4 ms·
Why would a robot inherently want to make a better robot, or change itself?
by sp332 10y ago
Why would a robot inherently want to make a better robot, or change itself?
- api 10y agoI love "stupid" questions like this. We can say that the vast majority of living beings on Earth do not seem to seek any form of radical self improvement beyond ordinary developmental learning and mastery of survival skills. There is no intrinsic reason that there must be an impulse to exceed oneself. Why would AI be different?
- JackFr 10y agoWhy indeed would an AIs motivations even be comprehensible to us.
- manmal 10y agoBecause we have neural networks in our heads. Sure, very differently structured, semantically and physically.
- enraged_camel 10y agoBecause an AI would be created by humans, and would therefore be modeled after human intelligence. An alien AI, on the other hand, would most likely be incomprehensible to us, at least until we understood the aliens that created it.
- Almaviva 10y agoMost of the smartest humans spend a significant part of their lives in learning and mastery of skills that go beyond survival.
- jack_pp 10y agoAnd not all hosts in the show are conscious. I would say that is a great metaphor for our current society, where you could say that the vast majority of humans aren't really conscious. They might eat and have sex and fight to survive, just like a host does. But they don't really comprehend what it means to be alive. AI's, like humans, need a purpose. The best way of achieving that purpose is by self improvement so any AI which does not self improve to some extent will be replaced by another that will. Just like humans who don't care to self improve eventually don't reproduce enough to spread their genes.
- sp332 10y agohttps://www.xkcd.com/610/ https://www.xkcd.com/610/
- Almaviva 10y agoIf it has any general goal at all that it takes seriously, it will be better achieved with self-improvement.
- pharrington 10y agoHow much wattage needs to be spent increasing its intelligence? How many watts will that save in achieving its original goals?
- rubber_duck 10y agoWho said anything about a robot wanting to do anything ? The creator would obviously - he would certainly not build a theme park with his robots. Imagine for one second that you could build such level of AI and robots - do you really think you would need to build a theme park to finance it - WTF ?!? It's like when the AI used human brains as electricity generators in matrix - but at least that movie had cool music and fight scenes.
- sp332 10y agoThey were trying to produce consciousness, not raw intelligence. The park was for the robots at first. After Arnold killed himself, Ford opened the park to humans to get money in a pinch without giving up control of the bots.
- rubber_duck 10y agoYou don't get it - even if you're some dreamer scientist genius who's trying to build whatever - if they actually got to that level of intelligence the tech would have been "acquired" by military/other companies/whoever and very quickly used for self improvement to get better results. If you could build that level of AI you are absolutely not building a open access theme park to fund it - how's that even remotely plausible to you ?
- noiv 10y ago> plausible Can't imagine the character played by A. Hopkins would even pick up a phone call from military.
- gnaritas 10y agoWith that kind of tech, they wouldn't allow him the option of choosing. It'd be classified immediately as a national security issue and the government would assert ownership via eminent domain. We do not live in a world where a lone genius would be allowed to do what happens in that show.