4 ms·
10-pound textbooks should definitely go. To be honest, I have a hard time singling out the kind of book that cannot be adequately (and attractively) represente
by Koshkin 10y ago
10-pound textbooks should definitely go.
To be honest, I have a hard time singling out the kind of book that cannot be adequately (and attractively) represented in a digital format.
Being able to zoom images/diagrams in and out, search, translate, etc. all seem like a big thing.
- ghaff 10y agoEbooks work well for linear (mostly) text. As soon as you have a lot of graphics or you're skipping around a lot in a reference book, they work a lot less well. (Some primarily text-based books that are purely reference, e.g. dictionaries, do work fine in electronic format but in my experience they're the exception.)
- makmanalp 10y agoI don't think this is really a limitation of the medium - a properly designed ebook can have links, references, figures, etc. EPub does suck a bit for this purpose, since it does ignore a lot of typesetting cues, like page breaks. PDFs suck for a different reason - it can't adapt to different text and screen sizes. But we've already solved this problem - HTML does exactly this. Up with HTML books!
- trentmb 10y agoAren't EPubs just zipped HTML+graphic assets?
- makmanalp 10y agoWow, looks like you're right! Then why do epub ebooks suck so bad in general? Probably publishers don't care enough to make them nice.
- yarrel 10y agoFlipping pages is faster for fuzzy search and navigation. I love searchable text though. And a hardcopy book has a built in full-screen productivity mode...
- coldpie 10y ago> To be honest, I have a hard time singling out the kind of book that cannot be adequately (and attractively) represented in a digital format. I can pick up books for a couple bucks at the used book store, and for free or maybe a quarter or two at garage sales. I don't care if I drop them or lose them or if someone borrows them and never gives them back. I'm not likely to be a target for mugging for reading a book the bus or train. I don't have to worry about some web store going out of business or some business deal changing or DRM breaking and invalidating my books. Sometimes digital is better, but not always.
- kasey_junk 10y agoKids picture books and pop out books. A big part of the learning process is getting them to engage with the act of reading by engaging with the physical object. I also worry about my child seeing me reading from an ereader and not a book because it might be harder for them to make the mental jump from "he is reading" instead of "he is consuming content on a tablet" as they look the same. But they are very different activities.
- yarrel 10y agoCD-ROMs such as "Living Books" had this degree of interaction twenty years ago. Not in 3D, though, which I agree is better.
- Kluny 10y agoI was once on a train for 30 hours. I had a book with me that was two inches thick, fine pages, small print, an anthology of 50's science fiction. I was rationing it carefully toward the end of the trip, because after the train ride there was an 8 hour flight. I wished I had a Kindle so I could carry more books - I haven't been without one since.
- LordKano 10y agoI like being able to read while I soak in the tub. I'm not going to spend the kind of money that would be necessary to do that with an e-reader.
- importantbrian 10y agoFunnily enough, textbooks are the one kind of book I really don't like to read in a digital format. I find that I'm constantly flipping back and forth to reference different concepts or check a chart. eBooks are painful for that kind of use case.
- awongh 10y agoI've probably read about 9.5/10 of the last books on a kindle. I think the format is perfect because of several factors: 1. for books I read through once and never actively reference again, or very seldomly 2. I don't have to wait for the paperback to come out 3. I don't have the eye strain of reading on an ipad or my phone 4. For a large majority of my purchases it doesn't make sense to own a physical copy of the book. It seems like it would be a hassle to own and carry and take up space. (also see #2) 5. a kindle is light and cheap enough that I don't have to stress too much about breaking it or leaving it somewhere or it being conspicuous to have out in public However, the kindle fails at some important things: It's not in color, so it doesn't do well for books that are image heavy (even in black and white) - the display is a little too small and any images in the book tend to look terrible for some reason (even though the supposed dpi is relatively high) -which brings me to your point, that in general I find that phones, tablets and kindles are not particularly good at replicating the browsing experience of a certain kind of book. I don't think all books fall into this category, but some important ones do and I can't imagine not having a physical copy for that reason. The last one that comes to mind for me is Code: The Hidden Language of Computer Hardware and Software. I like browsing through all of his examples and diagrams and flipping back and forth through the different parts that interrelate to each other. I've never found an electronic browsing experience that was as good as a physical book. (unless I was at the point of wanting to implement some formal system of organizing and linking my ideas, in which case I think a computer would be preferable) The kindle particularly fails at this experience, as an integrated piece of hardware / software it's merely competent and has a lot of rough edges. It's not as seamlessly integrated in the way iphones (for example) are.
- canadian_voter 10y agoWell the market apparently disagrees with you. Ebook growth is flat or falling. People buy 5 traditional books for every ebook sold. Ebooks have their place. People tell me they like to take them on vacation as backup. I figure half our customers have dedicated ebook readers, and almost all of them have devices that have the capacity to read ebooks. Yet our sales are up, and we're hiring. I'll switch to ebooks when Soylent becomes the primary source of calories in this country. In the meantime I have a nice organic salad to eat and a stack of books to read. Source: I own a bookstore.
- prostoalex 10y agoFor a new release if a hard copy of the book is priced at $20, the e-book is priced at $16 or so. When I'm done with hard copy, I typically either sell it on Amazon marketplace at roughly $12-14, while e-book's resale value is $0. I am not penny-pinching, but there are very few e-books that I want to actually own in order to re-read later, and I'd rather not have the digital junk pile up.
- lb1lf 10y agoMy experience echo the trend you describe above. I have a Kindle. Love it to bits; it has replaced all the paperbacks I used to buy when traveling (Which I do. A lot.) Can't be beat for its compact size and instant gratification - within seconds of deciding I'd like a new book, it is downloaded. Absolutely terrible for anything but clean text, though - add illustrations to the mix, and it looks like it is rendered without any thought given to aesthetics whatsoever. Most photos are just greyish muddles which had better been left out. However, one (unexpected) change occurred after I'd had the Kindle for a while - I realized how much I missed holding an actual book while reading. During the six or so years since I bought my Kindle, I've bought (and mostly read!) 3-400 books; most of them hard covers and quite a lot from what one could call the anti-Kindle - publishers like The Folio Society. (For those not familiar with it - they go the extra mile to make every title they publish a small piece of art - good paper, proper smyth sewn bindings, more often than not an illustrator is commissioned, slipcases - still surprisingly affordable, at least to someone from Norway) ) Norwegian bibliophiles suffer from the fact that just about every bookstore is owned by one of the larger publishing houses - guess what that does to prices; a new novel costs some US$45-50 on release. They even got a law enacted which makes it a crime to sell a book at too deep a discount!
- bigtunacan 10y agoI enjoy the convenience of ebooks and that is the majority of what I read. Personally, when it comes to books related to drawing, art, design, I prefer physical books in these cases. I like to lay these books out on a large working surface while I'm working on new techniques. I have tried digital books for this in the past, but found it inconvenient due to things like screens auto shutting off, poor resolutions, inability to flip quickly back and forth between marked sections causes an interupption in the thought process, etc...