7 ms·
Librarians in Florida went rogue to save 2,300 books from an algorithm
- paulddraper 10y ago> His creation, the fictional Charles Finley, FYI, that's the alias of choice for Sam Axe, a freelance vigilante in the TV series "Burn Notice" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sam_Axe#Sam_Axe_as_Chuck_Finley https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sam_Axe#Sam_Axe_as_Chuck_Finle...)
- the_watcher 10y agoChuck Finley also pitched in the MLB for 16 years[1]. The weirdest part of the whole story to me was that he gave his fake ballplayer the name of an actual ballplayer. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chuck_Finley https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chuck_Finley
- neaden 10y agoWhile I can certainly sympathies with the Librarian in this story and agree that human judgement should trump an algorithm in what books a library stocks the method used here seems inappropriate and counterproductive in the long term.
- dekhn 10y agoI agree. Library stocks really do need to be managed (nobody claimed any one library has to be "complete"), and circulation numbers are the strongest signal that a book is valuable. Working around that to "save" books when budgets are limited is actually zero-sum and will have consequences elsewhere in the system.
- sfrailsdev 10y agocirculation numbers look at recent circulation, with no consideration of the way certain books may change in popularity. Here we have a Domain expert without financial motive who is saying that the algorithm is inefficient. Algorithms should inform book culling decisions made by the Librarian, but they shouldn't replace the Librarian's knowledge and expertise.
- ashark 10y agoI don't use our local library system much because they stock few or no copies of the things I'm interested in getting from them, like non-fic outside the poppiest of pop-non-fic—not even hardcore academic stuff necessarily, just not-garbage non-fic—math/computing books, and semi-obscure classics or translations. It's usually a waste of time to even check for those sorts of things there, and they don't even seem to be part of an inter-library loan program that can provide them. How can circulation numbers take into account people who aren't using the library because it already doesn't have anything they want? I can't be alone in this, but simply looking at circulation numbers won't capture that, and piloting with a book or two from those categories won't get me back in (I probably won't notice because, after many disappointments, I've mostly stopped looking). Let an algorithm go nuts on that data without human judgement and I suspect you'll gradually put more and more people in my position, unless it's a damned smart one.
- cfmcdonald 10y agoAny chance they have an interlibrary loan system? I can get all sorts of books from a variety of library systems (including the main state university libraries) delivered to my local town branch.
- anigbrowl 10y agoInterlibrary loan is great, not least because it's given us WorldCat, but it's no excuse for having a crappy collection. Libraries should of course add new things constantly, but the library is not just a lending club for poor people; it's meant to function as a repository of renewable intellectual content, and provide people with the opportunity to encounter ideas they might not otherwise.
- stinkytaco 10y agoWe do a few things: 1. Regular strategic planning which includes a community survey. This is conducted by an outside firm and non-users are targeted as part of the survey. We also do focus groups. 2. Interlibrary loan. You local library can likely get titles from other libraries. This should inform the collection. 3. Patron driven acquisition. Some way of suggesting books should be available. We buy most suggestions and find that books that are suggested circ better than ones selected by staff (generally, anyway).
- canadian_voter 10y agoand circulation numbers are the strongest signal that a book is valuable I disagree. A book might go out once and chance someone's life. Another might go out a hundred times and sit unread, or have a negligible impact. An algorithm can't determine this. A good librarian can.
- anigbrowl 10y agocirculation numbers are the strongest signal that a book is valuable LOL no, by that logic The da Vinci Code or Harry Potter books would be literary landmarks. Now, I enjoy a good yarn as much as anyone (and Dan Brown and JK Rowling write great yarns) but it's not like books and the book selling industry are all a giant intellectual meritocracy, marketing and commercial leverage have a lot to do with it. Certainly popularity is a useful signal, but things can be popular because they appeal to a lowest common denominator rather than because they're of great quality. Let's take JK Rowling's Harry Potter works as an example. They're excellently crafted in terms of narrative pacing, clear characterization, and engaging storytelling. I enjoyed them hugely when I read them a few years ago, and happily spent a week or 10 days immersed in the wizarding world. Anyone who likes reading can enjoy them, and aspiring writers can learn plenty from studying them. At the same time, they're very formulaic and recycle lots of common fictional tropes --- indeed that's partly why they're worthy of study, - their very shallowness makes it easier to spot the structural features. But we would be making a mistake is took the excellent qualities as the standard of value, because the popularity of Harry Potter and its many imitators in the marketplace would have a tendency to crowd out books that excel in other areas where works of popular fiction are deficient. It's fine for publishers and bookstores to pursue the public taste wherever it leads, but the function of the library is provide more rounded and balanced offerings whose value will span generations rather than only focusing on what's most popular. There's a lovely little library a few blocks from me that I thought I would spend one day a week in when I first saw it, but I hardly ever go there because the selection is abysmal. It's full of multiple copies of things that used to be popular, and woefully lacking in good things that were never very popular. A library's primary purpose is to be full of good books so that even if you can't find a particular work you hoped to read today (perish the thought that one might have to wait for anything...), you will have many high quality alternatives. This is only possible of you allow librarians to do their job as curators. They should not be required to distil years of complex and highly individual literary and organizational knowledge into the sort of simplistic metrics that appeal to professional administrators. Of course, part of the problem is that some people see the intellectual and cultural diversity of libraries as a cultural threat that has the potential to undermine the status quo, and thus attack the function and independence of publicly-funded libraries in an effort to curtail rather than curate the spread of knowledge.
- drzaiusapelord 10y ago> and agree that human judgement should trump an algorithm in what books a library stocks Why? People are much more biased than machines. If this algorithm is well written and unbiased then we may have a case of someone saving books that speak to their biases. What if it was revealed it was books about young earth, anti-vaccination, promotion of Islamic extremism, and white supremacy? Would you be so welcoming of these rebel librarians? The nice part of the algorithm is that, in theory, it should just be looking at circulation numbers and culling appropriately. Regardless, this is all a stop-gap measure until we can get every library digital so we don't have to worry about shelf space.
- cestith 10y agoAn algorithm that only takes into account popularity and not reviews nor importance of the work to literature or to its technical field contains its own biases.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoSays who? It could cross-reference a list of important cultural works and make them exempt, for example. That list can be compiled by a committee instead of a lone guy who may have an agenda.
- anigbrowl 10y agoBut the whole point of librarians is to allow that to happen, rather than thinking there's one perfect list of books that everyone should just copy from. For sure you would see lots of bias - which you could then measure and challenge, but which could also turn out to be valuable. It's odd to me that you can't see the inherent bias in saying that popularity is a proxy for literary value and designing your algorithm around that. Sure, it'll give you an unbiased insight into what's popular, but that assumes that libraries are in the business of catering to the popular taste, when we have a bustling private sector to do that for us already, which takes account of the fact that a great deal of the publishing industry's output is disposable and of only short-term interest. I mean, McDonalds is arguably the world's most popular restaurant chain, but that doesn't mean their food has significant gastronomic value, does it? What is in the public interest, and what the public is currently interested in, are two wholly different things.
- anigbrowl 10y agoWell if you take people's autonomy away they're going to find other routes to the same objective. Librarians aren't shelf-stocking robots, but the law as written devalues their professional contribution in favor of a foolish consistency.
- brudgers 10y agoBooks book culling reminds me of: 1984 Canticle for Leibowitz Fahrenheit 451 The Name of the Rose
- neaden 10y agoAt the same time new books keep coming out, either a library stops buying new books, continually expands so it always has more room, or disposes of some old books. I think an algorithm is a good guide, but I would trust the Librarians to be able to veto it's recommendations and keep some books that are not read often.
- a3n 10y agoYeah, the algorithm probably needs adjustment and flexibility. As long as a book is available within reasonable time via inter-library loan, the library system hasn't lost the book. The algorithm (or more generally, "the practice") probably needs a "consolidate" outcome in addition to "drop."
- brudgers 10y agoInter-library loan is a distributed peer to peer system. There's no reason to believe that other libraries won't cull the same book...and culling from one library could be considered empirical evidence that it might be culled from other libraries.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> As long as a book is available within reasonable time via inter-library loan, the library system hasn't lost the book. That's not entirely true, as there is a significant difference between having a book browsable on the shelf and havingnit borrowable with substantial latency via ILL, so there is a loss even if there is still some access available.
- brudgers 10y agoI know how it's played out at my local library. The shelves are significantly less full and there are fewer of them. What did they cull? Among the the books was Richard Rhodes' Making of the Atomic Bomb which won a Pulitzer. Elsewhere though, there's eight shelf feet of Orson Scott Card and twelve of Danielle Steel.
- tokai 10y agoI do not understand why he loaned them with a fake name. He could just have made the loans in his own name. If they questioned his high loan numbers, he could have told them that he was compiling a bibliography, or researching typography, or something, in his own free time. He went through a lot of trouble to make what he did illegal.
- lotu 10y agoI doubt he knew this was illegal. Charging someone with faking a library card is about the same level as shutting down a lemonade stand for failure to have a business license.
- canadian_voter 10y ago> He says his aim was actually to save the library money in the long run, by not having to repurchase books which often go in and out of fashion with readers. One of Finley’s choices, for instance, was John Steinbeck’s “Cannery Row.” Any librarian worth their salt will tell you that every library should have a copy of Cannery Row. Any algorithm that says it should be discarded is simply wrong. Circulation numbers can be very useful. But they cannot tell you what people will be looking for in the future. Common sense and experience are necessary to put the list in the proper context. A good librarian can talk knowledgeably about thousands of books. They are community treasures that are not easily replaced by algorithms. They do a lot more than just put books on the shelf. Just as there will always be bartenders, there will always be librarians. There is a culture war going on in libraries. The old guard -- book reading, book loving librarians -- are being replaced, especially at the top, by hip "Library Scientists" who want to push ebooks, internet access terminals and even rock concerts in libraries. Ultimately there is a balance to be struck. Budgets are tight and libraries are evolving. But if libraries are going to remain useful and relevant, they will need to provide both internet access AND copies of "Cannery Row". That said, the guy in the article did a bad thing and he'll likely lose his job at minimum.
- stinkytaco 10y agoThere's more than just the merit of the title to consider, however. Condition is an ignored part of many library collection policies. Books that look old and dirty are a turn off for users. I've said over and over again, "If a book is worth buying, it's worth buying again." If in doubt, throw it out. Buy a new one.
- jbob2000 10y agoCurious why you think Cannery Row is such an important novel?
- canadian_voter 10y agoWell, it's no Of Mice and Men, but: - Steinbeck is a major American writer (Pulitzer Prize, Nobel Prize). I feel like any library should have a complete collection of his works, if possible. - He wrote a sequel called Sweet Thursday.If you're going to keep a copy of that, you'd best keep Cannery Row too. - It's really thin. Like maybe 1/6 of an inch. Won't take up much space. - It's often assigned in schools. To be honest, I didn't like it very much. Now that I think about it, maybe the algorithm was on to something. :)
- sbuttgereit 10y agoAnd yet no discussion of what books were not carried that otherwise could have been without this distortion in data. It's fine to talk about the merits of what was saved, but it is a false discussion if there isn't some inclusion of what opportunities may have been lost as well.
- mixmastamyk 10y agoSounds like if shelf-space is at a premium, free ebooks for everything over say, 50 years old should be the norm. (Broken copyright law is the likely impediment). Sure, keep a few physical copies for popular classics but ebooks are clearly the solution for the long tail, and so much easier to carry.
- anigbrowl 10y agoI don't agree. You can't browse an ebook the same way you can a physical book, and while I very much appreciate Amazon's 'you might also like...' suggestions, I only rate thema round a C+/B- grade. The great value of libraries and bookstores is discoverability as opposed to perfect organization (although that's also very valuable). I can think of quite a few books that I might not have encountered if some librarian or buyer hadn't bucked the prevailing taste; conversely on the rare occasions when I go into a big bookstore now I feel really alienated by the shallowness of the selection and the general lack of awareness among the bookstore staff about, well, anything. I never encountered this attitude of 'books as product' until I came to the US. I remember going into a Borders and looking for some Dashiell Hammett books - I had been in San Francisco a few months, and Dashiell Hammett was a very famous mystery writer who came from and wrote about SF in the 1930s, so I wanted to learn more about the literary culture of the city I had moved to. the people in the store had never heard of him, didn't understand why interest in local authors would be a thing, and couldn't recommend any other bookstores because they were not really Book People, they just happened to work in a store that sold books but whose corporate culture required staff to refer to them as 'product'. This would be like going to a store that specialized in Computer Science books and having to deal with people who had never heard the names Turing, Von Neumann, or Knuth. Capitalism can be very corrosive of culture that way, Absent a reliable metric for quality, it can only rate popularity and novelty and so discounts long-term relations at the expense of short-term returns. Amazon recommendations are often semantically on point but it will often recommend books that are merely derivative. 'Frequently bought together' is a great reminder to get some batteries or accessories for some electronic gizmo you bought, but that doesn't work so well for books, where reading one might alter your subsequent buying preferences onto a new path because you read the book and it changed your perspective in some fashion. Admittedly a lot of my reading tends towards the obscure, so I can't blame Amazon for doing what they do if it works for the vast majority of their consumers. It's great when I want something very specific and I'm a happy regular customer, but I could happily spend hours in a second hand bookstore.
- stinkytaco 10y agoSo, I'm a librarian. Our library uses what's called the CREW method [1]. It does a good job explaining the reasons for weeding and the parameters. It's important to mention that a well maintained collection gets used more than one that is not reviewed. The "younger" the average age of your collection, the more it gets used. This isn't just because people don't like old books, but they don't like books that are yellowing, grey, worn, irrelevant, etc, etc. I recognize that libraries have many roles to play, but it is not the place of every library to play every role. A community public library should check out books, not store them. (There's obviously exceptions here. For example, my library maintains a local history collection). Ultimately, for a public library there is much more going on than books. Wireless Internet, meeting rooms and simply its characteristic as a physical place (chairs, tables, etc.) are all part of why people support a library and having a new, clean and well maintained collection is part of increasing the library's appeal across all those areas. 1: https://www.tsl.texas.gov/ld/pubs/crew/index.html https://www.tsl.texas.gov/ld/pubs/crew/index.html
- jdmichal 10y ago> A community public library should check out books, not store them. There's obviously exceptions here. For example, my library maintains a local history collection. I could certainly see the value of each community library having some space allocated to different "specialty" sections. That would make for a pretty rich loan inventory.
- stinkytaco 10y agoAbsolutely. I've been to libraries with good specialized collections. Most of these focus on local interests or history. I've also been to many libraries that just feel like dumps and are not using space well. They have masses of cookbooks or old magazines that they call a special collection. There's a fetish surrounding "the book". In the end this guy is arbitrarily deciding which books have value and which don't, which should ring an alarm bell for us. We might agree with what he saved, but we also don't know what he didn't feel was worth saving. That's why as systemic approach is so important.
- jackskell 10y agoAnd, not one comment here or in the story about associating book title viewing activity with a library account with personally identifiable information. They could have used book activity records, I think. I guess stripping personal information was too much work.