14 ms·
Facebook will lose 80% of users by 2017, say Princeton researchers (2014)
- CoryG89 10y agoYeah, I totally didn't believe it then either. I wouldn't doubt they'll lose users one day, but I seriously doubt they'll lose many anytime soon.
- jyrkesh 10y agoThe title is a bit clickbait-y. From what I gathered, they really mean 80% of active users which is probably still too high, but I think it's probably Snapchat's year to peel off A LOT of active users from Facebook. Not that it's a zero-sum game, but I anecdotally I see a lot of FB fatigue around me.
- readhn 10y agoYep. FB fatigue is REAL!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- readhn 10y agoits impossible to predict when FB will die (most companies die). its like timing a market top, we know its coming but getting exact timing is hard. just some anecdotal facts: i know lots of my friends (mid age working professionals) realize that FB is a waste of time and if anything try to avoid it more and more. its just a matter of time before other platform takes over.
- devoply 10y agoZuckerborg is going to keep this thing around at least another 10 years. I mean I am skeptical of Zuck. But he's got some sort of management genius. So much so that I think it's not a bad idea to elect him President in 10 years.
- uptown 10y agoWhile I agree he's likely looking into the possibility of a political career, I'm not sure anyone will be elected President in 10 years.
- hellofunk 10y agoPlease explain.
- thecage411 10y agothere isn't a presidential election in 10 years.
- ricree 10y ago4 year election cycles, so 10 years from now would be just after midterm elections.
- jdross 10y agoFor starters, there's no (planned) presidential election in 10 years. There's one in 4 years, 8 years, and 12 years But he might be making a prediction/silly joke that Trump will destroy the US or something.
- knorby 10y agoThis last presidential race more or less started 2 years ago. If he were to run for President for the election in 12 years, he'd more or less start running in 10.
- devoply 10y agoNo I was just going by Zuck's age.
- nathan_f77 10y agoHe's 32 years old, and the President has to be at least 35 years old. So he could run in 4 years.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoThey realize, stop using it for a few weeks/months, starts missing it and then come back again. I myself have gone through a few such cycles. This is frustratingly similar to trying to quit an addiction.
- readhn 10y agoI see a lot of it too .. the fact that a lot of people want to stop using it is telling us whats coming for the company..
- zeroer 10y agoTrue, but I'm envious that my startup isn't in a situation where people were trying to quit it.
- hyh1048576 10y agoI went through several cycles like that. But somehow I stopped using Facebook in 2013. I managed to shift the mindset from "it's a waste of time" to "it's very shameful to use facebook" (and maybe connect it with some really shameful thing in your mind, like, "using Facebook is the same as stealing an old man's money") and that magically works! And it doesn't require any iron will for me. After that, every single time I think about using Facebook the shame engine in my mind generates enough repel force for me to not do it. I didn't do that whole process intensionally. I remember seeing some meme like "checking out Facebook in the summer -- all my friends are having fun somewhere and me masturbating lonely in a dark room" and that initiated the mindset change. To be honest, I know using Facebook is NOT a shame, but now I don't have any reason to use it at all. (There are some stupid website which only allows Facebook login, and I use my gf's account for it -- neither I nor her care about what's on her facebook.)
- dominotw 10y agoOne trick that worked for me is to gradually subscribe and like boring stuff like cat pictures, scientific journals ect. Anything that doesn't rile you mentally, i.e low mental imprint. Do this very very slowing but consciously after a while your facebook feed would become 'boring' making it easier to quit. I did this couple of years ago and never went back.
- personlurking 10y agoWhen there's lots of people on your FB, it's mostly noise and very little signal. When there's few (as mine is now), you realize there's still very little signal. I could never get over the fact that, IMO, broadcasting on a social network isn't meaningful. This is the main reason why I really like dedicated one-on-one messaging (ex, WhatsApp) but pretty much find FB proper useless in 9/10 cases (Events being the only nice aspect). That being said, I hold out little hope that FB will finally die.
- Spooky23 10y agoI unfollowed most people and started liking things. My feed turned into a sort of ghetto Google Reader... but they always tweak it to meet Facebooks objectives. To be honest, the only content left is the mommy swap pages. Fancy Craigslist. :)
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoThe signal fell off a cliff: when I used it 10 years ago in uni, it was actually useful (and the algorithm did a better job of showing things you wanted to see/there were less ads of all types); now it's mostly a proxy for emails about parties and spotify/hulu/tinder login. I think Facebook has failed to notice the precipitous drop, because they can only A/B test small changes, and none of the thousand cuts seemed like much damage. Now they lack the magic to get new users hooked, are transparently a psychologically-manipulative ad-network, and are wondering why engagement is dropping or young users are finding new platforms. I call it stats blindness: you optimize for a proxy, and end up walking slowly downhill.
- thisrod 10y agoI never used Facebook until I ended up as secretary of a sports club. It adds a lot of value for messages such as, "Could someone who regularly drives past the bottle shop please pick up a carton of beer and drop it off next time they come to the club rooms?" If you post that on Facebook, people read it a lot sooner than if it's on some group-specific message board. Then, whoever offers to do it gets to have the whole club see them volunteer. If you're trying to organise a community instead of just making money from its economy, then a semi-public space like Usenet or Facebook turns out to be really useful.
- nathan_f77 10y agoIt's true that most companies die, if you include every tiny startup and shop. I don't think it's necessarily true if you look at companies that are the size of Facebook. There are a lot of very, very old companies in the world: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_oldest_companies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_oldest_companies Kongō Gumi is a Japanese construction company that was started in 578 AD, and operated for over 1,400 years until it was bought in 2006. If Facebook lasts as long as Kongō Gumi, they'll still be around in the year 3432.
- Chathamization 10y agoWell, LiveJournal and MySpace are still around, as is AOL. But I think the big question is when Facebook will stop being the "it" page, and I'm guessing sooner rather than later. A lot of people already seem to be rather sick of it, and would jump on a halfway decent alternative if it arose (and targeted a community, rather than just being a "Facebook alternative").
- rplst8 10y agoDo you think those people are sick of Facebook or sick of the "connected lifestyle". For me it's the latter, especially when you hear "what, your not on Facebook?" I've heard people be suspicious of other people that didn't have an online presence. Especially if they were working in tech. It's just so weird sometimes.
- Chathamization 10y agoI guess it depends on what you mean by the "connected lifestyle." A focus on rapid-fire micro-updates sent out to a general audience instead of a more personalized and thought out conversation? I think there are a number of people tired of that. But alternatives don't have to follow this model. They could be based around longer, more thought out and more personalized correspondence (like e-mail), or on developing real world communities (like Meetup). I think Slack is a good example of this. What it's doing is possible on other platforms, but it's better at what it does and so it's attracting a lot of attention. Eventually some site like that is going to attract enough people who start using it as there primary online interpersonal interaction page, and let their presence on other sites stagnate. At which point other people will start navigating to the platform simply because that's where everyone's going, and you'll get a snowball effect. Like with a lot of things, once it gets started it will probably happen very rapidly.
- cblock811 10y agoReminds me of doing a math problem, getting an answer, and saying "well the math is correct so this value must be as well" and not actually thinking if the results really make sense.
- laxatives 10y ago9 women can make a baby in a one month. I used billions of data points to train my model.
- paulddraper 10y agoMy data model says 9 women and 9 men.
- verma7 10y agoMy data model says 9 women and 1 man.
- EGreg 10y agoMy data model doesn't say all that much in english but has amazing curves that I can integrate with the data I've got. Any intelligent person who sees the result can easily differentiate it from what's out there. You get more insight into curves on Facebook if you analyse them with the Cox-Zucker machine. No relation to the facebook founder.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoI read the linked paper and it's of a very poor quality. They fit an epidemiological model to the current data and then extrapolate it blindly to the future. (The fact that it worked in the case of MySpace is not as impressive as it sounds since by 2014 MySpace was long dead.)
- ysavir 10y ago> John Cannarella and Joshua Spechler, from the US university's mechanical and aerospace engineering department, have based their prediction on the number of times Facebook is typed into Google as a search term. The charts produced by the Google Trends service show Facebook searches peaked in December 2012 and have since begun to trail off. Well, yeah... The more people are already familiar with facebook, the less they will be googling/researching it. If anything, considering the popularity of Facebook at the time, it should have been seen as a sign of vitality. I'm pretty disappointed that the Princeton researchers were so blinded by googlinums that they forget those googlinums don't exist in a vacuum. Probably why mechanical and aerospace engineers aren't fit to make predictions of a social nature (among other engineers, too, sadly).
- cag_ii 10y agoNot to mention people who use facebook only through the phone app are not likely to ever search for facebook on google. I'm often amazed at how almost-completely phones have replaced "desktop computers" for many people I know (Anecdotal, I know).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sparkzilla 10y agoI agree with this to the extent that I don't even care if my site ranks well on Google. The traffic coming directly from Facebook is so much greater.
- mattnumbe 10y agoI've been in Japan for the last 7 years and it always bewilders me that so few people own desktop/laptop computers here but everybody is on the internet 24/7. (possibly not only anecdotal...)
- MaulingMonkey 10y agoI've heard explanations for this involving smaller, more space constrained apartments - and thus less interest in filling it up with yet another machine (tm) and less interest in spending time cramped up at home. This also goes hand in hand with e.g. PC Bangs being more popular over there.
- dmalvarado 10y ago"John Cannarella and Joshua Spechler ... have based their prediction on the number of times Facebook is typed into Google as a search term. The charts produced by the Google Trends service show Facebook searches peaked in December 2012 and have since begun to trail off" as more users started using their phone instead of google to experience the Facebook.
- paulhodge 10y agoIs this being posted for humor value? This was written in 2014, the researchers saw a small trend and extrapolated that the trend would continue, causing 80% user loss from 2014 to 2017. Since 2014, FB's active user count has increased from 1 billion to 1.7 billion and the stock price from ~60 to 120. This article is a great example of a very terrible and very wrong prediction.
- Johnny555 10y agoThere are around 3B internet connected people in the world, does FB really have half of them? I know more than a handful of people that eschew Facebook entirely, it's hard to beleive that half of the world is on FB. I also have 3 or 4 FB accounts myself, (that I created to test an app) am I counted as 3 people?
- nathan_f77 10y ago1.79 billion monthly active users. I guess you might be counted as 4 people if you use all your test accounts regularly, but the average number of Facebook accounts per person must be extremely close to 1. Facebook estimates that between 5.5% and 11.2% of accounts are fake [1]. So that's still around 1.59 billion real users. [1] http://thenextweb.com/facebook/2014/02/03/facebook-estimates-5-5-11-2-accounts-fake/ http://thenextweb.com/facebook/2014/02/03/facebook-estimates...
- ryanplant-au 10y agoI wonder how many active Facebook users aren't actually actively using Facebook. Per that link, Facebook defines an active user as anyone who logs into a Facebook account, but that includes using a Facebook account to log into a third-party service. An enormous number of apps and services now use Facebook OAuth rather than their own user registration system and, anecdotally, I know a surprising number of people who have zero-friend zero-post Facebook profiles solely because of that. As far as I can see Facebook doesn't publish information on how many of their active users are actively using Facebook itself.
- pessimizer 10y agoContemporary discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7104904 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7104904
- waspleg 10y agoa lot of people have an app on their phone. that means no search.
- ppierald 10y ago$58 in 2014, $120 today? Follow the money.
- donretag 10y ago"based their prediction on the number of times Facebook is typed into Google as a search term" While it might have been common to go to a website by searching for it, accidentally or not, many interact with Facebook via a mobile app. Using google search trends will not account for this change in behavior.
- chippy 10y agoThese things seem to come in cycles - as one service begins and attacts users the other one declines. We are not seeing the alternative to Facebook yet. In other words users are not going someplace else...yet, but they probably will.
- threeseed 10y agoThe alternative to Facebook already exists: Instagram. That's why it it was such an inspired move by Zuckerberg to acquire it when they did.
- xux 10y agoWhenever I see a prediction from academics, I'm reminded of this: http://www.msnbc.com/the-last-word/watch/scientist-predicts-99-chance-of-clinton-win-801634371744 http://www.msnbc.com/the-last-word/watch/scientist-predicts-... "Princeton professor predicts 99% chance of a Hillary Clinton win"
- asafira 10y agoThis is a little unfair, it's not clear to me why academics would always have worse predications than any other body of people. This especially goes for the presidential outcomes predictions.
- azinman2 10y agoEspecially when most predictions were for her. Also, if that summary is true, that meant 1% likelihood for Trump. Not zero. That's how stats work.
- paulddraper 10y ago> it's not clear to me why academics would always have worse predications than any other body of people You're right; it's a problem with predictions _generally_. It's just that academics make predictions that carry more credibility.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- xanderstrike 10y ago"Assuming a perfectly spherical voter..."
- nl 10y agoWhenever I comments like this I like to ask what they think the chances of losing the popular vote by 2.8 million (or whatever it ended up as) and winning the electoral vote actually are? Maybe she did have a 99% chance of winning? I don't think so - but I haven't actually worked it out. I'd be interested to see the conditional probabilities. 538 put Trumps chances at ~20%, which seemed about right overall.
- jwtadvice2 10y agoThe comparison of Facebook to a disease is entertaining (if because it has a little bit of truth from a certain perspective). But I'm not sure that the model they chose is the right one to use to make predictions. So I think immediately the predictions have to be in question. That said, I would like Facebook to go, and not only because of its repugnant behavior with regard to its partnership with the US and foreign governments for propaganda, censorship and surveillance. About a decade ago developers tried exhaustively to make every app "social". The reason for doing so is that, after a certain threshold, having a community locked into your platform raises barriers to competition. When it comes to large social media sites - Facebook now and Myspace before it - there can 'only be one'. There's only one place where large numbers of users can go. They don't want to post everything they think ten times to ten different communities. This makes the kind of large scale social media network Facebook represents a "natural monopoly". It can not have competition, except in the form of potential successors to market capture. This makes the "market" of social media look more like king-of-the-hill than it does efficient laissez faire competition. The better solution for social media would be a distributed platform with no central ownership. This solves privacy, censorship, and surveillance concerns and limits propaganda to a certain degree as well. It also creates an environment where there can be competition. Now companies are free to create different client software with different feature sets at different costs. So distributing the infrastructure for social media addresses the enormous problem of market failure as well.
- x2398dh1 10y agoThis makes no sense. Natural monopolies arise when there are extremely high fixed costs of distribution, like Utilities, Railways, things that are difficult to build. That is not what social media is at all, and there is absolutely nothing guaranteeing that what those Princeton researches predicted will not become true, precisely because software on servers is so easy to replicate, and distribution is inherently word of mouth. Facebook had to purchase Instagram because they couldn't figure out that type of social media. They may not be able to do that for the next Instagram. Facebook has started to suck hard because they inherently live based upon outrage and fake news. If they can't figure out ways to constantly reverse various trends that come up over time, they could get caught in a crap information spiral and fail.
- master_yoda_1 10y ago"John Cannarella and Joshua Spechler, from the US university's mechanical and aerospace engineering department, have based their prediction on the number of times Facebook is typed into Google as a search term" Really amusing. Now people type facebook.com and open facebook app on mobile. This research is garbage.
- master_yoda_1 10y agoGarbage research funding should be stopped for these phd students.
- mark-r 10y agoThis really points out the danger of using an analogy to extrapolate other similarities. Bacteria don't live forever, but there's nothing to prevent Facebook users from being Facebook users forever.
- xanderstrike 10y agoFacebook users also don't live forever, to be fair.
- mark-r 10y agoThey live forever in Internet years. At least most of them do.
- grigjd3 10y agoI recently quit Facebook, but I get the impression that I'm the exception.
- pacomerh 10y agoI quite FB in around 2009 with the plan of being more productive and it worked really well. I was being constantly distracted by unimportant events from other people. The one interesting thing that happened after that is that some of my "friends" actually contacted me to see if everything was ok with me, when in reality they where validating their egos making sure I didn't block them.
- grigjd3 10y agoI didn't find my productivity went up. Evidently, I can find enumerable things to distract myself with. I just got fed up with all the political hate flying around. Seems this year things went from people ironically commenting on the things our government does to claiming that anyone in disagreement belongs in a death camp. I just didn't want to see that shit anymore.
- rconti 10y agoI cannot enumerate the things I can distract myself with; I can therefore find innumerable things to distract myself with.
- rconti 10y agoMore productive Attending fewer events Misreading others' intentions Yeah, I think I'm gonna stick with Facebook. I don't need even MORE reasons to be a hermit -- it's already my natural tendency!
- pacomerh 10y agoThats fine if it works for you. To me its just noise that pollutes all the things I want to do. You don't have to be a hermit. If avoiding Facebook makes you a hermit, than I think we failed and we're depending too much on a single technology to be social, that doesn't sound right to me.
- conqrr 10y agoHave been using the Facebook eradicator plugin for a long time. No news feed, just the groups and messages. Perfect for me.
- newscracker 10y agoI've long stuck to just groups and messages over a web browser. But this extension can surely help people who just keep scrolling down the news feed and spend several hours a day on it without realizing. I found a similar extension for Firefox called Kill News Feed for Firefox [1], but it was last updated in 2014. I'll give it a try sometime. [1]: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-us/firefox/addon/kill-news-feed-for-firefox/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-us/firefox/addon/kill-news-fee...
- thatguy99 10y agoFirstly: https://www.statista.com/statistics/264810/number-of-monthly-active-facebook-users-worldwide/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/264810/number-of-monthly... Facebook's MAU is now at 1.7B users (That's almost 1 out of 4 people on the planet!) and is growing at about 10% per year. Secondly: Saying that Facebook's popularity will rise and fall in a similar trend that Myspace did is like saying Google's popularity would rise and fall like Ask Jeeves's. Thirdly: Facebook owns Instagram and WhatsApp Conclusion: Big brother Zuck is here to stay!
- paulddraper 10y agoSo sad that Jeeves is no longer around :(
- slantaclaus 10y agoEver tried to quit facebook? What happened?
- rubyfan 10y agoIt's kind of like Hotel California.
- skewart 10y agoI quit a while back. I don't miss it. The closest thing to a problem has been that I sometimes learn about events a little late. But I've found that pretty much anything I'd actually want to go to I find out about other ways, usually by talking with friends. I probably miss out on a lot of major life news from people I vaguely know, but I'm okay with that. And it probably pushes me to make a little more effort to stay in touch with people in old-fashioned ways, like seeing them in person, or talking on Snapchat.
- vinay427 10y agoSo far, I've had a somewhat similar experience. I am more energized to talk to people individually on Signal, WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger, etc. because of an interest in staying up to date on their life events, which personally feels healthier to me.
- corvallis 10y agoI deleted Facebook about 2 months ago. Nothing bad happened. In fact, I feel relieved more than anything that I don't have this data-collecting overlord following me around. Also it takes out the stress of possibly "missing" Facebook messages or invitations. I can't use one or two dating apps anymore, but I have a feeling my relationship status is unaffected regardless.
- robobenjie 10y agoA FB engineer's response at the time: https://www.facebook.com/notes/mike-develin/debunking-princeton/10151947421191849/ https://www.facebook.com/notes/mike-develin/debunking-prince...
- gohrt 10y agoNot everyone at FB is an engineer.
- b2600 10y agoEngineer is liberally defined nowadays. It apparently no longer means someone who has a B.S.(or above) in Engineering.
- luck_fenovo 10y agoIt also no longer means someone who shovels coal into a steam engine
- 1love2program 10y agoActually, that was the fireman.
- luck_fenovo 10y agoI stand corrected
- rconti 10y agooh man, that's great. I wish they had left it more snarky and hadn't soft-sold it by throwing in the "air" bit at the end, but that's just me.
- kresimirus 10y agoNice article! But sarcasm doesn't work as well when you have to explain it on the end.
- mikebay 10y agoI really recommend to get away from Facebook, Google and Twitter. Facebook, google and twitter. - big no thanks!
- niftich 10y agoBack in 2008-2010, FB conquered instant messaging [1]. Since then, other services proliferated, including WhatsApp (which they wisely bought), and others, but FB Chat, rebranded as Messenger, is still a hugely important platform. Instagram is growing among the demographic that Facebook first conquered when it first came out and is vying [2][3] for Snapchat (partially by its original premise, partially by copying its features [4]) to be the most popular platform for 18-25. Meanwhile the original Facebook's audience is aging, and most of the time it's an event scheduler (like Google Calendar), or photo album store (like Flickr), or a tumble-log of memes (like Tumblr), but lots of people still run the app on their phones and wander around with Location enabled. On desktops, a ton of people don't clear their cookies and the Like widget on websites lets Facebook know what sites they visit. Some people have taken to using Facebook Auth to log in to medium-value sites they visit less often -- like to buy concert tickets. All this contributes enormous value to Facebook's ad ecosystem, which is in second place to Google, and together those two are the only real players [5]. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11107321#11114518 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11107321#11114518 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12799794#12800418 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12799794#12800418 [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12799794#12800957 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12799794#12800957 [4] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12210324 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12210324 [5] https://twitter.com/jason_kint/status/814842452003659776 https://twitter.com/jason_kint/status/814842452003659776
- automatwon 10y agoWhat a coincidence Snapchat is supposed to IPO in 2017...
- bluedino 10y agoI'm almost two years FB free but I don't see anyone else quitting, just allowing it to suck them in 24/7. And new users are always joining.
- parthdesai 10y agoI uninstalled fb app and messenger but thats the most i can do. I can't quit facebook because my social life depends on it. I have 3-4 group chats on facebook, events i go to are announced and promoted on fb and as someone who went to a different country for Uni, it's a great way to be in touch with friends from high school occasionally.
- mattnumbe 10y agoI've also been off for quite some time now (I "deleted" my account 3 years ago). I know none of the information gets removed so I logged back on early last year to grab some old pictures for a wedding slideshow. It's really scary how much I wanted to keep it activated after re-activating it, and how quickly people started messaging me about why I was back on Facebook. I'd say it's less like the plague and more like gangrene.
- sporkologist 10y agoThere may be a Facebook app to blame.
- pfarnsworth 10y agoA great example of how most headline-grabbing "studies" are garbage.
- ggregoire 10y ago> most companies die I feel like Facebook and Google will never die, at least not during my life. Am I the only one?
- paulddraper 10y agoAOL and Yahoo aren't dead. Nor MySpace. The real question is if Facebook and Google will always be incredibly popular.
- FlorianRappl 10y agoNo, I am sure are not the only one. This is a temporary perception and it could change with just a single event. Take VW (Volkswagen) for instance: They looked like the dominant car vendor, but with the Dieselgate they hit a wall which will make it hard to recover. Another example would be Nokia. They still sold about 40% of the phones in 2010 - but they missed the crucial trends and made the wrong decisions.
- erikb 10y agoHow do you think about IBM, Intel and Microsoft? 15-25 years ago people had these feelings about these companies. And many people from back then are still alive. PS: I personally would believe Intel lives longer than Facebook.
- crispytx 10y agoFacebook still may lose 80% of users in the near future. AOL Instant Messenger used to be the shit and everybody used it...
- bhouston 10y agoI think that this may be true in that the desktop app has considerably lost users in favor of the mobile app. Search traffic has decreased significantly: https://www.google.ca/trends/explore?date=all&q=facebook,yahoo,twitter,snapchat https://www.google.ca/trends/explore?date=all&q=facebook,yah...
- macawfish 10y agoI had a dream recently (after the election that shall not be named) that Facebook's stock was spiking like an airplane about to stall. Indeed, it did stall and crashed like a rock. It feels to me like there is a reckoning coming that even Facebook is not immune to.
- stevehiehn 10y agoMaybe, but what if people just open the app now and don't search google for facebook?
- forgingahead 10y agoFake news!! /s
- h_avinash 10y agoWhat are your predictions for Facebook from 2017?
- edblarney 10y agoFB usage has shifted. I wonder how many people use it in the very social sense anymore, and how many use it for basic messaging.
- nl 10y agoI think the most interesting thing about this is the previous HN discussions[1][2]. It's worth noting that even back then people thought it wasn't a great piece of research. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9096125 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9096125 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7104904 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7104904
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- inverse_pi 10y agohttps://xkcd.com/605/ https://xkcd.com/605/
- sebiche 10y agoThis is proof that the signal-to-noise ratio of top links on HN is declining.
- syphilis2 10y agoBased on Google Trends, which is the source used in the paper, Facebook is only 43% as trendy now as it was at its peak in 2012. Compared to the past, Facebook is as trendy now as it was in 2009. The irSIR model that was predicted by the paper is about 2 years off from where we are now (the "late" model is about 1.5 years off). Repeating the study with information up to today and the new prediction is that Facebook's Google Trends measure will drop below 20% within 2 years. https://www.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=%2Fm%2F02y1vz https://www.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=%2Fm%2F02y1...
- arjie 10y agoThis made me go back and find a couple of Facebook threads right after IPO that made predictions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1719975 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1719975 (Facebook is not worth $33 billion) - This was more than a year before the IPO. The market cap is 10x that today. Lots of poor predictions but also some cautious optimism from some people. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4002730 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4002730 (FB down 8% at opening) - Some rubbish number pattern matching and lots of doom and gloom. Interesting
- codecamper 10y agoHmm. and I was just wondering how much longer Google would last. How often do people really use Google? Most everyone I see is just taking & sharing photos / occasionally updating a facebook page.
- dx034 10y agoGoogle is the #1 source of knowledge for most internet users in the world (excluding China). In addition to that they provide a large share of communication (GMail), orientation (Maps) and are responsible for ads on many other pages. Many companies (including Facebook) tried to beat Google's search algorithm, they all failed (except for Bing which seems to be used by some). Unless someone can make a search engine that is much better than Google, they will keep being successful. Same for an ad network. If you have a website, using Google for ads seems to be the best option so far. No one is really happy with Google, but they still seem to be better than most competitors.
- newscracker 10y ago> Many companies (including Facebook) tried to beat Google's search algorithm, they all failed I'm not sure how much Facebook tried, but searching within the Facebook platform is a really bad experience. It's as if many things are either not indexed or are indexed with only selected sentences or words from the content. I struggle so many times to find older content for reference and to point people to, and fail a lot more times than I succeed (I mostly search in groups). Since Facebook thrives on people wanting new content and clicks, it doesn't seem like it's in Facebook's interest to make searching within the platform better. From whatever I've seen over the last several years, if at all Facebook has been working on search, the engineering team is utterly incompetent on that front.
- dx034 10y agoI remember that there was this huge announcement about Facebook Graph, which was Facebooks idea of a revolutionary new way of searching. Didn't work at all, and searching on Facebook is indeed very limited. Which is somehow really problematic, as Google also cannot really search Facebook. Wikipedia with some background: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook_Graph_Search https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook_Graph_Search
- simonh 10y agoCan FB really be compared to these diseases though? Maybe I'm nitpicking the details here but a lot of diseases, including bubonic plague mentioned in the article, kill a large proportion of their hosts.
- newscracker 10y agoI'm a privacy nut, and to me FB is worse than these diseases and will kill society, progress, freedom from surveillance and many other things that will deny more people the rights that they ought to have without being oppressed or suppressed.
- fivre 10y agovkontakte fberyoad, bitches.
- nso95 10y agoIt is 2017
- grzm 10y agoThe article is from 2014.
- shiftoutbox 10y agoCoincidentally I canceled my account yesterday.
- arkj 10y agoPhew!!! What a searchers. It just means fb is as or more popular than google. You dont need to go to princeton to guess that. The funny part is, you don't even need to read the article to make it out.
- altitudinous 10y agoFacebook are smart and moving with the times - no doubt the original Fb blue website is losing hits etc but they move on with Instagram and Messenger which are more popular than ever - Insta I think is going through an intense growth phase at the moment
- giis 10y agoI found myself spending/wasting time with fb. I tried to close the account couple times but few days later reopened the account. Last year, I tried to close the account again. First unsubscribed from all email notifications from fb. And downloaded all my content from fb. Then closed the account. But this time too I logged in twice but made sure instead of logout I closed the account both times. That's it - its been more than 8months now. I didn't bother to login to fb. Honestly, I feel much peaceful now. Last week decided to quit, en.lichess.org its been week . let's see :-)
- curiousgal 10y agoTry Sublevel[0] if you feel a social itch. 0.https://sublevel.net/ https://sublevel.net/
- jl6 10y agoThey've already lost 80% of me.
- quickConclusion 10y agoI think Facebook's demise is closer than we believe, and that the main culprit will be Wall Street. Given that the Street wants the stock price to always go up, future earnings has to go up. Hard to do with less user growth, because 1.5B already. More ads is hard if you want to keep the platform interesting. Still, room to grow in lesser FB-developed countries, with FB benefiting from economy growth and ad market growing there. But how much growth left in main earning market (US) without destroying the user experience? With strong leadership, FB could say "to hell with higher and higher profits, I am happy to run a very profitable utility, not plastered with ads, a la Craiglist". But Zuckerberg seems all talk there. And he is trying to sell a lot of his stock. Yes, he's trying to retain control too, but that will be very hard (see current litigation on that). And employees don't like stocks that are not going up. With less user and financial growth, less momentum, fewer interesting challenges, FB can slowly turn into Yahoo/AOL, and people may start saying bad things about the company (users + employees), creating a bad momentum. It would be hard to reverse, especially if FB is managed quarterly by earnings, as opposed to strong leadership. Also, I get the feeling that FB got a small temporary break with Trump. A Hillary victory may have meant many very senior executives leaving to the new administration, possibly accelerating FB's loss of momentum. Obviously, lots of talk here, many "ifs" and "maybe", and no hard data. That's why in the end I am not shorting the stock today. But wondering if I should.
- Arkaad 10y agoThe article says "80% of its peak user base within the next three years", but the title says "by 2017"? Also, I'd have liked to know to what Facebook would lose its users. During the Pokémon GO craze Facebook and other social sites lost temporally their users before they came back.