5 ms·
As someone who ended up working in a company with "dynamic scheduling" after college, i.e. Walmart and call centers, I have an ethical problem with this product
by lovich 10y ago
As someone who ended up working in a company with "dynamic scheduling" after college, i.e. Walmart and call centers, I have an ethical problem with this product. Many workers at the bottom of the wage scale have a need for multiple jobs just to pay for rent and food. The companies I worked for with dynamic schedules seemed to use the scheduling to force their employees into a sort of indentured servitude by pressing on this need. They would change your schedule every week, and if you didn't say you were available your hours would be cut to nothing which would make putting food on the table literally impossible some weeks.
The only thing that helped alleviate this pressure from the company was arguing that you couldn't have seen a schedule change over the weekend if you had not been originally scheuled to come in that day. All I see this tool doing is helping managers force schedule changes ay any moment and forcing employees into an even worse situation.
Nothing against the founders for their hard work, but this is the sort of business I couldn't ethically invest in even if it gave me a guaranteed large return
- philip1209 10y agoThis V2 product is not dynamic algorithmic scheduling. Managers manually schedule, just like they would on paper. The focus is more on clear communication to the employees. In the future, we want to focus on data integrations (e.g. surfacing vacation days from other apps) and shift swaps (which largely benefit workers).
- lovich 10y agoMy point is that managers are already manually scheduling employees on a way that hurts the employee but benefits the company. The inability to guaruntee that scheduling updates were seen by the employee was the only thing I saw that kept people from being put to 0 hours or getting fired. I witnessed multiple events where someone had acknowledged a schedule change with a manage with a <1 week notice and had to refuse it. Every single time that happened, that person suddenly had 0-4 hours of work each following week. I don't see this product doing anything but forcing employees into even tighter servitude for the worst paying employers with how the current situation is in America. If there were greater workplace protections for employees concerning schedule changes I would not have such an issue with this product
- philip1209 10y agoWe're seeing the market care more about responsible scheduling now. The delayed Obamacare rules means that many more workers are eligible for overtime. We've seen many workers happy about this, and we're seeing more businesses take ownership of scheduling. If nothing else, Staffjoy maintains strict audit logs and could eventually help companies evaluate managers (average lead time per schedule, etc).
- lovich 10y agoI might be talking from a position of ignorance then as I haven't worked these jobs in about 5 years, but how are the Obamacare rules making companies care? My experience was that any benefit got tied to n hours of work per week, employees were scheduled to n-1 hours. This was held to so strictly across multiple companies that at one point I was told to work 2 hours overtime on a Thursday. The next Friday, the last day of the week for the business, I had the owner show up from their home in another state to take over from me exactly 2 hours before my shift was scheduled to end and I was sent home. If you're targeting mid tier and above businesses where someone can live off the salary of that one job, I could see them using this for a great benefit for both employee and the employer.Unfortunately I can't see any way that an employer paying minimum wage wouldn't use this to control their employees even more strictly than before
- softawre 10y agoHey, I work in a similar space. What has changed over the past five years is remote work. A call center can better fit their input by scheduling employees for a couple hours in a shift, and an employee can be happy with that if they can work that 2 hours from their living room. It looks like a win/win based on the customers I have talked to.
- 1123581321 10y agoIt sounds like you are saying that employees need to be able to passively resist schedule changes by staying ignorant of them. That sounds dysfunctional and like an impossible situation to maintain indefinitely. And, I don't see how remaining ignorant of a schedule can help an employee continue to be scheduled. You might think that ideally, schedules should be constant. However, businesses have a legitimate need to reschedule based on unexpectedly high or low volume, illnesses, emergencies, and so on. It isn't unethical to make reschedules easier for either employers or employees.
- lovich 10y agoIt's unethical to continue to give more and more power to one side in a situation where that side is already overpowered. Businesses may have a legitimate need to reschedule but they don't want to pay for it. Having an employee available for schedule changes 24/7 is no different then having them on call 24/7, except in this case the employees are not paid for the on call hours. Additionally the companies pay so little that employees are forced to have multiple jobs, which is impossible to do when one or more jobs will be changing schedule at random. Going back to the point about legitimate business needs for rescheduling. My experience was that those events accounted for less than 5% of the scheduling changes. Every employee would be working a different shift almost every day, resulting in the same number of employees working during each shift, but in a way that was maximally disruptive to the employees. I'd agree with you that this sort of situation is dysfunctional, but companies use ignorance to their benefit all the time. The laws companies break and then go, "oops" or even better have no reaction at all, show up on this forum all the time. I don't see why we should work towards removing that tool from employees
- 1123581321 10y agoSome fair points, especially that there is a difference between weekly availability and on-call availability. However, if businesses are already doing that and employees are struggling to defend missing shifts and keep their jobs, isn't there some benefit to the employees, who already think of themselves as on-call, to at least get the notice? Honestly, if the situation you are describing is real, I don't see how employees who don't check the paper schedule daily actually keep their jobs anyway and they might as well save gas and gain the ability to react to their new schedule instantly rather than hours later. If the same notification technology ends up making it painless to switch shifts and line them up, or even to automate more consistent shifts, does that change the ethics for you?