12 ms·
The science of Westworld
- ygra 10y ago> This sort of “escape hack” isn’t possible for human players because you have to do too many precise actions too quickly, so in the video it’s performed by a separate computer wired up to the gameport. Well, someone did the credits warp manually, at least: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HxFh1CJOrTU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HxFh1CJOrTU The video in the article shows basically shellcode injection, but that's not timing-sensitive, it'd just take longer for a human. And, as seen above, similar things are possible for humans, if just less convenient to do so.
- wtfishackernews 10y agoHe also injected flappy bird into SMW manually. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hB6eY73sLV0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hB6eY73sLV0
- oh_teh_meows 10y ago> The video in the article shows basically shellcode injection, but that's not timing-sensitive, it'd just take longer for a human. And, as seen above, similar things are possible for humans, if just less convenient to do so. Wow that just gave me an idea for a story. Humans found out they are mere pawns in a simulated reality, discovered a 'hack' to alter reality, but the 'hack' would take hundreds of years to complete. So generations of humans toiled over at completing the 'hack', passing the baton through each generation. There could be so many possible storylines from this - corruption/destruction of reality, dictator wanting to change the past, or a cult hell-bent on changing reality, or sorcerers practicing 'magic', or a lone protagonist who's on the verge of completing that hack after hundreds of years, but suffer from ethical conflict and existential crisis.
- IgorPartola 10y agoCheck out Off to be a Wizard. You will enjoy it.
- oh_teh_meows 10y agoSweet! Thanks I'll check it out.
- splicer 10y agoMy answers to those example bAbI questions don't match to "correct" answers. I guess I'm not human...
- sssparkkk 10y ago"Lily is a swan. Lily is white. Bernhard is green. Greg is a swan." -> "What color is Greg? Answer: white" At the risk of sounding somewhat stupid, but shouldn't this contain "Swans are white" for it to be a correct answer?
- NicoJuicy 10y agoI think no, Lilly = Swan, Swan = White, Bernhard = Green, Greg = Swan. Color of Swan or Greg = White
- 6d6b73 10y agothe correct answer, especially for any AI system should be - it likely that it's white but there is no way to know for sure. Australian black swans are black, but chicks are light grey:) Lilly could be chick while Greg could be adult Australian swan
- mlnhd 10y agoGreg is white. Also, Greg is Lily.
- phreeza 10y agoThat would make it a classic logic "puzzle". I think these Babi tests are meant to incorporate more fuzzy concepts. If you read this sentence to a 4-year-old, she would probably answer 'white', right?
- nkoren 10y agoI would hope that she would answer "white...?" -- eg., demonstrate the ability and willingness make a useful provisional inference, with the understanding that it is provisional and the curiosity to know more. That, it seems to me, would be the answer that is most useful and correct. But you're probably right, the answer would be 'white', at least until a black swan comes along and utterly fucks with her worldview. Humans prefer certainties and binaries, and eschew uncertainties, probabilities, and multiplicities. So they employ all sorts of cognitive errors to avoid these things. This s a problem, because the universe rarely comes in binaries or delivers enough information for real certainty. I would hope that machine consciousness would avoid these errors, as I think they are the foundations of some of our nastier tendencies.
- wonko1 10y agoIf I'm honest with myself I have to admit that a general purpose human level, strong AI would shake my world view significantly. For that reason, I find it difficult to have a completely unbiased opinion on our current state of progress. But... while we seem to be making great progress, it seems like we're a long way off understanding how the human mind works. AlphaGo was an amazing achievement, but I think it's unlikely that the human mind tackles Go in the same way. It's obviously possible that there are multiple routes to a general human level intelligence. But I think it's still unclear if the way AI is currently being developed is one of them.
- stephanheijl 10y ago> I think it's unlikely that the human mind tackles Go in the same way. This is very certainly true, which is what makes AlphaGo interesting to watch and study. The human mind, even one that has trained on Go for years on end, will still work with abstractions and ideas that do not relate to the game. AlphaGo and other computers lack this attribute, as any and all abstractions they may have learned relate entirely to the game. Any ideas about the "human perception" of Go they may have gleaned from games that are included in the initial training dataset, I suspect have long been supplanted by novel notions gathered during the phase where the Neural Nets played against themselves. These phases are documented in the AlphaGo blog from Deepmind[1]. I suspect that we may reach "human level intelligence", but that this intelligence will not arise in the same way. That is to say, computers will at some point match us in most tests of intelligence, but the solutions they devise will be completely novel. [1] https://blog.google/topics/machine-learning/alphago-machine-learning-game-go/ https://blog.google/topics/machine-learning/alphago-machine-...
- cel1ne 10y agoWhat I find puzzling is that many people seem to assume that AI can be generated using a specific uniform neurological structure, while the human brain is actually made of many different parts, some older, some newer, some more connected, some more isolated, some inhibiting others, some potentiating others, some mostly signalling with this neurotransmitter, some using that etc.
- 10y ago
- codewithcheese 10y agoI think the physiological and the logistical aspect of Westworld is more interesting than the AI
- katpas 10y agoAgreed, given the amount of damage the Hosts seem to receive each day it doesn't feel plausible that they could collect them all and do what seems to be a manual operation on each to return them to perfect condition overnight.
- dexterdog 10y agoJust create more hosts and have them do it.
- iUsedToCode 10y agoWhy not just very good VR? Cannot believe it'd be more difficult than creating robots that can't be told from real humans.
- jayjay71 10y agoThat was my thought when I started watching the show, but as you watch more episodes you realize why the creator didn't go that route. I don't want to spoil it for anybody that isn't a regular viewer.
- DasIch 10y agoI'm doubtful something like very good VR or even good VR can even exist. You'd need to simulate physical forces interacting on the human body and movement to make that happen. Unless we achieve the ability to essentially run a MITM attack on the brain, to intercept commands from the brain and to provide it with sensory input, VR won't come close to being something genuinely deserving the name virtual reality.
- 10y ago
- chvid 10y agoI really enjoyed westworld and found the coverage of ai amazingly not stupid as opposed to most other sci-fi shows. However the biggest idea in the show was the relationship between god (Anthony Hopkins), self (the robots) and consciousness as an extension of inner conversation. I had to look up the idea: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicameralism_(psychology) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicameralism_(psychology)
- codewithcheese 10y agoI really like this idea. However, i've had lots of conscious experiences with a quiet mind
- toupeira 10y agoRead more closely, the hypothesis is that bicameralism was an evolutionary stage in human consciousness that broke down at some point in antiquity. So it would entirely be expected that you don't experience it anymore :)
- lobster_johnson 10y agoThat would imply that everybody on earth "evolved" away from bicameralism at the same time.
- nitrogen 10y agoNot necessarily. It's conceivable that a cultural or linguistic change swept quickly through the population, but it wouldn't have to happen instantaneously, and might even continue in some way (see my other comment).
- azakai 10y agoPerhaps, but it wouldn't explain isolated human populations, of which we have several in the relevant time frames.
- k__ 10y agoWestworld reminded me a bit of Asimovs stories. Coupling the whole robotics and AI thing. In Asimovs stories they first built the robots, which get smarter and smarter, but this is not how reality worked. Robots are rather specialized and most AI/automation we have today is about data, which is virtual. They're all like, lets build a robot, then make it intelligent, but it should also move like a human, oh and why not replace their internals with life-like organs? It's like they make a run through all science and engineering in about 30 years of development and pretend it's mostly the work of one master mind, which is ridicioulus. The whole "technical" side of Westworld is trash. It's more a philosophical story than technical or psychological, with a few deus ex machina to get the ball rolling.
- cydonian_monk 10y ago> Westworld reminded me a bit of Asimovs stories. I suspect this isn't an accident, given (some of) the same writers/producers are developing the Foundation series for HBO. There are MANY Asimovian themes scattered throughout the series, and even a few things I'm reasonably certain are direct references. (Ex: "Someday".) > It's more a philosophical story than technical or psychological And that's why I enjoyed it. My favorite science fiction always fits that description, especially if the big philosophical question comes around for technical reasons. (Such as in "The Cold Equations.") That, and the first season was very much a complete story. They could stop here and I'd be happy with it. The series had its flaws, but I'm very optimistic if this is the shape of TV scifi to come. Even if it's all adaptations or of a derivative form.
- k__ 10y agoI don't know... I think it's a nice show and the story telling is really awesome and the philosophical questions and their answers are really interesting. But the rest feels a bit... meh. The charaters don't have any depth. Bernard and Ford had the most, but the rest? The Maeve story-line was utter crap and the people around it wer basically imbecills, Maeve included. William had something going on for him and when everything got together I was blown away, but only for a moment because some of the story telling puzzles were solved and not because he is a good character, his development is simply implausible. Teddy is just... empty? Dolores was okay, but since the whole story was about her uncovering her past and with it her personality, it took the show till the end of the season till she got some depth. The scifi aspect is also minimal and basically a huge plothole, it's more fantasy to me.
- OJFord 10y ago> Here’s a harder one that tests basic logical induction: Lily is a swan. Lily is white. Bernhard is green. Greg is a swan. What color is Greg? Answer: white That's not right is it? At least, not logical induction? Supposing the second premise were 'Lily is female'; the answer to 'What gender is Greg' should obviously not be 'female'.
- ssanders82 10y agoWell a strict logic question would be "All swans are white. Lily is a swan. What color is Lily?" But induction is more like learning about the world by observing it, and making probable guesses. So it may be correct for a machine to observe that if one swan is white, the best guess for the color of another swan (in the absence of other info) is white.
- OJFord 10y agoThanks, your first sentence is more like what I was expecting before reading the example. I'm not familiar with that definition of induction, but I haven't studied ML at all.
- espadrine 10y agoInference includes several means. Inductive reasoning (induction) guesses the general case from particular instances. I presume that you are thinking about deductive reasoning (deduction), which guesses the particular instance from the general case. Finally, abductive reasoning is usually the goal instead of simple induction, and technically what the neural networks do: compute the simplest general case that best explains particular instances they are trained with. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inference https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inference
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- qbrass 10y agoIs the quote missing the part where they say that Bernhard was not a swan? Using their flawed logic, since Lily and Greg are both swans, then Bernhard must be a swan, so Greg could be white or green. You're right about the answer not being correct, and not for the reason I gave. The test was a butchered version of the black swan problem. It shows that you can't generalize given prior examples. Even if you've seen a million swans, and they were all white, you haven't proven that all swans are white. I haven't seen the show, so I don't know if they were intentionally going for that, or they screwed it up and honestly thought it was a proper example of inductive reasoning.
- throw2016 10y agoI loved westworld. I think it shows imagination and elevates TV. But it starts at a point where the AI is already real. They robots are able to parse reality in all 5 senses in real time and respond. The are physically sophisticated, are supposed to be bio-chemical and match humans in dexterity and motion. Season 1 focuses on the next step which is consciousness and choice, and the 2 critical theories to explain the emergence of these in the show is bicameralism and memory. It doesn't dwell too much on the how and focuses more on the consequences of it, which is a fascinating journey.
- akvadrako 10y agoThey are apparently not having the same kind of inner thoughts that we have and most of what they do is scripted. I couldn't give evidence without some spoilers.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- faragon 10y agoWestworld (2016) is an amazing show. In my opinion it is more about how real it feels, than the thematic itself. I'm convinced that same approach would work for other genres, not just sci-fi. It is a kind of hyper-realist cinema, where the plot and acting is so superb that feels credible and breathtaking.
- hellofunk 10y agoPersonally I found the recent season of Humans a lot more interesting than Westworld, which (to my taste) tried too hard to be philosophical, while Humans managed to tell a similar philosophy more subtly without being on-the-nose. But we're all critics, so YMMV.
- BEEdwards 10y agoI totally agree with you in a philosophical sense, but in a which show I'd rather watch sense I pick westworld. Humans seems smarter about a similar subject matter, but westworld is just so much fun. Fortunately there is no conflict and I can watch both!
- johnohara 10y agoI tried watching season 1 of Humans but was jaded by first watching Akta Manniskor (Real Humans), the Swedish series it is based upon. It seems that sometimes a lower production budget yields a better story. Forced to rely instead on the viewer's imagination and subject interest. Especially if it's done with aplomb and intelligence. I found the dialogue in Humans to be too "explanatory." Haven't seen a full episode of Westworld yet, but imagine the same is true. Big budgets tend to to that.
- akvadrako 10y agoI haven't seen the US Humans but did enjoy the original and found Westworld to be even better in the subtleness category. It's probably due in part to being an original and even higher production values, so you get actual good writers. Maybe also a higher-brow target audience.
- ianamartin 10y agoMeh, I think that human intelligence is vastly overrated. We've been moving the goalposts for centuries to safeguard our place not only at the top of the intellectual food chain, but also to maintain the idea that we are on an altogether different chain. We've been doing this with regard to various animals since forever. Every time a chimp learns sign language, an elephant cares about its mother, or a dolphin has sex for fun, everyone loses their minds falling all over themselves to "prove" that we are qualitatively different. That there's something else going on with us that is special. I'm not passing judgment here. I do it too. It's extremely convenient for me to do so. If you start thinking of intelligence as a spectrum with some species closer to one end of it than others, it gets a lot harder to justify most of what we do to animals. And there's a dark place I don't want to go that suggests that some people are far enough down the spectrum that maybe you could justify doing bad things to them. It get really messy and ugly in both directions when you think about intelligence as a spectrum. At what point should an animal be considered smart enough to merit "human" rights? At what point should a human be considered so dumb that it doesn't? We, as a society, are not ready to have that conversation. We lack the moral fortitude to do so, which is why I happily participate in this artificial segregation. But we are going to be forced into dealing with it much sooner than we are ready to. I fully expect that within my lifetime, there will be Bladerunner scenarios with lifelike robots who are practically indistinguishable from actual people. We live in a bubble here, where all the women are beautiful, all the men are above average, and all the children are FBI agents. Human memory is far more corrupt and fallacious than we want to think it is. Weird social interactions with slightly (or very) dysfunctional people are far more common than we tend to think they are. Spend a day on the subway in NYC. Spend a day in my hometown in Texas (population: 498). Many of these people could easily be simulated with a high degree of believability. The real hypocrisy here is that no one wants to believe that you, as an individual, could be simulated with believability. I'll go on the record and say that it would be trivial to simulate me. I'm not that special. The problem we have with AI tests is that we are testing against the ability for an AI to be anyone. We're checking to see if an AI could be as good at impersonating absolutely anyone as one of the top .00001% of human character actors. We aren't checking the lower bounds. Because that's extremely uncomfortable for us. We're maintaining goals and standards that are designed to make the tests fail. Again, we are doing it for good reasons. We haven't yet solved the problem of how to treat each other when we know that we're only dealing with humans. We aren't ready to talk about bringing other entities into our world yet. Bladerunner was prescient; Westworld is near future. We need to get our shit together because these issues are going to come up far sooner than we expect. And when we're talking about an entity that speaks to us in our own language, with our own idioms, with our own concepts of feelings and emotions--it's going to be a lot harder to maintain the pretense that we are somehow qualitatively different. On the other hand, this could be really convenient for us. A moment of solidarity, if you will. We could create believable robot characters that we unite against and focus all our hate, violence, racism, and abuse towards. Maybe we all get along better after that. But what does that say about us? And have we really solved our problems? I think that's the question Westworld is asking, similarly to the question some open world games ask, like EvE Online: in a universe where everything is permissible, who are you?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mcguire 10y agoAs far as I can see, most of the points of this article were brought up in James P. Hogan's 1979 The Two Faces of Tomorrow.
- foxhop 10y agoI'm a huge westworld fan so I made a fan site: http://westworld2.com http://westworld2.com
- njharman 10y agoLily is a swan. Lily is white. Bernhard is green. Greg is a swan. What color is Greg? Answer: white How the hell is that logical? Greg may be white, he may be black or any other color. You could guess Greg is likely white. The correct answer is "can't tell". But I'd expect an intelligent responder to reply with questions and complaints of unanswerablity like I have done here.
- mike_hearn 10y agoAI that insists on hard logic even in inappropriate situations is a staple of science fiction, but there's no reason we'd build real machines that way. The cited example is taken from the bAbI papers, and is a case of inductive reasoning: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inductive_reasoning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inductive_reasoning Inductive reasoning (as opposed to deductive reasoning or abductive reasoning) is reasoning in which the premises are viewed as supplying strong evidence for the truth of the conclusion. While the conclusion of a deductive argument is certain, the truth of the conclusion of an inductive argument is probable, based upon the evidence given. In reality this is often the best you can do, as all you have to work on in the end is the input from your own sensors.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoMost of the plot of Westworld revolved around the complete absence of any rigorous release strategy - or at least Ford's privilege in thwarting it. That was necessary to expose the development arc of the hosts. The writers also appear to have used a variation on recursive plot, which is nice to see.
- mklim 10y ago>Put another way, there’s a risk of AIs learning to achieve their assigned task better by preventing humans from shutting them down. Thought experiment/short story that goes into this in depth: https://gist.github.com/deanmarano/142df7a8a824ab05fc777d8e054ab0f3 https://gist.github.com/deanmarano/142df7a8a824ab05fc777d8e0... The crux of the story hinges on the magical spontaneous development of general intelligence, so it's pretty unconvincing as a specific plausible scenario IMO. But the general idea, that an AI may take unethical/unprecedented actions to maximize a harmless goal, is a good one.