12 ms·
Silicon Valley Needs Startup Drano
- jimmywanger 10y agoIf the fed would raise interest rates, that'd go a long way to helping clear at least some of the backlog. Right now you got a lot of dumb money behind a lot of startups with bad business plans because there's no other place for the money to earn reasonable yields.
- ghaff 10y agoHigher interest rates aren't a magical elixir for investment returns though I agree that there's a lot of dumb money going into bad, me too business plans. However, the author seems to be most focused on how invested money gets out of the pipeline once it's in. In may well be the case that there aren't enough worthwhile tech VC targets to absorb the money people want to put in. (see also the boatloads of cash some companies are sitting on.) But that's a different argument from companies unwilling/unable to exit.
- Spooky23 10y agoThey're not magical, but there's literally nowhere to safely save liquid cash these days. I have a 6% Capital One 360 CD that matured last year. My credit union is offering 2.75% auto loans on 2014 model year cars up to 72 months. Clearly, money is too cheap when you're getting super low rates on terrible loan products.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoIf the car lasts at least 72 months, and you stay ahead of the depreciation, it's not a terrible loan product. It's a benefit of the world being awash in capital.
- jimmywanger 10y agoWell, there is a way for invested money to get out, as she points out. It's just that the incoming money is too great in volume. If we restricted the incoming money, the money in the pipeline would drain out the normal way.
- quanticle 10y agoHowever, the author seems to be most focused on how invested money gets out of the pipeline once it's in. The two problems are related. Money isn't being pulled out of the pipeline because investors are willing to let venture funds hold onto their cash for long periods of time. If investors had other opportunities for getting returns, they'd pressure venture funds to have shorter time horizons, and this, in turn, would lead venture funds to pressure companies to cash out or die.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- obstinate 10y agoS&P 500 returned an inflation adjusted 9% last year (Dec '15-Dec '16). If that's not a "reasonable yield," what is?
- zeroer 10y agoThe S&P 500 returned 12.25% last year. Unless you're throwing money away, you have to count dividends, too. https://dqydj.com/2016-sp-500-return/ https://dqydj.com/2016-sp-500-return/
- obstinate 10y agoThe number you're quoting is pre-inflation adjustment, I think? Or maybe I used the wrong endpoints. I used the calculator on that site [1], with the setting being from December '15 to December '16 since I'm not sure what moment in January '17 they measured. If I go Jan '16 to Jan '17, then we end up with 17.952%, which doesn't sound right. [1]: https://dqydj.com/sp-500-return-calculator/ https://dqydj.com/sp-500-return-calculator/
- zeroer 10y agoYou're right -- 12.25 is nominal, not inflation-adjusted. But inflation was in the range of 1.5-2%, so even adjusted for inflation, the real return exceeds 10% any way to slice it. I'm not sure what your calculator is measuring -- the date selection has a precision of one month. But swings of 5% in a month are common, so I would not immediately discount the idea that there are endpoint dates you could choose to get a 17% return.
- neom 10y agoI've had this thought in my head for quite some time about what I call "bottom line companies" - That is, companies that add "substance" to the bottom line of society. When I think about bottom line companies, I think about GE, AT&T, CN, JetBlue, Mondelez International (Kraft) and the like. I often wonder about how these ventures got started. Over the past 20 years, have we seen many bottom line companies founded? Also, tangentially but interestingly: http://www.inc.com/magazine/19850501/495.html http://www.inc.com/magazine/19850501/495.html
- ColanR 10y agoI'm going to remember that term. Do you think it's possible to quantify that concept?
- neom 10y agoI'm a crappy economist. In theory I think it should be somewhat/somehow linked to productivity. If a company positively impacts national productivity the company would be a "bottom line" company?
- roymurdock 10y agoThe term you're looking for is "natural monopoly". These companies are all so large and old because they were the first players in markets where returns to scale are staggering, and barriers to entry are almost impossibly high to overcome. Most of them were blocked from actually becoming horizontal or vertical monopolies by governments in order to protect consumers and foster innovation. But that didn't stop them from acquiring tangential companies and becoming multinational conglomerates - every country in the world needs Kraft's consumer goods and GE's industrial equipment. Software startups follow an entirely different business model - extremely low costs to entry, entering new markets with high rates of failure. Also, in many successful acquisition exits the startups are acquired and the brand disappears.
- djrogers 10y ago
- edblarney 10y agoThis is called the 'free market' in action. With very low interest rates, and ridiculous Fed policies (QE) designed to 'reinvigorate the economy', but which really just pumped tons of extra cash into stocks and bonds (i.e. mostly the 1%, and institutional holders like pension funds) - you have tons of liquidity chasing value creation. It'd rather seem that 'the power' is now in the hands of those who can create value. Or more cynically: money goes to those who can convince others that value is being created so they can 'collect money' for their product/service. There's nothing inherently wrong with this situation, it just means VC's are getting squeezed, and their 'amazing skill' of being able to 'spot the best opportunities' might be being commoditized a little bit. The 'risk' really is a sudden change one way or the other, i.e. fed-rate change, china-flop, tump-risk or just some general fear based panic causing a bubble burst.
- CalChris 10y agoYour second paragraph completely contradicts your first. Our very low interest rates are anything but free market. They are a Fed monetary policy.
- jartelt 10y agoEmployees are also getting forced to wait much longer before their equity stakes become liquid. It can be tough on an employee if they cannot leave their job without either losing all their options or paying a large upfront tax bill to exercise options (which may not be liquid for a while longer).
- marblar 10y ago> (which may not be liquid for a while longer). (Or ever)
- URSpider94 10y agoI disagree. The article isn't at all about the returns that people are getting on their investments. It's more about the fact that there's a normal lifecycle for venture-backed companies that ends with going public or being acquired. That lifecycle seems to have stalled out with mega-companies staying private for long periods of time. It's still highly likely that Uber's investors will make tons of cash when the company finally decides to go public, whenever that is. It's just that the VC money is staying locked up much longer, so that it's not available to fund other early-stage start-ups.
- gumby 10y agoThe downside of this lack of liquidity is the loss of fees flowing to the investment banks, the key constituency of Bloomberg.com. Oh no! Most financing documents allow the preferred investors to force a registration. And of course the investors want liquidity. So if it's not happening it's because they believe (and can convince their customers, err, LPs to believe) that the return will increase significantly if they wait. I say "significantly" because volatility increases value in the Black-Scholes equation, so forgoing it better be worth it! In the "old" days companies were essentially forced to do an offering when their staff got high enough, as they had enough shareholders that they had to file public reports anyway, so why not do a share offering and get some cash in return for the obligatory hassle. I say "old" days because this applied to FB. Nowadays you can do quite a lot of business with fewer employees so this forcing function is not as powerful as it used to be.
- steffan 10y agoAnother factor is that contemporary companies more often will issue RSUs instead of options. This (afaik) allows a company to avoid hitting the shareholder threshold which would require reporting. IIRC, Facebook didn't have to go public when they did, but once they hit the threshold they would have to start reporting, and at that point there's not much reason to not be a public company. (Another reason cited was allowing early employees to take advantage of the value of their shares without otherwise having to leave the company.)
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> Most financing documents allow the preferred investors to force a registration Registration rights are not a standard part of Silicon Valley financing. Voting rights agreements--which grant the Board or certain members of management your voting rights until IPO--are more prevalent.
- gumby 10y ago> Registration rights are not a standard part of Silicon Valley financing. I am surprised that you write this. Demand registration rights have been part of every equity financing I've done for the last 25 years in the Valley and in NYC.
- bertil 10y agoFor anyone not American: Drano is a drain cleaner brand common in the US.
- draw_down 10y agoAs a developer and therefore a person who benefits when lots of companies have demand for the field I work in, it's unclear to me why I should want "Startup Drano". I'm not a VC nor an LP, I don't mind if VCs waste their money funding "Uber for dog food" or whatever. People starting businesses with bad business models don't offend me on a moral level. It's their funeral, let them make bad decisions if they want.
- Analemma_ 10y ago> People starting businesses with bad business models don't offend me on a moral level. It's their funeral, let them make bad decisions if they want. If you want a good explanation of why you should be offended and why you should want Startup Drano, try: http://idlewords.com/talks/internet_with_a_human_face.htm http://idlewords.com/talks/internet_with_a_human_face.htm. Here's the key quote: "But investor storytime is a cancer on our industry. Because to make it work, to keep the edifice of promises from tumbling down, companies have to constantly find ways to make advertising more invasive and ubiquitous. Investor storytime only works if you can argue that advertising in the future is going to be effective and lucrative in ways it just isn't today. If the investors stop believing this, the money will dry up. And that's the motor destroying our online privacy. Investor storytime is why you'll see facial detection at store shelves and checkout counters. Investor storytime is why garbage cans in London are talking to your cell phone, to find out who you are." When all the free money is chasing advertising-driven business models, the advertising has to get ever more invasive in order to justify valuations. I'm all for letting business stand or fail on their merits if no one but the investors are harmed, but this is a very destructive externality that affects everyone.
- draw_down 10y agoHmm. Indeed that is bad, but I have a feeling what we're really talking about here is capitalism.
- Urbanxassassin 10y agoYes, that is a good portion of America's capitalism perspective.
- chplushsieh 10y agoStartups take several years to exit. So isn't it perfectly normal that it also takes several years for the total value of IPOs and acquisitions, i.e. money that flows out of startups, per year to catch up with the rising trend of total startup investment, i.e. money that flows into startups, per year?
- runamok 10y agoMuch more than a few years these days. So there should be at least a 3 to 5 year offset between comparing money in to money out.
- choxi 10y agoI'm surprised the author didn't mention anything about megarounds. I thought most of the increase in venture capital has been going to megarounds, and that these rounds are being raised exactly because companies want to delay their IPO and remain private longer. That would perfectly explain why there's a lag in the returns on these VC funds, right?
- Floegipoky 10y agotl;dr: plugs ears and closes eyes "there is no bubble, there is no bubble, there is no..." The author does not once address the possibility that less money is flowing out the other side of the pipe because so much of the money going in is being spent on companies that provide no value and will never be profitable.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- snowpanda 10y agoYour comment is spot on with my experience with clients from Silicon Valley. When they bring up their product, there is absolutely no sense of responsibility that their product might fail. Not sure if its a result of entitlement, or living in Silicon Valley for too long. Come to think of it, one might be causing the other.
- URSpider94 10y agoThe real significance of this article is related to the inside baseball of how most venture funds work. See this: http://www.theequitykicker.com/2011/01/12/how-does-the-structure-of-the-vc-industry-impact-investment-strategy/ http://www.theequitykicker.com/2011/01/12/how-does-the-struc... to learn more. In brief: Most venture funds are closed-end funds, with a certain amount committed up front from LP's, where each dollar can only be invested once. The fund stops making investments after 5-7 years, then closes down entirely after 10 years. After 10 years, the managing partners stop collecting their 2% management fee, and any additional returns aren't typically included in the performance of the fund. As such, there's a huge incentive for fund managers to invest early, and find an exit within the time horizon of their fund. A VC who pumped a ton of money into an early stage Uber in 2014 in year 6 of their fund, is going to be pretty screwed if Uber decides not to go public for another 5 years from now. Where this could go sour is that these same fund managers are spending years 9-10 passing the hat to raise money for their next fund. If the typical pool of investors still have a lot of money tied up in previous funds, then they're going to be less likely to ante up for the next fund, since they'd have to double down on VC as a proportion of their portfolio. It's also going to be a tough road show if your story is that you invested millions of dollars in your last fund and it's all still tied up ...
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> It's also going to be a tough road show if your story is that you invested millions of dollars in your last fund and it's all still tied up Depends on what you promised those investors and how the fund is doing. Nobody complains about being in SpaceX or Uber.
- vessenes 10y agoIn practice, this is not the major pain point I think you are calling it. The letters I read often have variants of "We've returned [0.8-2.5x] capital and still have [Uber] in the portfolio!" What may be painful is not being able to at least return capital by the end of the fund without a WONDERFUL story about coming liquidity. Current industry average 10 year IRR is 10% according to Cambridge Associates. You've really fucked things up badly if you can't return capital in year 9/10 on a 10% IRR.
- NelsonMinar 10y agoI feel like I've read this same "there aren't enough IPO exits" about the startup scene since at least 2002. What periods of time in the last twenty years have been considered good for tech VC IPOs?
- obstinate 10y agoI think the period between and including Google and Facebook's IPOs were considered good.
- paulpauper 10y agoLooks like data mining by the author to skim though 5 years of data and extrapolate a single inference from it. Just because something seems like something doesn't mean its important or significant or predictive of anything.
- ryandamm 10y agoYou wouldn't expect the uptick in venture financing to immediately result in an uptick in venture exits. Using the 'pipe' metaphor, the flow takes time. The pipe has nonzero length. In fact, the pipe's length should be roughly the length of the average time to exit for a startup (weighted by exit size). So the latency in the system should be much longer than one year. This is the problem with semi-quantitative thinking. And lazy journalism. Then again, I did click on the link and read the article, so maybe I'm misunderstanding the point: the author got what she wanted out of me.
- blazespin 10y agoThe pipe is too short in those graphs. I think 10 years would be better than 5
- kriro 10y agoI'm not sure it's that wise to look at this years money in and this years money out. Wouldn't it make more sense to look at say the last 5 years of money out and the last 5 years-X of money in (X being 6-10ish, whatever the average time to exit is)? I also only realized what Drano is halfway through the article (non-US guy). Why not use a more generic title that more of the world understands like "Silicon Valley Needs a Startup Plunger"?
- taneq 10y agoIs this not what a bubble burst looks like? It's still easy to pour money into the bubble, but it suddenly gets a lot harder and a lot less certain to pull that money back out?