is crucial to creating products and services that add value in the world. good luck out there, y'all.
- Apocryphon 10y agoAdditionally, a lot of times people might end up in a position where they end up harming themselves or others, by the very force of social conformity. "Oh, if this big prestigious company does this, then it must be alright. This is expected. I must meet expectations."
- TheOneTrueKyle 10y agoI once chose to live in my car instead of taking a crappy job. You absolutely have a choice. I really hate this kind of thinking. So rather than complain, let me ask this to people with kids, which seems to be the people who think they don't have a choice: What is better? Having a job to take care of kids? Or telling the story to your kids about how you left a place because you didn't believe in what the company believed/ was doing/ etc? It seems the latter would let your child see you as a genuine human being who doesn't allow money to dictate their lives. I don't have kids and never intend (on purpose), so please let me know if I am missing something. I don't talk to my parents because they didn't really provide value in my life. But they did sacrifice things for money. Didn't really work out
- ZenoArrow 10y agoNot everyone has savings. Not every country has an extensive welfare system. In some places if you don't earn you don't eat. In those circumstances, are you going to starve or turn to crime just because you didn't want a crappy job?
- guelo 10y agoThere's probably some subreddits and image boards where Microsoft could recruit willing employees to look at this kind of content. Though I don't think I'd want them as my coworkers.
- CaptSpify 10y agoI don't know if this is true or not but... I've heard that they limit the amount of time that you are allowed to serve on the "child services" team for some police departments. The idea is that, no matter how well adjusted you are, this messes with your head, and causes you to lose your cool. Anyone in a position to validate this?
- bitmapbrother 10y ago>Members of Microsoft’s Online Safety Team had “God-like” status, former employees Henry Soto and Greg Blauert allege in a lawsuit filed on Dec. 30. They “could literally view any customer’s communications at any time.” I wonder if these "God like" powers were ever abused. This isn't the first time Microsoft has snooped into their users accounts.
- k_sze 10y agoHere is a rather unbased what-if: I wonder if this PTSD can be alleviated if the content screeners get more positive feedback about what they do, so they don't feel they are just looking at aweful stuff all day long, so they feel they are actually making positive contributions to society, making the world a better place? E.g. what if they can take ownership of what they report to the NCMEC? What if they can call up NCMEC and ask about the progress of cases that were opened because of their reporting? What if they get feedback, like "holy shit, they found and saved this child, and arrested the monster!" What if they held (monthly) partie to celebrate their achievements in fighting crime? (ok, maybe not parties, but something to celebrate and give themselves a pat on the shoulder). I just think they may sleep better at night if they learn that the monsters are now locked up, no longer out there at large, hurting more innocent children.
- whack 10y ago"Soto and Blauert also allege that ... the company violated state law by failing to provide a safe workplace for them and should have realized how harmful viewing such images should have been for their employees." They might have some valid claims and expectations in their suit, but some of their allegations don't really sound reasonable. For example, the above. Of course Microsoft knew that viewing these videos is very psychologically disturbing. Hence why they hired moderators to find and censor them, on a voluntary at-will contract. If we're going to fault Microsoft for exposing their moderators to disturbing content, what exactly do we expect them to do instead? Not have such moderators and allow members of the public to be exposed to these highly disturbing videos instead? The lawsuit sounds a bit too much like firemen suing the fire department because "fighting fires creates an unsafe workspace that is harmful to firemen." If the fire department didn't do everything it can to help its firemen, the lawsuit would certainly be reasonable. But blaming the fire department for the intrinsic and unavoidable dangers involved in the job, doesn't sound reasonable at all.
- prostoalex 10y ago"while both men applied for worker’s compensation while taking medical leaves due to their PTSD, their claims were denied" Why is Microsoft being sued here and not the Washington state agency denying the claim?
- partycoder 10y agoWhenever you allow user generated content, there's a chance of people sharing content that violates the terms of service. I think AI that can identify an activity or situation and flag it automatically is technology that exists to some extent. For cases where the AI cannot determine what is happening with certainty, it might be able to "pre-filter" the image to make it less shocking.
- pluma 10y agoConsidering there are actual (legal) communities around real-life "gore" I think the "had to view child abuse content" part is the less interesting one, although it makes for a better headline. The import part is this: > Microsoft did not warn the workers about the dangers of this line of work and the potential for “debilitating injuries” People seeking out this content and watching it on a regular basis know what they are getting themselves into (even if it's the kind of stuff that wouldn't even fly on sites like 4chan). Regular employees of a software company might not. The moderators should have been screened, prepared and offered free counselling. If this had been the case, I would have argued that they shouldn't be able to claim damages because they knew what they were getting themselves into. As far as "they could have switched jobs" goes -- maybe that would have helped, maybe not. If some of the former moderators are suffering from actual trauma, that can be caused by a single impression. Sticking to the job may actually have been an (unhealthy) coping mechanism. Regular psychological exams might have avoided that. It's negligent. It's a horrifying job and not everyone has the mental strength (or is desensitised enough) to do it but they basically threw them in the cold water at the deep end and then just tried to CYA by saying "if you don't like it, you can do something else" -- but only when the damage had already been done.
- e2kp 10y agoPeople fap on that and it's giving him ptsd. Thats interesting
- sctb 10y agoPlease comment civilly and substantively on HN or not at all. https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- e2kp 10y agoMight have badly expressed myself, I meant its psychologically interesting.