13 ms·
Paper Centrifuge
- emeraldd 10y agoSometimes the most advanced technology in the world is the simplest most childish thing around.
- omginternets 10y ago"Perfection is achieved not when there is nothing more to add, but when there is nothing left to take away." Seems a propos! :)
- rawnlq 10y ago15 mins of human labor per test doesn't sound cheap but I guess you can get the patient to do it themselves. A bit curious, why is a cheap centrifuge hard to build? It seems like a pretty simple device and motors are pretty cheap.
- sgift 10y agoMotors need power, not having (much) power at hand is often one of the first problems helpers in such situation have, so something which doesn't need power is a huge boon.
- minikites 10y agoExactly. One of the reasons the recent ebola epidemic hit where it did is because there are still many areas where clean water and bleach (which would have prevented much of the outbreak) are difficult to obtain.
- ggame 10y agoDon't forget the cultural practice of kissing dead people.
- emeraldd 10y agoIn the environments this would be used Labor is cheaper than and probably more available than electric power. This could also be built on site rather than trucked in, all you need is the knowledge of how to build it. In some instances, this kind of tool may be the only way to meaningfully accomplish testing.
- mhb 10y agoIt's not: https://diybio.org/2012/06/11/dremelfuge-classic/ https://diybio.org/2012/06/11/dremelfuge-classic/ But presumably this could be for regions in which even those materials are difficult to obtain.
- dekhn 10y agoI use the dremelfuge. It's not particularly safe, but it does get the job done for very basic spin-downs. You don't have really precise RPM control, as well as many other things.
- chillingeffect 10y agoI wonder if you could use a laser tachometer to help dial in the RPM? e.g. https://www.amazon.com/Digital-Photo-Laser-Tachometer-Contact/dp/B001N4QY66 https://www.amazon.com/Digital-Photo-Laser-Tachometer-Contac...
- kognate 10y agoWhile they're not that hard to build, the lab ones tend to be very heavy and not able to survive being carried around and dropped. The centrifuge they describe can be easily transported, is durable, and easy to fix. It's a great idea to be able to provide field medics with a tool like this in difficult environments where a lab grade device would be impractical.
- mrexroad 10y agothink remote villages where it's difficult to bring equipment in, places without electricity, etc. [edit:] from article: A centrifuge is an essential tool for hospitals and labs across the world. Trouble is, centrifuges are expensive, bulky, and require electricity. In poor regions where tropical diseases flourish, these instruments can be hard to come by, thus limiting the ability of point-of-care healthcare workers to do their work. [...] The device, dubbed the “paperfuge,” can reach spinning speeds of 125,000 revolutions per minute (RPM), and exert centrifugal forces equivalent to 30,000 g’s. It’s roughly a hundred times faster than previous non-electrical efforts, and it’s considered the fastest rotational speed ever recorded for a human-powered device.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- BurningFrog 10y agoThis is for areas where humans lives are cheap. 15 minutes of human labor cost very little there.
- chopin 10y agoCheap for us. But maybe not for other people living there.
- juanviP 10y agoReally? Didnt anyone used to do this when you were a kid? http://www.makeandtakes.com/diy-paper-spinner http://www.makeandtakes.com/diy-paper-spinner
- adrianN 10y agoI can't remember using it to centrifuge blood samples, but maybe your childhood was different from mine.
- lightedman 10y agoWe used it to demonstrate centrifugal forces in elementary school by spinning one and putting drops of food coloring in the center. They were made of lightly-waxed parchment paper so you could see a trail it left behind as it got flung off. I'm just surprised it took this long. That particular lesson was... 26 years ago for me.
- oh_sigh 10y agoWell why didn't you tell the world about this 26 years ago. Heck, why didn't you tell the world 2 days ago?
- lightedman 10y agoThen, much like now, I'm too busy with minerals and the inordinate amounts of money people will pay for them.
- oh_sigh 10y agoIt must be tough having no free time over 26 years. Hope retirement goes well for you!
- lightedman 10y agoRetirement? That doesn't happen to workaholics like myself.
- bluetwo 10y agoCool idea but it can't possibly be safe to spin infected blood on a device such as this.
- Declanomous 10y agoI don't know why it would be any more dangerous than a typical centrifuge. Samples are in a vial, and that vial is what is responsible for containing the sample while you spin the samples. Having been around conventional centrifuges that have been destroyed due to improper balance, I assure you that any way you can imagine infected blood being distributed by the paper model would be 10x worse with a normal centrifuge. At least with this method, the motor has a brain and will stop as soon as things start going south. A lot of centrifuges are just controlled by a potentiometer. You couldn't pay me enough to to get close enough to turn one of those off while it is self-destructing. The amount of energy involved is enormous. Someone blew up a (rather inexpensive) medical centrifuge at my school when they balanced some non-water liquid with water. It was a huge mess. Centrifuges are basically designed to contain the most dangerous bits when they explode. They don't keep your error from spraying all over the room.
- bluetwo 10y agoYou are comparing when things go wrong with a centrifuge to every single use of this device. How would you contain the microscopic airborne particles?
- DanBC 10y ago>> Samples are in a vial
- Declanomous 10y agoIn re-reading my comment, I realized it isn't clear that normal centrifuges use vials to contain the sample as well. Regardless, having spent thousands of hours in a lab, I think the traditional lab centrifuge is probably more dangerous.
- ahoka 10y agoWhy is this on the front page?
- chriswarbo 10y agoThis is Hacker News, and this seems like an excellent hack. From http://catb.org/jargon/html/H/hack.html http://catb.org/jargon/html/H/hack.html > Originally, a quick job that produces what is needed, but not well. See also http://catb.org/jargon/html/meaning-of-hack.html http://catb.org/jargon/html/meaning-of-hack.html and https://stallman.org/articles/on-hacking.html https://stallman.org/articles/on-hacking.html
- readhn 10y agoits a nice toy, for kids to learn science. but really, what are we - stuck in the stone age? Its year 2017, there is no reason why those people should not have access to the advanced technology we enjoy today in the west. make a pathetic paper centrifuge and give ourselves a pat on the back, really? What have we become?
- witty_username 10y agoThat's because borders stop them from accessing much greater wages. Even if you find the situation bad, these researchers helped improve the situation.
- readhn 10y agoi understand that they do what they have to do. but lets not kid ourselves that this is some kind of solution that those people deserve. its an interesting student project, sure, if all equipment fails - there is a way to get your hematocrit count manually. How would most of us feel if we came into an office for a blood draw and saw this toy? At the same time when there are machines widely available that will do complete CBC and other panels of blood tests on a single vacutainer tube in under 3 minutes?
- the_watcher 10y agoIf you lived somewhere in which neither were available, you'd want the one that could actually be delivered in time to make an impact.
- MaulingMonkey 10y ago> How would most of us feel if we came into an office for a blood draw and saw this toy? Oh, good, I don't have to reschedule this appointment just because a firmware update took out their centrifuges. Eh? There's been a mass outbreak and the centrifuges are just busy? Frantic centrifuging
- witty_username 10y ago> How would most of us feel if we came into an office for a blood draw and saw this toy? "I might be dying of malaria; I don't care"
- readhn 10y agowhats next? a fake life size cut out image of a doctor with a smartphone attached to it for a speaker? its sad that people have to die because they don't have access to the technology that's not that expensive and readily available in the "developed countries". And now we have to come up with some pathetic paper gizmos to justify our actions? Are we really that developed? Seems to me that we are going backwards...
- witty_username 10y agoJustify what actions? How does this make the West go backward? The researches are helping to improve the situation. If you are so concerned, you can go donate to charities that distribute vaccines.
- readhn 10y agoWhat actions? We keep voting for the government that chooses to fund programs that kill people instead of saving lives. Iraq - Iran - 1 million dead Vietnam - up to 4 million dead Afghanistan - up to 1.5 million dead + trillions of dollars we spent to support all of this.
- hxegon 10y agoI'm not really sure what you are trying to say here. If you have a better solution to centrifuge availability than a 20c one made out of paper, please enlighten us.
- readhn 10y agoyes i have a better solution - kill one of those multibillion military projects and redirect the money to buy lifesaving medical equipment to the places that need it. equip research facilities with equipment and provide local training. paper centrifuge? its like a slap on the face.
- hx87 10y ago> kill one of those multibillion military projects and redirect the money And how are the inventors supposed to do that?
- nneonneo 10y agoAs usual, what you really want to do is read the paper: http://www.nature.com/articles/s41551-016-0009 http://www.nature.com/articles/s41551-016-0009 This is a well-written and very clear paper. It covers several aspects that went unmentioned in the Gizmodo article, and highlights that although building such a device may be trivial, evaluating and studying it is not. Some highlights: the paper covers how the device was built in detail, including information on the three safety mechanisms used to ensure the operator doesn't get exposed to infected blood (shatterproof plastic capillaries, epoxied sample holders made from drinking straws, and sealing of the capillaries inside two paper discs). It is exclusively made from low-cost materials, but it's more than just a piece of paper, handles and some string (fishing wire). The paper also covers the physical dynamics of the "paperfuge" in great detail, analyzing its rotational dynamics and building a theoretical model of motion that agrees well with the physical observations (captured with a 6000fps high-speed camera). It also shows that the max RPM varies with disc size, with 125000 RPM for a small disc (5mm diameter). The paper even mentions that this was submitted as a Guiness World Record. Finally it shows that the paperfuge produces sample separation results on par with electromechanical centrifuges using similar spinning time (1.5min for paperfuge, 2min for centrifuge for plasma separation), and does an analysis of the resulting blood samples.
- HCIdivision17 10y agoThanks a lot for the summary. It's so hard to look at simple things and see how difficult it is to make them a product, and even harder to see the edge cases that prevent it from being used in healthcare. I really like that there's a comparison to commercial centrifuges, since that shows the quality of medical care isn't going down simply to be cheap. Overall it looks like a well thought out design.
- csours 10y agoIf I was using this thing, I would fix one end to a solid endpoint and pull the other end so that I would not be in the line of fire if the thing exploded.
- taneq 10y ago
- readhn 10y agoWalk into any modern hospital central lab today, look at the life saving technology thats available to us and ask yourself why we still have not figured out how to give other people access to this? paper centrifuge? come on...
- DasIch 10y agoYou mean why haven't we achieved world peace and provided the entire world with stable electricity and sufficient capital to build labs and expensive medical equipment to fill them?
- grymoire1 10y agoRe-inventing a 5000-year-old toy is genius? H'okay......
- SamBam 10y agoPutting an ancient toy to a new and brilliant use is genius. If you can find a way to make pick-up-sticks into a seawater desalinator, I'll bet you could get a nice article written up about you too.
- JohnJamesRambo 10y agoI'd be suspect about the quality of the centrifuging since it is changing directions on every spin. But I haven't read the paper so maybe they have checked that. I know that when I centrifuge something delicate, even having even a very light magnetic force brake on the centrifuge on can screw up the pellet at the bottom. Rapidly changing the g-force direction like this seems like the worst case scenario.
- tejtm 10y agoWouldn't the g-force direction always be the same (away from the center) regardless of direction of spin and zero at the inflection between spin directions (normal gravity excepted)?
- JohnJamesRambo 10y agoIf you have something slung on one side of the tube, it will rapidly want to go to the other side of the tube as the centrifuge switches direction on the reverse spin.
- Xylakant 10y agoIf the diameter of the tube is small, the effect of changing direction is neglegtible compared to the centrifugal force.
- Florin_Andrei 10y ago1. The g-force always acts in one direction: towards the outside of the disc. 2. The diameter of the tube is small. It's nearly 1-D dynamics in there. 3. Very large g-forces only happen at top rotational speeds. When not rotating, the material gets slowly mixed back up, but at the regular (i.e. very slow) diffusion speed. So: separation works always towards the outside + re-mixing is a much slower process = it works as expected.
- JohnJamesRambo 10y agoYes I understand what you are saying, that the force is going to the outside of the disc, but using even light braking (over minutes or even hours for ultracentrifuging) can disturb a pellet or separation. This is rapidly coming to a complete stop and reversing direction over and over.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- williamle8300 10y agoThis is awesome! Hopefully no one decides "epi-pen" this idea
- okreallywtf 10y agoLooking at this makes me want to find a way to crowdsource basic research problems like this to try and take advantage of the ingenuity of people who would otherwise never even know that this kind of problem existed. There are probably a lot of problems like this that involve making something incredibly cheap to be used in the developing world. I think people would do that for free if they could know the bare minimum big picture of how their contribution would be used (ie, malaria treatment, even if you have no idea how your gadget could fit in). It could be something like "Need a device that can reach X rpms and can only be made of Y and Z and must cost less than N" and then just see what people can come up with. I'm not sure how it would work on more complex problems but for clever solutions that rely on limited resources and simplicity I would love to see what people could come up with.
- tdaltonc 10y agoI think that if you could get the problem statement as concise as "Need a device that can reach X rpms and can only be made of Y and Z and must cost less than N" then the battle is won. Another example of this kind of innovation that comes to mind is using freezing wax as a heat source to keep neonatal babies warm. http://extreme.stanford.edu/projects/embrace http://extreme.stanford.edu/projects/embrace The problem statement for that would be something like, "neonates need to be kept at a stable temp." For this one it might be, "We need some way to separate blood solids from liquids." But maybe even that is too close to a "solution stated as a problem after the fact." I think that challenges like this are commonly used as exercises for undergrad design students. But I love the idea of expanding it. A version of the x-prizes that require basically no capital, just imagination.
- okreallywtf 10y agoI agree that identifying the 'leaf' problems is the majority of the work but it would be nice to see if you could improve the quality of some of the solutions to these problems by opening them up to the entire world. It would be interesting to see if people in the 3rd world (who are used to making do with less and clever use of materials) could even improve on some lab solutions.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- twiceaday 10y agoI remember doing this with big coat buttons and string when I was a kid.
- feiss 10y agoyup. Amazing application..
- erikcw 10y agoThis is slightly off-topic -- but for any kitchen nerds out there, Dave Arnold of Cooking Issues (amazing podcast[0]) and Searzall fame is doing a crowdfunding campaign[1] to build an "affordable" centrifuge for the kitchen/bar. His goal is to make it the next piece of high-end modernist cooking gear within reach of the home cook... Not anywhere close to the $0.20 cost of this paper centrifuge, but still a pretty huge savings compared to the $6k-$10k units generally available currently. [0] http://heritageradionetwork.org/series/cooking-issues/ http://heritageradionetwork.org/series/cooking-issues/ [1] https://blog.modernistpantry.com/spinzall/ https://blog.modernistpantry.com/spinzall/
- Chris2048 10y agoNot sure the $6k centrifuge isn't a lot better though. See "DO I REALLY NEED TO BUY A CENTRIFUGE?" section here-> http://www.ginandluck.com/clarified-citrus-centrifuge-process/ http://www.ginandluck.com/clarified-citrus-centrifuge-proces... Also, do you have to clean this one each time (as opposed to using different bottles placed inside?
- erikcw 10y agoOf course the home cook doesn't need a centrifuge -- but I sure do want one! Kind of like how I started cooking sous vide 5 years ago with nothing but a pot, a probe thermometer, some ziplock bags, and a ton of patience. 3 meals later an I was wiring together my first home-made circulator...
- Chris2048 10y agoMy point is, that section discusses pricing. BTW, did you document the home made circulator? I bought a bunch of Anovas during cyber Monday, and wondering if that works out economically...
- onchance 10y agoThe lab behind this invention is led by Manu Prakash, a MacArthur Fellow [1] with a knack for unconventional solutions. He's the same guy who developed Foldscope, an ultra low cost microscope [2][3]. [1]: https://www.macfound.org/fellows/965/ https://www.macfound.org/fellows/965/ [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foldscope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foldscope [3]: https://www.ted.com/talks/manu_prakash_a_50_cent_microscope_that_folds_like_origami https://www.ted.com/talks/manu_prakash_a_50_cent_microscope_...
- agumonkey 10y agoHeh, not surprising. I must follow this Man.
- agumonkey 10y agoBeautiful, beautiful, just beautiful. Reminds me of primitivetechnology on YouTube. I'd love to see how far one can go with 'simple' physics.
- titzer 10y agoPart of me wonders, A.) if it's possible to enrich uranium using something like this, and B.) how many man-years of hand-spinning it would take to get enough weapons-grade material that way. Back of the envelope calculation: U-235 is a little less than 1% of naturally occurring Uranium, so supposing that you could load up 1 gram of Uranium per spin session, you'd get a maximum of 10 milligrams per session, so you'd need about 2.2 million sessions to get the requisite 22kg of U-235. Of course, you'd get nowhere near 100% efficiency out of a hand centrifuge in the first spin session, so it would probably require a cascade of several stages. If each stage gets rid of half of the U-238, then the number of spins you would need to get to 100% would asymptotically approach 2x, so we are looking at 4.4 million spin sessions. If each were to take 1 minute, we'd need about 8 years. To be honest that seems overly optimistic, and there are probably technical details like dealing with UF6 gas that are way harder than I thought. (happy to be corrected by a Nuclear engineer if there is one around).
- celticninja 10y agoAnd still a better product than whatever Thanos was working on.