3 ms·

Is Trello really a competitor though? JIRA and Trello couldn't be more different. I'd think Trello and Asana are much closer competitors. JIRA is like an over

Is Trello really a competitor though? JIRA and Trello couldn't be more different. I'd think Trello and Asana are much closer competitors. JIRA is like an over engineered spaceship with more features than anyone could learn in a lifetime. Comparatively Trello functions more like a Prius. Priuses and spaceships don't compete.

wattt 10y ago
Yes, I just recently evaluated switching my small team from JIRA->trello. I'd do it in a heartbeat if the licensing costs were better aligned.
matthewmacleod 10y ago
I totally agree. Trello is not a competitor to JIRA. Don't get me wrong – I like them both. When I have to plan out personal projects, Trello is great. During the day, we use JIRA. The use cases are different, and the products are both suitable. I'm madly bemused that people look at the very, very surface layer of the UI (oh look, it has cards in columns!) and assume the products are the same.
RUG3Y 10y ago
I think Trello fills a niche for people who don't need all of the features that JIRA provides, but they need something to track tickets/cards/whatever you want to call them. The products are pretty different but I can envision an overlap of users. I use both currently and if I didn't have Trello, I might have to use JIRA for everything.
farkas 10y ago
We don't view JIRA and Trello as competitors. JIRA shines in areas that (a) have workflow and (b) require repeatable processes across a number of people. Once you have 20+ people on a project, you need repeatable processes. In cases like bug tracking, project management, customer service, help desks, HR onboarding and hundreds others you need workflow. Trello shines in areas where you have (a) small teams or (b) require ad-hoc semi-structured data. In small teams, even if repeatable process would help you, it's not worth the cost of setting up a system - you achieve it by social means. Trello also has many, many use-cases where you want to start something quick, or personal. In this case it really shines, with near-zero friction to get started. Scott, CEO Atlassian
- makmanalp 10y ago
  This. I hear a lot of whining about JIRA, which is fair since it's a huge pain to configure and learn all the quirks of, but usually it's overkill for those folks (perhaps myself included right now). But the folks who have a working process and a large number of people and teams are usually complaining the other way round: that no tool supports their workflow. Which is where JIRA shines. I don't know another tool that can be configured to such ridiculous detail. The Trello acquisition makes total sense because it fills in that gap that JIRA is bad at.
- nimchimpsky 10y ago
  "We don't view JIRA and Trello as competitors." You might not view them as that, but they are, well were.
- haack 10y ago
  On a side note, I think it's great that you're involved in the discussion here.
jimbokun 10y ago
"Is Trello really a competitor though?" In the Innovator's Dilemma sense, absolutely.

wattt 10y ago

Yes, I just recently evaluated switching my small team from JIRA->trello. I'd do it in a heartbeat if the licensing costs were better aligned.

matthewmacleod 10y ago

I totally agree. Trello is not a competitor to JIRA. Don't get me wrong – I like them both. When I have to plan out personal projects, Trello is great. During the day, we use JIRA. The use cases are different, and the products are both suitable. I'm madly bemused that people look at the very, very surface layer of the UI (oh look, it has cards in columns!) and assume the products are the same.

RUG3Y 10y ago

I think Trello fills a niche for people who don't need all of the features that JIRA provides, but they need something to track tickets/cards/whatever you want to call them. The products are pretty different but I can envision an overlap of users. I use both currently and if I didn't have Trello, I might have to use JIRA for everything.

farkas 10y ago

We don't view JIRA and Trello as competitors. JIRA shines in areas that (a) have workflow and (b) require repeatable processes across a number of people. Once you have 20+ people on a project, you need repeatable processes. In cases like bug tracking, project management, customer service, help desks, HR onboarding and hundreds others you need workflow. Trello shines in areas where you have (a) small teams or (b) require ad-hoc semi-structured data. In small teams, even if repeatable process would help you, it's not worth the cost of setting up a system - you achieve it by social means. Trello also has many, many use-cases where you want to start something quick, or personal. In this case it really shines, with near-zero friction to get started. Scott, CEO Atlassian

makmanalp 10y ago
This. I hear a lot of whining about JIRA, which is fair since it's a huge pain to configure and learn all the quirks of, but usually it's overkill for those folks (perhaps myself included right now). But the folks who have a working process and a large number of people and teams are usually complaining the other way round: that no tool supports their workflow. Which is where JIRA shines. I don't know another tool that can be configured to such ridiculous detail. The Trello acquisition makes total sense because it fills in that gap that JIRA is bad at.
nimchimpsky 10y ago
"We don't view JIRA and Trello as competitors." You might not view them as that, but they are, well were.
haack 10y ago
On a side note, I think it's great that you're involved in the discussion here.

jimbokun 10y ago

"Is Trello really a competitor though?" In the Innovator's Dilemma sense, absolutely.